Abstract
This article defines and applies the concept of “network control” as a tool for understanding the challenges and opportunities available to states as they seek territorial control over the global communications infrastructure. Through an analysis of the conflict between WikiLeaks and the US government on the tactical and structural levels, it reveals a contemporary dynamic of the territory–technology nexus of network control. From the perspective of the security establishment, the free speech aspect in the WikiLeaks case is tangential; the publication of sensitive information is just one of the many undesirable consequences of anonymity. Solutions to the problem so defined include the overhaul of the Pentagon’s network or “the Internet minus the anonymity,” which, if realized, will shape the future of the Internet.
Keywords
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.§ 97.119 Station identification . Code of Federal Regulations . Available at: http://edocket.access.gpo.gov/cfr_2010/octqtr/pdf/47cfr97.115.pdf (accessed March 29, 2013 ).
2.
Ackerman
S
(2011 ) (November 7 ) Darpa begs hackers: secure our networks, end ‘Season of Darkness,’ . Wired . Available at: http://www.wired.com/dangerroom/2011/11/darpa-hackers-cybersecurity/ (accessed March 29, 2013 ).
3.Air Force tries to block reality (2010 ) (December 16 ) USA Today 17A . Online. Lexis-Nexis .
4.
Arrighi
G
(1998 ) Globalization and the rise of East Asia . International Sociology 13 (1 ): 59 –77 .
5.
Bar
F
Sandvig
C
(2008 ) US communication policy after convergence . Media, Culture and Society 30 (4 ): 531 –550 .
6.
Batty
D
(2010 ) (August 6 ) ‘Pentagon increases pressure on WikiLeaks to return military files,’ Guardian 23 . Online. Lexis-Nexis . Retrieved July 2012 .
7.
Benkler
Y
(2011a ) A free irresponsible press: WikiLeaks and the battle over the soul of the networked fourth estate . Harvard Civil Rights and Civil Liberties Law Journal 46 (2 ): 311 –397 .
8.
Benkler
Y
(2011b ) WikiLeaks and the PROTECT-IP Act: the New Public-Private Threat to the Internet Commons . Daedalus 140 (4 ): 154 –164 .
9.
Castells
M
(2009 ) Communication Power . New York : Oxford University Press .
10.
Clarke
R
Knake
RK
(2010 ) Cyber War . New York : Ecco .
11.
Clinton
H
(2010 ) (January 21 ) Remarks on Internet freedom . Available at: http://www.state.gov/secretary/rm/2010/01/135519.htm (accessed July 2012 )
12.
Clinton
H
(2011 ) (February 15 ) Internet rights and wrongs . Available at: http://www.state.gov/secretary/rm/2011/02/156619.htm (accessed July 2012 )
13.Council Working Group to prepare for the 2012 World Conference on International Telecommunications (2012 ) (June 18 ). Anticipated final draft of the future ITRs (first revision) . Available at: http://files.wcitleaks.org/public/T09-CWG.WCIT12–120620-TD-PLEN-0064!R1!MSW-E.pdf (accessed July 2012 )
14.
Deibert
R
Rohozinski
R
(2010 ) Risking security: Policies and paradoxes of cyberspace security . International Political Sociology 4 :15 –32 .
15.
Dorling
P
(2011 ) (December 3 ) U.S. targets WikiLeaks like no other organization . Sidney Morning Herald 10 . Online. Lexis-Nexis . Retrieved July 2012 .
16.
Erlanger
S
(2010 ) (December 10 ) Many Europeans find U.S. attacks on WikiLeaks puzzling . New York Times A12 . Online. Lexis-Nexis . Retrieved July 2012 .
17.
Goldsmith
J
Wu
T
(2008 ) Who Controls the Internet? New York : Oxford University Press .
18.
Greenberg
A
(2012 ) This Machine Kills Secrets . New York : Dutton .
19.
Guilliatt
R
(2009 ) (May 30 ) Searching for Assange . The Australian Magazine Online. Lexis-Nexis . Retrieved December 2011 .
20.
Hills
J
(2007 ) Telecommunications and Empire . Urbana, Ill. : University of Illinois Press .
21.
Horvath
MD
(2008 ) (March 18 ) WikiLeaks.org – An online reference to foreign intelligence services, insurgents or terrorist groups? Available at: http://mirror.wikileaks.info/leak/us-intel-wikileaks.pdf (accessed July 2012 ).
22.
Johnson
DR
Post
D
(1996 ) Law and borders – the rise of law in cyberspace . Stanford Law Review 48 : 1367 –1402 .
23.
Jordan
T
Taylor
PA
(2004 ) Hacktivism and Cyberwars . New York : Routledge .
24.Julian Assange, the man behind WikiLeaks (2011 ) (January 26 ). 60 Minutes . Available at: http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2011/01/26/60minutes/main7286686.shtml (accessed July 2012 ).
25.
Keller
B
(2011 ) (January 26 ) Dealing with Assange and the secrets he spilled . New York Times Available at: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/30/magazine/30WikiLeaks-t.html (accessed December 2011 ).
26.
Kerr
IA
(2007 ) Anonymity . In:
WG
Staples
(ed) Encyclopedia of Privacy . Westport, CT : Greenwood Publishing Group , 17 –18 .
27.
Keyes
C
Ure
L
(2010 ) (December 3 ) U.S . officials deny they are urging technical takedown of WikiLeaks . Available at: http://articles.cnn.com/2010–12–03/politics/WikiLeaks.takedown_1_julian-assange-WikiLeaks-cybercommand (accessed December 2011 ).
28.
Khatchadourian
R
(2010 ) (June 7 ) No secrets: Julian Assange’s mission for total transparency . New Yorker 40 –51 .
29.
Khatchadourian
R
(2011 ) (May 20 ) Manning, Assange and the Espionage Act . Available at: http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/newsdesk/2011/05/manning-assange-and-the-espionage-act.html (accessed July 2012 ).
30.
Knickerbocker
B
(2010 ) (December 4 ) WikiLeaks and Julian Assange: Stateless, penniless pariahs? Christian Science Monitor Online. Lexis-Nexis . Retrieved December 2011 .
31.
Krotoski
A
(2011 ) WikiLeaks and the new, transparent world order . Political Quarterly 82 (4 ): 526 –530 .
32.
Landler
M
(2011 ) (February 15 ) U.S. policy to address Internet freedom . New York Times A10 . Online. Lexis-Nexis . Retrieved December 2011 .
33.
Lessig
L
(2006 ) Code: Version 2.0 . New York : Basic Books .
34.
Ludlow
P
(2010 ) (October 4 ) WikiLeaks and Hacktivist Culture . Nation 25 –26 .
35.
Lynn
WJ
(2010 ) (September/October ) Defending a new domain . Foreign Affairs 89 : 97 –108 .
36.
Marx
GT
(1999 ) What’s in a name? Some reflections on the sociology of anonymity . The Information Society
15 (2 ): 99 –112 .
37.
McCullagh
D
(2008 ) (September 12 ) U.N . agency eyes curbs on Internet anonymity . Available at: http://news.cnet.com/8301–13578_3–10040152–38.html (accessed December 2011 ).
38.McIntyre v. Ohio Elections Commission, 514 U.S. 334 (1995 ).
39.
Morozov
E
(2010 ) (December 11 ) Why it’s hard to duplicate . Available at: http://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2010/12/09/what-has-wikileaks-started/wikileaks-relationship-with-the-media (accessed December 2011 ).
40.
Mueller
M
(2010 ) Networks and states . Cambridge, MA : MIT Press .
41.
Nakashima
E
(2011a ) (April 12 ) U.N. frustrated over Manning . Washington Post A2 . Online. Lexis-Nexis . Retrieved July 2012 .
42.
Nakashima
E
(2011c ) (December 20 ) Prosecutors show Manning link to WikiLeaks, Assange chats . Washington Post A4 . Online. Lexis-Nexis . Retrieved July 2012 .
43.
Nakashima
E
Tate
J
(2011 ) (December 23 ) Assange role cited in Manning case . Washington Post A3 . Online. Lexis-Nexis .
44.
Neuman
WR
. (1997 ) The Gordian Knot . Cambridge, MA : MIT Press .
45.
Neuman
S
(2010 ) (November 29 ) Clinton: WikiLeaks ‘tear at fabric’ of government . Available at: http://www.npr.org/2010/11/29/131668950/white-house-aims-to-limit-wikileaks-damage (accessed December 2011 ).
46.
Palmer
M
(2012 ) (February 28 ) WikiLeaks publishes hacked Stratfor e-mails . Financial Times 8 . Online. Lexis-Nexis . Retrieved July 2012 .
47.
Park
K
Lee
H
(2000 ) On the Effectiveness of Probabilistic Packet Marking for IP Traceback Under Denial of Service Attack . Computer Science Technical Reports Paper 1491. Available at: http://docs.lib.purdue.edu/cstech/1491 (accessed July 2012 ).
48.
Pilkington
E
(2011 ) (March 12 ) Clinton aide attacks Manning’s treatment . Guardian 32 . Online. Lexis-Nexis . Retrieved December 2011 .
49.
Rusbridger
A
(2011 ) (January 28 ) WikiLeaks; The Guardian’s role in the biggest leak in the history of the world . Guardian Available at: http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2011/jan/28/wikileaks-julian-assange-alan-rusbridger (accessed December 2011 )
50.
Sengupta
S
(2011 ) (July 26 ) For suspected hackers, a sense of social protest . New York Times B1 . Online. Lexis-Nexis . Retrieved January 2013 .
51.
Shane
S
Burns
JF
(2011 ) (January 8 ) Twitter records in WikiLeaks case are subpoenaed . New York Times A1 . Online. Lexis-Nexis . Retrieved July 2012 .
52.
Shirky
C
(2010a ) (December 6 ) WikiLeaks and the long haul . Available at: http://www.shirky.com/weblog/2010/12/wikileaks-and-the-long-haul/ (accessed December 2011 ).
53.
Shirky
C
(2010b ) (December 31 ) Half-formed thought on WikiLeaks and Global Action . Available at: http://www.shirky.com/weblog/2010/12/half-formed-thought-on-wikileaks-global-action/ (accessed December 2011 ).
54.
Sifry
ML
(2011 ) (March 21 ) The End of Secrecy . Nation 17 –22 .
55.
Singel
R
(2010 ) (March 1 ) Cyberwar Hype Intended to Destroy the Open Internet . Wired Available at: http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2010/03/cyber-war-hype/ (accessed December 2011 ).
56.
Sklerov
M
(2010 ) Responding to international cyber attacks as acts of war . In:
Carr
J
(ed) Inside Cyber Warfare . Sebastopol, CA : O’ Reilly Media .
57.
Slaughter
A
(2009 ) (January/February ) America’s edge: Power in the networked century . Foreign Affairs 88 (1 ): 94 –113 .
58.
Solove
DJ
(2007 ) The Future of Reputation . New Haven : Yale University Press .
59.
Strange
S
(1997 ) An international political economy perspective . In:
Dunning
JH
(ed) Governments, Globalization and International Business . New York : Oxford University Press, pp .132 –142 .
60.Submissions (2011 ) (n.d.) Available at: http://wikileaks.org/wiki/Submissions#Submissions_via_secure_upload (accessed December 2011 ).
61.U.S. Naval Research Lab . (n.d.) Available at: www.onion-router.net/summary.html (accessed December 2011 ).
62.
Winkler
JR
(2009 ) Information warfare in World War I . Journal of Military History (73) 3 : 845 –867 .