This article reviews currently used quality assurance techniques. It assumes a broad definition of quality that includes attention to the content and professional judgment exercised in the provision of health services, as well as the appropriateness of resource utilization. Emphasis is on more or less generic approaches to review that can be applied regardless of the specific health profession involved. After describing and contrasting various quality assurance techniques, the article concludes with a general discussion of effectiveness, problems in initiating behavior change, and opportunities for further research and evaluation.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
American College of Surgeons, Surgical Practice Department
(1982) Second Surgical Opinion Programs: A Review and Progress Report.
2.
BORCHARDT, P. J.
(1981) "Non-acute profiles: evaluation of physicians' non-acute utilization of hospital resources."Quality Rev. Bull.7: 21-26.
3.
BRIAN, E. W.
(1973) "Foundation for medical care control of hospital utilization: CHAP-A PSRO prototype."New England J. of Medicine288: 828-882.
4.
BRIAN, E. W.
(1972) "Government control of hospital utilization, a California experience."New England J. of Medicine286: 134-1344.
5.
BRISTOW, D.
, C. STICKNEY, and S. THOMPSON (1976) Discharge Planning for Continuity of Care. New York: National League for Nursing.
6.
BROOK, R. H.
, A. R. DAVIES, and C. J. KAMBERG (1980) "Selected reflections on quality of medical care evaluation in the 1980's."Nursing Research29: 127-133.
7.
BROWN, C., Jr.
, and H. UHL (1970) "Mandatory continuing education, sense or nonsense?"J. of the Amer. Medical Association213: 1660-1668.
8.
COLMAN, H. L.
(1976) "The problem oriented dental record."California Dental Association J.4: 50-54.
9.
Congressional Budget Office
(1981) The Impact of PSROs on Health Care Costs: Update of Congressional Budget Office's 1979 Evaluation. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
10.
DAVIDSON, S. M.
, R. C. Wacker, and D. H. KLEIN (1973) "Professional standards review organizations, acritique."J. of the Amer. Medical Association226: 1106-1108.
11.
DAVIS, K.
(1981) "Regulation of hospital costs: the evidence on performance." Prepared for the Duke University Medical Center Private Sector Conference, Durham, North Carolina, March 23.
12.
DEMLO, L. K.
and P. M. CAMPBELL (1981) "Improving hospital discharge data: lessons from the national hospital discharge survey."Medical Care10: 1030-1040.
13.
DEMLO, L. K.
and S. S. BROWN (1978) "Reliability of information abstracted from patients' medical records."Medical Care16: 995-1105.
14.
DINEL, B.
(1978) "Quality assurance in hospital pharmacy practice."Canadian J. of Hospital Pharmacy32: 101-105.
15.
DISTEL, L.
(1981) "More than chart review: a new problem-oriented nursing quality assurance program."Quality Rev. Bull.7: 26-29.
16.
DONABEDIAN, A.
(1982) Explorations in Quality Assessment and Monitoring, Vol. II. The Criteria and Standards of Quality. Ann Arbor, MI: Health Administration Press.
17.
DONABEDIAN, A.
(1980) Explorations in Quality Assessment and Monitoring, Vol. I. The Definition of Quality and Approaches to its Assessment. Ann Arbor, MI: Health Administration Press.
18.
DONABEDIAN, A.
(1979) "The quality of medical care: a concept in search of a definition."J. of Family Practice9: 277-284.
19.
DONEBEDIAN, A.
(1978) Needed Research in the Assessment and Monitoring of the Quality of Medical Care. Research Report Series. Hyattsville, MD: U.S. Department of Health, Education and Welfare, National Center for Health Services Research.
20.
DONEBEDIAN, A.
(1969) A Guide to Medical Care Administration, Vol. II. Medical Care Appraisal. New York: American Public Health Association.
21.
EISENBERG, J. M.
and S. V. WILLIAMS (1981) "Cost containment and changing physicians' practice behavior."J. of the Amer. Medical Association246: 2195-2201.
22.
ESCOVITZ, G.
, G. L. BURKETT, J. C. KUHN, C. ZELEZNIK, and J. GONNELLA (1978) "The effects of mandatory quality assurance: a review of hospital medical audit process."Medical Care16: 941-949.
23.
FLASHNER, B. A.
, S. REED, R. W. COBURN, and P. R. FINE (1973) "Professional standards review organizations, analysis of their development and implementation based on a preliminary review of the hospital admission and surveillance program in Illinois."J. of the Amer. Medical Association223: 1473-1484.
24.
FLEISHER, D. S.
, C. R. BROWN, Jr., C. ZELEZNIK, G.H. ESCOVITZ, and C. ONDAL (1976) "The Mandate Project: institutionalizing a system of patient care quality assurance."Pediatrics57: 775-775.
25.
GERTMAN, P. M.
and J. D. RESTUCCIA (1981) "The appropriateness evaluation protocol: a technique for assessing unnecessary day of hospital care."Medical Care19: 855-871.
26.
GOLDBERG, G. A.
and D. C. HOLLOWAY (1975) "Emphasizing 'level of care' over 'length of stay' in hospital utilization review."Medical Care13: 474-485.
27.
GOLDBERG, G. A.
, L. M. HEIN, S. M. ROSALES, and J. F. ALEXANDER (1977) "Criteria and flowsheet for utilization review by level of care."Western J. of Medicine126: 318-323.
28.
GONNELLA, J. S.
and M. J. GORAN (1975) "Quality of patient care-A measurement of change: the staging concept."Medical Care13: 467-473.
29.
GONNELLA, J. S.
, D. Z. LOUIS, and J. J. MC CORD (1976) "The staging concept-an approach to the assessment of outcome of ambulatory care."Medical Care14: 12-21.
30.
GORAN, M. J.
(1979) "The evaluation of the PSRO hospital review system."Medical Care Supplement17: 1-47.
31.
GORAN, M. J.
, J. S. ROBERTS, M. A. KELLOGG, J. FIELDING, and W. JESSEE (1975) "The PSRO hospital review system."Medical Care Supplement13: 1-33.
32.
GREENFIELD, S.
, C. E. LEWIS, S. H. KAPLAN, and M. B. DAVIDSON (1975) "Peer review by criteria mapping: criteria for diabetes mellitus."Annals of Internal Medicine83: 761-770.
33.
GREENFIELD, S.
, S. CRETIN, L. G. WORTHAM, F. J. DOREY, N. E. SOLOMON, and G. A. GOLDBERG (1981) "Comparison of a criteria map to a criteria list in quality-of-care assessment for patients with chest pain: the relation of each to outcome."Medical Care19: 255-272.
34.
Hancock/ Dikewood Services, Inc.
(1981) Final Report. Assessment of the Factors Which Impact on the Accuracy of Concurrent Review Decisions in Two PSROs Using ISD Criteria. Albuquerque, NM: Hancock/ Dikewood Services.
35.
Health Care Financing Administration
(1980) 1979 PSRO Program Evaluation. Washington, DC: HCFA.
36.
HESS, A. E.
(1966) "Medicare and utilization review."J. of the Amer. Medical Association196: 177-178.
37.
HILLSMAN, J. T.
(1978) "Quality assurance in dentistry."J. of the Amer. Dental Association97: 787-790.
38.
HOFFMAN, R. P.
, R. RAVIN, D. M. COLALUCA, R. GIFFORD, D. GRIMES, R. GRZEGORCZYK, F. KEOWN, F. KUHN, R. McKAY, J. PEYSER, T. RYAN, and C. ZALEWSKI (1980) "Development of a multi-hospital pharmacy quality assurance program."Hospital Pharmacy15: 365-380.
39.
HORN, B. J.
and M. A. SEVAIN (1978) Criteria Measures of Nursing Care Quality: A Health Status Instrument. Publication (PHS) 78-3187. Hyattsville, MD: National Center for Health Services Research, Department of Health, Education and Welfare.
40.
HOROWITZ, K. N.
and M. LAMNIN (1980) "Design and implementation of a quality assurance program for pharmaceutical services."Amer. J. of Hospital Pharmacy37: 82-84.
41.
Hospital Research and Educational Trust [HRET], American Hospital Association
(1975) "Final report on the quality assurance program demonstration project." Presented to the W. K. Kellogg Foundation, Chicago.
42.
HOVER, J.
and M. ZIMMER (1978) "Nursing quality assurance: the Wisconsin system." Nursing Outlook.
43.
Inquiry
(1965) Special Issue: National Research and Statistics Conference. Part I, Utilization Review and Control Mechanisms.
44.
InterQual
(1979) Description of Cyclic Review and of ISD Criteria. Bethesda, MD: InterQual.
45.
INUI, T. S.
, K. M. STEVENSON, D. PLORDE, and I. MURPHY (1981) "Identifying hospital patients who need early discharge planning for special dispositions: a comparison of alternative techniques."Medical Care19: 922-929.
46.
Institute of Medicine
(1976) Assessing Quality in Health Care: An Evaluation. Washington, DC: National Academy of Sciences.
47.
Institute of Medicine
(1973) A Strategy for Evaluating Health Services. Contrasts In Health Status, Vol. 2. Washington, DC. National Academy of Sciences.
48.
Joint Commission on-Accreditation of Hospitals [JCAH]
(1981) Accreditation Manual for Hospitals. Chicago: JCAH.
49.
KESSNER, D. M.
(1978) "Quality assessment and assurance: early signs of cognitive dissonance."New England J. of Medicine298: 381-386.
50.
KESSNER, D. M.
, C. E. KALK, and J. SINGER (1973) "Assessing health quality-the case for tracers."New England J. of Medicine288: 189-194.
51.
KESSNER, D. M.
, J. SINGER, and C. K. SNOW (1975) Assessing Ambulatory Care: The Use of an Enriched Encounter Form. Washington, DC: Department of Health, Education and Welfare, Office of Health Evaluation.
52.
KESSNER, D. M.
, C. K. SNOW, and J. SINGER (1974) Assessment of Medical Care for Children. Contrasts In Health Status. 3. Washington, DC: Institute of Medicine, National Academy of Sciences.
53.
KOLINS, M.
, and D. K. BAUGH (1978) "An evaluation of a Medicare concurrent utilization review project: the Sacramento certified hospital admission program."Health Insurance Statistics (March 17).
54.
LINDY, C.
(1980) "A three-part approach to quality assurance in nursing."Quality Rev. Bull.6: 12-16.
55.
MARCUS, M.
, A. L. KOCH, and J. A. GERSHEN (1979) "A record review model for assessing dental practices."California Dental Association J.7: 51-54.
56.
McAULIFFE, W. E.
(1979) "Measuring the quality of medical care: process versus outcome."Milbank Memorial Fund Q.57: 118-152.
57.
McAULIFFE, W. E.
(1978) "Studies of process-outcome correlations in medical care evaluations: a critique."Medical Care16: 907-930.
58.
Medical Care Foundation of the Sacramento County Medical Society
(1971) CHAPCertified Hospital Admission Program. Sacramento: SCMS.
59.
MILGROM, P.
(1978) Regulation and the Quality of Dental Care. Germantown, MD: Aspens System Corp.
60.
NOVICK, L. F.
, K. DICKINSON, R. ASNES, and R. LOWENSTEIN (1976) "Assessment of ambulatory care: application of the tracer methodology."Medical Care14: 1-12.
61.
NUTTING, P. A.
, G. I. SHORR, and B. R. BURKHALTER (1981) "Assessing the performance of medical care systems: a method and its application."Medical Care19: 281-296.
62.
PAYNE, B. C.
and T. F. LYONS (1972) Method of Evaluating and Improving Personal Medical Care Quality. Episode of Illness Study for Hawaii Medical Association. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan, School of Medicine.
63.
PSRO "X"
(1981) "Evaluating myocardial infarction using the staging concept."Quality Rev. Bull.7: 15-20.
64.
REICHELT, P. A.
and J. NEWCOMB (1980) "Organizational factors in discharge planning."J. of Nursing Administration (December): 36-42.
65.
RESTUCCIA, J. D.
and D. C. HOLLOWAY (1976) "Barriers to appropriate utilization."Medical Care14: 559-573.
66.
RIEDEL, D. C.
and T. B. FITZPATRICK (1964) Patterns of Patient Care, A Study of Hospital Use in Six Diagnoses. Ann Arbor: Univ. of Michigan Press.
67.
ROMM, F. J.
, B. S. HULKA, and F. MAYO (1976) "Correlations of outcomes in patients with congestive heart failure."Medical Care14: 765-776.
68.
RUBIN, L.
(1975) Comprehensive Quality Assurance System: The Kaiser-Permanente Approach. Alexandria, VA: American Group Practice Association.
69.
RUBIN, L.
and M. A. KELLOGG (1977) "The comprehensive quality assurance system," pp. 147-167 in G. Giebink and N. White (eds.) Ambulatory Medical Care Quality Assurance.
70.
RUTSTEIN, D. D.
, W. BERENBERG, T. C. CHALMERS, C. G. CHILD III, A. P. FISHMAN, and E. B. PERRIN (1976) "Measuring the quality of medical care (Tables Revised, 9/1/77): a clinical method."New England J. of Medicine294: 582-588.
71.
SAYETTA, R. B.
(1976) "Critique of an earlier study of the Sacramento medical care foundation's certified hospital admission program (CHAP)."Medical Care14: 80-90.
72.
SKILLICORN, S. A.
(1981) "The quality of a relationship."Quality Rev. Bull.7: 12-19.
73.
TABATABAI, C.
(1981) " A conversation with Dr. Stanley A. Skillicorn."Quality Rev. Bull.7: 20-23.
74.
THOMPSON, R.
(1982) Personal Communication in Nancy O. Graham, Quality Assurance in Hospitals: Strategies for Assessment and Implementation. Rockville, MD: Aspen Systems Corp.
75.
U.S. Department of Health, Education and Welfare, Social Security Administration
(1966) Headquarters Highlights27: 1-1.
76.
WELCH, C. E.
(1975) "PSRO Guidelines for criteria of care."J. of the Amer. Medical Association232: 47-50.
77.
WILLIAMSON, J. W.
(1978) "Formulating priorities for quality assurance activity: description of a method and its application."J. of the Amer. Medical Association239: 631-637.
78.
WILLIAMSON, J. W.
, H. R. BRASWELL, and S. D. HORN (1979) "Validity of medical staffjudgments in establishing quality assurance priorities."Medical Care17: 331-346.
79.
WILLIAMSON, J. W.
and S. LOHMEYER (1978) "Priority setting in quality assurance: reliability of staff judgments in medical institutions."Medical Care16: 931-940.
80.
WILLIAMSON, J. W.
, P. C. OSTROW, and H. R. BRASWELL (1981) Health Accounting for Quality Assurance. A Manual for Assessing and Improving Outcomes of Care. American Occupational Therapy Association.
81.
WILLIAMSON, J. W.
, S. ARONOVITCH, L. SIMONSON, C. RAMIREZ, and D. KELLY (1975) "Health accounting: an outcome-based system of quality assurance: illustrative applications to hypertension."Bulletin. New York Academy of Medicine51: 727-738.
82.
WHITE, S. J.
and H. H. GODWIN (1977) "A unit dose quality assurance program."Hospital Pharmacy12: 90-96.
83.
WYLIE, C. M.
, and B. A. FLASHNER (1979) "Reassessing the early effect of concurrent review on length of stay."Medical Care17: 607-617.
