Minimum Requirement of Artificial Noise Level for Using Noise-Assisted Correlation Algorithm to Suppress Artifacts in Ultrasonic Nakagami Images

Abstract

The Nakagami image is a complementary imaging mode for pulse-echo ultrasound B-scan to characterize tissues. White noise in anechoic areas induces artifacts in the Nakagami image. Recently, we proposed a noise-assisted correlation algorithm (NCA) for suppressing the Nakagami artifact. In the NCA, artificial white noise is intentionally added twice to backscattered signals to produce two noisy data, which are used to establish a correlation profile for rejecting noise. This study explored the effects of artificial noise level on the NCA to suppress the artifact of the Nakagami image. Simulations were conducted to produce B-mode images of anechoic regions under signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) of 20, 10 and 5 dB. Various artificial noise levels ranging from 0.1- to 1-fold of the intrinsic noise amplitude were used in the NCA for constructing the Nakagami images. Phantom experiments were conducted to validate the performance of using the optimal artificial noise level suggested by the simulation results to suppress the Nakagami artifacts by the NCA. The simulation results indicated that the artifacts of the Nakagami image in the anechoic regions can be gradually suppressed by increasing the artificial noise level used in the NCA to improve the image contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR). The CNR of the Nakagami image reached 20 dB when the artificial noise level was 0.7-fold of the intrinsic noise amplitude. This criterion was demonstrated by the phantom results to provide the NCA with an excellent ability to obtain artifact-free Nakagami images.

Keywords

Artifacts backscattered statistics noise-assisted analysis ultrasonic Nakagami images

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bamber

Hill

Acoustic properties of normal and cancerous human liver-I dependence on pathological condition.

Ultrasound Med Biol 7, 121–133 (1981).

Bamber

Hill

King

Acoustic properties of normal and cancerous human liver-II dependence on tissue structure.

Ultrasound Med Biol 7, 135–144 (1981).

Insana

Wagner

Brown

Hall

Describing small-scale structure in random media using pulse-echo ultrasound.

J Acoust Soc Am 87, 179–192 (1990).

Destrempes

Cloutier

A critical review and uniformized representation of statistical distributions modeling the ultrasound echo envelope.

Ultrasound Med Biol 36, 1037–1051 (2010).

Holfman

Statistical Methods on Radio Wave Propagation (Pergamon Press, New York 1960).

Hampshire

JBI

Strohbehn

McDaniel

Waugh

James

Probability density of myocardial ultrasonic backscatter. in Proc 14th Ann Northeast Bioeng Conf, pp. 305–308 (1988).

Zimmer

Akselrod

Tepper

The distribution of the local entropy in ultrasound images.

Ultrasound Med Biol 22, 431–439 (1996).

Shankar

A general statistical model for ultrasonic backscattering from tissues.

IEEE Trans Ultrason Ferroelec Freq Contr 47, 727–736 (2000).

Wachowiak

Smolikova

Tourassi

Elmaghraby

General ultrasound speckle models in determining scatterer density. in

Proc SPIE 4687, pp. 285–295 (2002).

10.

Tsui

Wan

Huang

Wang

Effect of adaptive threshold filtering on ultrasonic Nakagami parameter to detect variation in scatterer concentration.

Ultrasonic Imaging 32, 229–242 (2010).

11.

Tsui

Huang

Zhou

Shung

Cataract measurement by estimating the ultrasonic statistical parameter using an ultrasound needle transducer: an in vitro study.

Physiol Meas 32, 513–522 (2011).

12.

Lin

Shu

Chen

Chang

Tsui

Using ultrasound Nakagami imaging to assess liver fibrosis in rats.

Ultrasonics 52, 215–222 (2012).

13.

Shankar

Statistical modeling of scattering from biological media.

J Acoust Soc Amer 111, 2463 (2002).

14.

Kolar

Jirik

Jan

Estimator comparison of the Nakagami-m parameter and its application in echocardiography.

Radioengin 13, 8–12 (2004).

15.

Davignon

Deprez

Basset

A parametric imaging approach for the segmentation of ultrasound data.

Ultrasonics 43, 789–801 (2005).

16.

Tsui

Chang

Imaging local scatterer concentrations by the Nakagami statistical model.

Ultrasound Med Biol 33, 608–619 (2007).

17.

Tsui

Huang

Chang

Wang

Shung

Feasibility study of using high-frequency ultrasonic Nakagami imaging for characterizing the cataract lens in vitro.

Phys Med Biol 52, 6413–6425 (2007).

18.

Tsui

Yeh

Chang

Chen

Performance evaluation of ultrasonic Nakagami image in tissue characterization.

Ultrasonic Imaging 30, 78–94 (2008).

19.

Tsui

Yeh

Chang

Liao

Classification of breast masses by ultrasonic Nakagami imaging.

Phys Med Biol. 53, 6027–6044 (2008).

20.

Tsui

Liao

Chang

Kuo

Chang

Yeh

Classification of benign and malignant breast tumors by 2-D analysis based on contour description and scatterer characterization.

IEEE Trans Med Imag 29, 513–522 (2010).

21.

Tsui

Yeh

Chang

Microvascular flow estimation by contrast-assisted B-scan and statistical parametric images.

IEEE Trans Inf Technol Biomed 13, 360–369 (2009).

22.

Tsui

Huang

Sun

Dailey

Shung

Characterization of lamina propria and vocal muscle in human vocal fold tissue by ultrasound Nakagami imaging.

Med Phys 38, 2019–2026 (2011).

23.

Tsui

Yeh

Huang

Noise-assisted correlation algorithm for suppressing noise-induced artifacts in ultrasonic Nakagami images.

IEEE Trans Inf Technol Biomed (in press, 2012).

24.

Frinking

PJA

Cespedes

Kirkhorn

Torp

Jong

A new ultrasound contrast imaging approach based on the combination of multiple imaging pulses and a separate release burst.

IEEE Trans Ultrason Ferroelec Freq Contr 48, 643–651 (2001).

25.

Fontaine

Bertrand

Cloutier

A system-based approach to modeling the ultrasound signal backscattered by red blood cells.

Biophys J 77, 2387–2399 (1999).

26.

Christensen

Ultrasonic Bioinstrumentation (Wiley, New York, 1988)

27.

Tsui

Wang

The effect of transducer characteristics on the estimation of Nakagami parameter as a function of scatterer concentration.

Ultrasound Med Biol 30, 1345–1353 (2004).

28.

Tsui

Yeh

Chang

Noise effect on the performance of Nakagami image in ultrasound tissue characterization.

J Med Biol Eng 28, 197–202 (2008).

29.

Tsui

Wang

Huang

Chiu

Quantitative analysis of noise influence on the detection of scatterer concentration by Nakagami parameter.

J Med Biol Eng 25, 45–51 (2005).

30.

Rabbani

Vafadust

Abolmaesumi

Gazor

Speckle noise reduction of medical ultrasound images in complex wavelet domain using mixture priors.

IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 55, 2152–60 (2008).

31.

Karaman

Kutay

Bozdagi

An adaptive speckle suppression filter for medical ultrasonic imaging.

IEEE Trans Med Imag 14, 283–292 (1995).

32.

Thakur

Anand

Speckle reduction in ultrasound medical images using adaptive filter based on second order statistics.

J Med Eng Technol 31, 263–279 (2007).