I approach the debate on Mexican postrevolutionary rural schooling by describing both the intellectual environment encountered by Mexican educators who studied at the college, and the configuration of their involvement in federal education in the 1920s. I discuss findings in relation to current historiographical trends that view the transnational circulation and refraction of educational models as a complex, contextualized process.
Purpose:
I trace possible influences of John Dewey and other Teachers College (TC) scholars of the early 20th century on the Mexican Rural School project.
Research Design:
I examine various accounts written by leading educators and present documentary evidence from the Secretaría de Educación Pública (Ministry of Public Education) archives related to rural schooling in the 1920s. I also draw on archival evidence and oral testimonies to describe the schools Dewey visited in Tlaxcala that sparked his admiration.
Conclusion:
Despite long-term attribution of Mexico’s postrevolutionary rural schooling program to the adoption of Dewey’s ideas, primarily through Moisés Sáenz, I find evidence in support of the version voiced by contemporaries that the Mexican Rural School had endogenous origins and some significant differences with the diverse projects and practices of progressive schooling promoted by TC scholars in those years.
Bruno-JofréR.JoverG. (2009). Lecturas de la Obra de John Dewey en Intersección con el Catolicismo: Los casos de la Institución Libre de Enseñanza y la Tesis sobre Dewey del Padre Alberto Hurtado, S. J. [The readings of John Dewey’s work and the intersection of Catholicism: The cases of the lnstituci6n Libre de Enseñanza and the thesis of Father Alberto Hurtado, S. J. on Dewey]. Encuentros sobre Educación, 10, 3–22.
2.
Bruno-JofréR.Martínez ValleC. (2012). Ruralizing Dewey: The American friend, internal colonialism and action school in postrevolutionary México (1921–1940). In Bruno-JofréR. C.SchriewerJ. (Eds.), The global reception of John Dewey’s thought: Multiple refractions through time and space (pp. 59–80). Routledge.
3.
Caiceo EscuderoJ. (2022). The influence of educators, followers of John Dewey’s educational thought, in the Chilean school system: Irma Salas, Amanda Labarca, and Darío Salas. Teachers College Record, 124(10).
4.
Calderón MólgoraM. (2022). Rural education and the state in Mexico: The legacy of Elena Torres Cuellar. Teachers College Record, 124(10).
5.
Calderón MólgoraM. A. (2018). Educación rural, experimentos sociales y Estado en México: 1910-1933 [Rural education, social experiments and the State in Mexico: 1910–1933]. El Colegio de Michoacán.
CarneyM. (1912). Country life and the country school: A study of the agencies of rural progress and of the social relationship of the school to the rural community. Row, Peterson and Company. https://catalog.hathitrust.org/Record/001281618
8.
CastilloI. (2007). México y sus revoluciones sociales y la educación (Vol. 3) [Mexico and its social revolutions and education (Vol. 3)]. Libros Eddisa y Universidad Pedagógica de Guadalajara. (Original work published 1965)
9.
CiveraA. (2013). La escuela como opción de vida. La formación de maestros normalistas rurales en México, 1921-1945 [School as an option for life. The training of rural normal school teachers in México, 1921–1945). El Colegio Mexiquense.
10.
Corona MorfínE. (1986). La Casa del Pueblo. La escuela rural de la revolución [The Casa del Pueblo. The rural school of the revolution]. In FuentesB. (Ed.), Enrique Corona Morfín y la Educación Rural. Antología (pp. 21–46). Editorial El Caballito-SEP.
11.
CreminL. A.ShannonD. A.ShannonM. E. (1954). A history of Teachers College, Columbia University. Columbia University Press.
12.
DeweyJ. (1897). My pedagogic creed. E.L. Kellogg & Co.
13.
DeweyJ. (1915). The school and society (Rev. ed.). University of Chicago Press. (Original work published 1899)
14.
DeweyJ. (1926, September22). Mexico’s educational renaissance. The New Republic, 48, 116–118.
15.
EliasN. (2000). The civilizing process: Sociogenetic and psychogenetic investigations. Wiley-Blackwell.
16.
FallaceT.FantozziV. (2017). The Dewey School as triumph, tragedy, and misunderstood: Exploring the myths and historiography of the University of Chicago Laboratory School. Teachers College Record, 119(2) 1–32.
17.
FerrièreA. (1922). L’école active [The active school]. Editions Forum.
18.
GoodsellW. (1933). The New Education as it is: A reply to Professor Kandel. Teachers College Record, 34(7), 539–551.
19.
GuzmánE. (1923). La Escuela Nueva o de la Acción [The New School or of Action]. Editorial Cultura.
20.
IriyeA. (2012). Global and transnational history: The past, present, and future. Palgrave Macmillan.
21.
KandelI. L. (1923). The International Institute of Teachers College. Teachers College Record, 24(4), 366–373.
22.
KandelI. L. (1929). The influence of Dewey abroad. Teachers College Record, 31(3), 239–244.
23.
KnollM. (2012) “I had made a mistake”: William H. Kilpatrick and the project method. Teachers College Record, 114(2), 1–45.
24.
MatasciD.DrouxJ. (2019). (De)Constructing the global community: Education, childhood and the transnational history of international organizations. In: FuchsE.Roldán VeraE. (Eds.), The transnational in the history of education: Concepts and perspectives, pp. 231–260. Palgrave-Macmillan.
Moraga ValleF. (2017). Incluir para formar la nación: la “Escuela Nueva” o de la “Acción” en el México Posrevolucionario, 1921–1964 [Inclusion to form the nation: The “New School” or the School of Action in Postrevolutionary Mexico]. Cuadernos Chilenos de Historia de la Educación, 7, 9–46. https://www.historiadelaeducacion.cl/?journal=home&page=issue&op=view&path%5B%5D=7
27.
PalaciosG. (1998). Postrevolutionary intellectuals, rural readings and the shaping of the “peasant problem” in Mexico: El Maestro Rural, 1932–34. Journal of Latin American Studies, 30, 309–339.
Puig CasaurancJ. M. (1926). Public education in Mexico. Teachers College Record, 27(10), 865–868.
30.
Ramírez CastañedaR. (1924). Curso de educación rural and Técnica de la enseñanza [Course on rural education and Teaching techniques]. [Pamphlets]. SEP-Talleres Gráficos.
31.
Ramírez CastañedaR. (1928). La enseñanza de la lectura [The teaching of Reading]. Biblioteca del Maestro Rural Mexicano. SEP.
32.
Ramírez CastañedaR. (1986). El gran período constructivo del movimiento educacional de México surgido de la revolución [The great constructive period of the educational movement in Mexico that emerged from the Revolution]. In Jiménez AlarcónC. (Ed.), Rafael Ramírez y la escuela Rural Mexicana. Antología. SEP-Ediciones El Caballito. (Original work published ca. 1945)
33.
RockwellE. (2007). Hacer escuela, hacer estado. La educación posrevolucionaria vista desde Tlaxcala [Forming schools, forming the state. Postrevolutionary education seen from Tlaxcala]. El Colegio de Michoacán.
34.
RockwellE. (2009). Between community and state: The changing role of the “director de escuela” in postrevolutionary Mexico. Journal of Educational Administration and History, 41(3), 267–283.
35.
RockwellE. (2010). Escuelas en tiempos de guerra: La educación en el corazón de la Tlaxcala revolucionaria (1913–1918) [Schools in times of war: Education in the heart of revolutionary Tlaxcala]. In BuveR.SalaminiH. Fowler (Eds.), La Revolución Mexicana en el Oriente de México (1906–1940) [The Mexican Revolution in the Orient of Mexico(1906–1940)] (pp. 105–130). Verveut.
36.
Roldán VeraE.FuchsE. (Eds.). (2019). Introduction: The transnational in the history of education. In The transnational in the history of education: Concepts and perspectives (pp. 1–47). Palgrave Macmillan.
37.
RosserH. E. (1971). Beyond revolution. The social concern of Moisés Sáenz, Mexican educator (1888–1941) [Unpublished doctoral dissertation]. The American University.
38.
SáenzM. (1926). The program of the Mexican government. In SáenzM.PriestlyH. I., Some Mexican problems (Lectures on the Harris Foundation 1926) (pp. 3–84). University of Chicago Press.
39.
SáenzM. (1927). Mexico. In Educational Yearbook of the International Institute of Teachers College (pp. 261–313). Teachers College.
40.
SáenzM. (1936). Carapan, bosquejo de una experiencia [Carapan, sketch of an experience]. Librería e Imprenta Gil.
41.
SchriewerJ. (2012). Deweyan thought refracted through time and space: Studies on the trans-continental dissemination and cultural-specific re-contextualization of educational knowledge. In Bruno-JofréR. C.SchriewerJ. (Eds.), The global reception of John Dewey’s thought: Multiple refractions through time and space (pp. 1–20). Routledge.
42.
Secretaría de Educación Pública. (1923). Bases para la organización de la escuela primaria conforme al principio de la acción [Bases for the organization of primary schools according to the principle of action]. Publicaciones de la Secretaría de Educación Pública, Tomo X, Nº 8. Talleres de la Impresora.
43.
Steiner-KhamsiG. (2012). Understanding policy borrowing and lending: Building comparative policy studies. In Steiner-KhamsiG.WaldowF. (Eds.), World yearbook of education 2012: Policy borrowing and lending in education (pp. 2–17). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203137628.
44.
TakayamaK. (2018). Beyond comforting histories: The colonial/imperial entanglements of the International Institute, Paul Monroe, and Isaac L. Kandel at Teachers College, Columbia University. Comparative Education Review, 62(4), 459–481.
45.
Torres QuinteroG. (1917, November29). Informe General del Jefe de Departamento de Educación Pública acerca del Viaje que hizo por los Estados Unidos del Norte [General report to the Head of the Department of Public Education, on the trip to the United States of the North]. Manuscrito dirigido al Gobernador de Yucatán [Manuscript addressed to the Governor of Yucatán].
46.
WeilerK. (2005). Mabel Carney at Teachers College: From home missionary to White ally. Teachers College Record, 107(12), 2599–2633.
47.
VasconcelosJ. (1958 [1935]). El peligro Dewey. In Guevara NieblaG. (Ed.), Clásicos del Pensamiento Pedagógico (pp. 233–238). Instituto Nacional de Estudios Históricos de las Revoluciones Mexicanas. (Original work published in 1935).
