Selecting an outcomes assessment instrument requires knowledge of their relative merits, especially head-to-head comparisons. The authors compare health-related quality-of-life (HRQOL) instruments among older adults for theirpsychometric properties and subject burden, specifically the Sickness Impact Profile (SIP) and Medical Outcomes Study Short- Form 36 (SF-36). Subjects were 282 of 373 eligible older adults (75.6% response) ranging in age from 65 to 96. SIP scores demonstrated a strong skew toward low (good health) scores with a mean of 11.1% (SD 11.5) on the Total SIP index score. Similar components of the SIP and SF-36 were moderately to strongly correlated. The SIP suffered from a ceiling (good health) scaling effect, and the SF-36 scales also demonstrated some scaling extremes. These results demonstrate the relative scaling limits, especially the ceiling effect, of the SIP compared to the SF- 36, and in general, the SF-36 is preferredfor use among community-living older adults.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Anderson, C.
, Laubscher, S., & Burns, R. (1996). Validation of the Short Form 36 (SF-36) health survey questionnaire among stroke patients. Stroke, 27, 1812-1816.
2.
Andresen, E. M.
, Bowley, N., Rothenberg, B., Panzer, R., & Katz, P (1996). Test-retest performance of a mailed version of the SF-36 among older adults. Medical Care, 11, 1165-1170.
3.
Andresen, E. M.
, Patrick, D. L., Carter, W. B., & Malmgren, J. A. (1995). Comparing the performance of health status measures for healthy older adults. Journal of American Geriatric Society, 43, 1-5.
4.
Andresen, E. M.
, Rothenberg, B., & Zimmer, J. (Eds.). (1997). Measuring the health status of older adults. New York: Springer.
5.
Bagne, C. A.
, Luscombe, F. A., & Damiano, A. (1995). Relationships between glycemic control, diabetes-related symptoms, and SF-36 scales scores in patients with non-insulin dependent diabetes mellitus [Abstract]. Quality of Life Research, 4, 392-393.
6.
Beaton, D. E.
, Hogg-Johnson, S., & Bombardier, C. (1997). Evaluating changes in health status: Reliability and responsiveness of five generic health status measures in workers with musculoskeletal disorders. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 50, 79-93.
7.
Bendtsen, P.
, & Hornquist, J. O. (1993). Severity of rheumatoid arthritis, function and quality of life: Sub-group comparisons. Clinical and Experimental Rheumatology, 11, 495-502.
8.
Bergner, L.
, Bergner, M., Hallstrom, A. P., Eisenberg, M., Cobb, L. A. (1984). Health status of survivors of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest six months later. American Journal of Public Health, 74, 508-510.
9.
Bergner, L.
, Hallstrom, A. P., Bergner, M., Eisenberg, M. S., & Cobb, L. A. (1985). Health status of survivors of cardiac arrest and of myocardial infarction controls. American Journal of Public Health, 75, 1321-1323.
10.
Bergner, M.
, Bobbitt, R. A., Carter, W. B., & Gilson, B. S. (1981). The Sickness Impact Profile: Development and final revision of a health status measure. Medical Care, 19, 787-805.
11.
Bergner, M.
, Hudson L. D., Conrad, D. A., Patmont, C. M., McDonald, G. J., Perrin, E. B., & Gilson, B. S. (1988). The cost and efficacy of home care for patients with chronic lung disease. Medical Care, 26, 566-579.
12.
Boult, C.
, Dowd, B., McCaffrey, D., Boult, L., Hernandez, R., & Krulewitch, H. (1993). Screening elders for risk of hospital admission. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 41, 811-817.
13.
Bousquet, J.
, Knani, J., Dhivert, H., Richard, A., Chicoye, A., Ware, J. E., & Michel, F B. (1994). Quality of life in asthma: Vol. 1. Internal consistency and validity of the SF-36 questionnaire. American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine, 149, 371-375.
14.
Butcher, J. L.
, MacKenzie, E. J., Cushing, B., Jurovich, G., Morris, J., Burgess, A., McAndrew, M., & Swiontkowski, M. (1996). Long-term outcomes after lower extremity trauma. Journal of Trauma, 41, 4-9.
15.
Carmines, E.
, & Zeller, R. (1979). Reliability and validity assessment: Quantitative application in the social science. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
16.
Carter, W. B.
, & Deyo, R. (1981). The impact of questionnaire research on clinical populations: A dilemma in review of human subjects research resolved by a study of a study. Clinical Research, 29, 287-295.
17.
Chapko, M.
, Rothman, M. L., Ehreth, J., Hedrick, S. C., Sullivan, J., Erdly, W., & Cooper, S. (1993). Data collection in the Adult Day Health Care Study. Medical Care, 31(9, Suppl.), SS15-SS25.
18.
Charlier, L.
, Dutrannois, J., & Kaufman, L. (1997). The SF-36 questionnaire: A convenient way to assess quality of life in angina pectoris patients. Acta Cardiologica, 52, 247-260.
19.
Clark, N. M.
, Janz, N. K., Becker, M. H., Schork, M. A., Wheeler, J., Liang, J., Dodge, J. A., Keteyian, S., Rhoads, K. L., & Santinga, J. T. (1992). Impact of self-management education on the functional health status of older adults with heart disease. Gerontologist, 32, 438-443.
20.
Cronbach, L. J.
(1951). Coefficient alpha and the internal structure of tests. Psychometrika, 16, 297-334.
21.
de Haan, R.
, Horn, J., Limburg, M., & Van Der Meuien, J. (1993). A comparison of five stroke scales with measures of disability, handicap, and quality of life. Stroke, 24, 1178-1181.
22.
Deyo, R. A.
(1986). Comparative validity of the Sickness Impact Profile and shorter scales for functional assessment in low-back pain. Spine, 11, 951-954.
23.
Deyo, R. A.
, Inui, T. S., Leininger, J., & Overman, S. (1982). Physical and psychosocial function in rheumatoid arthritis: Clinical use of a self-administered health status instrument. Archives of Internal Medicine, 142, 879-882.
24.
Deyo, R. A.
, Inui, T. S., Leininger, J. D., & Overman, S. S. (1983). Measuring functional outcomes in chronic disease: A comparison of traditional scales and a self-administered health status questionnaire in patients with rheumatoid arthritis. Medical Care, 21, 180-192.
25.
Essink-Bot, M. L.
, Krabbe, P. F., van Agt, H. M., & Bonsel, G. J. (1996). NHP or SIP-A comparative study in renal insufficiency associated anemia. Quality of Life Research, 5, 91-100.
26.
Feasley, J. C.
(Ed.). (1996). Health outcomesfor older people: Questionsfor the coming decade Institute of Medicine. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
27.
Follick, M. J.
, Smith, T. W., & Ahern, D. K. (1985). The Sickness Impact Profile: A global measure of disability in chronic low back pain. Pain, 21, 67-76.
28.
Fortrin, P. R.
, Neville, C., & Abrahamowicz, M. (1995). Health status measure used to validate research in chronic diseases [Abstract]. Quality of Life Research, 4, 427-428.
29.
Gerety, M. B.
, Cornell, J. E., Mulrow, C. D., Tuley, M., Hazuda, H. P., Lichtenstein, M., Kanten, D. N., Aguilor, C., Kadri, A. A., & Rosenberg, J. (1994). The Sickness Impact Profile for nursing homes (SIP-NH). Journal of Gerontology, 49, M2-M8.
30.
Gouveia, W. A.
, Bungay, K. M., Massaro, F. J., & Ware J. E. (1991). Paradigm for the management of patient outcomes. American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy, 48, 1912-1916.
31.
Granger, C. V.
, Cotter, A. C., Hamilton, B. B., & Fiedler, R. C. (1993). Functional assessment scales: A study of persons after stroke. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 74, 133-138.
32.
Grieve, A. C.
, & Lankhorst, G. J. (1996). Functional outcome of lower-limb amputees: A prospective descriptive study in a general hospital. Prosthetics and Orthotics International, 20, 79-87.
33.
Hanestad, B. R.
, & Graue, M. (1995). To maintain quality of life and satisfactory metabolic control in Type II diabetes patients-One and the same? [Abstract]. Quality ofLife Research, 4, 436-437.
34.
Hasley, P. B.
, Brancati, F. L., Rogers, J., Hanusa, B. H., & Kapoor, W. N. (1993). Measuring functional change in community-acquired pneumonia: A preliminary study using the Sickness Impact Profile. Medical Care, 31, 649-657.
35.
Hays, R. D.
, Sherboume, C. D., & Mazel, R. M. (1993). The Rand 36-item Health Survey 1.0. Health Economics, 2, 217-227.
36.
Hedrick, S. C.
, Rothman, M. L., Chapko, M., Inui, T. S., Kelly, J. R., & Ehreth, J. (1993). Overview and patient recruitment in the Adult Day Health Care Evaluation study. Medical Care, 31(9, Suppl), SS3-SS14.
37.
HMO Workgroup on Care Management
. (1996, April). Identifying high-risk Medicare HMO members: A reportfrom the HMO Workgroup on Care Management. Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.
38.
Husted, J. A.
, Gladman, D. D., Farewell, V. T., Long, J. A., & Cook, R. J. (1997). Validating the SF-36 health survey questionnaire in patients with psoriatic arthritis. Journal of Rheumatology, 24, 511-517.
39.
Jacobson, A. M.
, Samson, J. A., & De Groot, M. (1994). The evaluation of two measures of quality of life in patients with type I and type II diabetes. Diabetes Care, 17, 267-274.
40.
Jenkinson, C.
, Jenkinson, D., Shepperd, S., Layte, R., & Petersen, S. (1997). Evaluation of treatment for congestive heart failure in patients aged 60 years and older using generic measures of health status (SF-36 and COOP charts). Age and Aging, 26, 7-13.
41.
Jette, D. U.
, & Downing, J. (1994). Health status of individuals entering a cardiac rehabilitation program as measured by the Medical Outcomes Study 36-item Short Form survey (SF-36). Physical Therapy, 74, 521-527.
42.
Johnson, P. A.
, Goldman, L., Orav, E. J., Garcia, T., Pearson, S. D., & Lee, T. H. (1995). Comparison of the Medical Outcomes Study Short-form 36-Item Health Survey in Black and White patients with acute chest pain. Medical Care, 33, 145-160.
43.
Jones, P. W.
, Baveystock, C. M., & Littlejohns, P. (1989). Relationship between general health measured with the Sickness Impact Profile and respiratory symptoms, physiological measures, and mood in patients with chronic airflow limitation. American Review of Respiratory Disease, 140, 1538-1543.
44.
Juniper, E. F.
, Guyatt, G. H., Ferrie, P. J., & Griffith, L. E. (1993). Measuring quality of life in asthma. American Review of Respiratory Disease, 147, 832-838.
45.
Karlsson, J.
, Sjostrom, L., & Sullivan, M. (1995). Swedish obese subjects (SOS)-An intervention study of obesity: Measuring psychosocial factors and health by means of short-form questionnaires. Results from a method study. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 48,817-823.
46.
Katz, J. N.
, Larson, M. G., Phillips, C. B., Fossel, A. H., & Liang, M. H. (1992). Comparative measurement sensitivity of short and longer health status instruments. Medical Care, 30, 917-925.
47.
Kurtin, P. S.
, Davies, A. R., Meyer, K. B., DeGiacomo, J. M., & Kantz, M. E. (1992). Patient-based health status measures in outpatient dialysis: Early experiences in developing an outcomes assessment program. Medical Care, 30, MS136-MS136
48.
Liang, M. H.
, Fossel, A. H., & Larson, M. G. (1990). Comparisons of five health status instruments for orthopedic evaluation. Medical Care, 28, 632-642.
49.
Lohr, K. N.
, Aaronson, N. K., Alonso, J., Burnam, M. A., Patrick, D. L., Perrin, E. B., & Roberts, J. S. (1996). Evaluating quality-of-life and health status instruments: Development of scientific review criteria. Clinical Therapeutics, 18, 979-992.
50.
Lundqvist, C.
, Siosteen, A., Sullivan, L., Bloomstrand, C., Lind, B., & Sullivan, M. (1997). Spinal cord injuries: A shortened measure of function and mood. Spinal Cord, 35, 17-21.
51.
Lyons, R. A.
, Parry, H. M., & Littlepage, B.N.C. (1994). Evidence for the validity of the Short-Form 36 questionnaire (SF-36) in an elderly population. Age and Aging, 23, 182-184.
52.
Martin, C.
, Marquis, P., & Bonfils, S. (1994). A "quality of life questionnaire" adapted to duodenal ulcer therapeutic trials. Scandinavian Journal of Gastroenterology, 29(Suppl. 206), 40-43.
53.
Martin, D. P.
, Engelberg, R., Agel, J., & Swiontkowski, M. F. (1997). Comparison of the Musculoskeletal Function Assessment questionnaire with the Short Form-36, the Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index, and the Sickness Impact Profile health-status measures. Journal Bone and Joint Surgery-American Volume, 79, 1323-1334.
54.
McHorney, C. A.
(1996). Measuring and monitoring general health status in elderly persons: Practical and methodological issues in using the SF-36 Health Survey. The Gerontologist, 36, 571-583.
55.
McHorney, C. A.
, Kosinski, M., & Ware, J. E. (1994). Comparisons of the costs and quality of norms for the SF-36 health survey collected by mail versus telephone interview: Results from a national survey. Medical Care, 32, 551-567.
56.
McSweeny, A. J.
, Grant, I., Heaton, R. K., Adams, K. M., & Timms, R. M. (1982). Life quality of patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Archives of Internal Medicine, 142, 473-478.
57.
Meyer, K. B.
, Espindle, D. M., DeGiacomo, J. M., Jenuleson, C. S., Kurtin, P. S., & Davies, A. R. (1994). Monitoring dialysis patients' health status. American Journal of Kidney Diseases, 24, 267-279.
58.
Mosier, C. I.
(1943). On the reliability of a weighted composite. Psychometrika, 8, 161-168.
59.
Muller, M. J.
, Aaronson, N. K., te Velde, A., Sprangers, M.A.G., Buitelaar, A. C., & Abbonk, E. M. (1995). Psychometric properties of the MOS SF-36 health survey in a population of patients with cancer [Abstract]. Quality of Life Research, 4, 465-465.
60.
Munster, A. M.
, Fauerbach, F. A., & Lawrence, J. (1996). Development and utilization of a psychometric instrument for measuring quality of life in burn patients, 1976 to 1996. Acta Chirurgiae Plasticae, 38, 128-131.
61.
Nerenz, D. R.
, Repasky, D. P., Whitehouse, F W., & Kahkonen, D. M. (1992). Ongoing assessment of health status in patients with diabetes mellitus. Medical Care, 30(5, Suppl.), MS112-MS124.
62.
Noonan, M.
, Chervinsky, P., Busse, W. W., Weisberg, S. C., Pinnas, J., DeBoisblanc, B. P., Boltansky, H., Pearlman, D., Repsher, L., & Kellerman, D. (1995). Fluticasone propionate reduces oral prednisone use while it improves asthma control and quality of life. American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine, 152, 1467-1473.
63.
Nunnally, J. C.
(1978). Psychometric theory. New York: McGraw-Hill.
64.
Nydevik, I.
, & Hulter-Asberg, K. (1991). Subjective dysfunction after stroke: A study with the Sickness Impact Profile. Scandinavian Journal of Primary Health Care, 9, 271-275.
65.
Nydevik, I.
, & Hulter-Asberg, K. (1992). Sickness impact after stroke: A 3-year follow-up. Scandinavian Journal of Primary Health Care, 10, 284-289.
66.
O'Brien, B. J.
, Buxton, M. J., & Patterson, D. L. (1993). Relationship between functional status and health-related quality-of-life after myocardial infarction. Medical Care, 31, 950-955.
67.
Okamoto, L. J.
, Noonan, M., DeBoisblanc, B. P., & Kellerman, D. J. (1996). Fluticasone propionate improves quality of life in patients with asthma requiring oral corticosteroids. Annals of Allergy, Asthma, and Immunology, 76, 455-461.
68.
Pacala, J. T.
, Boult, C., & Boult, L. (1995). Predictive validity of a questionnaire that identifies older persons at risk for hospital admission. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 43, 374-377.
69.
Patrick, D. L.
, & Erickson, P. (1993). Health status and health policy: Allocating resources to health care. New York: Oxford University Press.
70.
Provenzale, D.
, Shearin, M., Phillips-Bute, B. G., Drossman, D. A., Li, Z., Tillenger, W., Schmitt, C. M., Bollinger, R. R., & Koruda, M. J. (1997). Health-related quality of life after ileoanal pull-through evaluation and assessment of new health status measures. Gastroenterology, 113, 7-14.
71.
Rothman, M. L.
, Diehr, P., Hedrick, S. C., Erdly, W. W., & Nickinovich, D. G. (1993). Effects of contract adult day health care on health outcomes and satisfaction with care. Medical Care, 31, SS75-SS83.
72.
Rothman, M. L.
, Hedrick, S., & Inui, T. (1989). The Sickness Impact Profile as a measure of the health status of noncognitively impaired nursing home residents. Medical Care, 27, S157-S167.
73.
Ruta, D. A.
, Garratt, A. M., Leng, M., Russell, I. T., & MacDonald, L. M. (1994). Anew approach to the measurement of quality of life: The Patient Generated Index. Medical Care, 32, 1109-1126.
74.
Schanke, A. K.
(1997). Psychological distress, social support and coping behavior among polio survivors: A 5-year perspective on 63 polio patients. Disability and Rehabilitation, 19, 108-116.
75.
Scholes, D.
, LaCroix, A. Z., Wagner, E. H., Grothaus, L. C., & Hecht, J. A. (1991). Tracking progress toward national health objectives in the elderly: What do restricted activity days signify?American Journal of Public Health, 81, 485-488.
76.
Schrier, A. C.
, Dekker, F. W., Kaptein, A. A., & Dijkman, J. H. (1990). Quality of life in elderly patients with chronic nonspecific lung disease seen in family practice. Chest, 98, 894-899.
77.
Schuling, J.
, Greidanus, J., & Meyboom de Jonghe, B. (1993). Measuring functional status of stroke patients with the Sickness Impact Profile. Disability and Rehabilitation, 15, 19-23.
78.
Sherbourme, C. D.
, & Meredith, L. S. (1992). Quality of self-report data: A comparison of older and younger chronically ill patients. Journals of Gerontology (B), 47, S204-S211.
79.
SPSS, Inc. [Computer software]. (1996). SPSS 7.0 TM for Windows. Chicago: Author.
80.
Stucki, G.
, Liang, M. H., Lipson, S. J., Fossel, A. W., & Katz, J. N. (1994). Contribution of neuromuscular impairment to physical functional status in patients with lumbar spinal stenosis. Journal of Rheumatology, 21, 1338-1343.
81.
Sullivan, M.
, Ahlimen, M., Archenholtz, B., & Svensson, G. (1986). Measuring health in rheumatic disorders by means of a Swedish version of the Sickness Impact Profile: Results from a population study. Scandinavian Journal of Rheumatology, 15, 193-200.
82.
Sullivan, M.
, Karlsson, J., Sjostrom, L., Backman, L., Bengtsson, C., Bouchard, C., Dahlgren, S., Jonsson, E., Larsson, B., Linstedt, S., Naslund, I., Olbe, C., & Wedel, H. (1993). Swedish obese subjects (SOS)-An intervention study of obesity: Baseline evaluation of health and psychosocial functioning in the first 1743 subjects examined. International Journal of Obesity and Related Metabolic Disorders, 17, 503-512.
83.
Tarlov, A. R.
, Ware, J. E., Greenfield, S., Nelson, E. C., Perin, E., & Zubkoff, M. (1989). The Medical Outcomes Study: An application of methods for monitoring the results of medical care. Journal of the American Medical Association, 262, 925-930.
84.
Tennant, A.
, Fear, J., Hillman, M., & Chamberlain, M. A. (1995). Missing values and the MOS SF-36: An over 55-year-old sample with arthritis [Abstract]. Quality of Life Research, 4, 495-496.
85.
van Balen, H. G.
, Mulder, T., & Keyser, A. (1996). Towards a disability-oriented epidemiology of traumatic brain injury. Disability and Rehabilitation, 18, 181-190.
86.
van der Molen, T.
, Postma, D. S., Schreurs, A. J., Bosveld, H. E., Sears, M. R., & Meyboom de Jonghe, B. (1997). Discriminative aspects of two generic and two asthma-specific instruments: Relation with symptoms, bronchodilator use and lung function in patients with mild asthma. Quality of Life Research, 6, 353-361.
87.
van Tulder, M. W.
, Aaronson, N. K., & Bruning, P. F. (1994). The quality of life of long-term survivors of Hodgkin's Disease. Annals of Oncology, 5, 152-158.
88.
Visser, M. C.
, Fletcher, A. E., Parr, G., Simpson, A., & Bulpitt, C. J. (1994). A comparison of three quality of life instruments in subjects with angina pectoris: The Sickness Impact Profile, the Nottingham Health Profile, and the Quality of Well Being Scale. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 47, 157-163.
89.
Wagner, E. H.
, LaCroix, A. Z., Grothaus, L. C., & Hecht, J. A. (1993). Responsiveness of health status measures to change among older adults. Journal of the American Geriatric Society, 41, 241-248.
90.
Ware, J. E.
, Kosinski, M., & Keller, S. D. (1994). SF-36 Physical and Mental Health Summary Scales: A user's manual. Boston: The Health Institute.
91.
Ware, J. E.
, & Sherbourne, C. D. (1992). The MOS 36-item short-form health survey (SF-36): Vol. 1. Conceptual framework and item selection. Medical Care, 30,473-483.
92.
Ware, J. E.
, Snow, K. K., Kosinski, M., & Gandek, B. (1993). The SF-36 health survey: Manual and interpretation guide. Boston: The Health Institute.
93.
Weinberger, M.
, Nagle, B., & Hanlon, J. T. (1994). Assessing health-related quality of life in elderly outpatients: Telephone versus face-to-face administration. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 42, 1295-1299.
94.
Weinberger, M.
, Oddone, E. Z., Samsa, G. P., & Landsman, P. B. (1996). Are health-related quality-of-life measures affected by the mode of administration?Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 49, 135-140.
95.
Weinberger, M.
, Samsa, G. P., Hanlon, J. T., Schmaderk, K., Dogle, M. E., Cowper, P. A., Ultech, K. M., Cohen, H. J., & Feussner, J. R. (1991). An evaluation of a brief health status measure in elderly veterans. Journal of American Geriatric Society, 39, 691-694.
96.
Weinberger, M.
, Samsa, G. P., Tierney, W. M., Belyea, M. J., & Hiner, S. L. (1992). Generic versus disease specific health status measures: Comparing the Sickness Impact Profile and the Arthritis Impact Measurement Scales. Journal of Rheumatology, 19, 543-546.
97.
Winslow, R.
(1992, July 7). Questionnaire probes patients' quality of life. The Wall Street Journal, p. B1-B1.
