The paper describes research into charging mechanisms for the delivery of digitized texts to students in the higher education sector. A satisfactory pricing model in this domain is urgently required. The history and background of the use and pricing of digitized texts for students in the higher education sector is examined. Issues of economics in the electronic era are described. The issues involved are outlined in relation to the stakeholders involved, namely academics, authors, the CLA (Copyright Licensing Agency), HERON (Higher Education Resources On-demand) libraries in the HE sector, publishers and students. Past projects and research conducted to date are considered and the results discussed. Particular reference is made to the HERON project, a service provided for the UK higher education community that delivers copyright clearance, digitization and delivery of the text to UK Higher Education Institutions (HEIs). HERON is also building up a national database and resource bank of the texts. Other electronic resource models are considered, in particular library initiatives. International projects are covered in relation to how pricing issues are addressed throughout the world, particularly in the USA. The case is proposed of the benefits to all stakeholders of establishing a mutually acceptable pricing model for the distribution of digitized texts to the HE/FE community. The PELICAN project had the ultimate aim of developing pricing models for the delivery of digitized text to the UK HE community, satisfying all stakeholders as far as possible. The project’s initial research findings are described, including a table of the possible pricing mechanisms and initial conclusions drawn.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
[1] A. Treloar , Rethinking the library’s role in publishing , Learned Publishing12 (1999) 25-31 .
2.
[2] P. Sykes , On-demand publishing in the humanities , Learned Publishing10 (1997) 305-311 . Available at: http://dandini.catchword.com/vl=1345760/cl=15/nw=1/fm=docpdf/rpsv/catchword/alpsp/09531513/v10n4/s3/p305
3.
[3] C.J. Armstrong and R. Lonsdale , The Publishing of Electronic Scholarly Monographs and Textbooks. ELib study (1998). Available at: http://www.ukoln.ac.uk/dlis/models/studies/elec-pub
4.
[4] P. Kingston , E. Gadd and A. Poulter , Project ACORN: user reactions , Learned Publishing10 (1997) 165-166 .
5.
[5] A. Odlyzko , The Evolution of Electronic Scholarly Communication (1999). Available at: www.research.att.com/%257Eamo/doc/evolution.communications.txt
6.
[6] M. Ojala , The Linear File: to Pay or Not to Pay, That is the Question (1998). Available at: www.onlineinc.com/database/DB1998/linear4.html
7.
[7] D.C. Ming , Access to digital information: some breakthroughs and obstacles . Journal of Librarianship and Information Science32 (2000) 26-32 .
8.
[8] A. Muir and C. Oppenheim , Electrocopying: the publishers association and academic libraries , Journal of Librarianship and Information Science25 (1993) 175-186 .
9.
[9] C. Oppenheim , JISC/Publishers Association work on developing guidelines for copyright issues in the electronic environment . In: P. Connolly and D. Reidy (eds), Proceedings of the International Conference on the Digital Library: Challenges and Solutions for the New Millennium (IFLA, Boston Spa, 2000), pp. 39-43 .
10.
[10] B. Follett , A Report for Higher Education Funding Council for England, Scottish Higher Education Funding Council, Higher Education Funding Council for Wales ( Department of Education for Northern Ireland , 1993).
11.
[11] M. Bide , C. Oppenheim and A. Ramsden , Copyright Clearance and Digitisation in UK Higher Education: Supporting Study for the JISC/PA Clearance Mechanisms Working Party Report (August 1997). Available at: www.ukoln.ac.uk/services/elib/papers/pa/clearance/
12.
[12] M. Bide , C. Oppenheim and A. Ramsden , Charging Mechanisms for Digitised Texts: Second Supporting Study for the JISC/PA Report (October 1997). Available at: www.ukoln.ac.uk/services/elib/papers/pa/charging/
13.
[13] M. Bide , C. Oppenheim and A. Ramsden , Some proposals regarding copyright clearance and digitisation in higher education , Journal of Information Science23 (1997) 393-406 .
14.
[14] NESLI; www.nesli.ac.uk
15.
[15] L. Halliday and C. Oppenheim , Comparison and evaluation of some economic models of digital only journals , Journal of Documentation56 (2000) 660-673 .
16.
[16] L. Halliday , Copyright and digitisation in UK HEIs . VINE118 (2000) 27-34 .
17.
[17] C. Tenopir and D.W. King , Towards Electronic Journals ( SLA, Washington, DC , 2000).
18.
[18] M. Botet al. , The cost of publishing an electronic journal: a general model and a case study , D-Lib Magazine (1998). Available at: http://mirrored.ukoln.ac.uk/lisjournals/dlib/dlib/dlib/november98/11roes.html
19.
[19] F. Fishwicket al. , Economic Implications of Different Models of Publishing Scholarly Electronic Journals for Professional Societies and Other Small or Specialist Publishers ( South Bank University, London , 1998). Available at: www.ukoln.ac.uk/services/elib/papers/tavistock/scholarlyjournals/cranelib.html
20.
[20] K.L. Frey , Business models and pricing issues in the digital domain , Journal of Library Administration24 (1997) 27-37 .
21.
[21] W.Y. Arms , Economic models for open access publishing , iMPMarch (2000). Available at: www.cisp.org/imp/march_2000/03_00arms.htm
22.
[22] J. Sairamesh , C. Nikolaou , D.F. Ferguson and Y. Yemini , Economic Framework for Pricing and Charging in Digital Libraries (1996). Available at: www.dlib.org/dlib/february96/forth/02sairamesh.html
23.
[23] G. Machovec , Electronic Journal Market Overview (1997). Available at: www.coalliance.org/reports/ejournal.htm
24.
[24] A. Hampson , BUILDER and electronic delivery of learning materials , Learned Publishing12 (1999) 47-49 .
[36] Net Library; www.netlibrary.com/publisher_info.asp
37.
[37] Questia; www.questia.com
38.
[38] ebrary; www.ebrary.com/about/index
39.
[39] A. Dixon , The Impact of Electronic Publishing on the Academic Community Session 1: The Present Situation and the Likely Future. Electronic Publishing and the Academic Community: a Publisher’s Perspective ( Institute of Physics Publishing, Bristol , 1997). Available at: www.iop.org
40.
[40] C. Davies , Organizational influences on the university electronic library , Information Processing and Management33 (1997) 377-392 .
41.
[41] Charging Working Group , Final Report ( JISC Committee for Electronic Information , 2001).
42.
[42] E. Carmel and E. Collins , The impact of international copyright management and clearance systems on multimedia markets , Telematics and Informatics14 (1997) 97-109 .
43.
[43] Media Group , Competitiveness of the European Union Publishing Industries, Final Report prepared for the European Commission ( Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, Luxembourg , 2000).
44.
[44] J. Cox , Publisher-library relationships in the digital environment , Learned Publishing12 (1999) 173-178 .
45.
[45] E. Hewett , The Impact of the Electronic Delivery of Learning Materials in UK Higher Education (1999). Available at: http://builder.bham.ac.uk/reports/html/stakeholder.asp
46.
[46] D. King and C. Tenopir , Evolving journal costs: implications for publishers, libraries, and readers - cost to libraries of using electronic scholarly journals , Learned Publishing12 (1999) 251-258 .
47.
[47] R. Balkwill , Digital licensing - a role for the Publishers Licensing Society , Learned Publishing11 (1998) 119-122 .
[49] J. Forrester , Digital Books to Account for 17.5% of Publishing Sales in 5 Years ( AFX, San Francisco, CA , 2000). Available at: www.3b2consortium.org/news/janforrester.htm
50.
[50] R. Hardy , C. Oppenheim and I. Rubbert , If the price is right , Library Association Record103 (2001) 106-107 .
51.
[51] R. Hardy , C. Oppenheim and I. Rubbert , PELICAN: working towards the development of a suitable pricing mechanism for the electronic distribution of materials in the Higher Education community , SCONUL Newsletter21 (2001) 31-33 .
52.
[52] R. Hardy , C. Oppenheim and I. Rubbert , PELICAN: a pricing mechanism for the electronic distribution of materials in the Higher Education community , Learned Publishing14 (2001) 93-96 .
