Culturally responsive instruction (CRI) has garnered significant attention in local and state policy in recent years amid politicization of what is taught in schools, and the scholarly field is increasingly focused on how to develop culturally responsive schools and systems, not just culturally responsive teachers. As the field considers how to support teachers to take up culturally responsive practices, there is a need to understand practicing teachers’ current understandings and perceptions of CRI and their school and sociopolitical environments.
Purpose, Objective, Research Question, or Focus of Study:
I examine how practicing teachers understand and describe CRI and their perceptions of the aspects of their school and social contexts that may support CRI. Specifically, I ask: (1) What are practicing teachers’ conceptions of CRI? (2) What role do practicing teachers perceive their schools and the broader sociopolitical environment to have in supporting or hindering their efforts to engage in CRI, and how are these perspectives related to their conceptions of CRI?
Research Design:
This qualitative interview study draws on 22 interviews with teachers across five districts engaging in professional learning initiatives. Through coding, memoing, and use of analytic matrices, I conducted thematic analysis to understand teachers’ conceptions of and beliefs related to CRI, as well their perceptions of the ways their school and the broader social context influence their efforts to engage in CRI.
Conclusions or Recommendations:
I find that teachers’ conceptions of CRI and perceptions of their school and sociopolitical contexts were mutually reinforcing: teachers largely called attention to aspects of their contexts that aligned with and reinforced their conceptions of CRI. Teachers with more robust conceptions of CRI drew attention to dynamic school characteristics like a culture of critical reflection as helpful in promoting CRI, whereas teachers with less developed conceptions of CRI emphasized a set of static school factors that reflected a superficial treatment of cultural responsiveness. This study speaks to the need to center teachers’ meaning-making when supporting their development of CRI and to move toward more ecological perspectives for understanding and developing culturally responsive and justice-oriented systems.
AbdulrahimN. A.OroscoM. J. (2020). Culturally responsive mathematics teaching: A research synthesis. Urban Review, 52(1), 1–25. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11256-019-00509-2
2.
AchinsteinB.AguirreJ. (2008). Cultural match or cultural suspect: How new teachers of color negotiate socio-cultural challenges in the classroom. Teachers College Record, 110(8), 1505–1540.
3.
AchinsteinB.OgawaR. T. (2011). Change(d) agents: School contexts and the cultural/professional roles of new teachers of Mexican descent. Teachers College Record, 113(11), 2503–2551.
4.
AchinsteinB.OgawaR. T. (2012). New teachers of color and culturally responsive teaching in an era of educational accountability: Caught in a double bind. Journal of Educational Change, 13(1), 1–39. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10833-011-9165-y
5.
AndersonC. R.BullockE. C.CrossB. E.PowellA. (2017). From corporation to community: Culturally relevant pedagogy in an urban laboratory for school reform. Teachers College Record, 119(1), 1–34.
6.
AnnammaS. A.JacksonD. D.MorrisonD. (2017). Conceptualizing color-evasiveness: Using dis/ability critical race theory to expand a color-blind racial ideology in education and society. Race Ethnicity and Education, 20(2), 147–162.
7.
AronsonB.LaughterJ. (2016). The theory and practice of culturally relevant education: A synthesis of research across content areas. Review of Educational Research, 86(1), 163–206. https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654315582066
8.
BennettS. V. (2013). Effective facets of a field experience that contributed to eight preservice teachers’ developing understandings about culturally responsive teaching. Urban Education, 48(3), 380–419.
9.
BertrandA. R.LyonM. A.JacobsenR. (2023). Narrative spillover: A narrative policy framework analysis of critical race theory discourse at multiple levels. Policy Studies Journal, 52(2), 391–423.
10.
BishopR. S. (1990). Mirrors, windows, and sliding glass doors. Perspectives, 6(3), ix–xi.
11.
Bonilla-SilvaE. (2006). Racism without racists: Color-blind racism and the persistence of racial inequality in the United States. Rowman & Littlefield.
12.
BonnerE. P. (2014). Investigating practices of highly successful mathematics teachers of traditionally underserved students. Educational Studies in Mathematics, 86(3), 377–399. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10649-014-9533-7
13.
Brown-JeffyS.CooperJ. E. (2011). Toward a conceptual framework of culturally relevant pedagogy: An overview of the conceptual and theoretical literature. Teacher Education Quarterly, 38(1), 65–84.
BrykA. S.SebringP. B.AllensworthE.EastonJ. Q.LuppescuS. (2010). Organizing schools for improvement: Lessons from Chicago. University of Chicago Press.
16.
Buford MayR. A. (2014). When the methodological shoe is on the other foot: African American interviewer and White interviewees. Qualitative Sociology, 37, 117–136.
17.
California Department of Education (CDE). (2021). Mathematics framework. Chapter 2: Teaching for equity and engagement, first field review draft. https://www.cde.ca.gov/ci/ma/cf/
18.
CareyR. L.Farinde-WuA.MilnerH. R.IVDelale-O’ConnorL. (2018). The culture and teaching gap: What is it, and how can teacher educators help to close it? In HallG. E.QuinnL. F.GollnickD. M. (Eds.), The Wiley handbook of teaching and learning (pp. 59–78). Wiley.
19.
CastroA. J. (2010). Themes in the research on preservice teachers’ views of cultural diversity: Implications for researching millennial preservice teachers. Educational Researcher, 39(3), 198–210.
CivilM.HunterR.CrespoS. (2019). Mathematics teachers committed to equity: A review of teaching practices. In PotariD.ChapmanO. (Eds.), International Handbook of Mathematics Teacher Education (Vol. 1, pp. 243–273). Brill.
22.
CivitilloS.JuangL. P.SchachnerM. K. (2018). Challenging beliefs about cultural diversity in education: A synthesis and critical review of trainings with pre-service teachers. Educational Research Review, 24, 67–83.
23.
CivitilloS.JuangL. P.SchachnerM. K. (2021). Stressing similarities or ignoring differences? Shedding light into different forms of color-evasive ideology with pre- and in-service teachers. Zeitschrift Für Erziehungswissenschaft, 24(1), 135–153.
24.
CoburnC. E. (2001). Collective sensemaking about reading: How teachers mediate reading policy in their professional communities. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 23(2), 145–170. https://doi.org/10.3102/01623737023002145
25.
CoffeyH.Farinde-WuA. (2016). Navigating the journey to culturally responsive teaching: Lessons from the success and struggles of one first-year, Black female teacher of Black students in an urban school. Teaching and Teacher Education, 60, 24–33. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2016.07.021
26.
ComstockM.EdgertonA. K.DesimoneL. M. (2022). Connecting policy to practice: How state and local policy environments relate to teachers’ instruction. Teachers College Record, 124(11), 82–116.
27.
ComstockM.LitkeE.HillK. L.DesimoneL. M. (2023). A culturally responsive disposition: How professional learning and teachers’ beliefs about and self-efficacy for culturally responsive teaching relate to instruction. AERA Open, 9(1), 1–18.
28.
CreswellJ. W.PothC. N. (2017). Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five approaches (4th ed.). Sage.
29.
DesimoneL. (2002). How can comprehensive school reform models be successfully implemented?Review of Educational Research, 72(3), 433–479. https://doi.org/10.3102/00346543072003433
30.
DiamondJ. B. (2012). Accountability policy, school organization, and classroom practice: Partial recoupling and educational opportunity. Education and Urban Society, 44(2), 151–182.
31.
DiamondJ. B.LewisA. (2015). Despite the best intentions: How racial inequality thrives in good schools. Oxford University Press.
32.
DiamondJ. B.LewisA. E. (2019). Race and discipline at a racially mixed high school: Status, capital, and the practice of organizational routines. Urban Education, 54(6), 831–859.
33.
DiamondJ. B.RandolphA.SpillaneJ. P. (2004). Teachers’ expectations and sense of responsibility for student learning: The importance of race, class, and organizational habitus. Anthropology & Education Quarterly, 35(1), 75–98. https://doi.org/10.1525/aeq.2004.35.1.75
34.
DoverA. G. (2013). Teaching for social justice: From conceptual frameworks to classroom practices. Multicultural Perspectives, 15(1), 3–11. https://doi.org/10.1080/15210960.2013.754285
35.
Duncan-AndradeJ. M. (2022). Equality or equity: Toward a model of community-responsive education. Harvard Education Press.
36.
EvansL. M.TurnerC. R.AllenK. R. (2020). “Good teachers” with “good intentions”: Misappropriations of culturally responsive pedagogy. Journal of Urban Learning, Teaching, and Research, 15(1), 51–73.
37.
GayG. (2002). Preparing for culturally responsive teaching. Journal of Teacher Education, 53(2), 106–116.
HernándezM. G.LopezD. M.SwierR. (2022). Dismantling disproportionality: A culturally responsive and sustaining systems approach. Teachers College Press.
43.
HowardT. C. (2003). Culturally relevant pedagogy: Ingredients for critical teacher reflection. Theory into Practice, 42(3), 195–202.
44.
HowardT. C.Rodriguez-MinkoffA. C. (2017). Culturally relevant pedagogy 20 years later: Progress or pontificating? What have we learned, and where do we go?Teachers College Record, 119(1), 1–32.
45.
IrbyD. J. (2021). Stuck improving: Racial equity and school leadership. Harvard Education Press.
46.
KaulM.ComstockM.SimonN. S. (2022). Leading from the middle: How principals rely on district guidance and organizational conditions in times of crisis. AERA Open, 8(1), 1–17. https://doi.org/10.1177/23328584221077303
47.
KhalifaM. A.GoodenM. A.DavisJ. E. (2016). Culturally responsive school leadership: A synthesis of the literature. Review of Educational Research, 86(4), 1272–1311. https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654316630383
48.
KiskerE. E.LipkaJ.AdamsB. L.RickardA.Andrew-IhrkeD.YanezE. E.MillardA. (2012). The potential of a culturally based supplemental mathematics curriculum to improve the mathematics performance of Alaska native and other students. Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 43(1), 75–113. https://doi.org/10.5951/jresematheduc.43.1.0075
49.
KlingnerJ.ArtilesA. J.KozleskiE.HarryB.ZionS.TateW.DuránG. Z.RileyD. (2005). Addressing the disproportionate representation of culturally and linguistically diverse students in special education through culturally responsive educational systems. Education Policy Analysis Archives/Archivos Analíticos de Políticas Educativas, 13, 1–40.
50.
KraftM. A.PapayJ. P. (2014). Can professional environments in schools promote teacher development? Explaining heterogeneity in returns to teaching experience. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 36(4), 476–500.
51.
Ladson-BillingsG. (1995). Toward a theory of culturally relevant pedagogy. American Educational Research Journal, 32, 465–491. https://doi.org/10.2307/1163320
MalenB. (2006). Revisiting policy implementation as a political phenomenon: The case of reconstitution policies. In HonigM. (Ed.), New directions in policy implementation: Confronting complexity (pp. 83–104). SUNY Press.
54.
MayfieldV. M.Garrison-WadeD. (2015). Culturally responsive practices as whole school reform. Journal of Instructional Pedagogies, 16, 1–17.
55.
McCamblyH.VillanosaK.MackeviciusC. L. (2024). Educational philanthropy’s “racial reckoning” in the wake of 2020: Understanding grantmakers’ responses to racialized crises. Educational Policy, 1–41.
56.
MilesM. B.HubermanA. M.SaldañaJ. (2014). Qualitative data analysis: A methods sourcebook (3rd ed.). Sage.
57.
MillsC.BallantyneJ. (2010). Pre-service teachers’ dispositions towards diversity: Arguing for a developmental hierarchy of change. Teaching and Teacher Education, 26(3), 447–454. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2009.05.012
58.
MinM.LeeH.HodgeC.CroxtonN. (2022). What empowers teachers to become social justice–oriented change agents? Influential factors on teacher agency toward culturally responsive teaching. Education and Urban Society, 54(5), 560–584.
59.
MorrisonK. A.RobbinsH. H.RoseD. G. (2008). Operationalizing culturally relevant pedagogy: A synthesis of classroom-based research. Equity and Excellence in Education, 41(4), 433–452. https://doi.org/10.1080/10665680802400006
NoddingsN. (1984). “An ethic of caring.” In HeldV. (Ed.), Caring: A feminine approach to ethics and moral education (pp. 79–103). University of California Press.
62.
OberskiD. (2016). Mixture models: Latent profile and latent class analysis. In RobertsonJ.KapteinM. (Eds.), Modern statistical methods for HCI (pp. 275–287). Springer International.
63.
PagánO. (2022). A multilevel framework of racism as a barrier to teachers’ implementation of culturally relevant pedagogy. AERA Open, 8, 23328584221106193.
64.
ParisD. (2012). Culturally sustaining pedagogy: A needed change in stance, terminology, and practice. Educational Researcher, 41(3), 93–97.
65.
ParisD.AlimH. S. (2014). What are we seeking to sustain through culturally sustaining pedagogy? A loving critique forward. Harvard Educational Review, 84(1), 85–100.
66.
ParkerF.BartellT. G.NovakJ. D. (2017). Developing culturally responsive mathematics teachers: Secondary teachers’ evolving conceptions of knowing students. Journal of Mathematics Teacher Education, 20(4), 385–407. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10857-015-9328-5
67.
ParkhouseH.LuC. Y.MassaroV. R. (2019). Multicultural education professional development: A review of the literature. Review of Educational Research, 89(3), 416–458. https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654319840359
PowellR.CantrellS. C.Malo-JuveraV.CorrellP. (2016). Operationalizing culturally responsive instruction: Preliminary findings of CRIOP research. Teachers College Record, 118(1), 1–46.
70.
RavitchS. M.CarlN. M. (2016). Qualitative research: Bridging the conceptual, theoretical, and methodological. Sage.
71.
RayV. (2019). A theory of racialized organizations. American Sociological Review, 84(1), 26–53.
72.
RissanenI.KuusistoE.TimmS.KaukkoM. (2023). Diversity beliefs are associated with orientations to teaching for diversity and social justice: A study among German and Finnish student teachers. Teaching and Teacher Education, 123, 1–13.
73.
SerikiV. D.BrownC. T. (2017). A dream deferred: A retrospective view of culturally relevant pedagogy. Teachers College Record, 119(1), 1–8.
74.
SleeterC. E. (2012). Confronting the marginalization of culturally responsive pedagogy. Urban Education, 47(3), 562–584. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042085911431472
75.
SongK. H. (2006). Urban teachers’ beliefs on teaching, learning, and students: A pilot study in the United States of America. Education and Urban Society, 38(4), 481–499.
76.
SpillaneJ. P.DiamondJ. B.BurchP.HallettT.JitaL.ZoltnersJ. (2002). Managing in the middle: School leaders and the enactment of accountability policy. Educational Policy, 16(5), 731–762. https://doi.org/10.1177/089590402237311
77.
StillmanJ. (2011). Teacher learning in an era of high-stakes accountability: Productive tension and critical professional practice. Teachers College Record, 113, 133–180.
78.
Tintiangco-CubalesA.Duncan-AndradeJ. (2021). Chapter 2: Still fighting for ethnic studies: The origins, practices, and potential of community responsive pedagogy. Teachers College Record, 123(13), 1–28.
79.
VillegasA. M. (2007). Dispositions in teacher education: A look at social justice. Journal of Teacher Education, 58(5), 370–380.
80.
WareF. (2006). Warm demander pedagogy: Culturally responsive teaching that supports a culture of achievement for African American students. Urban Education, 41(4), 427–456.
81.
WarrenC. A. (2018). Empathy, teacher dispositions, and preparation for culturally responsive pedagogy. Journal of Teacher Education, 69(2), 169–183.
82.
YoungA. (2008). White ethnographers on the experiences of African American men: Then and now. In ZuberiT.Bonilla-SilvaE. (Eds.), White logic, white methods: Racism and methodology (p. 179–200). Rowman and Littlefield.
83.
YoungE. (2010). Challenges to conceptualizing and actualizing culturally relevant pedagogy: How viable is the theory in classroom practice?Journal of Teacher Education, 61(3), 248–260. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022487109359775
