Changes in beginning medical students' preferred interview responses appear attributable to a course that emphasizes communication techniques for developing patient rapport. For each offive successive classes, pre /postcourse preferences were obtained for alternative response modes (categorized as understanding, probing, interpretive, supportive, and evaluative. Analysis indicated significant increases in students' preferences for understanding responses and decreases in preferences for evaluative responses (p < .001). Changes are in the desired direction with respect to course goals, since rapport is generally enhanced by conveying understanding and refraining from premature evaluation. Effects on response preferences of some instructor characteristics are analyzed. Implications for health professions education and research are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BARBEE, R. A.
and L. W. CHOSY (1976) "The quantitative evaluation of student performance in the medical interview."J. of Medical Education42: 238-243.
2.
BARNES, H.V.
, M. ALBANESE, J. SCHROEDER, and S. REITER (1978) "Senior medical students teaching the basic skills of history and physical examination."J. of Medical Education53: 432-434.
3.
BERNSTEIN, L.
, R. S. BERNSTEIN, and R. H. DANA (1973) Interviewing: A guide for Health Professionals. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts.
4.
BLUM, R. H.
(1960) The Management of the Doctor-Patient Relationship. New York: McGrawHill.
5.
BOGDANOFF, M.D.
, C.R. NICHOLS, R. E KLEIN, and C. EISDORFER (1965) "The doctor-patient relationship."J. of the Amer. Medical Assn.192, 1: 45-48.
6.
CAMPBELL, D. T.
and J. C. STANLEY (1963) Experimental and QuasiExperimental Designs for Research. Skokie, IL: Rand McNally.
7.
CARROLL, J. C.
and J. MONROE (1980) "Teaching clinical interviewing in the health professions: a review of empirical research."Evaluation & the Health Professions3: 21-45.
8.
ENELOW, A.
and M. WEXLER (1966) Psychiatry in the Practice of Medicine. Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press.
9.
FLAX, J.
and J. GARRARD (1974) "Students teaching students: a model for medical education."J. of Medical Education49: 380-383.
10.
HELFER, R. E.
, M. A. BLACK and M. E. HELFER (1975) "Pediatric interviewing skills taught by non-physicians."Amer. J. of Diseases of Children129: 1053-1057.
11.
HESS, J. W.
(1969) " A comparison of methods for evaluating medical student skill in relating to patients."J. of Medical Education44: 934-938.
12.
HINZ, C. F
(1966) "Direct observation as a means of teaching and evaluating student skill in relating to patients."J. of Medical Education41: 150-161.
13.
HOPKE, W. E.
(1955) "The measurement of counselor attitudes."J. of Counseling Psychology2: 212-216.
14.
HULKA, B.
, J. CASSEL, L. KUPPER, and J. BURDETTE (1976) "Communication, compliance, and concordance between physicians and patients with prescribed medications."Amer. J. of Public Health66: 847-853.
15.
JACKSON, G.B.
(1980) "Methods for integrative reviews."Rev. of Educ. Research50, 3: 438-460.
16.
JARRETT F. J.
, P. WALDRON, P. BURRA, and J. R. HANDFORTH (1972) " Measuring interviewing skill: the Queen's University Interviewer Rating Scale (QUIRS)."Canadian Psychiatric Assn. J.17, 3: 183-188.
17.
JONES, J. E.
(1967) "Helping relationship response tendencies and occupational affiliation."Personnel and Guidance J.46: 671-675.
18.
KAHN, G.
, B. COHEN, and H. JASON (1979) "The teaching of interpersonal skills in the United States medical schools."J. of Medical Education54: 29-35.
19.
KERLINGER, E N.
(1973) Foundations of Behavioral Research. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
20.
KIMBALL, C. P.
(1969) "Techniques of interviewing, I: interviewing and the meaning of the sympton."Annals of Internal Medicine71, 1: 147-153.
21.
KORSCH, B. M.
, E. K. BOZZI, and V. FRANCIS (1969) " Gaps in doctor-patient communication."Pediatrics42: 855-871.
22.
LENNOX, B.
(1980) "Observations on some foul papers in medical education: a referee's whistle."Medical Education14: 179-183.
23.
MUNGER, P. F
, R. A. S. MYERS, and D. F BROWN (1963) " Guidance institutes and the persistence of attitudes: a progress report."Personnel and Guidance J.41: 415-419.
24.
PORTER, E. H., Jr.
(1950) An Introduction to Therapeutic Counseling. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
25.
REMOS, G. D.
and F H. ZUWAYLIF (1963) "Counselor movement as a result of an intensive six-week training program in counseling."Personnel and Guidance J.42: 125-128.
26.
ROGERS, C. R.
(1958) "The characteristics of helping relationship."Personnel and Guidance J.37, 1: 6-16.
27.
SMITH, C. K.
, R. R. HADAC, and J. H. LEVERSEE (1980) "Evaluating the effects of a medical interviewing course taught at multiple locations."J. of Medical Education55, 9: 792-794.
28.
STILLMAN, P. L.
, D. L. SABERS, and D. L. REDFIELD (1977) " Use of trained mothers to teach interviewing skills to first-year medical students: a follow-up study."Pediatrics66: 165-169.
