During the 2016 presidential election campaign, Hillary Clinton was “booed” while speaking at the National Education Association (NEA)'s annual representative assembly. The media suggested this evidenced a weakening of a powerful alliance. Since the NEA first endorsed Jimmy Carter in 1976, the claim that the Democratic party is “a wholly owned subsidiary of the NEA” has persisted. This characterization of the NEA and Democratic Party relationship has become so ubiquitous in political discourse that it is rarely questioned. As a result, the NEA is often portrayed as a powerful political player in national elections, while little evidence supports this conclusion.
Purpose/Objective/Research Question/Focus of Study
This study uses archival evidence to identify the NEA's political influence during presidential election campaigns to provide scholars a more nuanced history as they seek to understand current political happenings.
Research Design
The historical analysis used internal campaign and NEA documents located in 13 archives housed in six presidential libraries, four university libraries, two state historical societies, and one public policy institute as well as the NEA Collection at The George Washington University.
Findings/Results
Two factors explain NEA's limited influence on presidential politics despite its significant donations to the Democratic Party. First, Republican candidates used the NEA to attack Democrats as beholden to radical special interest groups. Democrats evidenced the success of this Republican strategy by taking positions the NEA opposed in an attempt to convince voters of their independence. Second, many NEA members did not support the NEA's involvement in party politics because they believed political activism was inconsistent with teacher professionalism or they were conservatives unwilling to support a Democratic candidate.
Conclusions/Recommendations
As they look to future presidential campaigns, scholars should remember: 1) Republican candidates’ attacks on the NEA have been part of a strategy to convince voters that Democratic candidates were beholden to special interests. Policy differences between Republican candidates and the NEA served as later justification for this strategy rather that its cause. 2) Democratic candidates supporting policies the NEA opposes is not an act of political courage. They have long found the power of the NEA rests not in its endorsement but in the opportunity for voters to see them stand up to this special interest group. Given the NEA's commitment to endorsing a candidate and the Republican strategy, Democrats have been able to challenge the NEA without fearing that it will cost them an endorsement or campaign contributions.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ArchibaldG. (2004, July 5). Teacher union calls for defeat of Bush; Kerry to address NEA conferees. The Washington Times.
2.
ArchibaldG. (2004, July 7). Kerry cancels on NEA convention; Hillary fills in, praises Union's 6-to-1 endorsement of candidate. The Washington Times.
3.
ArchibaldG. (2004, July 17). Kerry vows to cut health insurance costs; Seeks to rid system of ‘waste,’ ‘greed’. The Washington Times.
BakerJ. A. (1983, October). Action Plan: Reagan Campaign. James A. Baker III Papers (Box 136, Folder “1”), Princeton University Manuscripts Division, Princeton University Libraries Princeton, New Jersey, United States.
6.
BakerJ. A. (1984, April 9). [Note from James A. Baker to Terrel Bell]. James A. Baker III Papers (Box 42, Folder “44 Bell, Terrel, H. 1981-1984”), Princeton University Manuscripts Division, Princeton University Libraries Princeton, New Jersey, United States.
7.
BalzD. (1999, April 25). ‘Armies of compassion’ in Bush's plans. The Washington Post.
8.
BaumgartnerF. R.BerryJ. M.HojnackiM.LeechB. L., & KimballD. C. (2009). Lobbying and policy change: Who wins, who loses, and why. University of Chicago Press.
9.
BensonL. (1967). An approach to the scientific study of past public opinion. The Public Opinion Quarterly, 314, 522—567.
10.
BerubeM. R. (1988). Teacher Politics: The Influence of the Unions. Greenwood Press.
BushG. (1992, October 15). [Presidential debate at the University of Richmond.] Online by Gerhard Peters and John T. Woolley, The American Presidency Project. https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/node/217084
13.
CameronD. (2005). The Inside Story of the Teacher Revolution in America. Scarecrow Education, R & L Publishing.
14.
ChandlerM. A. (2011, July 3). At NEA convention, mixed feelings among Teachers for Obama ahead of 2012 vote. The Washington Post.
15.
ChaseB. (1997, February 5). The New NEA: Reinventing Teachers Unions for a New Era [Speech]. National Education Association Records (Box 2541, Folder “Press Kit–Bob Chase New Unionism Press Briefing, 2/1998”), The George Washington University Libraries, Gelman Library, Washington D.C., United States.
ClintonW. J. (1996, October 6). [Presidential debate in Hartford]. Online by Gerhard Peters and John T. Woolley, The American Presidency Project. https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/node/217284
18.
ClymerA. (1983, February 22). Mondale begins his ‘84 campaign. The New York Times.
19.
DarmanR. G. (1983). [March 1983 Report by Bob Teeter and Lee Atwater]. Richard G. Darman Files (Box 7, Folder “Politics 1984 [Lee Atwater Reports, 1985] (1)”), Ronald Reagan Presidential Library, Simi Valley, California, United States.
20.
DaviesG. (2007). Government grow: Education politics from Johnson to Reagan. University Press of Kansas.
21.
DeBray-PelotE., & McGuinnP. (2009). The new politics of education: Analyzing the federal education policy landscape in the post-NCLB era. Educational Policy, 231, 15—42.
FeinbergL. (1984, September 4). The ABCs of decline: New questions, old answers in 3-hour ‘closeup’ on schools. The Washington Post.
24.
Dole Campaign Papers. (1996a). [Memoranda]. (Box 163, Folder “Policy Research: Subject Files Education, 1996 [1 of 2]”), Robert J. Dole Institute of Politics, Lawrence, Kansas, United States.
25.
Dole Campaign Papers. (1996b). [Memoranda]. (Box 95, Folder “Policy Research, Background Research, Book I (Crime, Drugs, Education), 1996 [1 of 2])”), Robert J. Dole Institute of Politics, Lawrence, Kansas, United States.
26.
Dole Campaign Papers. (1996c). [Memoranda]. (Box 101, Folder “Policy Research, Debate, Debate materials, 1996” & “Policy Research, Debate, Debate Advice, 1996 [1 of 3]”), Robert J. Dole Institute of Politics, Lawrence, Kansas, United States.
27.
Dole Campaign Papers. (1996d, September 11). Debating Briefing Book Outline. (Box 102, Folder “Policy Research, Debates, Dole/Kemp Briefing Book, Volume I, September 11, 1996”), Robert J. Dole Institute of Politics, Lawrence, Kansas, United States.
28.
DoleR. (1996, August 15). [Address accepting the presidential nomination at the Republican National Convention in San Diego.] Online by Gerhard Peters and John T. Woolley, The American Presidency Project. https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/node/216679
29.
EizenstatS. (1976, June 3). [Memorandum Stu Eizenstat to Governor Carter]. 1976 Campaign Committee to Elect Jimmy Carter (Box 200, Folder “Memorandums-Stuart Eizenstat, 4/76-7/76”) Jimmy Carter Library, Atlanta, Georgia, United States.
30.
ElamS. M. (1981). The National Education Association: Political Powerhouse or Paper Tiger?The Phi Delta Kappan, 633, 169—174.
31.
FiskeE. B. (1984, October 29). Teacher union raises campaign aid for Mondale and other Democrats,”The New York Times.
32.
GallupG. H. (1976). Eighth annual Gallup Poll of the public's attitudes toward the public schools: A project jointly conducted by the Gallup Poll and the Charles F. Kettering Foundation. The Phi Delta Kappan, 582, 187—200.
33.
GeigerK. (1991, May 1). Remarks. National Education Association Records (Box 2542, Folder “Press Kit–NEA Endorses Bill Clinton for President 5/1992”), The George Washington University Libraries, Gelman Library, Washington D.C., United States.
34.
GeigerK., & CameronD. (1995, September 15). [Letter from Keith Geiger and Don Cameron to Local Affiliate Presidents & UniServ Directors]. National Education Association Records (Box 382, Folder “Agenda and Meeting Papers (file ½)”), The George Washington University Libraries, Gelman Library, Washington D.C., United States.
GreenhouseS. (2012, September 12). Labor right poses risks to coalition for Obama. The New York Times.
37.
HarrisJ. A. (1974, August 12). Letter to Gerald R. Ford. David H. Lissy Files (Box 9, Folder “National Education Association–Candidates Statements, 6/11/76”), Gerald R. Ford Library, Ann Arbor, Michigan, United States.
38.
HartneyM., & FlavinP. (2009). From the schoolhouse to the statehouse: teacher union political activism, public opinion, and state education reform policy. Paper presented at the Annual Conference on State Politics and Policy, Chapel Hill, North Carolina, May 22-23, 2009.
HerndonT. (1976, August 20). [Letter, Terry Herndon to Walter F. Mondale]. National Education Association Records (Box 728, Folder “PAC–Terry Herndon File”), The George Washington University Libraries, Gelman Library, Washington D.C., United States.
42.
HessF. M., & McGuinnP. J. (2002). Seeking the mantle of “opportunity”: Presidential politics and the educational metaphor, 1964-2000. Educational Policy, 161, 72—95.
43.
HochschildJ. L. (2004). Three puzzles in search of an answer from political scientists (with apologies to Pirandello). PS: Political Science and Politics, 372, 225—229.
44.
HoffmanD. (1983, May 27). Reagan presses plan for teacher merit pay, criticizes NEA stand. The Washington Post.
45.
HowardL. (1989, May 22). A White House snub to the NEA. Newsweek.
46.
JordanM. (1992, July 7). Education chief rebukes biggest teachers union; Alexander assails NEA for backing Clinton. The Washington Post.
47.
Joseph Napolitano Associates, Inc. (n. d.) A Political Action Program for the National Education Association [Report]. National Education Association Records (Box 723, Folder “PAC–Proposal and Guidelines”), The George Washington University Libraries, Gelman Library, Washington D.C., United States.
48.
KahlenbergR. D. (2012). Bipartisan, but unfounded: The assault on teachers’ unions. American educator, 354, 14—18.
49.
KronholzJ. (2004, July 28). Teachers unions name Kerry a price. The Wall Street Journal.
50.
LaytonL.WallstenP., & TurqueB. (2012, September 11). Chicago teachers strike places Obama at odds with key part of political base. The Washington Post.
51.
Letters. (1980). National Education Association Records (Box 674, Folder “Governance Committee–Presidential Endorsement (Carter/Mondale)”), The George Washington University Libraries, Gelman Library, Washington D.C., United States.
52.
LiebermanM. (1997). The Teacher Unions: How the NEA and AFT sabotage reform and hold students, parents, teachers, and taxpayers hostage to bureaucracy. The Free Press.
53.
MagruderJ. B. (1972). Committee for the Re-Election of the President. Jeb Stuart Magruder Papers (Box 19, Folder “Committee for the Re-Election of the President: Jeb Stuart Magruder, Subject Files: Alphabetical educators and teachers committee”), Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, Yorba Linda, California, United States.
54.
MalekF. (1972a). Committee for the Re-Election of the President: Frederic Malek Papers (Box 27, Folder “Citizen Groups: Educators”), Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, Yorba Linda, California, United States.
55.
MalekF. (1972b). Committee for the Re-Election of the President: Frederic Malek Papers (Box 27, Folder “Citizen Groups: Educator Scheduling”), Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, Yorba Linda, California, United States.
56.
MalekF. (1972c). Committee for the Re-Election of the President: Frederic Malek Papers (Box 27, Folder “Citizens Groups”), Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, Yorba Linda, California, United States.
57.
McAllisterB. (1992, August 7). Bush issues stinging criticism of Clinton's economic plans; President vows to ‘fight back,’ accentuate differences with Democrat. The Washington Post.
58.
McAndrewsL. J. (2006). The era of education: The President and the schools, 1965-2001. University of Illinois Press.
59.
McCainJ. (2008a, August 3). It's time for education reform. The Daily News.
60.
McCainJ. (2008b, September 4). [Address accepting the presidential nomination at the Republican National Convention in Saint Paul]. Online by Gerhard Peters and John T. Woolley, The American Presidency Project. https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/node/279091
61.
McGovernG. S. (1972). [Memoranda to Senator George McGovern, various authors]. George S. McGovern Papers (Box 102, Folder “Parochial Schools 1972”), Princeton University Manuscripts Division, Princeton University Libraries Princeton, New Jersey, United States.
62.
McGuinnP. J. (2006). No Child Left Behind and the transformation of federal education policy, 1965-2005. University Press of Kansas.
63.
MichelD. L. (2008). Jimmy Carter as educational policymaker: Equal opportunity and efficiency. State University of New York Press, 2008.
64.
MoeT. M. (2001). Teachers unions and the public schools. In MoeT. M. (Ed.), A Primer on America's Schools (pp. 151—184). Hoover Institution Press.
65.
MoeT. M. (2011). Special interest: Teachers unions and America's public schools. Brookings Institution Press.
66.
MondaleW. F. (1976). [Memorandum]. Walter F. Mondale Papers (153.J.4.9B, Folder “Correspondence and Miscellaneous Papers 1976”), Minnesota Historical Society, St. Paul, Minnesota, United States.
67.
MondaleW. F. (1983). [Memoranda from Martin Kaplan to Mondale]. Walter F. Mondale Papers (146.L.9.3 (B), Box 168, Folder “Copies 1983” & Folder “Martin Kaplan 1983”), Minnesota Historical Society, St. Paul, Minnesota, United States.
68.
MondaleW. F. (1984). [Memoranda]. Walter F. Mondale Papers (146.L.9.4 (F), Box 169, Folder “Margolis Memos to…In-House” & Folder “RCL to WFM Personal”), Minnesota Historical Society, St. Paul, Minnesota, United States.
69.
National Education Association Political Action Committee. (1976). The Teachers’ Voice in Politics [Booklet]. National Education Association Records (Box 722, Folder “PAC–Papers on Candidate Endorsement”), The George Washington University Libraries, Gelman Library, Washington D.C., United States.
NEA Delegate Daily. (1996, August 27). National Education Association Records (Box 1307, Folder “Democratic Convention [files 1/2]”), The George Washington University Libraries, Gelman Library, Washington D.C., United States.
72.
NEA Endorsements: Clout or Controversy, Greenberg-Lake: The Analysis Group [Report]. (n. d.). National Education Association Records (Box 1307, Folder “Election Communications to Members–1980 and 1988 Election [file ¼”), The George Washington University Libraries, Gelman Library, Washington D.C., United States.
73.
NEA Issue Backgrounder: Setting New Priorities, a Guide for evaluating Presidential Candidates, 1991 [Brochure]. (n. d.). National Education Association Records (Box 2535, Folder “Information Packet–Presidential Endorsement”), The George Washington University Libraries, Gelman Library, Washington D.C., United States.
74.
NEA Office of Government Relations and Citizenship. (n. d.) NEA: Education's Voice in Government. [Brochure]. National Education Association Records (Box 674, Folder “Governance Committee–Presidential Conference on School Finance 1971-1971”), The George Washington University Libraries, Gelman Library, Washington D.C., United States. NEA Presidential Endorsement Procedure: Campaign ‘88 [Brochure]. (n. d.). National Education Association Records (Box 2482, Folder “Communications–Presidential Endorsement Procedure 1988”), The George Washington University Libraries, Gelman Library, Washington D.C., United States.
75.
NEA Presidential Endorsement Procedure 1992 [Brochure]. (n. d.). National Education Association Records (Box 2535, Folder “Information Packet–Presidential Endorsement 12/1991”), The George Washington University Libraries, Gelman Library, Washington D.C., United States.
76.
NicholsonS. P. (2005). Voting the agenda: Candidates, elections, and ballot propositions. Princeton University Press.
77.
1976 Presidential Campaign: Issues Office. (1976). (Box 42, Folder “Endorsements”)Jimmy Carter Library, Atlanta, Georgia, United States.
78.
NorrisB. D. (1976, October 14). [Letter from Barbara D. Norris to Darcy Miller]. President Ford Committee Records (Box B79), Gerald R. Ford Library, Ann Arbor, Michigan, United States.
PowellJ. (1976, August). Analysis of Political Attitudes in the United States [Report]. Jody Powell Papers (Box 15, Folder “CRS: Analysis of Political Attitudes in the United States, Volume 2”), Jimmy Carter Library, Atlanta, Georgia, United States.
89.
PowellJ. (1980, June 25). General Election Strategy, Patrick H. Caddell [Report]. Jody Powell Papers (Box 20, Folder “General Election Strategy 6/25/80”), Jimmy Carter Library, Atlanta, Georgia, United States. President Ford Committee. (1975-1977). [Staff Records]. Gerald R. Ford Library (Box B7, Folder “Hughes Subject File–National Education Association” & Box B79, Folder “Correspondence Topics Education”), Ann Arbor, Michigan, United States.
90.
Presidential Candidate Debates. (1992, October 13). [Vice Presidential Debate in Atlanta, Georgia]. Online by Gerhard Peters and John T. Woolley, The American Presidency Project. https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/node/217188
91.
Presidential Candidate Debates. (2008, October 15). [Presidential debate at Hofstra University in Hempstead, New York]. Online by Gerhard Peters and John T. Woolley, The American Presidency Project. https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/node/284407
92.
Presidential Candidate Debates. (2016a, March 10). [Republican candidates debate in Miami, Florida]. Online by Gerhard Peters and John T. Woolley, The American Presidency Project. https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/node/316419.
93.
Presidential Candidate Debates. (2016b, October 19). [Presidential Debate at the University of Nevada in Las Vegas]. Online by Gerhard Peters and John T. Woolley, The American Presidency Project. https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/node/319020
94.
Program to Implement the NEA Presidential Endorsement Procedure [Report]. (1975, January 13). National Education Association Records (Box 723, Folder “PAC - Presidential Endorsement”), The George Washington University Libraries, Gelman Library, Washington D.C., United States.
95.
RapoportR. B.StoneW. J., & AbramowitzA. I. (1991). Do endorsements matter? Group influence in the 1984 Democratic caucuses. American Political Science Review, 851, 193—203.
96.
RascoC. (1996, April 23). [Memorandum, Carol H. Rasco to the President]. Carol Rasco: Subject Files (Box 21, Folder “Memorandums”), William J. Clinton Presidential Library, Little Rock, Arkansas, United States.
97.
ReaganR. (1980, September 13). [Memorandum, Max Hugel to Ed Meese, Stan Anderson, Bill Timmons, and Martin Anderson]. Ronald Reagan 1980 Campaign Papers (Box 257, Folder “Political Ops–Voters Groups–Professions (Timmons)”), Ronald Reagan Presidential Library, Simi Valley, California, United States.
98.
ReaganR. (1983, May 26). [Letter to the President of the National Education Association on merit pay for teachers.] Online by Gerhard Peters and John T. Woolley, The American Presidency Project. https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/node/262453
99.
ReardonD. G. (1980, March 20). [Letter from Donna G. Reardon to Willard McGuire]. National Education Association Records (Box 672, Folder “Governance Committee–Presidential Endorsement (Carter/Mondale)”), The George Washington University Libraries, Gelman Library, Washington D.C., United States.
100.
Records of Temporary Committees, Commissions, and Boards. (1971). Records of the Cabinet Committee on Education (Record Group 220, Box 20, Folder “National Education Association”), Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, Yorba Linda, California, United States.
101.
ReichleyA. J. (1976). [Memoranda]. A. James Reichley Files (Box 2, Folder “Constituency Analysis” and Box 4, folder “Nat'l Education Assoc. (1)”), Gerald R. Ford Library, Ann Arbor, Michigan, United States.
RomneyM. (2012a, September 10). [Statement by Mitt Romney on the strike by Chicago Teachers Union]. Online by Gerhard Peters and John T. Woolley, The American Presidency Project. https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/node/302954
104.
RomneyM. (2012b, September 13). Press Release: Romney for President Announces National Educators For Romney. Online by Gerhard Peters and John T. Woolley, The American Presidency Project. https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/node/303098
105.
RyorJ. (1976, August 25). [Letter]. National Education Association Records (Box 723, Folder “PAC - Presidential Endorsement Recommendation Letter”), The George Washington University Libraries, Gelman Library, Washington D.C., United States.
SawyerK. (1984, March 1). Organized labor attempts to gauge damage to Mondale, itself; Hart's victory illustrates risk union chiefs took endorsing Mondale. The Washington Post.
109.
SchemoD. J. (2004, August 12). Group pushes education as 2004 issue. The New York Times.
110.
SchwartzM. (1988, August 15). Would-be education President wins few friends in the NEA. The Washington Post.
ShoberA. F. (2016). In Common No More: The Politics of the Common Core State Standards: The Politics of the Common Core State Standards. Praeger; ABC-CLIO.
113.
ShottsC. T. (1976). The origin and development of the National Education Association Political Action Committee, 1969-1977. [Doctoral dissertation, Indiana University].
ShustD., & LewisC. (2004). The National Education Association's new bipartisanship. In HendersonR. D.UrbanW. J., & WolmanP. (Eds.), Teacher Unions and Education Policy: Retrenchment or Reform?Elsevier JAI.
116.
StephensD.President Carter, the Congress, and NEA: Creating the Department of Education. Political Science Quarterly, 98(4), 641—663.
117.
StraussV. (2002, May 23). Romney's education speech–text. The Washington Post.
TaylorJ. (1996, July 18). Dole calls Clinton teacher unions’ ‘Pet,’ offers plan to let parents choose schools. The Wall Street Journal. A14.
123.
The Economist. (2002, July 4). Lexington: Inching towards reform. https://www.economist.com/united-states/2002/07/04/inching-towards-reform The Power of the White House. Today's Education. (September-October, 1975). National Education Association Records (Box 723, Folder “PAC–Presidential Endorsement”), The George Washington University Libraries, Gelman Library, Washington D.C., United States.
ThorntonL. T. (1996, October 2). [Memorandum, Leslie T. Thornton to the President]. Bruce Reed: Education (Box 96, Folder “Vouchers”), William J. Clinton Presidential Library, Little Rock, Arkansas, United States.
126.
ToppoG. (2012, July 3). USA's top teachers union losing members. USA Today.
TrumpD. J. (2016a, September 8). [Remarks at the Cleveland Arts and Social Sciences Academy in Cleveland, Ohio]. Online by Gerhard Peters and John T. Woolley, The American Presidency Project https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/node/319638
129.
TrumpD. J. (2016b, September 12). [Remarks at the US Cellular Center in Asheville, North Carolina]. Online by Gerhard Peters and John T. Woolley, The American Presidency Project. https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/node/319617
130.
UrbanW. J. (2000). Gender, Race, and the National Education Association: Professionalism and its limitations (Vol. 10). Taylor & Francis.
131.
UrbanW. J. (2004). Teacher politics. In HendersonR. D.UrbanW. J., & WolmanP. (Eds.), Teacher unions and education policy: Retrenchment or reform?Elsevier JAI.
132.
USA Today. (1996, August 28). School debate degenerates as Dole misses the points. 14A.
133.
WeaverW.Jr. (1988, October 1). Bentsen, before teachers, seeks support ‘for future of schools’. The New York Times.
134.
White House Staff Offices, Chief of Staff: Jordan. (1980, April 18). [Memorandum from Landon Butler to Hamilton Jordan]. (Box 79, Folder “Labor-Political”), Jimmy Carter Library, Atlanta, Georgia, United States.
135.
White House Staff Offices, Domestic Policy Staff. (1980). Agenda, NEA Briefing. (Box 17, Folder “[National Education Assoc.,] NEA”), Jimmy Carter Library, Atlanta, Georgia, United States.
136.
White House Staff Offices, Domestic Policy Staff, Eizenstat. (1977). [Memoranda]. (Box 195, Folders “Education, Dept. of (Separate) [OA/ID 6238] [2]”, Education, Dept. of (Separate) [OA/ID 6238] [3] & “Separate Document”), Jimmy Carter Library, Atlanta, Georgia, United States.
137.
White House Staff Offices, Domestic Policy Staff, Human Resources, Hyatt. (n.d.). [Memorandum from Debbie Hyatt to Bert Carp]. (Box 17, Folder “[National Education Assoc.,] NEA”), Jimmy Carter Library, Atlanta, Georgia, United States.
138.
White House Staff Offices, Office of Staff Secretary. (n.d.). [Memorandum from Landon Butler and Gretchen to The President]. (Box 149, Folder “9/28/79”), Jimmy Carter Library, Atlanta, Georgia, United States.
