Two experiments were conducted to investigate the assumption that rich domain
knowledge can compensate for low overall aptitude on domain-related cognitive tasks.
Whereas previous research dealing with text recall and text comprehension tasks has
provided evidence supporting this assumption, recent studies examining the effects
of both expertise and intelligence on a strategic memory task (sort-recall task)
found that the effects of domain knowledge were not strong enough to eliminate
performance differences between high-and low-aptitude experts. In our experiments,
both text-recall and sort-recall measures related to the game of soccer were
presented to high-and low-aptitude fourth-grade children who were either soccer
experts or novices, using a within-subjects design. The main difference between the
two studies concerned the testing procedure: Whereas in Study 1 testing was
conducted in small groups, in Study 2 children were tested individually. Both
studies confirmed the outcome of previous research; that is, effects of aptitude on
text recall and comprehension were eliminated when the impact of expertise was
considered simultaneously. However, they also replicated the earlier finding that
this pattern of results does not generalise to other memory tasks. That is,
expertise does reduce but not eliminate the relationship of IQ to memory tasks
involving deliberate strategies.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alexander, J.M.
,
Schwanenflugel, P.J.
(1994).
Strategy regulation: The role of intelligence, metacognitive attributes,
and knowledge base
. Developmental Psychology, 30,
709-723
.
2.
Amstad, T. (1978). Wie verstandlich sind unsere Zeitungen?
Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Zurich.
3.
Bjorklund, D.F.
(1985). The role of conceptual knowledge in the
development of organization in children's memory. In
C.J. Brainerd
&
M. Pressley
(Eds.), Basic processes in memory development (pp.
103-142).
New York: Springer
.
4.
Bjorklund, D.F.
(1987).
How age changes in knowledge base contribute to the development of
children's memory: An interpretative review
. Developmental Review, 7,
93-130
.
5.
Bjorklund, D.F.
, &
Bjorklund, B.R.
(1985).
Organization versus item effects of an elaborated knowledge base on
children's memory
. Developmental Psychology, 21,
1120-1131
.
6.
Bjorklund, D.F.
,
Muir-Broaddus, J.E.
, &
Schneider, W.
(1990). The role of knowledge in the development of
strategies. In
D.F. Bjorklund
(Ed.), Children's strategies: Contemporary views of cognitive
development (pp. 93-128).
Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Inc.
7.
Bjorklund, D.F.
,
Schneider, W.
,
Harnishfeger, K.K.
,
Cassel, W.S.
,
Bjorklund, B.R.
, &
Bernholtz, J.E.
(1992).
The role of IQ, expertise, and motivation in the recall of familiar information
. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 17,
340-355
.
8.
Bjorklund, D.F.
, &
Zeman, B.R.
(1982).
Children's organization and metamemory awareness in their recall of
familiar information
. Child Development, 53,
799-810
.
9.
Bousfield, W.A.
(1953).
The occurrence of clustering in the recall of randomly arranged associates
. Journal of Genetic Psychology, 49,
229-240
.
10.
Brown, A.L.
,
Bransford, J.D.
,
Ferrara, R.A.
, &
Campione, J.C.
(1983). Learning, remembering, and understanding.
In
J.H. Flavell
&
E.M. Markman
(Eds.), Handbook of child psychology: Vol. III. Cognitive
development (pp. 77-166).
New York: Wiley
.
11.
Ceci, S.J.
(1990). On intelligence... More or less: A bio-ecological
theory of intellectual development.
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall
.
12.
Ceci, S.J.
, &
Liker, J.
(1986).
A day at the races: The study of IQ, expertise, and cognitive complexity
. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 115,
225-266
.
Chi, M.T.H.
(1978). Knowledge structures and memory
development. In
R.S. Siegler
(Ed.), Children's thinking: What develops? (pp.
73-96).
Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Inc.
15.
Chi, M.T.H.
(1985a).
Changing conception of sources of memory development
. Human Development, 28,
50-56
.
16.
Chi, M.T.H.
(1985b). Interactive roles of knowledge and strategies in
the development of organized sorting and recall. In
S.F. Chipman
,
J.W. Segal
, &
R. Glaser
(Eds.), Thinking and learning skills. Research and open questions (Vol.
2, pp. 457-483).
Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Inc.
17.
Chi, M.T.H.
, &
Ceci, S.J.
(1987). Content knowledge: Its role, representation, and
restructuring in memory development. In
H.W. Reese
(Ed.), Advances in child development and behavior (Vol. 20, pp.
91-142).
Orlando, FL: Academic Press
.
18.
Fivush, R.
, &
Hamond, N.R.
(1990). Autobiographical memory across the preschool
years: Toward reconceptualizing childhood amnesia. In
R. Fivush
&
J.A. Hudson
(Eds.), Knowing and remembering in young children (pp.
223-248).
Cambridge University Press
.
19.
Frankel, M.T.
, &
Rollins, H.A.
(1982).
Age-related differences in clustering: A new approach
. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 34,
113-122
.
20.
Gaultney, J.F.
,
Bjorklund, D.F.
, &
Schneider, W.
(1992).
The role of children's expertise in a strategic memory task
. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 17,
244-257
.
21.
Hasher, L.
, &
Zacks, R.T.
(1979).
Automatic and effortful processing in memory
. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 108,
356-388
.
22.
Hasselhorn, M.
(1990).
The emergence of strategic knowledge activation in categorical clustering
during retrieval
. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 50,
59-80
.
23.
Hasselhorn, M.
(1992).
Task dependency and the role of category typicality and metamemory in the
development of an organizational strategy
. Child Development, 63,
202-214
.
24.
Heller, M.S.
,
Gadike, A.K.
, &
Weinlader, H.
(1985). Kognitiver Fahigkeitstest fur Kinder (KFT
4-13).
Weinheim: Beltz
.
25.
Hudson, J.A.
(1990). The emergence of autobiographical memory in
mother-child conversation. In
R. Fivush
&
J.A. Hudson
(Eds.), Knowing and remembering in young children (pp.
166-196).
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
26.
Johnson, N.S.
, &
Mandler, J.M.
(1980).
A tale of two structures: Underlying surface forms in stories
. Poetics, 9,
51-86
.
27.
Kee, D.W.
(1994). The development of associative memory. In
H.W. Reese
(Ed.), Advances in child development and behavior (Vol. 28, pp.
7-32).
New York: Academic Press
.
28.
Kee, D.W.
, &
Bell, T.S.
(1981).
The development of organizational strategies in the storage and retrieval
of categorical items in free-recall learning
. Child Development, 52,
1163-1171
.
29.
Mandler, J.M.
, &
Johnson, N.S.
(1977).
Remembrance of things parsed: Story structure and recall
. Cognitive Psychology, 9,
111-151
.
30.
Muir-Broaddus, J.E.
, &
Bjorklund, D.F.
(1990). Developmental and individual differences in
children's memory strategies: The role of knowledge. In
W. Schneider
&
F.E. Weinert
(Eds.), Interactions among aptitudes, strategies, and knowledge in
cognitive performance (pp. 99-116).
New York: Springer
.
31.
Murphy, M.D.
, &
Puff, C.R.
(1982). Free recall: Basic methodology and
analyses. In
C.R. Puff
(Ed.), Handbook of research methods in human memory and cognition
(pp. 99-128).
New York: Academic Press
.
32.
Ornstein, P.A.
,
Baker-Ward, L.
, &
Naus, M.J.
(1988). The development of mnemonic skill. In
F.E. Weinert
&
M. Perlmutter
(Eds.), Memory development: Universal changes and individual
differences (pp. 31-50).
Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Inc.
33.
Ornstein, P.A.
, &
Naus, M.J.
(1985). Effects of the knowledge base on children's memory
strategies. In
H.W. Reese
(Ed.), Advances in child development and behavior (Vol. 19, pp.
113-148).
Orlando, FL: Academic Press
.
34.
Pentenrieder, J. (in preparation). Der Einfluss von Strategien und
Vorwissen auf das Lernen. [The impact of strategies and the knowledge base on
children's learning]. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Max Planck
Institute for Psychological Research, Munich.
35.
Pressley, M.
,
Borkowski, J.G.
, &
O'Sullivan, J.
(1985). Children's metamemory and the teaching of memory
strategies. In
D.L. Forrest-Pressley
,
G.E. MacKinnon
, &
T.G. Waller
(Eds.), Metacognition, cognition, and human performance (pp.
111-153).
Orlando, FL: Academic Press
.
36.
Pressley, M.
, &
Van Meter, P.
(1993). Memory strategies: Natural development and use
following instruction. In
R. Pasnak
&
M.L. Howe
(Eds.), Emerging themes in cognitive development (Vol. 2, pp.
125-165).
New York: Springer
.
37.
Rabinowitz, M.
(1984).
The use of categorical organization: Not an all-or-none situation
. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 38,
338-351
.
38.
Recht, D.R.
, &
Leslie, L.
(1988).
Effect of prior knowledge on good and poor readers' memory of text
. Journal of Educational Psychology, 80,
16-20
.
39.
Roth, C.
(1983).
Factors affecting developmental changes in the speed of processing
. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 35,
509-528
.
40.
Schneider, W.
(1986).
The role of conceptual knowledge and metamemory in the development of
organizational processes in memory
. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 42,
218-236
.
41.
Schneider, W.
(1993).
Domain-specific knowledge and memory performance in children
. Educational Psychology Review, 5,
257-274
.
42.
Schneider, W.
, &
Bjorklund, D.F.
(1992).
Expertise, aptitude, and strategic remembering
. Child Development, 63,
461-473
.
43.
Schneider, W.
,
Gruber, H.
,
Gold, A.
, &
Opwis, K.
(1993).
Chess expertise and memory for chess positions in children and adults
. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 56,
328-349
.
44.
Schneider, W.
, &
Korkel, J.
(1989).
The knowledge base and text recall: Evidence from a short-term longitudinal study
. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 14,
382-393
.
45.
Schneider, W.
,
Kbrkel, J.
, &
Weinert, F.E.
(1989).
Domain-specific knowledge and memory performance: A comparison of high-and
low-aptitude children
. Journal of Educational Psychology, 81,
306-312
.
46.
Schneider, W.
,
Korkel, J.
, &
Weinert, F.E.
(1990). Expert knowledge, general abilities, and text
processing. In
W. Schneider
&
F.E. Weinert
(Eds.), Interactions among aptitudes, strategies, and knowledge in
cognitive performance (pp. 235-251).
New York: Springer
.
47.
Schneider, W.
, &
Pressley, M.
(1989). Memory development between 2 and 20.
New York: Springer
.
48.
Voss, J.F.
,
Fincher-Kiefer, R.H.
,
Greene, T.R.
, &
Post, T.A.
(1986). Individual differences in performance: The
contrastive approach to knowledge. In
R.J. Sternberg
(Ed.), Advances in the psychology of human intelligence (Vol. 3,
pp. 297-334).
Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Inc.
49.
Walker, C.H.
(1987).
Relative importance of domain knowledge and overall aptitude on acquisition
of domain-related information
. Cognition and Instruction, 4,
25-42
.
