We examined symmetries and asymmetries within family members' psychological
distress and resources in general and when exposed to traumatic events in
particular. PTSD and depressive symptoms indicated distress and resilient attitudes,
and satisfaction with quality of life indicated resources. We also analysed
potential complementary dynamics between family members and identified family types
according to their distress and resources. Concerning trauma impact, we hypothesized
that exposure to family military violence (FMV) and recent personal trauma (RPT)
predict family members' psychological distress and resources differently,
indicating asymmetry in family responses. The participants were 65 Palestinian
families each consisting of a mother, a father and their 15-, 17and 19-year-old
children. The within-family MANOVA results showed asymmetric in psychological
distress and resources in sibling and spousal subsystems, for example older siblings
reported a higher level of depressive symptoms than both parents, and mothers
reported PTSD more often than fathers. The cluster analysis identified four family
types, two with symmetric responses: In the “resilient families”
all members showed low distress and high resources, and in the “ordeal
families” all showed distress and low resources. In the asymmetric
families either the children or the parents showed low distress and high resources,
named the “children's strength families” and the
“parental strength families”, respectively. Partial correlation
analysis revealed complementary dynamics between children and their parents: If
mothers reported high levels of psychological distress, the 15and 17-year-olds
reported low or vice versa. Spousal complementary dynamics were found in
psychosocial resources: If the mother showed highly resilient attitudes, the father
showed low or vice versa. As hypothesized, exposure to traumatic events was
differently associated with family members’ psychological distress and
resources. Family military trauma (FMT) predicted depressive symptoms only among the
youngest siblings, and recent personal trauma (RPT) was associated with
dissatisfaction with quality of life only among the oldest sibling and fathers.
Abrams, M.S.
(1999).
Intergenerational transmission of trauma. Recent contributions from the
literature of family systems approaches to treatment
. American Journal of Psychotherapy, 53,
225–231
.
2.
Almqvist, K.
(2000). Parent–child interaction and coping
strategies in refugee children. In
L. van Willigen
(Ed.), Health hazards of organized violence in children (II): Coping and
protective factors (pp. 53–68).
Utrecht: Pharos
.
3.
Almqvist, K.
, &
Hwang, C.P.
(1999).
Iranian refugees in Sweden: Coping processes in children and their families
.Childhood, 6,
167–188
.
4.
Apfel, T.J.
, &
Simon, B.
(1996). Introduction. In
R.J., Apfel
&
B. Simon
(Eds.), Minefields in their heats: The mental health of children in war
and communal violence (pp. 12–26).
New Haven, CT: Yale University Press
.
5.
Baker, A.M.
(1990).
The psychological impact of the Intifada on Palestinian children in the
occupied West Bank and Gaza
.American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 60,
496–505
.
6.
Barber, B.K.
(2001).
Political violence, social integration, and youth functioning: Palestinian
youth from the Intifada
.Journal of Community Psychology, 29,
259–280
.
7.
Bateson, G.
(1978). The birth of a matrix or double bind and
epistemology. In
M. Berger
(Ed.), Beyond the double bind (pp.
12–26).
New York: Brunner/Mazel
.
8.
Beardslee, W.R.
, &
Podorefsky, D.
(1988).
Resilient children whose parents have serious affective and other
psychiatric disorders: The importance of selfunderstanding and relationships
. American Journal of Psychiatry, 149,
63–69
.
9.
Beardslee, W.R.
,
Versage, E.M.
, &
Gladstone, T.R.
(1998).
Children of affectively ill parents: A review of the past 10 years
. Journal of American Academy of Child and Adolescence
Psychiatry, 37,
1134–1141
.
10.
Beck, A.T.
,
Ward, C.H.
,
Mendelsohn, M.
,
Mosck, L.
, &
Erlaugh, J.
(1961).
An inventory for measuring depression
. Archives of General Psychiatry, 4,
561–571
.
11.
Biscoe, B.
, &
Harris, B.
(1999).Resiliency Attitudes Scale RAS. Available online.
12.
Breslau, N.
(2002).
Epidemiologic studies of trauma, posttraumatic stress disorder, and other
psychiatric disorders
. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 47,
923–929
.
13.
Catherall, D.R.
(1997).
Family treatment when a member has PTSD
. National Center for PTSD: Clinical Quarterly, 7,
1–9
.
14.
Chase, N.D.
(1999). Burdened children: Theory, research, and treatment of
parentification.
London: SAGE Publications
.
15.
Cox, M.J.
, &
Paley, B.
(1997).
Families as systems
. Annual Review of Psychology, 48,
243–267
.
16.
Cummings, M.E.
,
Davies, P.T.
, &
Campbell, S.B.
(2000).Developmental psychopathology and family
process:Theory,research,and clinical implications.
New York: Guildford
.
17.
Danieli, Y.
(1980). Families of surviovors of Nazi Holocauset: Some
longand short-term effects. In
N. Milgram
(Ed.), Psychological stress and adjustment in times of war and
peace (pp. 240–247).
Washington, DC: Hemisphere Publications
.
18.
Davidson, A.C.
, &
Mellor, D.J.
(2001).
The adjustment of children of Australian Vietnam veterans: Is there
evidence for the transgenerational transmission of the effect of war-related trauma?Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 35,
345–351
.
19.
Davidson, J.R.T.
,
Tupler, L.A.
,
Wilson, W.H.
, &
Connor, K.M.
(1998).
A family study of chronic post-traumatic stress disorder following rape trauma
. Journal of Psychiatric Research, 32,
301–309
.
20.
de Jong, J.T.V.M.
,
Komproe, I.H.
,
van Ommeren, M.
,
El Masri, M.
,
Araya, M.
,
Khaled, N.
, et al. (2001).
Life events and posttraumatic stress disorder in 4 postconflict settings
. JAMA, 286,
555–562
.
21.
Figley, C.R.
(1989).Helping traumatized families.
San Francisco, CA: Josey-Bass
.
22.
Freedman, S.A.
,
Brandes, D.
,
Peri, T.
, &
Shalev, A.Y.
(1999).
Predictors of chronic post-traumatic stress disorder: A prospective study
. British Journal of Psychiatry, 174,
353–359
.
23.
Garbarino, J.
(2001).
An ecological perspective on the effects of violence on children
. Journal of Community Psychology, 29,
361–378
.
24.
Garbarino, J.
, &
Kostelny, K.
(1996).
The effects of political violence on Palestinian children's
behavior problems: A risk accumulation model
. Child Development, 67,
33–45
25.
Hair, J.
,
Anderson, R.
,
Tatham, R.
, &
Black, W.
(1995).Multivariate data analysis with readings.
Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall
.
26.
Harkness, L.
, &
Zador, N.
(2001) Treatment of PTSD in families and couples.
In
J.P. Wilson
, &
M.J. Friedmand
(Eds.), Treating psychological trauma and PTSD (pp.
335–353).
New York: Guilford Press
27.
Harrington, R.
,
Rutter, M.
, &
Fombonne, E.
(1996).
Developmental pathways in depression: Multiple meanings, antecedents, and endpoints
. Development and Psychopathology, 8,
601–616
.
28.
Hobfoll, S.
,
Spielberger, C.
,
Breznitz, S.
,
Figley, C.
,
Folkman, S.
,
Lepper-Green, B.
, et al. (1991).
War-related stress: Addressing the stress of and other traumatic events
. American Psychologist, 46,
848–855
.
29.
Jaffa, T.
(1993).Therapy with families who have experienced
torture. In
J.Wilson
&
B. Raphael
(Eds.), International handbook of traumatic stress syndromes(pp.
230–245).
London: Plenum Press
.
30.
Kanninen, K.
,
Salo, J.
, &
Punamäki, R.L.
(2000).
Attachment patterns and working alliance in trauma therapy for victims of
political violence
. Psychotherapy Research, 10,
435–449
.
31.
Kuterovac-Jagodic, G.
(2003).
Posttraumatic stress symptoms in Croatian children exposed to war: A
prospective study
. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 59,
9–17
.
32.
Laor, N.
,
Wolmer, L.
,
Mayes, L.
,
Gershon, A.
,
Weizman, R.
, &
Cohen, D.
(1997).
Israeli preschool children under scuds: A 30-month follow-up
. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent
Psychiatry, 36,
349–356
.
33.
Lichtman, H.
(1984).
Parental communication of Holocaust experiences and personality
characteristics among secondgeneration survivors
. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 40,
914–924
.
34.
Luthar, S.S.
(1993).
Annotation: Methodological and conceptual issues in research on childhood resilience
. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 34,
441–453
.
35.
Masten, A.S.
, &
Coatsworth, J.D.
(1998).
The development of competence in unfavorable environments: Lessons from
research on successful children
. American Psychologist, 53,
205–220
.
36.
Minuchin, S.
(1974).Families and family therapy.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
37.
Montgomery, E.
,
Krogh, Y.
,
Jacobsen, A.
, &
Lukman, B.
(1992).
Children of torture victims: Reactions and coping
. Child Abuse and Neglect: The International Journal,
16,
797–805
.
38.
Moser, R.P.
, &
Jacob, T.
(2002).
Parental and sibling effects in adolescent outcomes
. Psychological Reports, 91,
463–480
.
39.
Netland, M.
(2001).
Assessment of exposure to political violence and other potentially
traumatizing events: A critical review
. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 14,
311–326
.
40.
Olsson, C.A.
,
Bond, L.
,
Burns, J.M.
,
Vella-Brodrick, D.A.
, &
Sawyer, S.M.
(2003).
Adolescent resilience: A concept analysis
. Journal of Adolescence, 26,
1–11
.
41.
Ozer, E.J.
,
Best, S.R.
,
Lipsey, T.L.
, &
Weiss, D.S.
(2003).
Predictors of posttraumatic stress disorder and symptoms in adults: A meta-analysis
. Psychological Bulletin, 12,
52–73
.
42.
Palazzoli, M.S.
,
Boscolo, L.
,
Cecchin, G.
, &
Prata, G.
(1978). Paradox and counter paradox.
New York: Jason Aronson
.
43.
Punamäki, R.L.
(1986).
Stress among Palestinian women under military occupation: Women's
appraisal of stressors, their coping modes, and their mental health
. International Journal of Psychology, 21,
445–462
.
44.
Punamäki, R.L.
(1987).
Psychological stress of Palestinian mothers and their children in
conditions of political violence
. The Quarterly Newsletter of the Laboratory of Comparative Human
Cognition, 9,
116–119
.
45.
Punamäki, R.L.
(1988).
Historical-political and individualistic determinants of coping modes and
fears among Palestinian children
. International Journal of Psychology, 23,
721–739
.
46.
Punamäki, R.L.Qouta, S.
, &
El Sarraj, E.
(1997).
Models of traumatic experiences and children's psychological
adjustment: The role of perceived parenting, children's resources
and activity
. Child Development, 68,
718–728
.
47.
Punamäki, R.L.Qouta, S.
, &
El Sarraj, E.
(2001).
Resiliency factors predicting psychological adjustment after political
violence among Palestinian children
. International Journal of Developmental Behaviour,
25,
256–267
.
48.
Punamäki, R.L.
,
Komproe, I.
,
Qouta, S.
,
El Masri, M.
, &
de Jong, J.T.V.M
(2005).
The role of peritraumatic dissociation and gender in the association
between trauma and mental health in a Palestinian community sample
. American Journal of Psychiatry, 162,
545–551
.
49.
Pynoos, R.S.
,
Frederick, C.
,
Nader, K.
,
Arroy, W.
,
Steinberg, A.
,
Eth, S.
, et al. (1987).
Life threat and post-traumatic stress in school-age children
. Archives of General Psychiatry, 44,
1057–1063
.
50.
Qouta, S.
, &
El-Masri, M.
(1999). Mental health conditions of Palestinian population in
Gaza Strip: A survey.
Gaza: Gaza Community Mental Health Program Publications
.
51.
Qouta, S.
,
Punamäki, R.L.
, &
El Sarraj, E.
(1995).
Relations between traumatic experiences, activity and cognitive and
emotional responses among Palestinian children
. International Journal of Psychology, 30,
289–304
.
52.
Qouta, S.
,
Punamäki, R.L.
, &
El Sarraj, E.
(2003).
Prevalence and determinants of PTSD among Palestinian children exposed to
military violence
. European Journal of Child and Adolescence Psychiatry,
12,
265–272
.
53.
Qouta, S.
,
Punamäki, R.L.
, &
El Sarraj, E.
(2005).
Mother–child expression of symptoms in life-endangering situations
. Clinical Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 10,
135–156
.
54.
Riggs, D.S.
,
Byrne, C.A.
,
Weathers, F.W.
, &
Litz, B.T.
(1998).
The quality of the intimate relationships of male Vietnam veterans:
Problems associated with posttraumatic stress disorder
. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 11,
87–101
.
55.
Rutter, M.
(1985).
Resiliency in the face of adversity: Protective factors and resistance to
psychiatric disorder
. British Journal of Psychiatry, 147,
598–611
.
56.
Rutter, M.
(2000). Resiliency reconsidered: Conceptual consideration,
empirical findings and policy implications. In
J.P. Shonkoff
&
S. Meisels
(Eds.), Handbook of childhood intervention (pp.
651–683).
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
57.
Sack, W.H.
,
Clarke, G.N.
, &
Seeley, J.
(1995).
Posttraumatic stress disorder across two generations of Cambodian refugees
. Journal of American Academy of Child and Adolescence
Psychiatry, 34,
1160–1166
.
58.
Shalev, A.Y.
, &
Yehuda, R.
(1998). Longitudinal development of traumatic stress
disorders. In
R. Yehuda
(Ed.), Psychological trauma (pp.
31–66).
Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press
.
59.
Smith, P.
,
Perrin, S.
,
Yule, W.
, &
Rabe-Hesketh, S.
(2001).
War exposure and maternal reactions in the psychological adjustment of
children from Bosnia–Hercegovina
. Journal of Child Psychology & Psychiatry & Allied
Disciplines, 42,
395–404
.
60.
Solomon, Z.
,
Kotler, M.
, &
Mikulincer, M.
(1988).
Compact-related posttraumatic stress disorder among second generation
Holocaust survivors: Preliminary findings
. American Journal of Psychiatry, 145,
865–868
.
61.
Taylor, S.E.
,
Klein, L.
,
Lewis, B.P.
,
Grunewald, T.L.
,
Gurung, R.A.R.
, &
Updegraff, J.A.
(2000).
Biobehavioral responses to stress in females: Tend and befriend, not
fight-or flight
. Psychological Review, 107,
411–429
.
62.
Teasdale, J.
(1988).
Cognitive vulnerability to persistent depression
. Cognition & Emotion, 2,
247–274
.
63.
Tedeschi, R.G.
(1999).
Violence transformed: Posttraumatic growth in survivors and their societies
. Aggression and Violent Behavior, 4,
319–341
.
64.
Thabet, A.A.M.
, &
Vostanis, Y.
(1999).
Posttraumatic stress reactions in children of war
. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 40,
385–391
.
65.
Thomson, E.
, &
Williams, R.
(1984).
A note on correlated measurement error in wife–husband data
. Journal of Marriage and the Family, 46,
643–649
.
66.
Van der Kolk, B.
(2002). Assessment and treatment of complex PTSD.
In
R. Yehuda
(Ed.), Treating trauma survivors with PTSD (pp.
127–156).
Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press
.
67.
Ware J.E.
, &
Gandek, B.
(1998).
Overview of the SF-36 health survey and the international quality of life
assessment (IQOLA) project
. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 51,
903–912
.
68.
Watzlawick, P.
,
Beavin, J.H.
, &
Jackson, D.D.
(1967). Pragmatics of human communication.
New York: Plenum Press
.
69.
Weine, S.
,
Muzurovic, N.
,
Kulauzovic, Y.
,
Besic, S.
,
Lezic, A.
,
Mujagic, A.
, et al. (2004).
Family consequences of refugee trauma
. Family Process, 43,
147–160
.
70.
Weisenberg, M.
,
Schwarzwald, J.
,
Waysman, M.
,
Solomon, Z.
, &
Klingman, A.
(1993).
Coping of school-age children in the sealed room during scud missile
bombardment and post-war stress reactions
. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 61,
462–467
.
71.
Westerink, J.
, &
Giarratano, L
(1999).
The impact of posttraumatic stress disorder on partners and children of
Australian Vietnam veteran
. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry,
33,
841–847
.
72.
Yehuda, R.
,
Halligan, S.L.
, &
Bierer, L.M.
(2001).
Relationship of parental trauma exposure and PTSD to PTSD, depressive and
anxiety disorders in offspring
. Journal of Psychiatric Research, 35,
261–270
.
73.
Yehuda, R.
,
Schmeidler, J.
,
Giller, E.L.
,
Siever, L.J.
,
Binder-Brynes, K.
(1998).
Relationship between posttraumatic stress disorder characteristics of
Holocaust survivors and their adult offspring
. American Journal of Psychiatry, 155,
841–841
.
74.
Yule, W.
(2002).
Alleviating the effects of war and displacement on Children
. Traumatology, 10,
1–71
.
75.
Zahn-Waxler C.
, &
Radke-Yarrow M.
(1990).
The origins of empathic concern
. Motivation & Emotion, 14,
107–130
.
76.
Zwaanswijk, M.
,
Verhaak, P.F.M.
,
Bensing, J.M.
,
van der Ende, J.
, &
Verhulst, F.C.
(2003).
Help seeking for emotional and behavioural problems in children and children
. European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry,
12,
153–172
.
