Hierarchical logistic regression was used with the results of a factorial vignette survey of a national sample of case managers for the disabled elderly in Medicaid home- and community-based services waiver programs. The effects of client, case manager, and agency factors on case managers’out-of-home placement decisions in response to hypothetical case studies were estimated. Results show that client preferences, workload, and division of labor affect the probability that a case manager will recommend an out-of-home placement, controlling for client’s physical and cognitive disability and the available resources. Significant variation among individuals was found. Implications of the findings are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abrahams, R.
, J. Captiman, E. Leutz, and P. Macko. 1989. “Variations in Care Planning Practice in the Social/HMO: An Exploratory Study.”The Gerontologist29: 725-736.
2.
Alexander, Cheryl
and Henry Becker. 1978. “The Use of Vignettes on Survey Research.”Public Opinion Quarterly42: 93-104.
3.
Applebaum, Robert
and Carol Austin. 1990. Long-Term Care Case Management: Design and Evaluation. New York: Springer.
4.
American Public Welfare Association
. 1995. Home and Community Based Waivers Clearing-house. Washington, DC: American Public Welfare Association.
5.
Austin, Carol
and Frederick Seidl. 1981. “Validating Professional Judgment in a Home Care Agency.”Health and Social Work6: 50-56.
6.
Bryk, Anthony
and Stephen Raudenbush. 1992. In Hierarchical Linear Models, vol. 1, edited by J. De Leeuw. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
7.
Carcagno, George J.
and Peter Kemper. 1988. “The Evaluation of the National Long Term Care Demonstration: 1. An Overview of the Channeling Demonstration and Its Evaluation.”Health Services Research23: 1-22.
8.
Clemens, Elizabeth
, Terrie Wetle, Michael Feltes, Benjamin Crabtree, and Deborah Dubitzky. 1994. “Contradictions in Case Management: Client-Centered Theory and Directive Practice With Frail Elderly.”Journal of Aging and Health6: 70-88.
9.
Congressional Research Service
. 1993. Medicaid Source Book: Background Data and Analysis. Subcommittee on Health and Environment of the Committee on Energy and Commerce, U.S. House of Representatives. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
10.
De Leeuw, Jan
and Ita G. G. Kreft. 1995. “Questioning Multilevel Models.”Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics20: 171-189.
11.
Degenholtz, Howard B. 1997. “Modeling Case Managers’Care Planning Decisions for Community Dwelling Disabled Elders in Medicaid Home and Community Based Services Waiver Programs.” Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Health Services Research and Policy, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis.
12.
Degenholtz, Howard B.
, Rosalie A. Kane, Robert L. Kane, and Michael D. Finch. 1998. What’s in a Care Plan? Results of a National Study of Long-Term Care Case Managers’Care Plan Recommendations. Minneapolis: Minnesota Health Services Research Conference.
13.
Diggle, Peter J.
, Kung-Yee Liang, and Scott L. Zeger. 1994. “Marginal Models.” Pp. 146-165 in Analysis of Longitudinal Data, edited by A. C. Atkinson, J. B. Copas, D. A. Pierce, M. J. Schervish, and D. M. Titterington. New York: Oxford University Press.
14.
Doty, Pamela
. 1995. “Family Caregiving and Access to Publicly Funded Home Care: Implicit and Explicit Influences on Decision Making.” Pp. 92-122 in Family Caregiving in an Aging Society: Policy Perspectives, edited by R. A. Kane and J. D. Penrod. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
15.
Draper, David
. 1995. “Inference and Hierarchical Modeling in the Social Sciences.”Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics20: 115-148.
16.
Folkemer, Donna
. 1994. State Use of Home and Community-Based Services for the Aged Under Medicaid: Waiver Programs, Personal Care, Frail Elderly Services and Home Health Services. Washington, DC: Center on Elderly People Living Alone, AARP Public Policy Institute.
17.
Gatsonis, Constantie A.
, Arnold Epstein, Joseph P. Newhouse, Sharon-Lise Normand, and Barbara J. McNeil. 1995. “Variations in the Utilization of Coronary Angiography for Elderly Patients With an Acute Myocardial Infarction.”Medical Care33: 625-642.
18.
General Accounting Office
. 1993. Long-Term Care Case Management: State Experiences and Implications for Federal Policy. Washington, DC: U.S. General Accounting Office.
19.
Goldstein, Harvey
. 1995. Multilevel Statistical Models. New York: John Wiley.
20.
Goldstein, Harvey
. 1998. MLwiN. London: Institute for Education.
21.
Goldstein, Harvey
and Jon Rasbash. 1995. Improved Approximations for Multilevel Models With Binary Responses. London: Institute of Education, University of London.
22.
Greene, Vernon L.
, Mary E. Lovely, Mark D. Miller, and Jan I. Ondrich. 1995. “Reducing Nursing Home Use Through Community Long-Term Care: An Optimization Analysis.”Journal of Gerontology: Social Sciences50B: 259-268.
23.
Hennessy, C. H.1993. “Modeling Case Management Decision-Making in a Consolidated Long-Term Care Program.”The Gerontologist33: 333-341.
24.
Hennessy, C. H.
and J. Shen. 1986. “Sources of ‘Unreliability’ in Multidisciplinary Team Assessment of the Elderly.”Evaluation Review10: 178-192.
25.
Hosmer, David W.
and Stanley Lemeshow. 1989. Applied Logistic Regression. New York: John Wiley.
26.
Hox, Joop
and Ita Kreft. 1994. “Multilevel Analysis Methods.”Sociological Methods & Research22: 283-299.
27.
Hox, Joop
, Ita Kreft, and Piet Hermkens. 1991. “The Analysis of Factorial Surveys.”Sociological Methods & Research19: 493-510.
28.
Jasso, Guillermina
. 1990. “Methods for the Theoretical and Empirical Analysis of Comparison Processes.”Sociological Methodology20: 369-419.
29.
Justice, Diane
. 1991. The Integral Role of Case Management in Authorizing Services Under State Community Care Programs. Washington, DC: National Association of State Units on Aging.
30.
Justice, Diane
. 1993. Case Management Standards in State Community-Based Long-Term Care Programs. Washington, DC: National Association of State Units on Aging.
31.
Kane, R.1992. “Case Management in Long-Term Care: It Can Be Ethical and Efficacious.”Journal of Case Management1: 76-81.
32.
Kane, R.
and A. L. Caplan. 1993. Ethical Conflicts in the Management of Home Care: The Case Manager’s Dilemma. New York: Springer.
33.
Kane, R. A.
, H. B. Degenholtz, and R. L. Kane. 1998. “Adding Values: An Experiment in Systematic Attention to Values and Preferences of Community Long-Term Care Clients.”Journals of Gerontology: Social Science.
34.
Kane, R.
, J. Penrod, and H. Kivnick. 1993. “Ethics and Case Management: Preliminary Results of an Empirical Study.” Pp. 7-25 in Ethical Conflicts in the Management of Home Care: The Case Manager’s Dilemma, edited by R. Kane and A. Caplan. New York: Springer.
35.
Kemper, Peter
. 1990. “Case Management Agency Systems of Administering Long-Term Care: Evidence From the Channeling Demonstration.”The Gerontologist30: 817-824.
36.
Kennedy, Perter
. 1992. A Guide to Econometrics. Cambridge: MIT Press.
37.
Leutz, Walter
, Ruby Abrahams, and John Capitman. 1993. “The Administration of Eligibility for Community Long-Term Care.”The Gerontologist33: 92-104.
38.
Liu, Korbin
, Jean Hanson, and Teresa Coughlin. 1995. “Characteristics and Outcomes of Persons Screened Into Connecticut’s 2176 Program.” Pp. 215-244 in Persons With Disabilities: Issues in Health Care Financing and Service Delivery, Brookings Dialogues on Public Policy, edited by J. Weiner, S. Clauser, and D. Kennell. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.
39.
McArdle, J. J.
and F. Hamagami. 1994. “Logit and Multilevel Logit Modeling Studies of College Graduation for 1984-85 Freshman Student-Athletes.”Journal of the American Statistical Association89: 1107-1123.
40.
Morris, Carl
. 1996. Hierarchical Statistical Modeling in Health Policy Research. Rockville, MD: Agency for Health Care Policy and Research.
41.
Moscovice, Ira
. 1978. “The Influence of Training Level and Practice Setting on Patterns of Primary Care Provided by Nursing Personnel.”Journal of Community Health4: 4-14.
42.
Murray, David
and Peter Hannan. 1990. “Planning for the Appropriate Analysis in School-Based Drug-Use Prevention Studies.”Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology58: 458-468.
43.
Phillips, B. R.
, P. Kemper, and R. A. Applebaum. 1988. “The Evaluation of the National Long Term Care Demonstration: 4. Case Management Under Channeling.”Health Services Research23: 67-82.
44.
Quinn, Joan
. 1993. Successful Case Management in Long-Term Care. New York: Springer.
45.
Rasbash, J.
and G. Woodhouse. 1995. MLn Command Reference. Version 1.0a. London: Multilevel Models Project, Institute of Education, University of London.
46.
Raudenbush, Stephen
and Anthony S. Bryk. 1986. “A Hierarchical Model for Studying School Effects.”Sociology of Education59: 1-17.
47.
Rodriguez, German
and Noreen Goldman. 1995. “An Assessment of Estimation Procedures for Multilevel Models With Binary Responses.”Journal of the Royal Statistical Society A158: 73-89.
48.
Rossi, Peter
and Steven Nock. 1982. Measuring Social Judgments. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
49.
Schneider, B.
and M. White. 1989. Concepts in Case Management. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Long-Term Care Decisions Resource Center.
50.
Spector, W.
and P. Kemper. 1994. “Disability and Cognitive Impairment Criteria: Targeting Those Who Need the Most Home Care.”The Gerontologist34: 640-651.
51.
Weissert, William G.
, Cynthia Cready, and James Pawelak. 1988. “The Past and Future of Home- and Community-Based Long-Term Care.”The Millbank Quarterly66: 309-388.
52.
Wetle, Terri
. 1992. “A Taxonomy of Ethical Issues in Case Management of the Frail Older Person.”Journal of Case Management1: 71-75.
53.
Wong, G.
and W. M. Mason. 1985. “The Hierarchical Logistic Regression Model for Multilevel Analysis.”Journal of the American Statistical Association80: 513.
54.
Woodhouse, Geoffrey
. 1995. A Guide to MLn for New Users. London: University of London Institute of Education.
55.
Zeger, Scott L.
, Kung-Yee Liang, and Paul S. Albert. 1988. “Models for Longitudinal Data: A Generalized Estimating Equation Approach.”Biometrics44: 1049-1060.
