Understanding of Horizontality in College Women: Effects of Two Training Procedures

Abstract

Previous research has shown that many college females cannot correctly represent the horizontal on the Piagetian water-level task. The present study focuses on some possible reasons for this and attempts to determine if performance on the task can be modified. Sixty-eight college women were tested on the water-level task and on related measures of verticality, spatial relations, and cognitive style. Those failing the water-level task (N = 49) were assigned to one of three conditions: (a) physical knowledge training, (b) Euclidean reference training, or (c) a control group, and then were retested on the same measures. As predicted, both training groups improved on the water-level task while the control group did not. However, contrary to predictions, reference training did not show transfer to related measures. The results have implications for understanding the role of experience in spatial abilities.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Blatter, P. , 1983. Training in spatial ability: a test of Sherman's hypothesis . Perceptual and Motor Skills 57, 987-992 .

Connor, J.M. , M. Schackman and L.A. Serbin , 1978. Sex-related differences in response to practice on a visual-spatial test and generalization to a related test . Child Development 49, 24-29 .

Geiringer, E. and J. Hyde , 1976. Sex differences on Piaget's water-level task: spatial ability incognito . Perceptual and Motor Skills 42, 1323-1328 .

Goldberg, J. and W. Meredith , 1975. A longitudinal study of spatial ability . Behavior Genetics 5, 127-133 .

Goldstein, A.G. and J.E. Chance , 1965. Effects of practice on sex-related differences in performance on Embedded Figures . Psychonomic Science 3, 361-361 .

Johnson, S. , J.M. Flinn and Z.E. Tyer , 1979. Effect of practice and training in spatial skills on Embedded Figures scores of males and females . Perceptual and Motor Skills 48, 975-984 .

Kelly, J.T. and G.N. Kelly , 1977. Perception of horizontality by male and female college students . Perceptual and Motor Skills 44, 724-726 .

Kuhn, D. , 1974. Inducing development experimentally: comments on a research paradigm . Developmental Psychology 10, 590--600 .

Liben, L.S. , 1978. Performance on Piagetian spatial tasks as a function of sex, field dependence, and training . Merrill-Palmer Quarterly 24, 97-109 .

10.

Liben, L.S. and S.L. Golbeck , 1980. Sex differences in performance on Piagetian spatial tasks: differences in competence or performance? Child Development 51, 594-597 .

11.

Liben, L.S. and S.L. Golbeck , 1984. Performance on Piagetian horizontality and verticality tasks: sex-related differences in knowledge of relevant physical phenomena . Developmental Psychology 20, 595-606 .

12.

McGee, M.G. , 1978. Effects of training and practice on sex differences in mental rotation test scores . The Journal of Psychology 100, 87-90 .

13.

McGillicuddy-DeLisi, A. , R. DeLisi and J. Youniss , 1978. Representation of the horizontal with and without liquid . Merrill-Palmer Quarterly 24, 201-201 .

14.

Neimark, E. , 1981. 'Confounding with cognitive style factors: an artifact explanation for the apparent non-universal incidence of formal operations'. In: I. Sigel , D.M. Brodzinsky and R.M. Golinkoff (eds.), New directions in Piagetian theory. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum . pp. 177-189.

15.

Piaget, J. and B. Inhelder , 1956. The child's conception of space. New York: Norton .

16.

Rebelsky, F. , 1964. Adult perception of the horizontal . Perceptual and Motor Skills 19, 371-374 .

17.

Sherman, J.A. , 1974. Field articulation, sex, spatial visualization, dependency, practice, laterality of the brain and birth order . Perceptual and Motor Skills 38, 1223-1235 .

18.

Thomas, H. and W. Jamison , 1975. On the acquisition of understanding that still water is horizontal . Merrill-Palmer Quarterly 21, 31-53 .

19.

Thomas, H. , W. Jamison and D. Hummel , 1973. Observation is insufficient for discovering that the surface of still water is invariantly horizontal . Science 181, 173-174 .

20.

Thurstone, L.L. and T.G. Thurstone , 1963. Primary mental abilities. Chicago, IL: Science Research Associates .

21.

Willemson, E. , A. Bucholz , M.S. Budrow and N. Giannacopulus , 1973. The relationship between Witkin's Rod and Frame task and Piaget's water-level task for college women . Journal of Perceptual and Motor Skills 36, 958-958 .

22.

Witkin, H.A. , 1959. The perception of the upright . Scientific American 200, 50-56 .

23.

Witkin, H.A. and D.R. Goodenough , 1977. Field dependence and interpersonal behavior . Psychological Bulletin 84, 661-689 .

24.

Witkin, H.A. , P. Oltman , E. Raskin and S. Karp , 1971. Embedded Figures test. Palo Alto, CA: Consulting Psychologists Press, Inc.