Invisible Shifts in and Out of the Classroom: Dynamics of Teacher Salary and Teacher Supply in Urban China

Abstract

Background

The remarkable economic growth in contemporary China is unprecedented, but scholars voice concerns regarding unintended consequences during this transitional phase. Of particular concern is the constant challenge to staff schools with highly qualified teachers.

Purpose

This study sets out to understand subtle yet consequential changes in schools during a sustained period of economic boom, through the lens of teacher occupational choice. This study contributes empirically to the teacher occupational choice literature by identifying the magnitude of lag in wage growth and returns to human capital in the teaching profession, and their critical relationship affecting high-ability workers’ career decisions.

Research Design

Using a nationally representative repeated cross-sectional data set spanning a quarter century (1988–2013), this study estimates Mincer earnings function regression models and multinomial probit regression models to assess wage differentials and heterogeneous rates of return to human capital in teaching and nonteaching sectors, in addition to untangling complex relationships between worker quality and observed occupational choice.

Findings

We documented several novel facts about teachers in contemporary urban China. First, we found sharp shifts in the relative career attractiveness of teaching, such that a 13% wage premium for teachers in 1988 dissipated over time and regressed to a 11% wage penalty in 2013, when compared with similar workers. Second, returns to tertiary education are markedly higher in nonteaching careers—about 11–15 percentage points more so than in teaching. Third, highly educated workers in younger cohorts are half as likely to become teachers relative to older cohorts, particularly in recent years.

Conclusions

The authors contextualize findings and discuss appropriate policy implications. Most importantly, holding back teacher wage levels from broader market prices has consequential effects on teacher supply. Policy makers need to reconsider existing forms of teacher compensation arrangements and develop sustainable wage dynamics that can attract and retain bright minds to enter and stay in teaching.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Allegretto

Corcoran

, & Mishel

(2008). The teaching penalty: Teacher pay losing ground. Economic Policy Institute.

Bacolod

(2007). Who teaches and where they choose to teach: College graduates of the 1990s. Education Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 29 3, 155—168.

Bau

, & Das

(2017). The misallocation of pay and productivity in the public sector: Evidence from the labor market for teachers. World Bank.

Bradley

Postel-Vinay

, & Turon

(2017). Public sector wage policy and labor market equilibrium: A structural model. Journal of the European Economic Association, 15 6, 1214—1257.

Brandt

, & Zhu

(2000). Redistribution in a decentralizing economy: Growth and inflation in reform China. Journal of Political Economy, 108, 422—435.

Bruns

, & Luque

(2014). Great teachers: How to raise student learning in Latin America and the Caribbean. World Bank.

Che

, & Zhang

(2018). Human capital, technology adoption and firm performance: Impacts of China's higher education expansion in the late 1990s. The Economic Journal, 128 614, 2282—2320.

Chen

(2003). A probe into problems of teacher salaries in 1990's. Tsinghua Journal of Education, 24 1, 92—96.

Chetty

Friedman

, & Rockoff

(2014). Measuring the impacts of teachers II: Teacher value-added and student outcomes in adulthood. American Economic Review, 104 9, 2633—2679.

10.

Chingos

, & West

(2012). Do more effective teachers earn more outside the classroom? Education Finance and Policy, 7 1, 8—43.

11.

Clogg

Petkova

, & Haritou

(1995). Statistical methods for comparing regression coefficients between models. American Journal of Sociology, 100 5, 1261—1293. doi:10.1086/230638

12.

Correa

Parro

, & Reyes

(2015). Self-selection in the market of teachers. Applied Economics, 47 13, 1331—1349.

13.

Darling-Hammond

(2000). Teacher quality and student achievement. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 8, 1—44.

14.

Demurger

, & Yang

(2012). Earnings differentials between the public and private sectors in China: Exploring changes for urban local residents in the 2000s. China Economic Review, 23 1, 138—153.

15.

Dolton

, & Marcenaro-Gutierrez

(2011). If you pay peanuts do you get monkeys? A crosscountry analysis of teacher pay and pupil performance. Economic Policy, 26 65, 5—55.

16.

Eddy

(2004). The hiring of rejects: Teacher recruitment and crises of socialism in the early PRC years. Modern China, 30 1, 46—80.

17.

Han

Borgonovi

, & Guerriero

(2018). What motivates high school students to want to be teachers? The role of salary, working conditions, and societal evaluations about occupations in a comparative perspective. American Educational Research Journal, 55 1, 3—39.

18.

Hanushek

, & Rivkin

(2012). The distribution of teacher quality and implications for policy. Annual Review of Economics, 4 1, 131—157.

19.

Hendricks

(2014). Does it pay to pay teachers more? Evidence from Texas. Journal of Public Economics, 109, 50—63.

20.

Hoxby

, & Leigh

(2004). Pulled away or pushed out? Explaining the decline of teacher aptitude in the United States. American Economic Review, 94 2, 236—240.

21.

(2015). Review of elevation of primary school teacher's record of schooling in Chinese mainland. Jiangsu Educational Research, 262 10, 7—12.

22.

Ingersoll

(2012). Beginning teacher induction: What the data tell us. Phi Delta Kappan, 93 8, 47—51.

23.

Jackson

(2012). Recruiting, retaining, and creating quality teachers. Nordic Economic Policy Review, 3 1, 61—104.

24.

Jiang

, & Du

(2014). On the project design of enhancing financial input of primary and secondary school teachers’ salary and its feasibility analysis. Educational Research, 419 12, 54—60.

25.

Jiang

, & Du

(2015). Analysis of primary and secondary school teacher salary levels (1990–2010). Shanghai Education Research Journal, 5, 10—13.

26.

Leigh

(2012). Teacher pay and teacher aptitude. Economics of Education Review, 31 3, 41—53.

27.

Liu

(2020). Exploring teacher attrition in urban China through interplay of wages and well-being. Education and Urban Society. doi:10.1177/0013124520958410

28.

Loyalka

Sylvia

Liu

Chu

, & Shi

(2019). Pay by design: Teacher performance pay design and the distribution of student achievement. Journal of Labor Economics, 37 3, 621—662.

29.

National Bureau of Statistics. (2010). China statistical yearbook.

30.

National Bureau of Statistics. (2011). China statistical yearbook.

31.

National Bureau of Statistics. (2017). China education statistical yearbook.

32.

Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development. (2016). Education at a glance 2016: OECD indicators. OECD Publishing.

33.

Park

, & Byun

(2015). Why some countries attract more high-ability young students to teaching: Cross-national comparisons of students’ expectation of becoming a teacher. Comparative Education Review, 59 3, 523—549.

34.

Roy

(1951). Some thoughts on the distribution of earnings. Oxford Economic Papers, 3, 135—146.

35.

Rubin

(1974). Estimating causal effects of treatments in randomized and nonrandomized studies. Journal of Educational Psychology, 65 5, 688—701.

36.

Shi

, & Yan

(2006). Focus on rural primary and secondary school teachers. Research in Education Development, 27 1, 8—13.

37.

Steiner-Khamsi

(2012). The global local nexus in comparative policy studies: Analyzing the triple bonus system in Mongolia over time. Comparative Education, 48 4, 455—471.

38.

Temin

(2002). Teacher quality and the future of America. Eastern Economic Journal, 28 3, 285—300.

39.

Watt

, & Richardson

(2012). An introduction to teaching motivations in different countries: Comparisons using the FIT-Choice scale. Asia Pacific Journal of Teacher Education, 40 3, 185—197.

40.

Wen

(2015). The making of an economic superpower—Unlocking China's secret of rapid industrialization. Federal Reserve Bank.

41.

West

Nagler

, & Piopiunik

(2020). Weak markets, strong teachers: Recession at career start and teacher effectiveness. Journal of Labor Economics, 38 2, 453—500.

42.

Xue

, & Li

(2015). Policy evaluation of urban and rural balanced allocation of compulsory education teaching staff. Educational Research, 8, 65—73.

43.

Zhou

Gong

, & Tang

(2011). Studying undergraduate teacher preparation programs. Contemporary Teacher Education, 4 2, 13—17.

44.

Zhou

, & Wang

(2016). Understanding the constraints on the supply of public education to the migrant population in China: Evidence from Shanghai. Journal of Contemporary China, 25 100, 563—578.