Paul Gugiu argues that Kaplan and Baron-Epel’s central idea or underlying premise is not merely wrong, but “dangerous with potentially dire consequences,” particularly in our current circumstances of a pandemic and a polarized political atmosphere. We disagree in the strongest terms and believe that nothing in Kaplan and Baron-Epel’s article can be fairly thought to support such a claim. We begin by addressing Gugiu’s framing of Kaplan and Baron-Epel’s position, before examining his criticisms of that position in turn.
ArnoldD.GirlingA.StevensA.LilfordR. (2009). Comparison of direct and indirect methods of estimating health state utilities for resource allocation: Review and empirical analysis. BMJ (Clinical research ed.), 339, b2688.
2.
AshcraftL. E.QuinnD. A.BrownsonR. C. (2020). Strategies for effective dissemination of research to United States policymakers: A systematic review. Implementation Science, 15, 89.
3.
BaronJ. (1997). Biases in the quantitative measurement of values for public decisions. Psychological Bulletin, 122, 72–88.
4.
DanielsN. (2016). Resource allocation and priority setting. In BarrettD. H.OrtmannL. W.DawsonA.SaenzC.ReisA.BolanG. (Eds.), Public health ethics: Cases spanning the globe (pp. 61–94). Springer International Publishing.
5.
GugiuP. (in press). Governing by polling public opinion: A potentially dangerous idea for our healthcare system. Evaluation and the Health Professions.
6.
HumeD. (1998/1751). An enquiry concerning the principles of morals, BeauchampT. L. (Ed.). Oxford University Press.
7.
KaplanG.Baron-EpelO. (in press). What does the public prefer versus what is the public ready to forgo?Evaluation and the Health Professions.
RoggeJ.KittelB. (2016). Who shall not be treated: Public attitudes on setting health care priorities by person-based criteria in 28 nations. PLoS One, 11, e0157018–e0157018.
10.
WilliamsA. (1997). Intergenerational equity: An exploration of the “fair innings” argument. Health Economics, 6, 117–132.
11.
WilliamsA.EvansJ. G. (1997). The rationing debate. Rationing health care by age. BMJ (Clinical research ed.), 314, 820–825.
