In most research fields, particular theories and lines of study tend to become dominant. Thomas Kuhn has shown that 'scientific revolutions' nevertheless occur. Citations in an ex panding research area are analysed with particular reference to a few theories which conflict with the mainstream of scientific thought on the topic. The progress of these theories past editors and referees into the primary literature and, if they make it, into citations and reviews is examined. The example used concentrates on mechanisms rather than the validity or other wise of the theories reported.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
A. Steinschneider , Prolonged apnea and the sudden infant death syndrome: Clinical and laboratory observations, Pediatrics50 (1972) 644-654.
2.
T.S. Kuhn, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1962).
3.
J.G. Gregory , Citation study of a scientific revolution: Sudden infant death syndrome. 1. The new paradigm, Scientometrics5 (1983) 313-327.
4.
R.L. Naeye , Pulmonary arterial abnormalities in the sudden-infant-death syndrome, New Engl. J. Med.289 (1973) 1167-1170.
5.
M.A. Valdes-Dapena , Sudden unexpected and unexplained death in infancy—A status report-1973, New Engl. J. Med.289 (1973) 195-197.
6.
C. Guilleminault , W.C. Dement and N. Monod, Sudden infant death syndrome: Apnea during sleep. New hypothesis, Nouv. Presse Med.2 (1973) 1355-1358.
7.
D.F.L. Money , Vitamin E and selenium deficiencies and their possible aetiological role in the sudden death in infants syndrome, N.Z. Med. J.71 (1970) 32-34.
8.
W.J. Rhead , E.E. Cary, W.H. Allaway, S.L. Saltstein and G.N. Schrauzer, The vitamin E and selenium status of infants and the sudden infant death syndrome, Bioinorg. Chem.1 (1972) 289-294.
9.
G.N. Schrauzer , W.J. Rhead and S.L. Saltstein, Sudden infant death syndrome: Plasma vitamin E levels and dietary factors. Ann. Clin. Lab. Sci.5 (1975) 31-37.
10.
S.R.M. Kendeel and J.A.J. Ferris, Sudden infant death syndrome: A review of literature, J. Forensic Sci. Soc.17 (1977) 223-255.
11.
M. Valdes-Dapena , Sudden unexplained infant death, 1970 through 1975: An evolution in understanding, Path. Ann.12 (1977) 117-145.
12.
D.F.L. Money , Vitamin E, selenium, iron, and vitamin A content of livers from sudden infant death syndrome cases and control children: Interrelationships and possible significance, N.Z. J. Science21 (1978) 41-55.
13.
D.F.L. Money , Anti- and pro-oxidant in infant nutrition, N.Z. Med. J.89 (1979) 494-495.
J.L. Caddell , Exploring the magnesium-deficient weanling rat as an animal model for the sudden infant death syndrome: physical, biochemical, electrocardiographic and gross pathologic changes, Pediat. Res.12 (1978) 1157-1158.
16.
R.M. Raie and H. Smith, Trace element deficiency and cot deaths , Med. Sci. Law21 ( 1981) 41-45.
17.
P.M. Mulvey , Cot death survey: Anaphylaxis and the house dust mite, Med. J. Aust.2 (1972) 1240-1244.
18.
K.J. Turner , B.A. Baldo, R.F. Carter and H.R. Kerr, Sudden infant death syndrome in South Australia. Measurement of serum IgE antibodies to three common allergens, Med. J. Aust.2 (1975) 855-859.
19.
J.W. Clark , J.W. Yunginger, P.A. Bonnes, C.G. Ray and S.L. Saltstein, Serum IgE antibodies in sudden infant death syndrome, J. Pediatrics95 (1979) 85-86.
20.
D.C. Shannon and D.H. Kelly.SIDS and near-SIDS, New Engl. J. Med.306 (1982) 959-965 and 1022-1028.
21.
M. Valdes-Dapena , The pathologist and the sudden infant death syndrome, Am. J. Path.106 (1982) 118-131.
22.
S. Tonkin , Sudden infant death syndrome: Hypothesis of causation, Pediatrics55 (1975) 650-661.
23.
S. Tonkin , The pharyngeal effect of partial nasal obstruction , Pediatrics63 ( 1979) 261-271.
24.
D.J.C. Read , The aetiology of the sudden infant death syndrome: Current ideas on breathing and sleep and possible links to deranged thiamine neurochemistry, Aust. N.Z. J. Med.8 (1978).
25.
M. Valdes-Dapena , Sudden infant death syndrome: A review of the medical literature 1974-1979, Pediatrics66 (1980) 597-614.
26.
D.J.C. Read , H.E. Jeffery and P. Rahilly, Sudden infant death syndrome and suspected 'near-miss': An overview for clinicians, Med. J. Aust.1 (1982) 82-86.
27.
D.P.G. Bolton , K.W. Cross and A.C. McKettrick, Are babies in carry cots at risk from CO2 accumulation?, Br. Med. J.4 (1972) 80-81.
28.
P. Seifert , Unexpected sudden death in infancy (cot death) , Med. J. Aust.60 ( 1973) 1128-1129.
29.
N. Lewak , Mythology and SIDS, New Engl. J. Med.291 (1974) 740-741.
30.
C. Guilleminault , R. Peraita, M. Souquet and W.C. Dement, Apneas during sleep in infants: Possible relationship with sudden infant death syndrome, Science190 (1975) 677-679.
31.
Anon., The sudden infant death syndrome: Expanded research program, Pediatrics50 (1972) 386.
32.
G.T. Stewart , Whooping cough in the United Kingdom 1977-8 , Br. Med. J. (1980) 451-452.
33.
G.E. Godber , Deaths of infants after triple vaccine, Lancet2 (1979) 472-473.
34.
G.T. Stewart , Deaths of infants after triple vaccine, Lancet2 (1979) 354-355.
35.
D.L. Phelps , Vitamin E: where do we stand? Pediatrics63 (1979) 933-935.
36.
J.M. Brown , The fatal 'burp', Med. J. Aust.1 (1975) 841.
37.
M.S. Lachs , Cot death—thoughts on a personal experience , Med. J. Aust.61 ( 1974) 139-140.
38.
W.V. Harman , Death of my baby, Br. Med. J.282 (1981) 35-37.
39.
B.A. Schwartz , Sleep-induced apnea and sudden infant death , New Engl. J. Med.290 (1974) 750.
40.
K.J. Turner and J.F. Soothill, Sudden-infant-death syndrome and immuno-deficiency , Lancet2 (1975 ) 917.
41.
D.F.L. Money , Cot deaths and deficiency of vitamin E and seleniumBr. Med. J.4 ( 1971) 559.
42.
W.J. Rhead , S.L. Saltstein, E.E. Cary and W.M. Allaway.Vitamin E, selenium and the sudden infant death syndrome, J. Pediatrics81 (1972) 415-416.
43.
S.L. Saltstein , G.N. Schrauzer and W.J. Rhead, Sudden infant deaths and deficiencies in diet, J. Am. Med. Assoc.226 (1973) 466.
44.
W.J. Rhead , G.N. Schrauzer and S.L. Saltstein, Sudden death in infancy and vitamin E deficiencyBr. Med. J.4 (1973) 548.
45.
S.L. Saltstein , Vitamin E deficiency in cot deaths, Lancet1 (1975) 1095.
46.
W.J. Rhead , A final note on the lack of relationship of selenium, other trace elements, and vitamin E in the causation of SIDS, J. Pediatrics90 (1977) 500.
47.
C.A. Lapin , G. Morrow, M. Chuapil, D.P. Belke and R.S. Fisher, Hepatic trace elements in the sudden infant death syndrome, J. Pediatrics89 (1976) 607-608.
48.
J.L. Caddell , Hepatic trace elements in the sudden infant death syndrome, J. Pediatrics90 (1977) 1039.
49.
P.G.F. Swift and J.L. Emery, Magnesium and sudden infant deathLancet2 (1972) 871.
50.
W.Q. Sturner , Lancet2 (1972) 1150; J.D. Godwin and P. Brown, Lancet1 (1973) 1176; D.R. Peterson and J.B. Beckwith, Lancet2 (1973) 330; J.P.A. Baak, Lancet1 (1974) 415.
51.
M.E. Avery andI.D. Frantz.To breathe or not to breathe, New Engl. J. Med.297 (1977) 781-782.
52.
J.V. Weil , Familial factors, ventilatory control, and sudden infant death, New Engl. J. Med.302 (1980) 517-519.
53.
Anon., Cot death, Lancet2 (1975) 1024-1025.
54.
R.G. Carpenter and J.L. Emery, Identification and follow-up of infants at risk of sudden death in infancy, Nature250 (1974) 729.
55.
Anon., Cot death and respiratory drive, Lancet2 (1977) 1064.
56.
Anon., Apnoea and unexpected child death, Lancet2 (1979) 339-340.
57.
Anon., Risk of cot deaths, Br. Med. J.3 (1975) 664.
58.
Anon., What kind of cot death?, Br. Med. J.1 (1978), 671-672.
59.
Anon., Sudden infant death syndrome and ventilatory control , Br. Med. J.3 ( 1980) 337.
Anon., The sudden infant death syndrome. Med. J. Aust.287 (1972) 1050-1052.
62.
W.J. Hensley and R.P. Shearman, Sudden infant death syndrome, Aust. N.Z. J. Med.8 (1978) 247-249.
63.
E.M. Allen, Sudden infant death syndrome, N.Z. Med. J. ( 1982) 183-184.
64.
T.E. Kuich and D. Zimmerman, Endorphins, ventilatory control, and sudden infant death syndrome—A review and synthesis, Medical Hypotheses7 (1981) 1231-1240.
