In,on,and under: Examining the Relationship between Cognitive and Language Skills

Abstract

Based on language comprehension data, previous literature had suggested that cognitive rules determined the order of acquisition of the spatial concepts 'in', 'on', and 'under'. However, this research had not independently assessed language and cognitive sequences in the same children. The present research examined the order of emergence of these concepts using both a non-verbal cognitive task and linguistic comprehension and production tasks. Subjects were 75 Israeli children between 14 and 30 months of age. In the cognitive tasks, children actively manipulated blocks in procedures designed to elicit the three types of space. In the language tasks, children were either asked to follow verbal instructions of the form "put X (in, on or under) the Y", or to use the respective locatives in their language. Scalogram analyses of the construction, comprehension, and production tasks indicated that 'in' space developed earlier than 'on' space, which developed before 'under' space. In general, cognitive tasks were solved prior to language comprehension tasks, which occurred prior to language production tasks. The discussion concludes that the same underlying skills are necessary for the solution of both the cognitive and language tasks.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bates, E. ( with L. Benigni , I. Bretherton , L. Camaioni and V. Volterra ), 1979. The emergence of symbols. New York: Academic Press .

Bower, T.G.R. , 1974. Development in infancy. San Francisco, CA: W.H. Freeman .

Brown, R. , 1973. A first language. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .

Clark, E. , 1973. Non-linguistic strategies and the acquisition of word meanings . Cognition 2, 161-182 .

Corrigan, R. , 1979. Cognitive correlates of language: differential criteria yield differential results . Child Development 50, 617-631 .

Corrigan, R. , E. Halpern , O. Aviezer and A. Goldblatt , 1981. The development of three spatial concepts: in, on, under . International Journal of Behavioral Development 4, 403-419 .

Fischer, K. , 1980. A theory of cognitive development: control and construction of a hierarchy of skills . Psychological Review 87, 477-531 .

Fischer, K. and R. Corrigan , 1981. 'A skill approach to language development'. In: R. Stark (ed.), Language behavior in infancy and early childhood. Amsterdam: Elsevier .

Gouin-Decarie, T. , 1965. Intelligence and affectivity in early childhood. New York: International Universities Press .

10.

Greenfield, P.M. , K. Nelson and E. Saltzman , 1972. The development of rule bound strategies for manipulating seriated cups. A parallel between action and grammar . Cognitive Psychology 3, 291-310 .

11.

Halpern, E. and O. Aviezer , 1976. Psycholinguistic skills and sensory-motor development within a Piagetian theoretical framework . Paper presented at the 21st International Congress of Psychology, Paris.

12.

Halpern, E. and O. Aviezer , 1979. An investigation of the appearance of three spatial concepts: in, on, under . Paper presented at the International Congress of Psychology of the Child, Paris.

13.

Halpern, E. , R. Corrigan and O. Aviezer , in press. Two types of "under"? Implications for the relationship between cognition and language . International Journal of Psycholinguistics.

14.

Hoogenraad, R. , R. Grieve , P. Baldwin and R.N. Campbell , 1978. 'Comprehension as an interactive process'. In: R. Campbell and P. Smith (eds.). The Sterling psychology of language conference, Vol. 1: Language development and mother-child interaction. London: Plenum .

15.

McCall, R. , R. Parke and R. Kavanaugh , 1977. Imitation of live and televised models by children one to three years of age . Monographs of the Society to Research in Child Development 42 (5, Serial No. 173).

16.

McNeill, D. , 1970. 'The development of language'. In: P.A. Mussen (ed.), Carmichael's manual of child psychology, Vol. 1. (3rd ed.) New York: Wiley .

17.

Moore, M.K. and A.N. Meltzoff , 1978. 'Object permanence, imitation and language development in infancy. Toward a Neo-Piagetian perspective on communicative and cognitive development'. In: F. Minifie and L. Lloyd (eds.), Communicative and cognitive development early behavioral assessment.

18.

Nelson, K. , 1979. 'The role of language in infant development'. In: M. Bornstein and W. Kessen (eds.), Psychological development from infancy: image to intention. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum .

19.

Nie, N. , C. Hull , J. Jenkins , K. Steinbrenner and D. Bent , 1975. Statistical package for the social sciences. New York: McGraw Hill .

20.

Schlesinger, I.M. , 1977. The role of cognitive development and linguistic input in language acquisition . Journal of Child Language 4, 153-170 .

21.

Schlesinger, I.M. , 1982. Steps to language: toward a theory of native' language acquisition. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum .

22.

Slobin, D.I. , 1971. 'Developmental psycholinguistics'. In: W.O. Dingwall (ed.), A survey of linguistic science. College Park, MD: University of Maryland Press .

23.

Torgerson, W.S. , 1963. Theory and method of scaling. New York: Wiley .

24.

Watson, M. and K. Fischer , 1977. A developmental sequence of agent use in late infancy . Child Development 48, 828-836 .

25.

Wilcox, S. and D. Palermo , 1974/75. In, on, and under revisited . Cognition 3, 245-254 .