Can Survey Data Be Used to Estimate Physician Practice Costs?

Abstract

Health policy makers rely on survey estimates of physician practice costs to set reimbursement rates. The Health Care Financing Administration has just funded a multimillion dollar effort to collect survey data that will be used to revise payments under the Medicare Fee Schedule. However, the ability of largescale physician surveys to obtain accurate information about practice costs is not apparent. This article examines several of the key obstacles encountered when trying to obtain accurate estimates. Rates of both unit and item nonresponse over time are described; in general, there is a trend toward lower unit response rates and higher item response rates. The article also examines logical inconsistencies in data The results suggest thatphysician surveys may not be the most appropriate source of data about physician practice expenses. Health policy makers concerned about provider reimbursement issues should seriously scrutinize the accuracy of results from physician practice cost surveys. This article concludes by suggesting alternative methodologies for incorporating physician practice costs into reimbursement rates.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderson, R. , Kasper, J. , & Frankel, M. (1979). Total survey error. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

Balamuth, E. (1965). Health interview responses compared with medical records (Vital and Health Statistics, Data Evaluation and Methods Research Series 2, No. 7). Washington, DC: National Center for Health Statistics, U.S. Department of Health, Education and Welfare.

Berk, M. L. (1985). Interviewing physicians: The effect of improved response rate. American Journal of Public Health, 75(11), 1338-1340.

Berk, M. L. , Goldfield, H. , & Pfeiffer, P. (1989, January). Hostility to government as a reason for nonresponse on physician surveys 1977-1988. Paper presented at the winter meetings of the American Statistical Association, San Diego, CA.

Berk, M. L. , Horgan, C. M. , & Meyers, S. (1986). Thereportingofstigmatizinghealthconditions: A comparison of proxy and self-reporting. Journal of Economics and Social Measurement, 14, 197-205.

Berk, M. L. , Kutzin, J. , & Mohr, P. (1988). Final report-1988 National Survey of Physicians (Contract No. T53644235). Report prepared by Project Hope for the Physician Payment Review Commission, Bethesda, MD.

Berk, M. L. , Mohr, P. , & Kutzin, J. (1989). Alternative strategies for measuring physicians' practice costs. In Proceedings of the Social Statistics Section-Papers presented at the annual meeting of the American Statistical Association, Washington, DC, August 1989. Alexandria, VA: American Statistical Association.

Berk, M. L. , Schur, C. , & Mohr, P. (1990, Fall). Using survey data to estimate prescription drug costs. Health Affairs, pp. 146-156.

Berry, S. H. , & Kanouse, D. E. (1987). Physician response to a mailed survey: An experiment in timing of payment. Public Opinion Quarterly, 51, 102-116.

10.

Brown, R. , Strouse, R. , Hall, J. , & Shin, R. (1990). Design ofaphysicians'practice costs survey. Princeton, NJ: Mathematica Policy Research.

11.

Groves, R. (1989). Survey errors and survey costs. New York: Wiley.

12.

Guadagnoli, E. , & Cunningham, S. (1989). The effects of nonresponse and late response on a survey of physician attitudes. Evaluation & the Health Professions, 12, 318-328.

13.

Marder, W. , & Thran, S. (1989). Proxy or principal: Cost minimizing strategies of survey respondents. In Proceedings of the Survey Research Section-Papers presented at the annual meeting of the American Statistical Association, Washington, DC, August 1989. Alexandria, VA: American Statistical Association.

14.

Medicare: Fee schedule for physicians' services . (1991, November 28). Federal Register, p. 59502-59502.

15.

Mueller, C. D. , & Berk, M. L. (1993). Proxy responses and survey error: Additional evidence from the 1988 Physicians'Practice Costs and Income Survey. Final report submitted to the Health Care Financing Administration, Bethesda, MD.

16.

Project HOPE . (1991). Statistical properties of physician surveys: Evaluation of codelines and public use tape at the 1988 Physicians'Practice Costs and Income Survey. Bethesda, MD: Project HOPE.

17.

Schoenman, J. (1988). An examination of the factors influencing the short-run supply of registered nurses. In The Secretary's Commission on Nursing: Final report (Vol. 2). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.

18.

Sobal, J. , & Ferentz, K. (1989). Comparing physician responses to the first and second mailing of a questionnaire. Evaluation & the Health Professions, 12, 329-339.

19.

Sprachman, S. , Burich, M. , Rosenbach, M. , Cromwell, J. , Spencer, B. , & Frankel, M. (1985, December). Physicians' Practice Costs and Income Survey-Final methodological report (HCFA Contract No. 500-83-0025). Prepared by the National Opinion Research Center, University of Chicago, for the Health Care Financing Administration.

20.

Thalji, L. , Rosenbach, M. , Frankel, M. , et al. (1991). 1988 Physicians' Practice Costs and Income Survey-Final report and user's manual (Contract No. 500-88-0045). Prepared by the National Opinion Research Center, University of Chicago, for the Health Care Financing Administration.