Effects of Hardiness and Appraisal on the Psychological Distress and Physical Health of Caregivers to Elderly Relatives

Abstract

The goal of this study was to identify characteristics of caregivers that contribute to differences in psychological distress and physical health in family caregivers to elderly relatives. It was hypothesized that hardiness would predict caregiver's distress and physical health beyond what could be accounted for by the demands of caregiving (relative's cognitive impairment and functional/behavioral impairment, and caregiver's level of responsibility for needed care); that hardiness would decrease distress and increase physical health; and that the effect of hardiness would be mediated by appraisals of caregiving. In a sample of 53 caregivers to relatives age 65 or older, results indicated that both hardiness and appraisals predicted psychological distress (depression and life satisfaction). Neither predicted physical health. Appraisals partially explained the relationship between hardiness and psychological distress, but it appears that both general personality characteristics and situation-specific perceptions determine the impact on the caregiver.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Andrews, Frank M. and Stephen B. Withey . 1976. Social Indicators of Well-Being. New York: Plenum.

Antonovsky, Aaron . 1990. "Pathways Leading to Successful Coping and Health." Pp. 31-63 in Learned Resourcefulness: On Coping Skills, Self-Control, and Adaptive Behavior, edited by M. Rosenbaum . New York: Springer.

Auerbach, Jeffrey E. , Terrence D. Oleson , and George F. Solomon . 1992. "A Behavioral Medicine Intervention as an Adjunctive Treatment for HIV-Related Illness." Psychology and Health 6:325-334.

Banks, Joseph K. and Linda R. Gannon . 1988. "The Influence of Hardiness on the Relationship Between Stressors and Psychosomatic Symptomatology." American Journal of Community Psychology 16:25-37.

Beck, Aaron T. , A. John Rush , Brian F Shaw , and Gary Emery . 1979. Cognitive Therapy of Depression. New York: Guilford.

Brody, Elaine M. , Norah P. Dempsey , and Rachel A. Pruchno . 1990. "Mental Health of Sons and Daughters of the Institutionalized Aged." The Gerontologist 30:212-219.

Cohen, Sheldon and Jeffrey R. Edwards . 1989. "Personality Characteristics as Moderators of the Relationship Between Stress and Disorder." Pp. 235-238 in Advances in the Investigation of Psychological Stress, edited by R.W.J. Neufeld . New York: Wiley.

Colerick, Elizabeth J. and Linda K. George . 1986. "Predictors of Institutionalization Among Caregivers of Patients With Alzheimer's Disease." Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 34:493-498.

Cramer, Elliot. M. 1972. "Significance Tests and Tests of Models in Multiple Regression." The American Statistician 26:26-30.

10.

Deimling, Gary T. and David M. Bass . 1986. "Symptoms of Mental Impairment Among Elderly Adults and Their Effects on Family Caregivers." Journal of Gerontology 41:778-784.

11.

Dundon, Margaret M. , Stanley H. Cramer , and Carol A. Nowak . 1987. "Distress and Coping Among Caregivers of Victims of Alzheimer's Disease." Presented at the annual meeting of the American Psychological Association, August, New York.

12.

Funk, Steven C. 1992. "Hardiness: A Review of Theory and Research." Health Psychology 11:335-345.

13.

George, Linda K. and Lisa P. Gwyther . 1986. "Caregiver Well-Being: A Multidimensional Examination of Family Caregivers of Demented Adults." The Gerontologist 26:253-259.

14.

Haley, William E. , Ellen G. Levine , S. Lane Brown , and Alfred A. Bartolucci . 1987. "Stress, Appraisal, Coping, and Social Support as Predictors of Adaptational Outcomes Among Dementia Caregivers." Psychology and Aging 2:323-330.

15.

Hardiness Institute. 1985. Personal Views Survey. Available from Skip Dane, Ph.D., Director, Hardiness Research, P.O. Box 2119, Caspar, WY 82602-2119.

16.

Hardiness Institute. 1986. Fact Sheet for Third Generation HARDINESS TEST. Available from Skip Dane, Ph.D., Director, Hardiness Research, P.O. Box 2119, Caspar, WY 82602-2119.

17.

Hooker, Karen , Deborah Monahan , Kim Shifren , and Cheryl Hutchinson . 1992. "Mental and Physical Health of Spouse Caregivers: The Role of Personality." Psychology and Aging 7:367-375.

18.

Hull, Jay G. , Ronald R. Van Treuren , and Suzanne Virnelli . 1987. "Hardiness and Health: A Critique and Alternative Approach." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 53:518-530.

19.

Kinney, Jennifer M. and Mary Ann P. Stephens . 1989. "Hassles and Uplifts of Giving Care to a Family Member With Dementia." Psychology and Aging 4:402-408.

20.

Kobasa, Suzanne C. 1979. "Stressful Life Events, Personality, and Health: An Inquiry Into Hardiness." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 37:1-11.

21.

Kobasa, Suzanne C.. 1982. "The Hardy Personality: Toward a Social Psychology of Stress and Health." In The Social Psychology of Health and Illness, edited by J. Suls and G. Sanders . Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.

22.

Kobasa, Suzanne C. , Salvatore R. Maddi , and Stephen Kahn . 1982. "Hardiness and Health: A Prospective Study." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 42:168-177.

23.

Lawton, M. Powell , Morton H. Kleban , Miriam Moss , Michael Rovine , and Allen Glicksman . 1989. "Measuring Caregiving Appraisal." Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences 44:P61-P71.

24.

Lawton, M. Powell , Miriam Moss , Morton H. Kleban , Allen Glicksman , and Michael Rovine . 1991. "A Two-Factor Model of Caregiving Appraisal and Psychological Well-Being." Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences 46:P181-P189.

25.

Lazarus, Richard S. and Susan Folkman . 1984. Stress, Appraisal, and Coping. New York: Springer.

26.

Maddi, Salvatore R. 1967. "The Existential Neurosis." Journal of Abnormal Psychology 72:311-325.

27.

Maddi, Salvatore R. and Deborah M. Khoshaba . 1994. "Hardiness and Mental Health." Journal of Personality Assessment 63:265-274.

28.

Maddi, Salvatore R. and Suzanne C. Kobasa . 1984. The Hardy Executive: Health Under Stress. Homewood, IL: Dow Jones-Irwin.

29.

Maxwell, Scott E. and Harold D. Delaney . 1990. Designing Experiments and Analyzing Data: A Model Comparison Perspective. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.

30.

McMullin, Rian E. 1986. Handbook of Cognitive Therapy Techniques. New York: W. W. Norton.

31.

Miller, Baila , Stephanie McFall , and Andrew Montgomery . 1991. "The Impact of Elder Health, Caregiver Involvement, and Global Stress on Two Dimensions of Caregiver Burden." Journal of Gerontology: Social Sciences 46:S9-S19.

32.

Moos, Rudolf H. , Ruth C. Cronkite , Andrew G. Billings , and John W. Finney . 1988. Health and Daily Living Form Manual. Available from the Social Ecology Laboratory, Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Veterans Administration and Stanford University Medical Centers, Palo Alto, CA 94305.

33.

Moos, Rudolf H. and Jeanne A. Schaefer . 1993. "Coping Resources and Processes: Current Concepts and Measures." Pp. 234-257 in Handbook of Stress: Theoretical and Clinical Aspects, 2d ed., edited by L. Goldberger and S. Breznitz . New York: Free Press.

34.

Moss, Miriam S. , M. Powell Lawton , Morton H. Kleban , and Louise Duhamel . 1993. "Time Use of Caregivers of Impaired Elders Before and After Institutionalization." Journal of Gerontology: Social Sciences 48:S102-S111.

35.

Niederehe, George 1988. "TRIMS Behavioral Problem Checklist (BPC)." Psychopharmacology Bulletin 24:771-778.

36.

Niederehe, George and Ernest Fruge . 1984. "Dementia and Family Dynamics: Clinical Research Issues." Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry 17:21-56.

37.

Niederehe, George and Judith Scott . 1987. "Psychological and Family Factors Influencing Caregiver Stress in Senile Dementia." The Southwestern: The Journal of Aging for the Southwest 4:48-58.

38.

Orr, Emda and Mina Westman . 1990. "Does Hardiness Moderate Stress, and How?: A Review." Pp. 64-94 in Learned Resourcefulness: On Coping Skills, Self-Control, and Adaptive Behavior, edited by M. Rosenbaum . New York: Springer.

39.

Pagel, Mark D. , Joseph Becker , and David B. Coppel . 1985. "Loss of Control, Self-Blame, and Depression: An Investigation of Spouse Caregivers of Alzheimer's Disease Patients." Journal of Abnormal Psychology 94:169-182.

40.

Pearlin, Leonard J. , Joseph T. Mullan , Shirley J. Semple , and Marilyn M. Skaff . 1990. "Care- giving and the Stress Process: An Overview of Concepts and Their Measures." The Gerontologist 30:583-594.

41.

Rhodewalt, Frederick and Sjofn Agustsdottir . 1984. "On the Relationship of Hardiness to the Type A Behavior Pattern: Perception of Life Events Versus Coping With Life Events." Journal of Research in Personality 18:212-223.

42.

Rhodewalt, Frederick and Joan B. Zone . 1989. "Appraisal of Life Change, Depression, and Illness in Hardy and Nonhardy Women." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 56:81-88.

43.

Rich, Victoria L. 1985. "An Investigation Into Modification of Personality Hardiness in Nurse Managers." University of Pittsburgh, PA. Unpublished manuscript.

44.

Rosenthal, Carolyn J. , Joanne Sulman , and Victor W. Marshall . 1993. "Depressive Symptoms in Family Caregivers of Long-Stay Patients." The Gerontologist 33:249-257.

45.

Schafale, Christena M. D. 1989. "Family Caregivers of Dementia Patients: An Exploration of Coping." Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Psychology, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

46.

Schlosser, M. Barry and Leigh A. Sheeley . 1985. "The Hardy Personality: Females Coping With Stress." Presented at the 93rd annual convention of the American Psychological Association, August, Los Angeles.

47.

Schulz, Richard , Paul Visintainer , and Gail M. Williamson . 1990. "Psychiatric and Physical Morbidity Effects of Caregiving." Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences 45:P181-P191.

48.

Scott, Judith , Geoffrey Wiegand , and George Niederehe . 1984. "Measuring Behavioral Problems and Dimensions of Family Caregiving in Senile Dementia." Presented at the 37th annual scientific meeting of the Gerontological Society of America, November, San Antonio, TX.

49.

Stone, Robyn , Gail L. Cafferata , and Judith Sangl . 1987. "Caregivers of the Frail Elderly: A National Profile." The Gerontologist 27:616-626.

50.

Townsend, Aloen , Linda Noelker , Gary Deimling , and David Bass . 1989. "Longitudinal Impact of Interhousehold Caregiving on Adult Children's Mental Health." Psychology and Aging 4: 393-401.

51.

Williams, Paula G. , Deborah J. Wiebe , and Timothy W. Smith . 1992. "Coping Processes as Mediators of the Relationship Between Hardiness and Health." Journal of Behavioral Medicine 15:237-255.

52.

Wright, Lore K. , Elizabeth C. Clipp , and Linda K. George . 1993. "Health Consequences of Caregiver Stress." Medicine, Exercise, Nutrition, and Health 2:181-195.

53.

Zone, Jone B. 1986. "A Study of the Life Events-Illness Relationship in Women: The Roles of Perception of Life Events, Personality, and Life-Style in the Prediction of Physical Illness and Depression." Ph.D. dissertation, University of Utah. Dissertation Abstracts International 47: 03A.