Structural Equation Models of Moral Reasoning and Physician Performance

Abstract

In order to identify and explain those aspects of clinical performance related to moral reasoning, 39 family medicine residents were studied as they interacted with each of two simulated patients. Residents were interviewed to assess their performance with each patient, elicit their general philosophy of being a doctor, and measure their moral reasoning. General performance as residents was rated by three faculty supervisors. Scoringprotocols were developedfor each measure to ensure objectivity. Factor analysis of each measure guided selection of the most meaningful variablefrom each instrument. Based upon general models relating attitude to behavior, structural equations were used to explicate the relationship between moral reasoning, performance on the simulated cases, performance as a resident, attitude, and intention. Chi-square goodness offit indicates that the general attitude-behavior models adequatelyfit the data. These models would suggest that moral reasoning and physician attitudes have more of an influence on behavior than physician intentions.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

BENTLER, P. M. (1980) "Multivariate analysis with latent variables: causal modeling." Ann. Rev. of Psychology 31: 419-456.

BENTLER, P. M. and G. SPECKART (1979) "Models of attitude-behavior relations." Psych. Rev. 86: 452-464.

BLASI, A. (1980) "Bridging moral cognition and moral action: a critical review of the literature." Psych. Bull. 88: 1-45.

CANDEE, D. (1978, October) "Role concepts as predictors of pediatric residents'performance." Presented at the American Pediatric Association Meeting, New York.

CANDEE, D. , T. J. SHEEHAN , C. D. COOK , S.D.R. HUSTED , and M. BARGEN (1982) "Moral reasoning and decisions in dilemmas of neonatal care." Pediatric Research 16: 846-850.

COLBY, A. , L. KOHLBERG , J. C. GIBBS , D. CANDEE , A. HEWER , and B. SPEICHER-DUBIN (forthcoming) The Measurement of Moral Judgment. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.

DONNELLY, J. (1979) "The internship experience: coping and ego development in young physicians." Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Harvard University.

FISHBEIN, M. and I. AJZEN (1975) Belief, Attitude, Intention and Behavior: An Introduction to Theory and Research. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.

FLANDERS, N. A. (1970) Analyzing Teaching Behavior. Reading, MA: AddisonWesley.

10.

GILLIGAN, C. (1982) In a Different Voice: Psychological Theory and Women's Development. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Univ. Press.

11.

HILFIKER, D. (1983) "Allowing the debilitated to die." New England J. of Medicine 308: 716-719.

12.

JORESKOG, K. G. and D. SORBOM (1981) LISREL V: Analysis of Linear Structural Relationships by the Method of Maximum Likelihood (User's Guide). Chicago: International Educational Services.

13.

KOHLBERG, L. (1969) "Stage and sequence: the cognitive-developmental approach to socialization," in D. Goslin (ed.) Handbook of Socialization Theory and Research. Skokie, IL: Rand-McNally.

14.

KOHLBERG, L. and A. HEWER (1983) "Moral stages: the current formulation of Kohlberg's theory and a response to critics," in Human Development Monographs (vol. 10). New York: S. Karger.

15.

KOLLEMORTEN, I. , C. STRANDBERG , B. M. THOMSEN , O. WIBERG , T. WINDFELD-SCHMIDT , V. BINDER , L. ELSBORG , C. HENDRIKSEN , E. KRISTENSEN , J. R. MADSEN , M. K RASMUSSEN , L. WILLUMSEN , H. R. WULFF , and P. RIIS (1981) "Ethical aspects of clinical decision-making." J. of Medical Ethics 7: 67-69.

16.

KURTINESS, W. and W. GRIEF (1974) "The development of moral thought: review and evaluation of Kohlberg's approach." Psych. Bull. 81: 453-470.

17.

LOEVINGER, J. (1976) Ego Development: Conceptions and Theories. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

18.

NORMAN, G. , P. TUGWELL , and J. FEIGHTNER (1982) "A comparison of resident performance in real and simulated patients." J. of Medical Education 57: 708-715.

19.

PRICE, P. B. , C. W. TAYLOR , D. E. NELSON , E. G. LEWIS , G. E. LOUGHMILLER , R. MATHIESEN , S. MURRAY , and J. MAXWELL (1971) Measurement and Predictors of Physician Performance: Two Decades of Intermittently Sustained Research. Salt Lake City: LLR Press.

20.

REST, J. R. (forthcoming) "Morality," in J. Flavell and E. Markam (eds.) Carmichael's Manual of Child Psychology, Volume on Cognitive Development (4th ed.), New York: John Wiley.

21.

REST, J. R. (1979) Development in Judging Moral Issues. Minneapolis: Univ. of Minnesota Press.

22.

SANAZARO, P. J. and J. W. WILLIAMSON (1970) "Physician performance and its effects on patients: a classification based on reports by internists, surgeons, pediatricians and obstetricians." Medical Care 8: 299-308.

23.

SANAZARO, P. J. and J. W. WILLIAMSON (1968) "A classification of physician performance in internal medicine." J. of Medical Education 43: 389-397.

24.

SHEEHAN, T. J. , S.D.R. HUSTED , D. CANDEE , C. D. COOK , and M. BARGEN (1980) "Moral judgment as a predictor of clinical performance." Evaluation & The Health Professions 3: 393-404.

25.

SHWEDER, R. (1982) "Review of Lawrence Kohlberg's essays on moral development, vol. 1: the philosophy of moral development." Contemporary Psychology 27:421-424.

26.

SIMPSON, E. L. (1974) "Moral development research." Human Development 17: 81-106.

27.

WALKER, L. (forthcoming) "Sex differences in the development of moral reasoning: a critical review." Child Development.

28.

WINGARD, J. R. and J. W. WILLIAMSON (1973) "Grades as predictors of physicians' career performance: an evaluative literature review." J. of Medical Education 48: 311-322.