Life-Span Developmental Changes in Mnemonic Organization: A Multimethod Analysis

Abstract

A set of pictures of common objects classifiable either perceptually on the basis of five color categories or semantically on the basis of five categories of meaning was randomly arranged and presented to groups of 4-year old, 6-year old, 10-year old, adult and elderly adult subjects. Free recall was assessed for the tendency to cluster semantically related items and items of the same color. In a recognition memory task, the tendency for subjects to erroneously select semantically or chromatically similar distractors was measured. Subjects also classified the pictures in a free sorting task, and the amount of semantic and color sorting was measured. A maximum-likelihood multimethod factor analysis of the correlations among the measures of recall clustering, free sorting and recognition errors revealed significant convergent validity for consistent use of a semantic and perceptual organization strategy in the three tasks. Subsequent analysis of errorfree "latent" organization scores revealed that 10-year old, adult, and elderly adult subjects relied on a semantic strategy. Four and six-year olds encoded both semantic and perceptual information about the stimulus items, with the younger preschoolers relying primarily upon the latter when using an organizational strategy. Age differences in memory capacity did not substantially affect this developmental trend in strategy use. Implications of these findings for parallel developments in memory and cognition were discussed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Baltes, P.B. , 1968. Longitudinal and cross-sectional sequences for the study of age and generation effects . Human Development 11, 145-171 .

Bentler, P.M. , 1973. 'Assessment of developmental factor change at the individual and group level'. In: J.R. Nessleroade and H.W. Reese (eds.), Life-span developmental psychology: methodological issues. New York: Academic Press . pp. 145-174.

Bentler, P.M. , 1976. Multistructure statistical model applied to factor analysis . Multivariate Behavioral Research 11, 3-25 .

Bousfield, W.A. , J. Esterson and G.A. Whitmarsh , 1958. A study of developmental changes in conceptual and perceptual associative clustering . The Journal of Genetic Psychology 92, 95-102 .

Brown, R.M. , 1977. An examination of visual and verbal coding processes in preschool children . Child Development 48, 38-45 .

Bruner, J.S. , R.R. Olver and P.M. Greenfield , 1966. Studies in cognitive growth. New York: Wiley .

Campbell, D.T. and D.W. Fiske , 1959. Convergent and discriminant validation by the multitrait-multimethod matrix . Psychological Bulletin 81, 81-105 .

Craik, F.I.M. , 1977. 'Age differences in human memory'. In: J.E. Birren and K.W. Schaie (eds.), Handbook of the psychology of aging. New York: Van Nostrad Reinhold . pp. 384-420.

Craik, F.I.M. and B.A. Levy , 1976. 'The concept of primary memory'. In: W.K. Estes (ed.), Handbook of learning and cognitive processes, Vol. 4: Attention and memory. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates . pp. 133-176.

10.

Cronbach, L.J. , 1951. Coefficient alpha and the internal consistency of tests . Psychometrika 16, 297-334 .

11.

Denney, D.R. , 1975. Developmental changes in concept utilization among normal and retarded children . Developmental Psychology 11, 359-368 .

12.

Denney, D.R. and P.A. Moulton , 1976. Conceptual preferences among preschool children . Developmental Psychology 12, 509-513 .

13.

Denney, N.W. , 1974. Evidence for developmental changes in categorization criteria for children and adults . Human Development 17, 41-53 .

14.

Denney, N.W. and S.W. Cornelius , 1975. Class inclusion and multiple classification in middle and old age . Developmental Psychology 11, 521-522 .

15.

Denney, N.W. and M.L. Lennon , 1972. Classification: a comparison of middle and old age . Developmental Psychology 7, 210-213 .

16.

Denney, N.W. and M. Ziobrowski , 1972. Developmental changes in clustering criteria . Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 13, 275-282 .

17.

Flavell, J.H. , 1971. What is memory development the development of? Human Development 14, 272-278 .

18.

Friedman, H. , 1974. Interrelation of two types of immediate memory in the aged . Journal of Psychology 87, 177-181 .

19.

Goodson, B.D. and P.M. Greenfield , 1975. The search for structural principles in children's manipulative play: a parallel with linguistic development . Child Development 46, 734-746 .

20.

Greenfield, P.M. , K. Nelson and E. Saltzman , 1972. The development of rebound strategies for manipulating seriated cups: a parallel between grammar and action . Cognitive Psychology 3, 291-310 .

21.

Joreskog, K.G. , 1969. A general approach to confirmatory maximum likelihood factor analysis . Psychometrika 34, 183-202 .

22.

Jéeskog, K.G. , 1974. 'Analyzing psychological data by structural analysis of covariance matrices'. In: D.H. Krantz , R.C. Atkinson , R.D. Luce and P. Suppes (eds.), Contemporary developments in mathematical psychology, Vol. II: Measurement, psychophysics and neural information processing. San Francisco: W.H. Freeman . pp. 1-56.

23.

Joreskog, K.G. , G.T. Gruvaeus and M. van Thillo , 1970. ACOVS: a general computer program for analysis of covariance structures (ETS RB-10-15). Princeton, NJ: Educational Testing Service .

24.

Kail, R.V. and A.W. Siegel , 1977. 'The development of mnemonic encoding in children: from perception to abstraction'. In: R.V. Kail and J.W. Hagen (eds.), Perspectives on the development of memory and cognition. New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum . pp. 61-88.

25.

Kobasigawa, A. and R.R. Orr , 1973. Free recall and retrieval speed of categorized items by kindergarten children . Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 15, 187-192 .

26.

Melkman, R. and C. Deutsch , 1977. Memory functioning as related to developmental changes in bases of organization . Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 23, 84-97 .

27.

Moely, B.E. and S.I. Shapiro , 1971. Free recall and clustering at four age levels: effects of learning to learn and presentation method . Developmental Psychology 4, 490-490 .

28.

Murphy, M.D. , C.R. Puff and J.C. Campione , 1977. Clustering measures and organization theory . Paper presented at the biennial meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development, New Orleans, March 1977.

29.

Odom, R.D. and R.D. Guzman , 1972. Development of hierarchies of dimensional salience . Developmental Psychology 6, 271-287 .

30.

Osler, S.F. , M. Draxl and J. Madden , 1977. The utilization of verbal and perceptual cues by preschool children in concept identification problems . Child Development 48, 1071-1074 .

31.

Pellegrino, J.W. , 1975. A reply to Fender and Doubilet on the measurement of clustering . Psychological Bulletin 82, 66-67 .

32.

Perlmutter, M. and M. Ricks , 1979. Recall in preschool children . Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 21, 423-436 .

33.

Piaget, J. and B. Inhelder , 1973. Memory and intelligence. New York: Basic Books .

34.

Roenker, D.L. , C.P. Thompson and S.C. Brown , 1971. Comparison of measures for the estimation of clustering in recall . Psychological Bulletin 76, 46-48 .

35.

Sanders, S. , M. Laurendeau and J. Bergeron , 1966. Aging and the concept of space: the conservation of surfaces . Journal of Gerontology 21, 281-285 .

36.

Schaie, K.W. , 1965. A general model for the study of developmental problems . Psychological Bulletin 64, 92-107 .

37.

Schaie, K.W. , 1973. 'Methodological problems in descriptive developmental research on adulthood and aging'. In: J.R. Nesselroade and H.W. Reese (eds.), Life-span developmental psychology: methodological issues. New York: Academic Press . pp. 253-280.

38.

Walsh, D.A. , 1975. 'Age differences in learning and memory'. In: D.S. Woodruff and J.E. Birren (eds.), Aging: scientific perspectives and social issues. New York: D. Van Nostrand .

39.

Waugh, N.C. and D.A. Norman , 1965. Primary memory . Psychological Review 72, 89-104 .

40.

Wechsler, D.A. , 1949. Wechsler intelligence scale for children. New York: The Psychological Corporation .

41.

Winer, B.J. , 1971. Statistical principles in experimental design. (2nd ed.) New York: McGraw-Hill .

42.

Wingard, J.A., 1976. Life-span developmental changes in mnemonic organization. (Doctoral dissertation, University of California, Los Angeles, 1976.) Dissertation Abstracts International 37, 1951B-1952B. (University Microfilms No. 76-22, 225.)

43.

Wingard, J.A. , J.P. Buchanan and A. Burnell , 1978. Organizational changes in the memory of young children . Perceptual and Motor Skills 46, 735-742 .

44.

Worden, P.E. , 1976. The effects of classification structure on organized free recall in children . Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 22, 519-529 .