All life on Earth shares the same ancestor, the most primitive form of life that arose, in still unknown circumstances, more than 3.5 billion years ago. At least this is what is commonly assumed. Astrobiologists have revisited this assumption and advanced the hypothesis of the existence of a “shadow biosphere” on Earth: a parallel tree of life whose instances, being different at the molecular level to the kind of life we are used to, would remain hidden from view. In this paper, I take the emergence of the so-called shadow biosphere hypothesis and the controversial discovery of GFAJ-1, a microbe thriving in the arsenic-rich waters of Mono Lake, as an entry point to look into the strategic role of non-knowledge claims. I juxtapose the Latourian black-box, that is, those undiscussed technoscientific artifacts that are taken for granted in scientific practice, with the shadowy nature of non-knowledge claims in order to pay closer attention to the contingent, active, performative, and always social nature of the making of what is unknown. I conclude this paper by claiming that in the negotiation of what is unknown, emerging disciplines position themselves within the larger scientific community.
AbbottAndrew. 2010. “Varieties of Ignorance.” The American Sociologist41 (2): 174–89.
2.
AnkenyRachel A.LeonelliSabina. 2016. “Repertoires: A Post-Kuhnian Perspective on Scientific Change and Collaborative Research.” Studies in History and Philosophy of Science60 (2016): 18–28.
3.
BeckUlrich. (1986) 1992. Risk Society. Towards a New Modernity. Translated byRitterMark. Los Angeles, CA: Sage.
4.
BennerSteven A.BainsWilliamSeagerSara. 2013. “Models and Standards of Proof in Cross-disciplinary Science: The Case of Arsenic DNA.” Astrobiology13(5): 510–13.
5.
BorupMadsBrownNikKonradKorneliaLenteHarro van. 2006. “The Sociology of Expectations in Science and Technology.” Technology Analysis & Strategic Management18 (3/4): 285–98.
6.
BöschenStefanKastenhoferKarenRustInaSoentgenJensWehlingPeter. 2010. “Scientific Nonknowledge and Its Political Dynamics: The Cases of Agri-biotechnology and Mobile Phoning.” Science, Technology, & Human Values35 (6): 783–811.
7.
ClelandCarol. 2007. “Epistemological Issues in the Study of Microbial Life: Alternative Terran Biospheres?” Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences38 (4): 847–61.
8.
ClelandCarolCopleyShelly. 2005. “The Possibility of Alternative Microbial Life on Earth.” International Journal of Astrobiology4 (3-4): 165–73.
9.
CocconiGiuseppeMorrisonPhilip. 1959. “Searching for Interstellar Communications.” Nature184 (4690): 844–46.
10.
CollinsHarry. 1985. Changing Order: Replication and Induction in Scientific Practice. London, UK: Sage.
11.
CostelloMark J.2015. “Biodiversity: The Known, Unknown, and Rates of Extinction.” Current Biology25 (9): R368–71.
CrickFrancis. 1981. Life Itself. Its Origin and Nature. New York: Simon & Schuster.
14.
CroissantJennifer. 2014. “Agnotology: Ignorance and Absence or towards a Sociology of Things That Aren’t There.” Social Epistemology28 (1): 4–25.
15.
DaviesPaul. 2010. “The ‘Give Me a Job’ Microbe. A Young Researcher Risked It All to Chase an Arsenic-guzzling Bug.” Wall Street Journal, December 4. Accessed March 15, 2018. https://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/14/science/14arsenic.html.
16.
DaviesPaul. 2011. “Searching for a Shadow Biosphere on Earth as a Test of the ‘Cosmic Imperative’.” Philosophical Transactions. Series A, Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences369 (1936): 624–32.
17.
DaviesPaulBennerS. A.ClelandC. E.LineweaverC. H.McKayC. P.Wolfe-SimonF.. 2009. “Signatures of a Shadow Biosphere.” Astrobiology9 (2): 241–49.
18.
de DuveChristian. 2011. “Life as a Cosmic Imperative?” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences369 (2011): 620–23.
19.
Des MaraisDavidNuthJoseph A.AllamandolaLouis J.BossAlan P.FarmerJack D.HoehlerTori M.JakoskyBruce M.. 2008. “The NASA Astrobiology Roadmap.” Astrobiology8 (4): 715–30.
20.
DickStephen. 1996. The Biological Universe. The Twentieth-century Extraterrestrial Life Debate and The Limits of Science. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
21.
DickSteven J.StrickJames E.. 2004. The Living Universe. NASA and the Development of Astrobiology. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
22.
FarleyJohnGeisonGerald. 1974. “Science, Politics and Spontaneous Generation in Nineteenth Century France: The Pasteur-Pouchet Debate.” Bulletin of the History of Medicine48 (2): 161–98.
23.
GalisonPeter. 2010. “Secrecy in Three Acts.” Social Research77 (3): 941–74.
24.
GiddensAnthony. 1990. The Consequences of Modernity. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
25.
GierynThomas. 1983. “Boundary-work and the Demarcation of Science from Non-science: Strains and Interests in Professional Ideologies of Scientists.” American Sociological Review48 (6): 781–95.
26.
GouldStephen J.1989. Wonderful Life: The Burgess Shale and the Nature of History. New York: W. W. Norton.
27.
GrossMatthias. 2007. “The Unknown in Process: Dynamic Connections of Ignorance, Non-knowledge and Related Concepts.” Current Sociology55 (5): 742–59.
28.
GrossMatthias. 2016. “Risk as Zombie Category: Ulrich Beck’s Unfinished Project of the ‘Non-knowledge’ Society.” Security Dialogue47 (5): 386–402.
29.
HackettEdward J.2005. “Essential Tensions. Identity, Control and Risk in Research.” Social Studies of Science35 (5): 787–826.
JogalekarAshutosh. 2015. “Social Media, Peer Review, and Responsible Conduct of Research (RCR) in Chemistry: Trends, Pitfalls, and Promises.” Accountability in Research22 (6): 402–30.
34.
Knorr-CetinaKarin. 1999. Epistemic Cultures: How the Sciences Make Knowledge. Cambridge, UK: Harvard University Press.
35.
KuhnThomas. 1962. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
36.
LatourBruno. 1987. Science in Action, How to Follow Scientists and Engineers through Society. Milton Keynes, UK: Open University Press.
37.
LatourBruno. [1987] 1995. “Pasteur-Pouchet, the Heterogenesis of the History of Science.” In A History of Scientific Thought. Elements of a History of Science, edited by SerresMichel, 526–55. Oxford, UK: Blackwell.
38.
LatourBruno. 2000. “On the Partial Existence of Existing and Nonexisting Objects.” In Biographies of Scientific Objects, edited by DastonLorraine, 247–69. Chicago: Chicago University Press.
MertonRobert. 1987. “Three Fragments from a Sociologist’s Notebooks: Establishing the Phenomenon, Specified Ignorance, and Strategic Research Materials.” Annual Review of Sociology12 (1987): 1–28.
44.
MesseriLisa. 2016. Placing Outer Space: An Earthly Ethnography of Other Worlds. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
45.
MichaelsDavid. 2008. Doubt Is Their Product: How Industry’s Assault on Science Threatens Your Health. New York: Oxford University Press.
46.
MulkayMichaelGilbertNigel. 1982. “Accounting for Error: How Scientists Construct Their Social World When They Account for Correct and Incorrect Belief.” Sociology16 (2): 165–83.
47.
OremlandRonaldSaltikovChad W.Wolfe-SimonFelisaStolzJohn. 2009. “Arsenic in the Evolution of Earth and Extraterrestrial Ecosystems.” Geomicrobiology Journal26 (7): 522–36.
48.
OreskesNaomiConwayErik M.. 2010. Merchants of Doubt: How a Handful of Scientists Obscured the Truth on Issues from Tobacco Smoke to Global Warming. New York: Bloomsbury Press.
49.
PaceNorman R.1997. “A Molecular View of Microbial Diversity and the Biosphere.” Science274 (1997): 734–40.
50.
ProctorRobert. 2008. “Agnotology: A Missing Term to Describe the Cultural Production of Ignorance.” In Agnotology: The Making and Unmaking of Ignorance, edited by ProctorR.SchiebingerL., 1–36. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
RheinbergerHans-Jorg. 1997. Toward a History of Epistemic Things: Synthesizing Proteins in the Test Tube. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
53.
Roll-HansenNeil. 1979. “Experimental Method and Spontaneous Generation: The Controversy between Pasteur and Pouchet, 1959-64.” Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences34 (3): 273–92.
54.
SaganCarlHorowitzNormanMurrayBruce. 1977. “Continuing Puzzles about Mars.” Bulletin of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences30 (7): 10–31.
SmithsonMichael. 1985. “Toward a Social Theory of Ignorance.” Journal of the Theory of Social Behaviour15 (2): 151–72.
57.
SmithsonMichael. 1989. Ignorance and Uncertainty: Emerging Paradigms. New York: Springer-Verlag.
58.
SteeleA.GoddardD. T.StapletonD.ToporskiJ. K. W.PetersV.BassingerV.SharplesG.Wynn-WilliamsD. D.McKayD. S.. 2000. “Investigations into an Unknown Organism on the Martian Meteorite Allan Hills 84001.” Meteoritics and Planetary Science35 (2): 273–41.
59.
StreetAlice. 2011. “Artefacts of Non-knowing: The Medical Record, the Diagnosis and the Production of Uncertainty in Papua New Guinean Biomedicine.” Social Studies of Science41 (6): 815–34.
Wolfe-SimonFelisaBlumJodiKulpThomasGordonGwynethHoeftShelleyPett-RidgeJenniferStolzJohn, et al.2011. “A Bacterium That Can Grow by Using Arsenic Instead of Phosphorus.” Science332 (6034): 1163–67.
64.
Wolfe-SimonFelisaDaviesPaul C. W.AnbarAriel D.. 2009. “Did Nature Also Choose Arsenic?” International Journal of Astrobiology8 (2): 69–74.
65.
YoungRichard. 1976. “Viking on Mars, a Preliminary Survey.” American Scientist64 (6): 620–27.
