Rating systems and criteria, developedfor peer review, were used for evaluation of dental care as part of a study to determine the feasibility of using computers as a first level screening mechanism for quality assurance. Ten dentists were trained and standardized in the use of the system, and 646 patients receivedfull-mouth examinations by two examiners. Disagreements were resolved by joint examination. More than 22,000 individual judgments were recorded. Of all dental services evaluated, 91.5% were rated satisfactory. Data on subratings, Range of Excellence versus Range of Acceptability and Replace for Prevention (future damage likely) versus Replace Statim (damage now occurring) are also presented, together with interexaminer agreement levels. The rating system permitted full-mouth examination by two trained examiners, including resolution of disagreements, to be carried out in an average of 24 minutes. The system is suitablefor verification of computer screening of treatment records for quality assurance.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ABRAMOWITZ, J.
(1966) "Expanded functions for dental assistants: a preliminary study." of the Amer. Dental Assn.72 (February): 386-391.
2.
ABRAMOWITZ, J.
and R. E. MECKLENBURG (1972) "Quality of care in dental practice: the approach of the Indian Health Service."J. of Public Health Dentistry32 (Spring): 90-99.
3.
BAILIT, H. L.
, M. KOSLOWSKY, J. E. GRASSO, S. HOLZMAN, R. LEVINE, P. VALLUZZO, and P. ATWOOD (1974) "Quality of dental care: development of standards."J. of the Amer. Dental Assn.80 (October): 842-853.
4.
California Dental Association [CDA]
(1977) Quality Evaluation for Dental Care: Guidelines for the Assessment of Clinical Quality and Professional Performance. Los Angeles: CDA.
5.
CONS, N. C.
(1971) "Method for post-treatment evaluation of the quality of dental care."J. of Public Health Dentistry31 (Spring): 104-108.
6.
Council on Dental Care Programs, American Dental Association [ADA]
(1967) "Dental Society review committees,"Statement approved by the House of Delegates in 1967. Chicago: ADA.
7.
DEVINCENZI, R. G.
and G. RYGE (1979) "Using computer technology for screening in dental quality assurance."California Dental Assn. J.7 (October): 31-45.
8.
DIEFENBACH, V.
(1972) "The role of organized dentistry in quality of dental care." Presented at the Spring Work Conference of the Philadelphia County Dental Society, Philadelphia, April 7.
9.
FRIEDMAN, J. W.
(1972) A Guide for the Evaluation of Dental Care. Los Angeles: University of California School of Public Health.
10.
GRASSO, J. E.
, J. NABALDIAN, C. SANFORD, and H. L. BAILIT (1979) "The quality of restorative dental care."J. of Prosthetic Dentistry42 (November): 571-578.
11.
HAMMONDS, P. E.
, H. C. JAMISON, and L L. WILSON (1971) "Quality of service provided by dental therapists in experimental programs at the University of Alabama."J. of the Amer. Dental Assn.82 (May): 1060-1066.
12.
HILLSMAN, J. J.
(1978) "Quality assurance in dentistry."J. of the Amer. Dental Assn.97 (November) 787-790.
13.
JAGO, J. D.
(1974) "Issues in assurance of quality dental care."J. of the Amer. Dental Assn.89 (October): 854-865.
14.
KESSNER, D. M.
, C. E. KALK, and J. SINGER (1973) "Assessing health quality-the case for tracers."New England J. of Medicine288 (January): 189-194.
15.
LINDAL, R.
(1980) Personal communication, April.
16.
LOTZKAR, S.
, D. W. JOHNSON, and M. B. THOMPSON (1971) "Experimental program in expanded functions for dental assistants: Phase 3 experiment with dental teams."J. of the Amer. Dental Assn.82 (May): 1067-1081.
17.
MARCUS, M.
(1978) "Quality assessment and assurance." Presented to the National Dental Quality Assurance Workshop, American Fund for Dental Health, Scotsdale, Arizona, February.
18.
MILGROM, P.
(1978a) "Demonstration and evaluation of dental quality assurance model in a predominantly rural state-Montana," Presented to the National Dental Quality Assurance Workshop, American Fund for Dental Health, Scottsdale, Arizona, February.
19.
MILGROM, P.
(1978b) "Dental examinations for quality control: peer review vs. self-assessment."Amer. J. of Public Health63 (April): 394-401.
20.
RAPPAPORT, S. C.
(1971)"Quality control in dental care."New York State Dental J.37 (May): 275-280.
21.
RYGE, G.
(1972) "Biological evaluation of dental materials." In Proceedings of the 50th Anniversary Symposium on Dental Materials Research. National Bureau of Standards Special Publication 354, Dental Materials Research, June.
22.
RYGE, G.
and M. A. SNYDER (1973) "Evaluating the clinical quality of restorations."J. of the Amer. Dental Assn.87 (August): 369-377.
23.
SCHONFELD, H. K.
(1971) "Quality of dental care."J. of the Amer. College of Dentists38 (October): 194-206.
24.
SCHONFELD, H. K.
(1969) "Peer review of quality of dental care."J. of the Amer. Dental Assn.79 (December): 1376-1382.
25.
SCHONFELD, H. K.
(1967) "The quality of dental care in community programs."J. of Public Health Dentistry27 (Spring): 70-82.
26.
SORRICELLI, D. A.
(1970) "Controlling quality in the delivery of dental care." Presented at the 21st National Dental Health Conference, American Dental Association, Chicago, April.
27.
SORRICELLI, D. A.
(1968) "Methods of administrative control for the promotion of quality in dental programs."Amer. J. of Public Health58 (September): 1723-1737.
28.
STERN, S. K.
, S. C. MORRISEY, and J. E. MAUDLIN (1978a) Quality Assurance in Dentistry, Vol. 1: The State of the Art of Dental Quality Assurance. Chicago: American Dental Association.
29.
STERN, S. K.
, S. C. MORRISEY, and J. E. MAUDLIN (1978b) Quality Assurance in Dentistry, Vol. 2: Summary Reports of Quality Assurance Systems. Chicago: American Dental Association.
30.
STRIFFLER, D. F.
(1963) "Quality control in dentistry in integrity and courage." Presented at the 14th National Dental Health Conference, American Dental Association, Chicago, April.
31.
WECKWERT, V. E.
(1970) "On evaluation: a tool or a tyranny-II."Systems Development Project Comment Series 9-11. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota School of Public Health.
