The Accuracy of Age Reporting among Elderly African Americans

Abstract

This article expands on previous research that has documented disparities in age information for elderly African Americans. Drawing on a sample of death certificates for Maryland-born African Americans purportedly aged 65-79 years, the validity of age data on both death certificates and social security records is examined through comparison with birth dates provided on linked birth records. The commonly assumed relationship between birth registration and quality of age reporting also is investigated. When compared to birth records, age reporting on social security records is significantly more accurate than that on death records. Age agreement between matched death and social security records closely reflects age validity as determined from birth records. Findings based on logistic regression analysis support the hypothesized birth registration effect: Controlling for demographic characteristics, persons known to have birth certificates exhibited significantly greater age agreement on linked death certificates and social security records (odds ratio = 2.3).

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Armstrong, D. L. , S. B. Wing , and H. A. Tyroler . 1995. "United States Mortality From Ill-Defined Causes, 1968-1988: Potential Effects on Heart Disease Mortality Trends." International Journal of Epidemiology 24:522-527.

Aziz, F. and W. Buckler . 1992. "The Status of Death Information in Social Security Administration Files." Pp. 262-267 in Proceedings of the Social Statistics Section, American Statistical Association. Alexandria, VA: American Statistical Association.

Bayo, F. 1972. "Mortality of the Aged." Transactions of the Society of Actuaries 24:1-24.

Blytheway, B. 1990. "The Measurement of Age." Pp. 9-18 in Researching Social Gerontology: Concepts, Methods and Issues, edited by S. M. Peace . Newbury Park, CA: Sage.

Coale, A. J. and E. E. Kisker . 1986. "Mortality Crossovers: Reality or Bad Data?" Population Studies 40:389-401.

Deutch, J. 1973. "Proof of Age Policies-Past, Present and Future: Selected EMS Data." Report prepared by evaluation and measurement system staff, Office of Research and Statistics, Department of Health, Education and Welfare, August 20.

Elo, I. T. and S. H. Preston . 1994. "Estimating African-American Mortality From Inaccurate Data." Demography 31:427-458.

Elo, I. T. , S. H. Preston , I. Rosenwaike , M. Hill , and T. P. Cheney . In press. "Consistency of Age Reporting on Death Certificates and Social Security Administration Records Among Elderly African-American Decedents." Social Science Research 25.

Hambright, T. Z. 1969. "Comparison of Information on Death Certificates and Matching 1960 Census Records: Age, Marital Status, Race, Nativity and Country of Origin." Demography 6:413-423.

10.

Kestenbaum, B. 1992. "A Description of the Extreme Aged Population Based on Improved Medicare Enrollment Data." Demography 29:565-580.

11.

Kitagawa, E. M. and P. H. Hauser . 1973. Differential Mortality in the United States: A Study of Socioeconomic Epidemiology. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

12.

Manton, K. G. 1982. "Differential Life Expectancy: Possible Explanations During the Later Ages." Pp. 63-68 in Minority Aging: Sociological and Social Psychological Issues, edited by R. C. Manuel . Westport, CT: Greenwood.

13.

National Center for Health Statistics . 1968. Comparability of Age on the Death Certificate and Matching Census Record, United States: May-August 1960. Vital and Health Statistics, Series 2, No. 29. Washington, DC: Author.

14.

Preston, S. H. , I. T. Elo , I. Rosenwaike , and M. Hill . 1996. "African-American Mortality at Older Ages: Results of a Matching Study." Demography 33:193-209.

15.

Shapiro, S. 1950. "Development of Birth Registration and Birth Statistics in the United States." Population Studies 4:86-111.

16.

Zelnik, M. 1969. "Age Patterns of Mortality Among American Negroes: 1900-02 to 1959-61." Journal of the American Statistical Association 64:433-451.