This study explored differences in DeCSS posting between EU member nations, the PRC, Hong Kong, and Macau. DeCSS is a software program that circumvents DVD copy and access protection systems. The study investigated the number of websites in each nation that posted DeCSS. The study also examined the degree to which website authors included political speech on their websites referring to changes in copyright law brought about by World Intellectual Property Organization Treaty requirements. It also examined whether or not websites made reference to Free/Open Source software. Results found no DeCSS posting websites in the PRC, Macau, Luxembourg, Spain or Portugal; and results found few DeCSS posting websites in Hong Kong, Ireland, Italy and Greece. Results show more DeCSS posting websites in northern EU nations, especially the Netherlands, Germany, the UK and France. The paper draws on institutional theory and collective action theory to suggest explanations for the observed differences in DeCSS posting.
Motion Picture Association of America , Worldwide Internet Piracy Study: a Motion Picture Association of America Survey (2004). Available at: www.mpaa.com (accessed September 2004).
2.
C. Oppenheim , Does copyright have any future on the Internet?Journal of Documentation56(3) (2000) 279-298 .
3.
L. Lessig , The Future of Ideas ( Random House, New York , 2001).
4.
WIPO Performances and Phonograms Treaty (WPPT) , International Legal Materials (36) (1997) 76-91 . Available at www.wipo.int/treaties/en/ip/wppt/index.html (accessed January 2005).
5.
T. Gillespie , Copyright and commerce: the DMCA, trusted systems, and the stabilization of distribution , The Information Society20(4) (2004) 239-254 .
6.
R. Phillips , DVD Players , Linux Journal (December 2003). Available at: www.linuxjournal.com (accessed May 2004).
7.
R. Boynton , The tyranny of copyright , New York Times Magazine (25 January) (2004) 40-45 .
8.
S. Vaidhyanathan , The state of copyright activism , First Monday9(4) (2004). Available at: www.firstmonday.org/issues/issue9_4/siva/index.html (accessed April 2004).
9.
K.R. Eschenfelder and A.C. Desai , Software as protest: the unexpected resiliency of US based DeCSS posting and linking , The Information Society20(2) (2004) 101-116 .
10.
K.R. Eschenfelder , R.G. Howard and A.C. Desai , Why do Website authors post DeCSS? A content analysis of Websites posting DVD circumvention software , Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology (in press).
11.
P. DiMaggio and W. Powell , Introduction. In: P. DiMaggio and W. Powell (eds), The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis ( University of Chicago Press, Chicago , 1991) 1-38.
12.
W.R. Scott , Institutions and Organizations ( Sage, Thousand Oaks , 2001).
13.
P. Agre , Real-time politics: the Internet and the political process , The Information Society18(5) (2002) 311-331 .
14.
W.R. Scott , The adolescence of institutional theory , Administrative Science Quarterly32(4) (1987) 493-511 .
15.
D. McAdam , S. Tarrow and C. Tilly , Dynamics of Contention ( Cambridge University Press, Cambridge , 2001).
16.
China Internet Network Information Center , China’s Internet Development and Usage Report (January 2004). Available at: www.cnnic.net.cn/en/index/0O/02/index.htm (accessed June 2004).
17.
International Telecommunications Union , World Telecommunication Indicators (2003). Available at: www.itu.int/ITU-D/ict (accessed November 2004).
18.
M. Stefik , Shifting the possible: how trusted systems and digital property rights challenge us to rethink digital publishing , Berkeley Technology Law Journal12 (1997) 137-159 .
19.
A. Foroughi , M. Albin and S. Gillard , Digital rights management: a delicate balance between protection and accessibility , Journal of Information Science28(5) (2002) 389-395 .
20.
P. Samuelson , The US digital agenda at WIPO , Virginia Journal of International Law37 (1997) 369-439 .
21.
M. Ficsor , The Law of Copyright and the Internet ( Oxford University Press, Oxford/New York , 2002).
22.
M. Hart , The Copyright in the Information Society Directive: an overview , European Intellectual Property Review24 (2002), 58-64 .
23.
N. Braun , The interface between the protection of technological measures and the exercise of exceptions to copyright and related rights , European Intellectual Property Review25 (2003) 496-503 .
24.
J.C. Fernandez-Molina , Laws against the circumvention of copyright technological protection , Journal of Documentation59(1) (2003) 41-68 .
25.
S. Dusollier , Fair use by design in the European Union Copyright Directive of 2001 . Communications of the ACM46(4) (2003) 51-55 .
26.
A. Strowel and S. Dusollier , Workshop on Implementation Issues of the WIPO Copyright Treaty (WCT) and the WIPO Performances and Phonograms Treaty (WPPT) (1999). Available at: http://www.wipo.int/documents/en/meetings/1999/wct_wppt/doc/imp99_2.doc, 1999 (accessed May 2004).
27.
U. Gasser and M. Girsberger , Transposing the Copyright Directive: Legal Protection of Technological Measures in EU-Member States (Berkman Publication Series No. 2004-10). Available at: http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/publications (accessed November 2004).
28.
X. Hong , China, International Copyright Law and Practice (Release 15) ( Matthew Bender & Co., Newark, NJ , 2003) CHI-1 to CHI-81.
29.
Copyright Law of the Peoples’ Republic of China, Article 47(6).
30.
Z. Lian , Copyright Protection of Technological Measures (2002). Available at: http://wwww.chinacourt.org/public/detail.php?id=12335 (accessed May 2004).
31.
G. Greenleaf , IP, phone home: the uneasy relationship between copyright and privacy, illustrated in the laws of Hong Kong and Australia , Hong Kong Law Journal32 (2002) 35-38 .
32.
Copyright Ordinance §273 (Hong Kong SAR Copyright Ordinance § 273).
33.
K. O’Neill , Websites of resistance: internetworking and civil society. In: M. Pendakur and R. Harris (eds), Citizenship and Participation in the Information Age ( Garamond Press, Aurora , 2000) 322-335.
34.
S. Fray , On electronic civil disobedience , Peace Review11(1) (1999) 107-111 .
35.
D.S. Meyer and S. Tarrow , The Social Movement Society ( Rowman & Littlefield, Lanham , 1998).
36.
S. Kalathil and T. Boas , Open Network: Closed Regimes ( Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, Washington D.C. , 2003).
37.
J. Zittrain, J. and B. Edelman , Empirical Analysis of Internet Filtering in China (2003). Available at: cyber. law.harvard.edu/publications, Research Publication No. 2003-02 ( Berkman Center for Internet and Society, Cambridge, MA ., 2003) (accessed December 2003).
38.
L. Xiguang , ICT and the demise of propaganda: China’s Internet experience. In S. Gan , J. Gomez and U. Johannen (eds), Asian Cyberactivism: Freedom of Expression and Media Censorship ( Friedrich Naumann Foundation, Bangkok , 2004) 234-269.
39.
M. Crutsinger , US, China reach trade agreements on copyright piracy, opening China’s distribution , Washington Dateline (21 April 2004).
40.
USTR , US Department of Commerce , Special 301 Report (2004). Available at: http://www.ustr.gov/Document_Library/Reports_Publications/2004/2004_Special_301/Section_Index.html (accessed November 2004).
41.
IIPA , IIPA’s 2003 Estimated Trade Losses Due to Copyright Piracy and Piracy Levels In-Country (2004). Available at: http://www.iipa.com (accessed November 2004).
42.
J. Ginsburg , A tale of two copyrights: literary property in revolutionary France and America , Tulane Law Review64 (1990) 991-1023 .
43.
J.C. Fernandez-Molina and E. Peis , The moral rights of authors in the age of digital information , Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology52(2) (2001), 109-117 .
44.
W. Alford , To Steal a Book is an Elegant Offense: Intellectual Property Law in Chinese Civilization ( Stanford University Press, Stanford , 1995).
45.
J. Du , T. Hiang , and F. Ma , An evaluation of the construction of information laws and regulations in China with recommendations for improvement , Journal of Information Science30(4) (2004) 321-336 .
46.
X. Feng , L. Yang and F.X. Huang , Awakening of a sleeping dragon: the evolution of copyright conception in China , Journal of the Copyright Society of the U.S.A51(3) (2004) 615-644 .
47.
J.J. Bing , Sunde vs. Johansen ( Norwegian Research Center for Computers and Law, Oslo , 2003). Available at: http://www.domstol.no/archive/Oslotingrett/Nye%20avgjorelser/DVD-jon.doc, English translation (accessed February 2004).
48.
E. Felten , A skeptical view of DRM and fair use , Communications of the ACM46(4) (2003) 56-59 .
49.
P. Samuelson , Legally speaking: reverse engineering under siege , Communications of the ACM45(10) (2002) 15-20 .
50.
B. Simons , To DVD or not to DVD , Communications of the ACM42(5) (1999) 31-32 .
51.
R. McMillan , Microsoft’s power play: will trusting computing mean the end of the PC as we know it?Linux Magazine (January 2003).
52.
R. Weisman , Linux rising in China , Linux Insider (January 30 2004).
53.
J. Krikke , Linux revolution: Asian countries push open source , Linux Insider (December 17 2003).
54.
J. Chao , Linux to benefit from law in China , Palm Beach Post (14 March 2004), 3F .
55.
Sun Microsystems , Sun and the China Standard Software Company Partner to Establish the JAVA Desktop System as the Foundation for China’s Fast Growing IT Industry (2003). Available at: www.sun.com/smi/Press/sunflash/2003-11 (accessed June 2004).
56.
L. Liu , Chinese Firms Could Benefit From Microsoft’s Loss in China (2003). Available at: www.gartner.com, Research Report: FT-15-2027 (accessed April 2004).
57.
J. James , Free software and the digital divide: opportunities and constraints for developing nations , Journal of Information Science29(1) (2002) 25-33 .
58.
B.J. Dempsey , D. Weiss , P. Jones and J. Greenburg , Who is an open source developer?Communications of the ACM54(2) (2002) 67-72 .
59.
International Institute of Infonomics , Free/Libre and Open Source Software: Survey and Study (FLOSS) ( University of Maastricht, The Netherlands , 2002). Available at: http://www.infonomics.nl/FLOSS/report/ (accessed September 2004).
60.
Boston Consulting Group , Boston Consulting Group Hacker Survey Phase I (2002). Available at: http://www.bcg.com/opensource/BCGHackerSurveyOSCON24July02v073.pdf (accessed September 2004).
61.
G. Moody , Rebel Code: Inside Linux and the Open Source Revolution ( Perseus, Cambridge, MA , 2001).
62.
C. Weare and W. Lin , Content analysis of the World Wide Web: opportunities and challenges , Social Science Computer Review18(3) (2000) 272-292 .
63.
K. Krippendorf , Content Analysis: an Introduction to Its Methodology ( Sage, Beverly Hills , 1980).
64.
R. Weber , Basic Content Analysis ( Sage, Newbury Park , 1990).
65.
Mr Bad , Pigdog Journal DeCSS Distribution Center (2002). Available at: http://skunk.pigdog.org/decss (accessed February 2004).
66.
J. Kahn , Let freedom ring? Not so fast. China’s still China , The New York Times (May 3 2004).
67.
China Information Center , Shanghai and Shandong to Monitor Internet Cafes (2004). Available at: www.cicus.org (accessed April 2004).
68.
European Union The Languages of Europe. Available at: http://europa.eu.int/comm/education/policies/lang/languages/index_en.html%23non-native%20speakers (accessed January 2005).
69.
S. Shankland , Linux, digital rights on collision course , CNET News (3 August 2004). Available at: http://news.com.com/2100-7344-5295804.html (accessed September 2004).
70.
E. Raymond , Homesteading the Noosphere (2002). Available at:www.tuxedo.org/%7Eesr (accessed February 2004).
71.
R. Pavlicek , Embracing Insanity: Open Source Software Development ( SAMS, Indianapolis , 2000).
72.
S. McMillan , The microscope and the moving target: the challenge of applying content analysis to the World Wide Web , Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly77(1) (2000) 80-98 .
73.
J. Borland , Tech, Studio Giants Team on new DVD locks , CNET News (July 14, 2004). Available at: http://news.com.com/2100-1025-5269286.html (accessed September 2004).
74.
Reuters News Service , Firms announce video antipiracy technology , CNET News (10 September 2004). Available at: http://news.com.com/2011-1026-5361429.html (accessed September 2004).
