Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

This paper reports on a study that examined citation practice in a set of scholarly papers. After evaluating 2162 bibliographic references it was found that 48.1% (1041) of all citations used in the papers referred to a Web-located resource. A significant number of references to URLs were found to be missing (45.8%) and an evaluation of these Weblocated citations allowed the average half-life (4.8 years) for these missing resources to be determined. The study also examined the composition of the top-level domains associated with resource loss as well as the proportional use of Web-located resources in individual articles. The proportional use of Web-located resources in individual articles and their corresponding evaluation for disappearance has not been previously documented. The paper utilized the proportional Web-citation aspect of articles in proposing a Webresource contribution index and a Web-citation use-loss grid that may aid future authors, editors and, in particular, researchers in investigating this growing aspect of citation behaviour.

Keywords

citation permanency Web-located resource URL evaluation framework

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Y. Zhang , Scholarly use of Internet-based electronic resources , Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology 52(8) (2001) 628–654 .

C. Zerby , The Devil’s Advocate: A History of Footnotes* ( Touchstone, NY , 2002).

J. Webster and R.T. Watson , Analyzing the past to prepare the future: writing a literature review , MIS Quarterly 26(2) (2002) xiii–xxiii .

M. Thelwall , A comparison of sources of links for academic Web impact factor calculations , Journal of Documentation 58 (2002) 60–72 .

L. Vaughan and M. Thelwall , Scholarly use of the Web: what are the key inducers of links to journal Web sites , Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology 54(1) (2003) 29–38 .

L. Egghe , New informetric aspects of the Internet: some reflections – many problems , Journal of Information Science 26(5) (2000) 329–335 .

B. Cronin , Bibliometrics and beyond , Journal of Information Science 24(1) (2001) 1–7 .

W. Koehler , A longitudinal study of Web pages continued: a consideration of document persistence , Information Research 9(2) (2004). Available at: http://informationr.net/ir/9–2/paper174.html (accessed 23 June 2004).

M.F. Casserly and J.E. Bird , Web citation availability: analysis and implications for scholarship , College and Research Libraries 64(7) (2003) 300–317 .

10.

Publication Manual of the American Psychological Association ( APA, Washington DC , 2001).

11.

The Oxford Style Manual ( Oxford University Press, Oxford , 2003).

12.

M. Rumsey , Runaway train: problems of permanence, accessibility, and sustainability in the use of Web sources in law review citations , Law Library Journal 94 (2002) 27–39 .

13.

D. Spinellis , The decay and failures of Web references , ACM 46(1) (2003) 71–77 .

14.

B. Kahle , Preserving the Internet , Scientific American 276(3) (1997) 72–74 .

15.

J. Markwell and D.W. Brooks , Broken links: the ephemeral nature of educational WWW hyperlinks , Journal of Science Education and Technology 11 (2002) 105–108 .

16.

J. Markwell and D.W. Brooks , Link rot limits the usefulness of Web-based educational material in biochemistry and molecular biology , Biochemistry and Molecular Biology Education 31 (2003) 69–72 .

17.

S. Lawrence , F. Coetzee , E. Glover , D.M. Pennock , G. Flake and F. Nielsen , Persistence of Web references in scientific research , IEEE Computer 34(2) (2001) 26–31 .

18.

C.A. Germaine , URLs: Uniform Resource Locators or Unreliable Resource Locators? College & Research Libraries 61(4) (2000) 359–365 .

19.

W. Koehler , An analysis of Web page and Web site constancy and permanence , Journal of the American Society for Information Science 50(2) (1999) 162–180 .

20.

W. Koehler , Web page change and persistence: a four-year Longitudinal Study , Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology 53(2) (2002) 162–171 .

21.

W. Koehler , A.D. Anderson , B.A. Dowdy , D.E. Fields , M. Golden , D. Hall , A.C. Johnson , C. Kipp , L.L. Ortega , E.B. Ripley , R.L. Roddy , K.B. Shaffer , S. Shelburn and C.D. Wasteneys , A profile in statistics of journal articles: fifty years of American documentation and the Journal of the American Society for Information Science , International Journal of Scientometrics, Informetrics and Bibliometrics (Cybermetrics) 4(1, Paper 3) (2000). Available at: http://web.archive.org/web/20030623200359/http://www.cindoc.csic.es/cybermetrics/articles/v4i1p3.html (accessed 23 June 2004).

22.

IW3C2 , International World Wide Web Conference Committee (IW3C2) Home Page (2000). Available at: http://web.archive.org/web/20030417144818/www.iw3c2.org/Welcome.html (accessed 10 August 2004).

23.

P.M. Davis and S.A. Cohen , The effect of the Web on undergraduate citation behavior 1996–1999 , Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology 52(4) (2001) 309–314 .

A study of missing Web-cites in scholarly articles: towards an evaluation framework

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References