The Development of Referential Communication in Deaf and Hearing Children: Competence and Style

Abstract

The paper examines the development of communicative competence in deaf children and its interactions with the use of gestures and/or words to comunicate. Deaf children, in addition to the cognitive problem involved in communication, must also choose a particular channel to produce the verbal and/or gestural message. In the first experiment the experimenter designated one out of four drawings to the "transmitter", who had to produce a message for the "receiver" to enable him to identify the drawing. The data show that (1) the use of gestures to communicate increases with age while the speech used remains constant, and (2) the amount of gestures used is correlated with communicative accuracy. A possible explanation of these data is that the increased use of gestures has a cognitive base: i.e., that it comes from a better understanding of the communication situation. Experiment 2 is aimed to test this hypothesis. The main results show that individual differences in communicative competence are correlated with the use of gestures but not with the use of speech, and that children increased the number of gestures, but not the number of words, when communication difficulty increased.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Asher, S.R. , 1976. Children's ability to appraise their own and other person's communicative performance . Developmental Psychology 12, 24-32 ;

Asher, S.R. , 1979. 'Referential communication'. In: G.K. Whitehurst and B.J. Zimmerman (eds.), The function of language and cognition. New York: Academic Press . pp. 175-198.

Asher, S.R. and S.L. Oden , 1976. Children's failure to communicate: an assessment of comparison and egocentrism explanations . Developmental Psychology 12, 132-139 .

Bellugi, U. and E. Klima , 1975. 'Aspects of sign language and its structure'. In: J.F. Kavanagh and J.E. Cutting (eds.), The role of speech in language. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press . pp. 171-203.

Glucksberg, S. and R.M. Krauss , 1967. What do people say after they have learned how to talk? Studies of the development of referential communication . Merrill-Palmer Quarterly 13, 309-316 .

Glucksberg, S. , R.M. Krauss and R. Weisberg , 1966. Referential communication in nursery school children: method and some preliminary findings . Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 3, 333-342 .

Maratsos, M.P. , 1973. Monegocentric communication abilities in preschool children . Child Development 44, 697-700 .

Martens, A.F., V. Poncelet and J. Alegria, 1980. Developpement de l'habilete a communiquer chez l'enfant sourd: effets d'un entrainement bref au moyen de tdches logiques. In preparation.

Robinson, E.J. and W.P. Robinson , 1976a. Developmental changes in the child's explanation of communication failure . Australian Journal of Psychology 28, 155-165 .

10.

Robinson, E.J. and W.P. Robinson , 1976b. The young child's understanding of communication . Developmental Psychology 12, 328-333 .

11.

Robinson, E.J. and W.P. Robinson , 1977. The young child's explanation of communication failure: a re-interpretation of results . Perceptual and Motor Skills 44, 363-366 .