An online questionnaire survey of more than 1,000 users of a consumer health website, SurgeryDoor, was conducted, which sought to discover why the site was consulted and whether the information obtained from it had any health outcome. The majority of respondents were women and middle aged. Doctors were the first port of call for information, but 50% of respondents cited the Internet as one of their top three information sources. Most people did not come to the site with a particular illness or medical condition. Two-thirds of users said that the information found had ‘helped a lot’ in being better informed. Just under half felt that the information they found had helped in their dealings with the doctor, while just over half felt that information found had changed the way they felt about their condition. More importantly, over one-third of respondents said that their condition had improved after having visited the site and more than one in four said that Web information had resulted in a deferred visit or had actually replaced a visit to the doctor.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
[1] The Web, the Kiosk, Digital TV and the Changing Face of Consumer Health Information Provision: A National Impact Study, April 2000-January 2002.
2.
[2] S. Bowseley , Web life: health , The Guardian (16 December 1999). Online section, p. 9 .
3.
[3] New York Times (1997) nytsyn.com/live/week/178_062797_16001217232.html (not publicly accessible; quoted in [4]).
4.
[4] L.K. Grossman , An outbreak of Internet phobia , Columbia Journalism Review38(3) (1999) 15-16 .
5.
[5] J. London , Lay public use of healthcare web sites. In: P. Davidson (ed.), Healthcare Information Systems ( Auerbach, New York , 1999).
6.
[6] Available at: www.kcc.tju.edu
7.
[7] G. Eysenbach , S.A. Er and T.L. Diepgen , Shopping around the Internet today and tomorrow: towards the millennium of cybermedicine , British Medical Journal319 (1999) 1294 .
8.
[8] A.M. Arthur , Written patient information: a review of the literature , Journal of Advanced Nursing21 (1995) 1081-1086 .
9.
[9] P. Ley , Satisfaction compliance and communication , British Journal of Clinical Psychology21 (1982) 241-254 .
10.
[10] S. Greenfield , S. Kaplan and J.E. Ware , Expanding patient involvement in care: effects on patient outcomes , Annals of Internal Medicine102(4) (1985) 520-528 .
11.
[11] S.A. Mazzuca , Does patient education in chronic disease have therapeutic value?Journal of Chronic Disease35 (1982) 521-529 .
12.
[12] Cyber Dialogue , Cybercitizen Health 2000. Available at: www.cyberdialogue.com (5 January 2001).
13.
thinking IT and Health ( Institiute for Public Policy Research, London , 1998)
14.
[14] B.G. Quick, The Role of Support Groups on the Internet for Those Suffering from Chronic Kidney Disease (University of The Pacific, 1999) [Volume 3705 of Dissertation Abstracts International, p. 1522.]
15.
[15] E.S. Bacon, A Description of an Internet Self -Help Group for Widows with Dependent Children (MSc thesis) (Hampton University, 1999) [Volume 3705 of Dissertation Abstracts International, p. 1432.]
16.
[16] J. Finn , An exploration of helping processes in an online self-help group focusing on issues of disability , Health and Social Work24(3) (1999) 220-231 .
17.
[17] A.R. Jadad , Promoting partnerships: challenges for the Internet age , British Medical Journal319 (1999) 761-764 .
18.
[18] H. Rumbelow , Doctors usurped by the Internet , The Times (6 November 1999) 7 .
19.
[19] Available at: www.surgerydoor.co.uk - 3W Marketing Ltd was responsible for gathering the information, but not its analysis.
20.
[20] C.B. Smith , Casting the net: surveying an Internet population , JCMC3(1) (1997). Available at: http://www.ascusc.org/jcmc/vol3/issue1 (28 February 2001).
21.
[21] Intouch with Health, owner of the site, confirms that no special marketing programmes have targeted women.
22.
[22] D. Nicholas , P. Huntington and P. Williams , Developing and testing methods to determine the use of web sites: case study newspapers , Aslib Proceedings51(5) (1999) 144-154 .
23.
[23] HONF (Health On The Net Foundation) , HONF’s fourth survey on the use of the Internet for medical and health purposes (1999). Available at: www.honf.ch/Survey/ (accessed 17 April 2000).
24.
[24] D. Nicholas , P. Williams , H. Martin and P. Cole , The Media and the Internet ( Aslib, London , 1998).
25.
[25] P. Williams and D. Nicholas , Not an age thing! Grey-netters in the newsroom defy the stereotype , New Library World99(1142) (1998) 143-148 .
26.
[26] P. Williams and D. Nicholas , The Internet and the Changing Information Environment ( Aslib, London , 2000).P 276276
27.
[27] B. Marsh , GP tells sick not to call ‘dangerous’ NHS helpline , Daily Mail (22 February 2000) 41 .
28.
[28] J. Carvel , Doctors attack ‘consumerist’ NHS initiatives , The Guardian (27 June 2000) 9 .
29.
[29] British Medical Association , Health Which? And NHS Direct - BMA Comment (BMA Press Release) ( BMA, London , 2000). Available at: http://web.bma.org.uk/pressrel.nsf/a4a6effeb2d171b8802568590051feb8/3b29a1270768f118802569350032e09c?OpenDocument
30.
[30] The hypothesis of no association between nature of interest and if the information found improved their condition is rejected at the 5% significance level (chi = 27.47, df = 10, p = 0.002).
31.
[31] The hypothesis of no association between Internet use and if the information helped them to become better informed is rejected at the 5% significance level (chi = 35.30, df = 8).
32.
[32] The hypothesis of no association between trust of site and the four outcomes (‘helped with talking to doctor’, ‘felt better informed’, ‘changed attitude towards condition’ and ‘improved condition’) are rejected at the 5% significance level (chi = 13.94, df = 2, p = 0.001; chi = 59.62, df = 2, p = 0.000; chi = 21.41, df = 2, p = 0.000; chi = 16.627, df = 2, p = 0.000).
33.
[33] There were four possible responses: poor, OK, good and excellent.
34.
[34] R.H. Corney , Sex differences in general practice attendance and help seeking for minor illness , Journal of Psychosomatic Research34(5) (1990) 525-534 .
35.
[35] W.A. Norcross , C. Ramirez and L.A. Palinkas , The influence of women on the health care-seeking behavior of men , Journal of Family Practice43(5) (1996) 475-480 .
36.
[36] The January 2001 edition of Reader’s Digest, for example, contains the health-related article ‘Health heroes’ (available at: http://www.rdhealth.com/internal/heroes/) and BBC Online often contains information about health that ties in with TV programmes.
