Aggressive behavior in childhood has long been separated into that which is
proactively motivated and that which is reactive. We report a meta-analytic review
of the existing empirical literature that examines the associations of each type of
aggression with six indices of psychosocial adjustment: internalizing problems,
emotional dysregulation and ADHD-type symptoms, delinquent behaviors, prosocial
behavior, sociometric status, and peer victimization. Even though not detectable in
most single studies, meta-analytic combination revealed that reactive aggression was
more strongly related to most of the indices of adjustment than was proactive
aggression. This difference was small, however, and we argue that the difficulty in
detecting differential correlates is due to the high intercorrelation between the
functions of aggression, which appears to be an artifact of traditional measurement
procedures. It is recommended that future research use measures that provide
distinct assessment of the functions in order to more clearly distinguish the
correlates of proactive and reactive aggression.
*Arsenio, W.F.
,
Gold, J.
, &
Adams, E.
(2004).
Adolescents' emotion expectancies regarding aggressive and
nonaggressive events: Connections with behavior problems
. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 89,
338–355
.
3.
*Atkins, M.S.
,
McKay, M.M.
,
Frazier, S.L.
,
Jakobsons, L.J.
,
Arvanitis, P.
,
Cunningham, T.
, et al. (2002).
Suspensions and detentions in an urban, low-income school: Punishment or reward?Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 30,
361–371
.
4.
Bandura, A.
(1973). Aggression: A social learning analysis.
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall
.
5.
Bandura, A.
(1986). Social foundations of thought and action.
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall
.
6.
Berkowitz, L.
(1993). Aggression: Its causes, consequences, and
control.
Philadelphia,PA: Temple University Press
.
*Brendgen, M.
,
Vitaro, F.
,
Tremblay, R.E.
, &
Lavoie, F.
(2001).
Reactive and proactive aggression: Predictions to physical violence in
different contexts and moderating effects of parental monitoring and
caregiving behavior
. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 29,
293–304
.
9.
*Brown, K.
,
Atkins, M.S.
,
Osborne, M.L.
, &
Milnamow, M.
(1996).
A revised teacher rating scale for reactive and proactive aggression
. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 24,
473–480
.
10.
Bukowski, W.M.
,
Sippola, L.
,
Hoza, B.
, &
Newcomb, A.F.
(2000). Pages from a sociometric notebook: An analysis of
nomination and rating scale measures of acceptance, rejection, and social
preference. In
A.H.N. Cillessen
&
W.M. Bukowski
(Eds.), Recent advances in the measurement of acceptance and rejection in the
peer system, New Directions for Child and Adolescent Development, 88,
11–26.
San Francisco: Jossey-Bass
.
11.
Bushman, B.J.
, &
Anderson, C.A.
(2001).
Is it time to pull the plug on hostile versus instrumental aggression dichotomy?Psychological Review, 108,
273–279
.
12.
Cairns, R.B.
,
Cairns, B.D.
,
Neckerman, H.J.
,
Ferguson, L.L.
, &
Gariépy, J.L.
(1989).
Growth and aggression: I. Childhood to early adolescence
. Developmental Psychology, 25,
320–330
.
13.
*Camodeca, M.
,
Goossens, F.A.
,
Terwogt, M.M.
, &
Schuengel, C.
(2002).
Bullying and victimization among school-age children: Stability and links
to instrumental and reactive aggression
. Social Development, 11,
332–345
.
14.
*Camodeca, M.
, &
Goossens, F.A.
(2005).
Aggression, social cognitions, anger and sadness in bullies and victims
. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 46,
186–197
.
15.
Cillessen, A.H.N.
, &
Mayeux, L.
(2004).
From censure to reinforcement: Developmental changes in the association
between aggression and social status
. Child Development, 75,
147–163
.
16.
Cohen, J.
(1969). Statistical power analysis for the behavioral
sciences.
New York: Academic Press
.
17.
Cohen, J.
, &
Cohen, P.
(1983). Applied multiple regression/correlation analysis for
the behavioral sciences.
Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum
.
18.
Coie, J.D.
, &
Dodge, K.A.
(1998). Aggression and antisocial behavior. In
W. Damon
(Series Ed.) &
N. Eisenberg
(Vol. Ed.), Handbook of child psychology (5th
edn, Vol. 3, pp. 779–862).
New York: Wiley
.
19.
*Coie, J.D.
,
Dodge, K.A.
,
Terry, R.
, &
Wright, V.
(1991).
The role of aggression in peer relations: An analysis of aggressive
episodes in boys’ play groups
. Child Development, 62,
812–826
.
20.
*Crain, M.M. (2002). The relationship of intent attributions,
goals and outcome expectancies to relationally aggressive behavior in
pre-adolescent girls. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, California School
of Professional Psychology, Alliant International University.
21.
Crick, N.R.
(1997).
Engagement in gender normative versus nonnormative forms of aggression:
Links to social-psychological adjustment
. Developmental Psychology, 33,
610–617
.
22.
Crick, N.R.
, &
Dodge, K.A.
(1994).
A review and reformulation of social information-processing mechanisms in
children's social adjustment
. Psychological Bulletin, 115,
74–101
.
23.
*Crick, N.R.
, &
Dodge, K.A.
(1996).
Social information-processing mechanisms in reactive and instrumental aggression
. Child Development, 67,
993–1002
.
*Day, D.M.
,
Bream, L.A.
, &
Pal, A.
(1992).
Instrumental and reactive aggression: An analysis of subtypes based on
teacher perceptions
. Journal of Clinical Child Psychology, 21,
210–217
.
26.
Dodge, K.A.
(1986). A social information processing model of social
competence in children. In
M. Perlmutter
(Ed.), Minnesota Symposium on Child Psychology (Vol. 18, pp.
77–125).
Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum
.
27.
*Dodge, K.A.
, &
Coie, J.D.
(1987).
Social information-processing factors in reactive and instrumental
aggression in children's playgroups
. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 53,
1146–1158
.
28.
*Dodge, K.A.
,
Coie, J.D.
,
Pettit, G.S.
, &
Price, J.M.
(1990).
Peer status and aggression in boys' groups: Developmental and
contextual analyses
. Child Development, 61,
1289–1309
.
29.
*Dodge, K.A.
,
Lochman, J.E.
,
Harnish, J.D.
,
Bates, J.E.
, &
Pettit, G.S.
(1997).
Reactive and instrumental aggression in school children and psychiatrically
impaired chronically assaultive youth
. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 106,
37–51
.
30.
Egan, S.K.
,
Monson, T.C.
, &
Perry, D.G.
(1998).
Social-cognitive influences on change in aggression over time
. Developmental Psychology, 34,
299–309
.
31.
Farrington, D.P.
(1991). Childhood aggression and adult violence: Early
precursors and life outcomes. In
D.J. Pepler
&
K.H. Rubin
(Eds.), The development and treatment of childhood aggression (pp.
5–29).
Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum
.
32.
*Farver, J.M.
(1996).
Aggressive behavior in preschoolers' social networks: Do birds of
a feather flock together?Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 11,
333–350
.
33.
*Frick, P.J.
,
Cornell, A.H.
,
Barry, C.T.
,
Bodin, S.D.
, &
Dane, H.E.
(2003).
Callous-unemotional traits and conduct problems in the prediction of
conduct problem severity, aggression, and self-report of delinquency
. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 31,
457–470
.
34.
Gifford-Smith, M.E.
, &
Rabiner, D.L.
(2004). Social information processing and
children's social adjustment. In
J.B. Kupersmidt
&
K.A. Dodge
(Eds.), Children's peer relations: From development to
intervention (pp. 61–79).
Washington, DC: American Psychological Association
.
35.
Graham, S.
, &
Hudley, C.
(1994).
Attributions of aggressive and nonaggressive African-American male early
adolescents: A study of construct accessibility
. Developmental Psychology, 30,
365–373
.
36.
Graham, S.
, &
Juvonen, J.
(1998).
Self-blame and peer victimization in middle school: An attributional analysis
. Developmental Psychology, 34,
587–599
.
37.
Guerra, N.G.
, &
Slaby, R.G.
(1989).
Evaluative factors in social problem solving by aggressive boys
. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 17,
277–289
.
38.
*Hartup, W.W.
(1974).
Aggression in childhood: Developmental perspectives
. American Psychologist, 29,
336–341
.
39.
Hawley, P.H.
(2003).
Prosocial and coercive configurations of resource control in early
adolescence: A case for the well-adapted Machiavellian
. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly, 49,
279–309
.
40.
Hawley, P.H.
,
Little, T.D.
, &
Pasupathi, M.
(2002).
Winning friends and influencing peers: Strategies of peer influence in late childhood
. International Journal of Behavioral Development,
26,
466–474
.
*Hegland, S.M.
, &
Rix, M.K.
(1990).
Aggression and assertiveness in kindergarten children differing in day care experiences
. Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 5,
105–116
.
43.
Hodges, E.V.E.
,
Card, N.A.
, &
Isaacs, J.
(2003). Learning of aggression in the home and the peer
group. In
W. Heitmeyer
&
J. Hagan
(Eds.), International handbook of research on violence (pp.
495–509).
New York: Westview Press
.
44.
*Hubbard, J.A.
,
Parker, E.H.
,
Ramsden, S.R.
,
Flanagan, K.D.
,
Relyea, N.
,
Dearing, K.F.
, et al. (2004).
The relations among observational, physiological, and self-report measures
of children's anger
. Social Development, 13,
14–39
.
45.
*Hubbard, J.A.
,
Smithmyer, C.M.
,
Ramsden, S.R.
,
Parker, E.H.
,
Flanagan, K.D.
,
Dearing, K.
, et al. (2002).
Observational, physiological, and self-report measures of
children's anger: Relations to reactive versus instrumental aggression
. Child Development, 73,
1101–1118
.
46.
Lagerspetz, K.M.J.
,
Björkqvist, K.
, &
Peltonen, T.
(1988).
Is indirect aggression typical of females? Gender differences in
aggressiveness in 11to 12-year-old children
. Aggressive Behavior, 14,
403–414
.
47.
Lancelotta, G.X.
, &
Vaughn, S.
(1989).
Relation between types of aggression and sociometric status: Peer and
teacher perceptions
. Journal of Educational Psychology, 81,
86–90
.
48.
*Lento, J. (2001). The role of child maltreatment and peer
victimization in the prediction of playground social behaviors in early
elementary school. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of
California, San Diego.
49.
Lipsey, M.W.
(2003).
Those confounded moderators in meta-analysis: Good, bad, and ugly
. The Annals, 587,
69–81
.
*Little, T.D.
,
Jones, S.M.
,
Henrich, C.C.
, &
Hawley, P.H.
(2003).
Disentangling the “whys” from the
“whats” of aggressive behaviour
. International Journal of Behavioral Development,
27,
122–133
.
52.
Loeber, R.
, &
Stouthamer-Loeber, M.
(1998).
Development of juvenile aggression and violence: Some common misconceptions
and controversies
. American Psychologist, 53,
242–259
.
53.
Lorenz, K.
(1966). On aggression.
New York: Harcourt
.
54.
MacCallum, R.C.
,
Zhang, S.
,
Preacher, K.J.
, &
Rucker, D.D.
(2002).
On the practice of dichotomization of quantitative variables
. Psychological Methods, 7,
19–40
.
55.
*Marcus, R.F.
, &
Kramer, C.
(2001).
Reactive and proactive aggression: Attachment and social competence predictors
. The Journal of Genetic Psychology, 162,
260–275
.
56.
Newcomb, A.F.
,
Bukowski, W.M.
, &
Pattee, L.
(1993).
Children's peer relations: A meta-analytic review of popular,
rejected, neglected, controversial, and average sociometric status
. Psychological Bulletin, 113,
99–128
.
57.
*Orobio de Castro, B.
,
Merk, W.
,
Koops, W.
,
Veerman, J.W.
, &
Bosch, J.D.
(2005).
Emotions in social information processing and their relations with reactive
and proactive aggression in referred aggressive boys
. Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology,
34,
105–116
.
58.
Parker, J.G.
, &
Asher, S.R.
(1987).
Peer relations and later personal adjustment: Are low-accepted children at risk?Psychological Bulletin, 102,
357–389
.
59.
Pellegrini, A.D.
,
Bartini, M.
, &
Brooks, F.
(1999).
School bullies, victims, and aggressive victims: Factors relating to group
affiliation and victimization in early adolescence
. Journal of Educational Psychology,
91(2),
216–224
.
60.
Pepler, D.J.
,
Craig, W.M.
, &
Roberts, W.L.
(1998).
Observations of aggressive and nonaggressive children in the school playground
. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly, 44,
55–76
.
61.
Perry, D.G.
,
Perry, L.C.
, &
Kennedy, E.
(1992). Conflict and the development of antisocial
behavior. In
C.U. Shantz
&
W.W. Hartup
, Conflict in child and adolescent development (pp.
301–329).
New York: Cambridge University Press
.
62.
Perry, D.G.
,
Perry, L.C.
, &
Rasmussen, P.
(1986).
Cognitive social learning mediators of aggression
. Child Development, 57,
700–711
.
Phillipsen, L.C.
,
Deptula, D.P.
, &
Cohen, R.
(1999).
Relating characteristics of children and their friends to relational and
overt aggression
. Child Study Journal, 29,
269–289
.
65.
*Poulin, F.
, &
Boivin, M.
(1999).
Proactive and reactive aggression and boys' friendship quality in
mainstream classrooms
. Journal of Emotional and Behavioral Disorders, 7,
168–177
.
66.
*Poulin, F.
, &
Boivin, M.
(2000).
Reactive and instrumental aggression: Evidence of a two-factor model
. Psychological Assessment, 12,
115–122
.
67.
*Poulin, F.
,
Cillessen, A.H.N.
,
Hubbard, J.A.
,
Coie, J.D.
,
Dodge, K.A.
, &
Schwartz, D.
(1997).
Children's friends and behavioral similarity in two social contexts
. Social Development, 6,
224–236
.
68.
*Price, J.M.
, &
Dodge, K.A.
(1989).
Reactive and proactive aggression in childhood: Relations to peer status
and social context dimensions
. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 17,
455–471
.
69.
*Prinstein, M.J.
, &
Cillessen, A.H.
N. (2003).
Forms and functions of adolescent peer aggression associated with high
levels of peer status
. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly, 49,
310–342
.
70.
*Pulkkinen, L.
(1996).
Proactive and reactive aggression in early adolescence as precursors to
antiand prosocial behavior in young adults
. Aggressive Behavior, 22,
241–257
.
71.
*Ramsden, S.R. (2001). Family expressiveness and parental emotion
coaching:Their roles in emotion regulation, social status, and childhood
aggression. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Delaware.
72.
*Ramsden, S.R.
, &
Hubbard, J.A.
(2002).
Family expressiveness and parental emotion coaching: Their role in
children's emotion regulation and aggression
. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 30,
657–667
.
73.
Rodkin, P.
,
Farmer, T.
,
Pearl, R.
, &
Van Acker, R.
(2000).
Heterogeneity of popular boys: Antisocial and prosocial configurations
. Developmental Psychology, 36,
14–24
.
74.
*Roland, E.
, &
Idsøe, T.
(2001).
Aggression and bullying
. Aggressive Behavior, 27,
446–462
.
75.
Rose, A.J.
,
Swenson, L.P.
, &
Waller, E.M.
(2004).
Overt and relational aggression and perceived popularity: Developmental
differences in concurrent and prospective relations
. Developmental Psychology, 40,
378–387
.
76.
Rosenthal, R.
(1991). Meta-analytic procedures for social research
(revised edition).
Newbury Park, CA: Sage
.
77.
Salmivalli, C.
,
Kaukiainen, A.
, &
Lagerspetz, K.
(2000).
Aggression and sociometric status among peers: Do gender and type of
aggression matter?Scandinavian Journal of Psychology, 41,
17–24
.
78.
*Salmivalli, C.
, &
Nieminen, E.
(2002).
Proactive and reactive aggression among school bullies, victims, and bully-victims
. Aggressive Behavior, 28,
30–44
.
79.
*Salmivalli, C.
,
Ojanen, T.
,
Haanpää, J.
, &
Peets, K.
(2005).
“I'm OK but you're not” and other
peer-relational schemas: Explaining individual differences in
children's social goals
. Developmental Psychology, 41,
363–375
.
80.
*Schippell, P.L. (2001). The role of narcissism, self-esteem and
attentional biases in childhood reactive and proactive aggression.
Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Ohio State University.
81.
*Schippell, P.L.
,
Vasey, M.W.
,
Cravens-Brown, L.M.
, &
Bretveld, R.A.
(2003).
Suppressed attention to rejection, ridicule, and failure cues: A unique
correlate of reactive but not proactive aggression in youth
. Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology,
32,
40–55
.
82.
*Schwartz, D. (1994). The social behavior of bullied
children. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Vanderbilt University.
83.
Schwartz, D.
(2000).
Subtypes of victims and aggressors in children's peer groups
. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 28,
181–192
.
84.
*Schwartz, D.
,
Dodge, K.A.
,
Coie, J.D.
,
Hubbard, J.A.
,
Cillessen, A.H.N.
,
Lemerise, E.A.
, et al. (1998).
Social-cognitive and behavioral correlates of aggression and victimization
in boys' play groups
. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 26,
431–440
.
85.
Schwartz, D.
,
Proctor, L.J.
, &
Chien, D.H.
(2001). The aggressive victim of bullying: Emotional and
behavioral dysregulation as a pathway to victimization by peers. In
J. Juvonen
&
S. Graham
(Eds.), Peer harassment in school:The plight of the vulnerable and
victimized (pp. 147–174).
New York: Guilford
.
86.
Shields, A.
, &
Cicchetti, D.
(1998).
Reactive aggression among maltreated children: The contributions of
attention and emotion dysregulation
. Journal of Clinical Child Psychology, 27,
381–395
.
87.
Slaby, R.G.
, &
Guerra, N.G.
(1988).
Cognitive mediators of aggression in adolescent offenders: I. Assessment
. Developmental Psychology, 24,
580–588
.
88.
*Smithmyer, C.M. (2001). Reactive aggression and low social
preference versus proactive aggression: Differential autonomic reactivity to an
anger-inducing social situation. Unpublished doctoral dissertation,
University of Delaware.
89.
Smithmyer, C.M.
,
Hubbard, J.A.
, &
Simons, R.F.
(2000).
Instrumental and reactive aggression in delinquent adolescents: Relations
to aggression outcome expectancies
. Journal of Clinical Child Psychology, 29,
86–93
.
90.
*Strassberg, Z.
,
Dodge, K.A.
,
Pettit, G.S.
, &
Bates, J.E.
(1994).
Spanking in the home and children's subsequent aggression toward
kindergarten peers
. Development and Psychopathology, 6,
445–461
.
91.
*Van Manen, T.G.
,
Prins, P.J.M.
, &
Emmelkamp, P.M.G.
(2001).
Assessing social cognitive skills in aggressive children from a
developmental perspective: The social cognitive skills test
. Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy, 8,
341–351
.
92.
*Vazzana, A.D. (2001). Outcome expectations and outcome values of
proactive, reactive, and nonaggressive boys. Unpublished doctoral
dissertation, Northern Illinois University.
93.
*Vitaro, F.
,
Brendgen, M.
, &
Tremblay, R.E.
(2002).
Reactively and instrumentally aggressive children: Antecedent and
subsequent characteristics
. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 43,
495–505
.
94.
*Vitaro, F.
,
Gendreau, P.L.
,
Tremblay, R.E.
, &
Oligny, P.
(1998).
Reactive and proactive aggression differentially predict later conduct problems
. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 39,
377–385
.
95.
*Volling, B.L.
,
MacKinnon-Lewis, C.
,
Rabiner, D.
, &
Baradaran, L.P.
(1993).
Children's social competence and sociometric status: Further
exploration of aggression, social withdrawal, and peer rejection
. Development and Psychopathology, 5,
459–483
.
96.
*Vorbach, A.M. (2002). The relationship between emotional
competence and social competence among early adolescents. Unpublished
doctoral dissertation, Alliant International University.
97.
*Waschbusch, D.A.
,
Willoughby, M.T.
, &
Pelham, W.E., Jr.
(1998).
Criterion validity and the utility of reactive and proactive aggression:
Comparisons to attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, oppositional
defiant disorder, conduct disorder, and other measures of functioning
. Journal of Clinical Child Psychology, 27,
396–405
.
98.
*Washburn, J.J.
,
McMahon, S.D.
,
King, C.A.
,
Reinecke, M.A.
, &
Silver, C.
(2004).
Narcissistic features in young adolescents: Relations to aggression and
internalizing symptoms
. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 33,
247–260
.
99.
Xie, H.
,
Cairns, B.D.
, &
Cairns, R.B.
(2005). The development of aggressive behaviors among
girls: Measurement issues, social functions, and differential
trajectories. In
D.J. Pepler
,
K.C. Madsen
,
C. Webster
, &
K.S. Levene
(Eds.), The development and treatment of girlhood aggression (pp.
105–136).
Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
.
