An incrementalist view of the R&Dprocess is developed, according to which R&D
consists of informed trial and error. One way of avoiding expensive mistakes is to
avoid choices within the R&D program that are highly sensitive to a particular
scientific claim, because a great deal of time and money may have been spent to no
avail should the claim turn out to befalse. The incremental view of R&D therefore
entails that no choice within any R&D program is sensitive to any scientific claim
made at the time. Two tests are presented, antiseptic surgery and the first atomic
pile, both of which confirm the incrementalist thesis.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Barnes, B.1982. The science-technology relationship: A model and a query . Social Studies of Science12:166-172.
2.
Battelle Corporation.1973. Interactions of science and technology in the innovative process: Some case studies. Report on Contract NSF-C667. Columbus, OH: Author.
3.
Bohme, G., W. van den Daele, and W. Krohn.1978. The "scientification" of technology . Pp. 219-250 in The dynamics of science and technology, edited by W. Krohn, E. Layton, and P. Weingart.Dordrecht: Reidel.
4.
Brayrooke, D. and C. Lindblom.1963. AstrategyofdecisionLondon: Collier-Macmillan.
5.
Brooks, H.1965. The interaction of science and technology, another view . Pp. 37-62 in The impact of science on technology, edited by W. Morse and A. Eichner.New York: Columbia University Press.
6.
Bunge, M.1966. Technology as applied science. Technology and Culture7:329-347.
7.
Callon, M.1980. The state and technological innovation: The electric vehicle in France. Research Policy9:358-376.
8.
Cardwell, D.1977/1978. Science and the steam engine reconsidered . Transactions of the Newcomen Society49:111-120.
9.
Cartwright, F.1986. Antiseptic surgery. Pp. 77-104 in Medicine and science in the 1860s, edited by F. Poynter.London: Wellcome Institute .
10.
Collingridge, D.1982. Critical decision making. London : Frances Pinter.
11.
---and J. Douglas.1984. Three models of policy making : Expert advice in the control of environmental lead." Social Studies of Science14:343-370.
12.
Collingridge, D. and C. Reeve.1986a. Science speaks to power-The role of experts in policymaking. London: Frances Pinter.
13.
——— 1986b. Why the marriage between science and policy is so unhappy . Bulletin of Science, Technology, and Society6:356-372.
14.
Dukes, C.1924. Lord Lister. London: Leonard Parsons.
15.
Fermi, E.1965. Collected papers. Vol. 2. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
16.
Fisher, R.1977. Joseph Lister. London: Macdonald & James.
17.
Gazis, D.1979. Influence of technology on science: A comment on some experiences at IBM." Research Policy8:244-259.
18.
Gibbons, M. and R. Johnston.1974. The roles of science in technological innovation." Research Policy3:220-242.
19.
Godlee, R.1917. Lord Lister. London: Macmillan.
20.
——— 1921. Six papers by Lord Lister. London: Bale & Danielson.
21.
Goldman, M.1986. Lister Ward. London: Adam Hilger.
22.
Hall, A.1978. On knowing how to. History of Technology3:91-104.
23.
Heclo, H. and A. Wildavsky.1981. The private governance ofpublic money: Community and policy inside Britain. 2nd ed. London: Macmillan.
24.
Hewlett, R. and O. Anderson.1962. A history of the U.S. Atomic Energy Commission. Vol. 1. The New World. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press.
25.
Hughes, T.1976. The science-technology interaction: High voltage power transmission systems. Technology and Culture17:646-662.
26.
IIT Research Institute.1968. Technology in retrospect and critical events in science. Report on Contract NSF-C535. Washington, DC: National Science Foundation.
27.
Industrial Research Institute Research Corporation.1979. Contributions of basic research to recent successful industrial innovation. Report on Contract IRI/ RC PB 80-160179. St. Louis: Author.
28.
Jewkes, J., D. Sawers, and R. Stillerman.1969. The sources of invention. 2nd ed. New York: Norton .
29.
Keller, A.1984. Has science created technology? Minerva22:160-182.
30.
Langrish, J., M. Gibbons, W. Evans, and F. Jevons.1972. Wealth from knowledge. London: Macmillan.
31.
Lieberman, M.1978. Literature citation study of science and technology coupling in electronics. Proceedings of the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers66:5-13.
32.
Lindblom, C.1965. The intelligence of democracy. London : Collier-Macmillan.
33.
——— 1968. The decision making process. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
34.
——— 1977. Politics and markets: The world's political-economic systems . New York: Basic Books.
35.
Mulkay, M.1979. Knowledge and utility, implications for the sociology of knowledge. Social Studies of Science9:63-80.
36.
Pinch, T. and W. Bijker.1984. The social construction of facts and artifacts. Social Studies of Science14:399-444.
37.
Quinn, A.1984. Logical incrementalism. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
38.
Reynolds, T.1979. Scientific influences on technology: The case of the overshot waterwheel. Technology and Culture20:270-294.
39.
Schmookler, J.1966. Invention and economic growth. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
40.
Seeley, R.1984. The scientific mystique in engineering: Highways research and the Bureau of Public Roads 1918-1940. Technology and Culture25:798-829.
41.
Sherwin, C. and R. Isenson.1966. First interim report on Project Hindsight . Washington, DC: Office of the Director of Defense Research.
42.
Smyth, H.1945. A general account of the development of methods ofusing atomic energy for military purposes under the auspices of the U.S. government 1940-1945. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
43.
Symes, J.1979. Policy and maturity in science. Social Science Information15:337-347.
44.
Vincenti, W.1984. Technological innovation without science: The innovation of flash riveting in U.S. airplanes 1930-50. Technology and Culture25:540-576.
45.
Weiss, C.1982. Policy research in the context of diffuse decision making . Pp. 288-314 in Social science research and public policy-making: A reappraisal , edited by D. Kallen, G. Kosse, H. Wagenaar, J. Kloprogge, and M. Vorbeck.Windsor: NFER-Nelson.
46.
---and M. Bucuvalas.1980. Social science research and decision making. New York: Columbia University Press.
47.
Wildavsky, A.1980. The art and craft of policy analysis. London: Macmillan.
48.
Wrench, G.1913. Lord Lister: His life and work. London : Fisher & Unwin.
49.
Youngson, A.1979. The scientific revolution in Victorian medicine . London: Croom Helm.
