Evaluation Criteria in Studies of Continuing Education in the Health Professions : A Critical Review and a Suggested Strategy

Abstract

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Barlow, D. J. , & Bruhn, J. G. Role-plays on television--a new teaching technique . Nursing Outlook, 1973, 20, 265-266.

Benfield, W. R. , Rosenbluth, S. A. , Ryan, M. R. , & Smith, M. C. Detection of early warning signs of cancer by community pharmacists : an evaluation of training on professional behavior. American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education, 1977, 41, 23-28.

Bloch, D. Evaluation of nursing care in terms of process and outcome : issues in research and quality assurance. Nursing Research, 1975, 24, 256-263.

Boeck, M. A. , Wood, F. C. & Dohner, C. W. Continuing education: assessment of value of discussion sessions and of course impact on physician practice. Northwest Medicine , 1972, 71,519-522.

Caplan, R. M. Measuring the effectiveness of continuing medical education. Journal of Medical Education , 1973, 48, 1150-1152.

Carpenter, K. F. , & Kroth, J. A. Effects of videotaped role playing on nurses' therapeutic communication skills. Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing, 1976, 7, 47-53.

Chambers, D. W.

How can learning experiences in continuing dental education be evaluated in relation to patient benefit?

The Journal of the American College of Dentists, 1976, 43,238-248.

Chambers, D. W. , & Hamilton, D. L. Continuing dental education: reasonable answers to unreasonable questions. Journal of the American Dental Association , 1975, 90, 116-120.

Condon, S. M. B. Teaching the teachers. Nursing Outlook, 1971,19, 804-806.

10.

Condon, S. M. B. Inservice education...impact on patient care. Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing , 1972, 3, 34-38.

11.

del Bueno, D. Continuing education, spinach and other good things. Journal of Nursing Administration , 1977,7, 32-34.

12.

Denne, K. T. , Schorow, M. , Ulicny, S. , & Ulmer, D. Mass communication media in continuing education.Journal of Medical Education, 1972 , 47, 712-716.

13.

Donegan, J. H. , Reid, C. , & Eggers, G. W. N. The use of test results from ASA workshops to evaluate workshop effectiveness . Journal of Medical Education, 1976, 51, 500-505.

14.

Donnelly, F. A. , Ware, J. E. , Wolkon, G. H. , & Naftulin, D.H. Evaluation of weekend seminars for physicians. Journal of Medical Education, 1972, 47, 184-187.

15.

Forni, P. R. , & Overman, R. T. Does continuing education have an effect on the practice of nursing? a survey. Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing , 1974, 5, 44-51.

16.

Hazlett, C. B. , Bachynski, J. E. , & Embleton, J. Evaluation on on-campus continuing medical education programs in Alberta . Canadian Medical Association Journal, 1973 , 108, 1282-1287.

17.

Heffernan, B. M. Keeping nurses up to date . Nursing Outlook, 1972, 20, 265-266.

18.

Inui, T. S. , Yourtee, E. L. , & Williamson, J. W. Improved outcomes in hypertension after physician tutorials: a controlled trial. Annals of Internal Medicine, 1976, 84, 646-651.

19.

Jansen, E. Description of evaluation model of oncology nursing project at Wayne State University.Zerox publication distributed at Oncology Nursing Program Evaluation Meeting, New Haven, Connecticut, January, 1977.

20.

Kane, R. , & Bailey, R. Q. Evaluation of a postgraduate educational programme in early cancer detection. British Journal of Medical Education , 1971, 5, 134-137.

21.

Lewis, C. E. , & Hassanein, R. S. Continuing medical education--an epidemiological evaluation. New England Journal of Medicine, 1970, 282, 254-259.

22.

Linn, L. S. Indicated versus actual behavior: the pharmacist as health adviser. Social Science and Medicine , 1973, 7, 191-197.

23.

Lohrisch, D. , Ryan, M. R. , & Rosenbluth, S. A. The effects of time on continuing education for pharmacists. Paper presented at annual meeting of the American Pharmaceutical Association, New York, May, 1977.

24.

Long, L. D. The evaluation of continuing education efforts. American Journal of Public Health, 1969, 59, 967-973.

25.

Loughmiller, G. C. , Ellison, R. L. , Taylor, C. W. , & Price, P. B. Predicting career performance of physicians using the biographical inventory approach. Proceedings, 78th Annual Convention of the American Psychological Association , 1970, 5 (Part 1), 153-154.

26.

Lynch, L. Toward appropriate change in behavior: measuring knowledge, attitude and skill in continuing education. Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing, 1972 , 3, 6-10.

27.

Lytton, B. , Weiss, R. M. , Schiff, M. , McGuire, E. J. , Scott, R. , & Glenn, J. F. Results of objective evaluation of postgraduate urologic seminar. The Journal of Urology, 1973, 110, 582-584.

28.

McGuire, C. , Hurley, R. E. , Babbott, D. , & Butterworth, J. S. Auscultatory skill: gain and retention after intensive instruction. Journal of Medical Education, 1964, 39,120-131.

29.

McMahon, J. , & Neuman, M. M. Tool for evaluating the impact of an in-service program on nursing care. Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing , 1972, 3, 5-7.

30.

Moraco, R. J. Out-patient nurse involvement--an answer to success. Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing , 1976, 7, 10-17.

31.

Naftulin, D. H. , Ware, J. E. , & Donnelly, F. A. The Doctor Fox lecture: a paradigm of educational seduction. Journal of Medical Education, 1973, 48, 630-635.

32.

Parker, B. , Pierce, M. , & Sturm, I. E. Problem oriented record. Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing, 1975, 6, 35-39.

33.

Popiel, E. S.

Evaluation of the effectiveness of the continuing education course--"new perspectives in college health nursing."

Journal of the American College Health Association, 1971, 19, 169-173.

34.

Provus, M. M. The discrepancy evaluation model . In P. A. Taylor & D. M. Crowley (Eds.), Readings in curriculum evaluation.Dubuque, Iowa: Wm. C. Brown Company, Publishers, 1972.

35.

Rubenstein, E. Continuing medical education at Stanford:the back-to-medical-school program. Journal of Medical Education, 1973, 48, 911-918.

36.

Rudkin, G. J. , & Hamister, S. I. Evaluation of a training program for nursing assistants . Nursing Outlook, 1973, 21, 404-407.

37.

Seifert, M. H. , & Racer, H. Seminar construction through evaluation. Journal of Medical Education, 1972, 47, 660-662.

38.

Shephard, R. M. Evaluation of continuing education . Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine, 1971, 64, 149-150.

39.

Smith, E. N. , Mirabella, J. P. , Hurwitz, F. L. , & Margolin, R. J. Evaluation of a counselors' pilot workshop. Rehabilitation Record, 1963 , 4, 3-7.

40.

Stude, E. W. Evaluation of short-term training for rehabilitation counselors: effectiveness of an institute on epilepsy .Rehabiliation Counselors Bulletin, 1973 , 16, 146-154.

41.

Suchman, E. A. Evaluation research: principles and practice in public service and social action programs. New York: Russell Sage Foundation, 1967.

42.

Taylor, C. W. , Price, P. B. , Richards, J. M. , & Jacobsen, T. L. An investigation of the criterion problem for medical school faculty. Journal of Applied Psychology , 1964, 48, 294-301.

43.

Taylor, C. W. , Price, P. B. , Richards, J. M. & Jacobsen, T. L. An investigation of the criterion problem for a group of medical general practitioners. Journal of Applied Psychology, 1965, 49, 399-406.

44.

Vandewater, S. L. , & Kraus, A. S. Family physician anesthetists: continuing education, observations, evaluation. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 1973, 109, 1228-31.

45.

Wan, L. S. , Lehfeldt, H. , Tsuel, J. J. , Sobrero, A. J. ,& Douglas, G. W. Continuing education in family planning for practicing physicians. American Journal of Public Health, 1974, 64,32-36.

46.

Ware, J. E. , Donnelly, F. A. , & Naftulin, D. H. The evaluation of medical education. Journal of Medical Education , 1970, 45, 813.

47.

Ware, J. E. , & Williams, R. G. The Dr. Fox effect: a study of lecturer effectiveness and ratings of instruction. Journal of Medical Education , 1975, 50, 149-156.

48.

Weinburg, E. Retraining physicians. Journal of Medical Education, 1972, 47, 625-630.

49.

Weiss, C. H. Evaluation research. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, Inc. , 1972.

50.

Williams, R. G. , & Ware, J. E. Validity of student ratings of instruction under different incentive conditions: a further study of the Dr. Fox effect. Paper presented at annual meeting of American Educational Research Association, Washington, D. C, April, 1975.

51.

Williamson, J. W. , Alexander, M. , & Miller, G. E. Continuing education and patient care research: physician response to screening test results. Journal of the American Medical Association , 1967, 201, 118-122.

52.

Wolken, G. H. , Donnelly, F. A. , & Naftulin, D. H. Physician feedback in continuing education courses in psychiatry. Psychosomatics, 1973, 14, 148-152.

53.

Zerzan, C. J. , Yagi, K. , & Grover, M. R. Community continuing education : the Oregon circuit course program. Northwest Medicine , 1973, 72, 15-18.