This article reviews: (a) the descriptive models and research findings of the processes and skills characterizing medical problem-solving, and (b) the recent investigations of teaching and predicting medical problem-solving ability. Results are discussed and suggestions for direction and design of future studies are provided in an effort to increase the usefulness of results for applications to medical education.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AllalL. K.ShulmanL.(1974)“Training medical students to generate diagnostic problem formulations,” pp. 267–268 in Proceedings of the 13th Annual Conference on Research in Medical Education. Washington, DC: Association of American Medical Colleges
2.
AndrewB. J.(1974)“An approach to the construction of simulated exercises in clinical problem-solving.”J. of Medical Education47: 952–958
3.
BarrowsH. S.(1977)“An approach to teaching clinical problem-solving.” Paper adapted from two presentations at the 16th Annual Conference on Research in Medical Education
4.
BarrowsH. S.BennettK.(1972)“The diagnostic (problem-solving) skill of the neurologist.”Archives of Neurology26: 273–277
5.
BarrowsH. S.TamblynR. M.(1977)“The portable patient problem pack: a problem-based learning unit.”J. of Medical Education52: 1002–1004
6.
BashookP. G.(1976)“A conceptual framework for measuring clinical problem-solving.”J. of Medical Education51: 109–113
7.
BernerE. S.TremontiL. P.(1976)“The attainment of specified objectives by medical students in different learning environments.”Medical Education10: 167–169
8.
BernerE. S.BlighT. J.GuerinR. O.(1977)“An indication for a process dimension in medical problem-solving.”J. of Medical Education11: 324–328
9.
BernerE.S.TremontiL. P.KuliekeJ. J.ShafterH. A.(1976)“Teasing apart the problem-solving process,” pp. 155–160 in Proceedings of the 15th Annual Conference on Research in Medical Education. Washington, DC: Association of American Medical Colleges
10.
BieriJ.AtkinsA. L.BriarS.LeamanR. L.MillerH.TripodiT.(1966)Clinical and Social Judgement.New York: John Wiley
11.
DonnellyM. B.GallagherR. E.HessJ. W.HoganM. J.(1974)“The dimensionality of measures derived from complex clinical simulations,” pp. 14–19 in Proceedings of the 15th Annual Conference on Research in Medical Education
12.
EkwoE. E.(1977)“An analysis of the problem-solving process of third year medical students.” pp. 317–322 in Proceedings of the 16th Annual Conference on Research in Medical Education. Washington, DC: Association of American Medical Colleges
13.
ElsteinA. S.(1974)“The Medical Inquiry Project: major findings and implications for medical education,” pp. 264–266 in Proceedings of the 13th Annual Conference on Research in Medical Education. Washington, DC: Association of American Medical Colleges
14.
ElsteinA. S.ShulmanL. S.SprafkaS. A.(1978)Medical Problem-Solving: An Analysis of Clinical Reasoning.Cambridge, MA: Harvard Univ. Press
15.
ErdmannJ. B.(1964)An Appraisal of Three Scoring Procedures as Discriminators Between Good and Poor Problem-Solvers.Chicago: Psychometric Laboratory. (Loyola Psychometric Laboratory Publication 40)
16.
FeightnerJ. W.(1977)“Clinical methods of physicians: a comparison of primary and secondary care physicians,” pp. 354–355 in Proceedings of the 16th Annual Conference on Research in Medical Education. Washington, DC: Association of American Medical Colleges
17.
FeightnerJ. W.NormanG. R.(1976)“Concurrent validity of patient management problems by comparison with the clinical encounter,” pp. 149–160 in Proceedings of the 15th Annual Conference on Research in Medical Education. Washington, DC: Association of American Medical Colleges
18.
FreemanJ.ByrneP. S.(1977)“Clinical factual recall and patient management skill in general practice.”Medical Education11: 39–47
19.
FrenchJ. W.EkstromR. B.PriceL. A.(1963)Manual for the Kit of Reference Tests for Cognitive Factors.Princeton, NJ: Educational Testing Service
20.
FriedmanR. B.KorstD. R.SchultzJ. V.BeattyE.EntineS.(1978)“Experience with the simulated patient physician encounter.”J. of Medical Education53: 825–830
21.
GordonM. J.(1974)“Heuristic training for diagnostic problem-solving,” p. 269 in Proceedings of the 13th Annual Conference of Research in Medical Education
22.
GorryA. G.(1970)“Modeling the diagnostic process.”J. of Medical Education45: 293–302
HelferR. E.SlaterC. H.(1971)“Measuring the process of solving clinical diagnostic problems.”British J. of Medical Education5: 53–55
25.
HoganM. J.SirotkinR. A.GallagherR. E.(1977)“Clinical problem-solving: the relationship of cognitive abilities to PMP performance.” pp. 323–326 in Proceedings of the 16th Annual Conference on Research in Medical Education. Washington, DC: Association of American Medical Colleges
26.
KozieleckiJ.(1972)“Model for diagnostic problem-solving.”Acta Psychologica36: 370–380
27.
KrugS. E.ScheierJ. H.CattellR. B.(1976)Handbook for the IPAT Anxiety Scale.Champaign, IL: Institute for Personality and Ability Testing
28.
KrupkaJ. W.ElsteinA. S.MolidorJ. B.KingL.ParsonsM.SonL.(1977)“Assessment of empathy skills and problem-solving skills as a screen for admission to medical school.” Final Report on the National Fund for Medical Education. (NFME Grant #47–74)
29.
MawardiB. H.(1978)“Perceptual style as predictor of clinical performance in medicine. Presented at the meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Toronto, April
30.
MccarthyW. H.GonnellaJ. S.(1967)“The simulated patient management problem: a technique for evaluating and teaching clinical competence.”British J. of Medical Education1: 348–352
31.
McguireC.PageG.(1973)“The assessment of clinical performance by written and oral simulations.” Report to the faculty, 1972–1973, Center for Educational Development, University of Illinois College of Medicine, Chicago
MillerG. E. [ed.] (1961)Teaching and Learning in Medical School.Cambridge, MA: Harvard Univ. Press
35.
MurrayT. S.CupplesR. W.BarberJ. H.DunnW. R.ScottD. B.HannayD. R.(1977)“Teaching decision-making to medical undergraduates by computer-assisted learning.”Medical Education11: 262–264
36.
NeufeldV. R.(1977)“Clinical reasoning of medical students–-a longitudinal study,” pp. 352–354 in Proceedings of the 16th Annual Conference on Research in Medical Education. Washington, DC: Association of American Medical Colleges
37.
NeufeldV. R.NormanG. R.FeightnerJ. W.BarrowsH. S.(1975)“Clinical methods of medical students 11: a cross-sectional analysis.” pp. 149–154 in Proceedings of the 14th Annual Conference on Research in Medical Education. Washington, DC: Association of American Medical Colleges
38.
NormanG. R.BarrowsH. S.FeightnerJ. W.NeufeldV. R.(1974)“Clinical judgment of students–-a preliminary report,” pp. 56–61 in Proceedings of the 13th Annual Conference on Research in Medical Education. Washington, DC: Association of American Medical Colleges
Omnibus Personality Inventory(1968)New York: Psychological Corporation
41.
ParmeterJ. T.SprafkaS. A.DennyM. S.MintzesC. A.(1975)“Procedure for evaluating clinically correlated problem-solving skills which maximizes information,” pp. 155–160 in Proceedings of the 14th Annual Conference on Research in Medical Education. Washington, DC: Association of American Medical Colleges
42.
PaukerS. J.GorryG. A.KassirerJ. P.SchwartzW. B.(1976)“Towards the simulation of clinical cognition.”Amer. J. of Medicine60: 981–996
43.
RokeachM.(1960)The Open and Closed Mind.New York: Basic Books
44.
SchwartzS. H.SimonR. I.(1976)“Systems approach to studying information processing and decision making in medical diagnosis,” in WesleyH. H. (eds.) Health Research: The Systems Approach. New York: Springer
TaylorP. J.HarasymP. H.LaurensonR. D.(1978)“Introducing first-year medical students of early diagnostic hypotheses.”J. of Medical Education53: 402–409
47.
VisonhalerJ. F.ChanS. W.WagnerC.ElsteinA. S.(1975)“Computer simulation of clinical decision-making: a new approach.” pp. 105–110 in Proceedings of the 14th Annual Conference on Research in Medical Education. Washington, DC: Association of American Medical Colleges
48.
VuN. V.(1979)“Medical problem-solving assessment: a review of methods and instruments.”Evaluation and the Health Professions2: 281–307
