Watching me,watching you: privacy attitudes and reactions to identity card implementation scenarios in the United Kingdom

Abstract

In the United Kingdom, government proposals for the introduction of an identity (ID) card have raised considerable privacy concerns. In the present research, opinions and attitudes about different ways of implementing ID cards are examined using an experimental methodology. Specifically, the level and type of compulsion and application process, and the use of a centralized database or trusted third party to hold personal information, are compared for attitudes towards ID cards. Moreover, the impact of implementation scenarios on people with different privacy concern profiles is examined. The results show that an implementation that combines high compulsion with a centralized database (the approach currently favoured by the UK Government) leads to the greatest negative shift in attitudes towards ID cards. Implementations proposed by others (e.g. the London School of Economics) show significantly less negative shift in attitudes. People’s pre-existing privacy concerns also influence their evaluation of the different implementation scenarios.

Keywords

privacy identity cards

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

L. S. Strickland and L. E. Hunt , Technology, security, and individual privacy: new tools, new threats, and new public perceptions , Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology 56 (2004) 221-234 .

No2ID (2005). Available at: www.no2id.co.uk/ (accessed 20 June 2005).

The Guardian , ID Cards Bill Faces Tough Time in Lords after Battering from Critics (2005). Available at: www.guardian.co.uk/guardianpolitics/story/0,,1605141,00.html (accessed 31 October 2005).

P. 6 , Should we be compelled to have identity cards? Justifications for the legal enforcement of obligations , Political Studies 53 (2005) 243-261 .

The Office of the Information Commissioner , The Identity Cards Bill: the Information Commissioner’s Concerns (2005). Available at: www.ico.gov.uk/cms/DocumentUploads/the_identity_cards_bill_ico_concerns_october_2005.pdf (accessed 2 November 2005).

J. Fishenden , ID Cards Will Lead to ‘Massive Fraud’ (2005). Available at: http://news.scotsman.com/index.cfm?id=2103982005 (accessed 18 October 2005).

Home Office , Identity Cards: an Assessment of Awareness and Demand for the Identity Card Scheme (2005). Available at: www.identitycards.gov.uk/library/2005-10-12_Trade_Off_final_report.pdf (accessed 2 November 2005).

M. J. Metzger , Privacy, Trust and Disclosure: Exploring Barriers to Electronic Commerce (2004). Available at http://jcmc.indiana.edu/vol9/issue4/metzger.html (accessed 20 June 2005).

J. Nickel and H. Schaumburg , Privacy, trust and self-disclosure in e-recruitment . (Paper presented at CHI, Vienna, Austria, 24-29 April 2004.)

10.

J. Phelps , G. Novak and E. Ferrell , Privacy concerns and consumer willingness to provide personal information , Journal of Public Policy and Marketing 19 (2000) 27-41 .

11.

D. A. Taylor and I. Altman , Self-disclosure as a function of reward-cost outcomes , Sociometry 38 (1975) 18-31 .

12.

T. B. White , Consumer disclosure and disclosure avoidance: a motivational framework , Journal of Consumer Psychology 14 (2004) 41-51 .

13.

S. G. M. Bailey and N. Caidi , How much is too little? Privacy and smart cards in Hong Kong and Ontario , Journal of Information Science 31 (2005) 354-364 .

14.

M. J. Culnan and P. K. Armstrong , Information privacy concerns, procedural fairness, and impersonal trust: an empirical investigation , Organization Science 10 (1999) 104-115 .

15.

J. Oates , Internet Worries US Consumers (2005). Available at www.theregister.co.uk/2005/10/18/survey_fears/ (accessed 18 October 2005).

16.

Harris and Associates Inc . and A. Westin , E-commerce and Privacy: What Net Users Want, Privacy and American Business and Pricewaterhouse Coopers LLP (1998). Available at: www.pandan.org/ecommercesurvey.html (accessed 20 June 2005).

17.

Computerworld. Available at: www.computerworld.com/printthis/2005/0,4814,101766,00.html (accessed 4 November 2005).

18.

The Times , Cost of ID Cards ‘may spiral to £300’ (2005) Available at: http://www.timesonline.co.uk/newspaper/0,,173-1656121,00.htm (accessed 5 July 2005).

19.

LSE , Alternative Blueprint for a National Identification System (2005). Available at: www.lse.ac.uk/collections/pressAndInformationOffice/PDF/LSE_ID_blueprint.pdf (accessed 5 July 2005).

20.

Home Office , Home Office Response to the London School of Economics’ ID Cards Cost Estimates and Alternative Blueprint (2005). Available at: www.identitycards.gov.uk/library/Response_LSE_Alternative_Blueprint.pdf (accessed 2 November 2005).

21.

Home Office , Identity Cards Trade Off Research Interim Report (2005). Available at: www.identitycards.gov.uk/library/2005-06-27_Identity_Cards_Trade_Off_Research-Interim_Report_v1.0.pdf (accessed 2 November 2005)

22.

C. Bellamy , P. 6 and C. Raab , Joined-up government and privacy in the United Kingdom: managing tensions between data protection and social policy, Part II , Public Administration 83 (2005) 393-415 .

23.

A. Westin , Consumers, Privacy and Survey Research (Paper presented at CASRO, Las Vegas, October 2003). Available at: www.harrisinteractive.com/advantages/pubs/DNC_AlanWestinConsumersPrivacyandSurveyResearch.pdf (accessed 5 July 2005).

24.

A. F. Westin , Social and political dimensions of privacy , Journal of Social Issues 59(2) (2003) 431-453 .

25.

H. Taylor , Most people are ‘Privacy Pragmatists’ who, while concerned about privacy, will sometimes trade it off for other benefits , The Harris Poll March (2003). Available at www.harrisinteractive.com/harris_poll/index.asp?PID=365 (accessed 5 July 2005).

26.

Privacy Knowledge Base (2005). Available at http://privacyknowledgebase.com (accessed 20 June 2005).

27.

Electronic Privacy Information Centre , Public Opinion and Privacy (2005). Available at www.epic.org/privacy/survey/default.html (accessed 1 December 2005).

28.

O. H. Gandy Jr , The role of theory in the policy process: a response to Professor Westin. In: C. Firestone and J. Schement (eds), Toward an Information Bill of Rights and Responsibilities ( The Aspen Institute Communications and Society Program, Washington, DC , 1995).

29.

T. Buchanan , C. Paine , A. Joinson and U.-D. Reips , Development of measures of online privacy concern and protection for use on the internet , Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology (in press).