The Differential Contribution of Field-dependent and Field-independent Cognitive Styles to Sociocognitive Transaction in Promoting Scientific Reasoning

Abstract

This study examines the influence of two types of conflict-arousing intervention on reasoning about speed among subjects with different cognitive styles. It focuses on the types of argumentations provided in sociocognitive transaction by field-dependent and field-independent subjects and on the role of such argumentations in cognitive change. A total of 360 6th, 8th, and 10th graders participated in four stages: individual pre-test; interventioninterpersonal conflict (created by sociocognitive transaction) or intrapersonal conflict (created by multiple-choice testing); immediate post-test: and delayed post-test. In each stage subjects dealt with speed problems involving both linear and rotational motions. Sociocognitive transaction was found to be efficacious in improving the understanding of the speed concept, especially for field-dependent subjects. Analyses of the cognitive and social aspects of the transaction discourse revealed that although field-independent subjects made a greater cognitive contribution, field-dependent subjects' contribution was closer to co-subjectivity. The results suggest that sociocognitive transaction is an appropriate learning environment in the subject of physics for fielddependent as well as field-independent subjects.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Acredolo, C. , & Schmid, J. (1981). The understanding of relative speeds, distances and durations of movement . Developmental Psychology, 17, 490-493 .

Ames, G.J. , & Murray, F.B. (1982). When two wrongs make a right: Promoting cognitive change by social conflict . Developmental Psychology, 18, 894-897 .

Azmitia, M. (1988). Peer interaction and problem solving: When are two heads better than one? Child Development, 59, 87-96 .

Bearison, J.D. , Magzamen, S. , & Filardo, E.K. (1986). Socio-cognitive conflict and cognitive growth in young children . Merrill-Palmer Quarterly, 2, 51-72 .

Case, R. (1974). Structures and strictures: Some functional limitations of the course of cognitive growth . Cognitive Psychology, 6, 544-573 .

Case, R. (1975). Gearing the demands of instruction to the developmental capacities of the learner . Review of Educational Research, 45, 59-87 .

Case, R. , & Globerson, T. (1974). Field independence and central computing space . Child Development, 45, 772-778 .

Case, R. , & Pascual-Leone, J. (1975). Failure of conservation training of disadvantaged black teenagers: A neo-Piagetion interpretation . Perceptual and Motor Skills, 40, 545-546 .

Doise. W. , & Mugny, G. (1979). Individual and collective conflicts of centrations in cognitive development . European Journal of Social Psychology, 9, 105-108 .

10.

Doise, W. , & Mugny, G. (1984). The social development of the intellect. New York: Pergamon .

11.

Doise, W. , Mugny, G. , & Perret-Clermont, A.N. (1975). Social interaction and the development of cognitive operations . European Journal of Social Psychology, 5, 367-383 .

12.

Ehri, L.C. , & Muzio, I.M. (1974). Cognitive style and reasoning about speed . Journal of Educational Psychology, 66, 569-571 .

13.

Federico, P.A. (1980). Adapting instruction: Trends and issues. In R.E. Snow , P.A. Federico , & W.E. Montague (Eds.), Aptitude, learning and instruction. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Inc.

14.

Fireman, G. & Kose, G. (1990). Piaget, Vygotsky, and the development of consciousness . The Genetic Epistemologist, 18, 17-23 .

15.

Frank, B.M. (1984). Effect of field independence-dependence and study technique on learning from a lecture . American Educational Research Journal, 21, 669-678 .

16.

Frank, B.M. (1986). Cognitive styles and teacher education: Field dependence and areas of specialization among teacher education majors . Journal of Educational Research, 80, 19-22 .

17.

Garlinger, D.K. , & Frank, B.M. (1986). Teacher-student cognitive style and academic achievement: A review and mini meta-analysis . Journal of Classroom Interaction, 21, 2-8 .

18.

Globerson, T. (1977). Field independence information processing capacity, and mental effort . Dissertation Abstracts International, 37(9-A), 56-98 .

19.

Globerson, T. (1983). Mental capacity, mental effort and cognitive style . Developmental Review, 3, 292-302 .

20.

Globerson, T. (1989). What is the relationship between cognitive style and cognitive development? In T. Globerson & T. Zelniker (Eds.), Cognitive style and cognitive development. Norwood, NJ: Ablex .

21.

Globerson, T. , & Case, R. (1974). Field dependence and central computing space . Child Development, 45, 772-778 .

22.

Goodenough, D.R. (1976). The role of individual differences in field dependence as a factor in learning and memory . Psychological Bulletin, 83, 675-694 .

23.

Hutchins, E. (1991). The social organization of distributed cognition. In L.B. Resnick , J.M. Levine , & S.D. Teasley (Eds.), Perspectives on socially shared cognition (pp. 283-307). Washington, DC: American Psychology Association .

24.

Kogan, N. (1971). Educational implications of cognitive styles. In G.S. Lesser (Ed.), Psychology and educational practice (pp. 242-292). London: Scott, Foresman & Company .

25.

Kogan, N. , & Saarni, C. (1989). Cognitive styles in children: Some evolving trends . Early Child Development and Care, 43, 101-128 .

26.

Levin, I. , & Druyan, S. (1993). When socio-cognitive transaction among peers fails: The case of misconceptions in science . Child Development, 64, 1571-1591 .

27.

Levin, I. , & Gardosh, R. (1994). Everyday concepts and formal concepts: Do children distinguish between linear and rotational speed? In D. Tirosh (Ed.), Implicit and explicit knowledge: An educational approach (pp. 181-203). Norwood, NJ: Ablex .

28.

Levin, I. , Siegler, R.S. , & Druyan, S. (1990). Misconceptions about motion: Development and training effects . Child Development, 61, 1544-1557 .

29.

Linn, M.C. (1978). Influence of cognitive style and training on tasks requiring the separation of variables scheme . Child Development, 49, 874-877 .

30.

Linn, M.C. , & Kyllonen, P.K. (1981). The field dependence-independence construct some, one or none . Journal of Educational Psychology, 73, 261-273 .

31.

Lovell, K. , Kellett, V.L. , & Moorehouse, E. (1962). The growth of the concept of speed: A comparative study . Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 3, 101-110 .

32.

Messick, S. (1976). Personality consistencies in cognition and creativity. In S. Messick (Ed.), Individuality in learning (pp. 4-22). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass .

33.

Miller, M. (1987). Argumentation and cognition. In M. Hickmann (Ed.), Social and functional approaches to language and thought (pp. 37-62). San Diego, CA: Academic Press .

34.

Nastasi, B.K. , Clements, D.H. , & Battista, M.T. (1990). Social cognitive interactions, motivation and cognitive growth in Logo programming and CAI problem solving environments . Journal of Educational Psychology, 82, 150-158 .

35.

Oltman, P.R. (1968). The portable Rod-and-Frame apparatus . Perceptual and Motor Skills, 26, 503-506 .

36.

Pascual-Leone, J. (1969). Cognitive development and cognitive style: A general psychological integration. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Geneva.

37.

Pascual-Leone, J. (1970). A mathematical model for the transition rule in Piaget's developmental stages . Acta Psychologica, 32, 301-345 .

38.

Pascual-Leone, J. (1974). A new-Piagetian process-structural model of Witkin's psychological differentiation . Paper presented at the meeting of the international association for cross-cultural psychology, Kingston, Ontario.

39.

Perret-Clermont, A.N. , & Schubauer-Leoni, M.L. (1981). Conflict and cooperation as opportunities for learning. In W.P. Robinson (Ed.), European monographs in social psychology (Vol. 24, pp. 203-231). New York: Academic Press .

40.

Piaget, J. (1932). The moral judgment of the child. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul .

41.

Piaget, J. (1970). The child's conception of movement and speed. New York: Basic Books . (Original work published 1946)

42.

Piaget, J. (1971). Biology and knowledge. University of Chicago Press .

43.

Piaget, J. (1980). Experiments in contradiction. University of Chicago Press . (Original work published 1974)

44.

Rogoff, B. (1990). Apprenticeship in thinking: cognitive development in social context. New York: Oxford University Press .

45.

Ronning, R.R. , Mccurdy, D. , & Ballinger, R. (1984). Individual differences: A third component in problem-solving instruction . Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 21, 71-82 .

46.

Russell, J. (1982). Cognitive conflict transmission and justification: Conservation attainment through dyadic interaction . Journal of Genetic Psychology, 140, 283-297 .

47.

Russell, J. , Mills, I. , & Reiff-Musgrove, P. (1990). The role of symmetrical and asymmetrical social conflict in cognitive change . Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 49, 58-78 .

48.

Siegler, R.S. , & Richards, D.D. (1979). The development of time, speed and distance concepts . Developmental Psychology, 15, 288-298 .

49.

Tanaka, M. (1971). The development of the concept of speed . Journal of Child Development, 7, 1-11 .

50.

Tudge, J.R.H. , & Rogoff, B. (1989). Peer influence on cognitive development: Piagetian and Vygotskian perspectives. In M. Bornstein & J. Bruner (Eds.), Interaction in human development. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Inc.

51.

Vernon, P.E. (1973). Multivariate approaches to the study of cognitive styles. In J.R. Royce (Ed.), Multivariate analysis and psychological theory (pp. 125-148). New York: Academic Press .

52.

Viennot, L. (1979). Spontaneous reasoning in elementary dynamics . European Journal of Science Education, 1, 205-221 .

53.

Vygotsky, L.S. (1962). Thought and language. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press .

54.

Vygotsky, L.S. (1978). Mind in society. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .

55.

Witkin, H.A. , Moore, C.A. , Goodenough, D.R. , & Cox, P.W. (1977). Field-dependent and field-independent cognitive styles and their educational implications . Review of Educational Research, 47, 1-64 .

56.

Witkin, H.A. , Oltman, P.K. , Raskin, E. , & Karp, S.A. (1971). A manual for the embedded figures tests. Palo Alto, CA: Consulting Psychologists Press .

57.

Za'rour, I.G. , & Khuri, A.G. (1977). The development of the concept of speed by Jordanian children in Amman. In P.R. Dasen (Ed.), Piagetian psychology: Cross cultural contributions. New York: Gardner .