Policies featuring individualized learning plans (ILPs) have become increasingly popular among states seeking to improve college and career readiness through early postsecondary planning. Although ILPs are featured in legislation for more than 35 states, limited work has been done on measuring their effectiveness to ensure that students are better prepared for college and career.
Purpose
In this study, we fill this gap in the literature by exploring the effects of completing an ILP and potential spillover effects in schools that require the use of this tool. We also explore whether these effects vary by parental income status. Using a quasi-experimental design, we offer nationally generalizable evidence of the ILP on individual student's transition from secondary to postsecondary education
Research Design
We use data from the High School Longitudinal Survey of 2009 (HSLS:09), a nationally representative survey of students in 944 public and private high schools who are surveyed at multiple points during their time in high school. Using these data, we employ the quasi-experimental propensity score matching approach to generate balance between treated and untreated groups on observed covariates.
Findings
The findings from this study suggest that students who completed ILPs were more likely to identify a career of interest and make informed college choices with respect to institutional fit as compared with peers who did not use this tool. In particular, low-income students who completed an ILP were more likely to apply for financial aid and submit applications to multiple institutions when compared with economically similar students who did not use ILPs. Also, schools offering ILPs were more likely to help students enroll in moderately selective four-year colleges and to complete some advanced credits in English.
Conclusions
This study's findings offer evidence that schools can use ILPs to help students prepare for college through the college search and selection process. Although ILPs seem to be most effective in helping students plan for the process of applying to college, greater emphasis may be needed to ensure that ILPs also support students in the effort of academic course planning.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlonS. (2009). The evolution of class inequality in higher education: Competition, exclusion, and adaptation. American Sociological Review, 745, 731—755.
2.
AlonS., & TiendaM. (2005). Assessing the “mismatch” hypothesis: Differences in college graduation rates by institutional selectivity. Sociology of Education, 784, 294—315.
ArumR., & RoksaJ. (2011). Academically adrift. University of Chicago Press.
5.
AveryC., & HoxbyC., (2012). The missing “one-offs”: The hidden supply of high merit students for highly selective colleges (NBER Working Paper No. 18586). National Bureau of Economic Research.
6.
AveryC., & KaneT. J. (2004). Students’ perceptions of college opportunities: The Boston COACH program. In HoxbyC. M. (Ed.), College choices: The economics of where to go, when to go, and how to pay for it (pp. 355—394). University of Chicago Press.
7.
BellA. D.Rowan-KenyonH. T., & PernaL. W. (2009). College knowledge of 9th and 11th grade students: Variation by school and state context. The Journal of Higher Education, 806, 663—685.
8.
BettingerE. P., & LongB. T. (2005). Remediation at the community college: Student participation and outcomes. New Directions for Community Colleges, 2005129, 17—26.
9.
BlackA. C.LittleC. A.McCoachD. B.PurcellJ. H., & SiegleD. (2008). Advancement via individual determination: Method selection in conclusions about program effectiveness. The Journal of Educational Research, 1022, 111—124.
10.
BowenW. G.ChingosM. M., & McPhersonM. S. (2009). Crossing the finish line: Completing college at America's public universities. Princeton University Press.
11.
BoziakR., & DaltonB. (2013). Balancing career and technical education with academic coursework: The consequences for mathematics achievement in high school. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 352, 123—138.
12.
BrittonT. (2019). The best laid plans: Postsecondary educational expectations and college enrollment in Massachusetts. The Journal of Higher Education, 906, 940—964.
13.
BuiK. V. T. (2002). First-generation college students at a four-year university: Background characteristics, reasons for pursuing higher education, and first-year experiences. College Student Journal, 361, 3—12.
CabreraA. F., & La NasaS. M. (2000). Overcoming the tasks on the path to college for America's disadvantaged. In CabreraA. F., & La NasaS. M. (Eds.), Understanding the college choice of disadvantaged students (pp. 31—43). Jossey-Bass.
16.
CabreraA. F., & La NasaS. M. (2001). On the path to college: Three critical tasks facing America's disadvantaged. Research in Higher Education, 422, 119—149.
17.
CaliendoM., & KopeinigS. (2008). Some practical guidance for the implementation of propensity score matching. Journal of Economic Surveys, 221, 31—72.
18.
Carl D. Perkins Career and Technical Education Improvement Act. Pub. L. No. 109-270 (2006).
19.
CarnevaleA. P., & RoseS. J. (2004). Socioeconomic status, race/ethnicity, and selective college admissions. In KahlenbergR. D. (Ed.), America's untapped resource: Low-income students in higher education (pp. 101—156). Century Foundation Press.
20.
CarnevaleA. P.SmithN., & StrohlJ. (2013). Postsecondary education and economic opportunity. In PernaL. (Ed.), Preparing today's students for tomorrow's jobs in metropolitan America (pp. 93—120). University of Pennsylvania Press.
21.
CastlemanB., & GoodmanJ. (2018). Intensive college counseling and the enrollment and persistence of low-income students. Education Finance and Policy, 131, 19—41.
22.
CastlemanB. L., & PageL. C. (2015). Summer nudging: Can personalized text messages and peer mentor outreach increase college going among low-income high school graduates?Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 115, 144—160.
23.
Darling-HammondL.WilhoitG., & PittengerL. (2014). Accountability for college and career readiness: Developing a new paradigm. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 2286, 1—38.
24.
De La RosaM. L. (2006). Is opportunity knocking? Low-income students’ perceptions of college and financial aid. American Behavioral Scientist, 49, 1670—1686.
25.
DominaT. (2009). What works in college outreach: Assessing targeted and schoolwide interventions for disadvantaged students. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 31, 127—152.
26.
DuckworthA. L.KirbyT. A.GollwitzerA., & OettingenG. (2013). From fantasy to action: Mental contrasting with implementation intentions (MCII) improves academic performance in children. Social Psychological and Personality Science, 46, 745—753.
27.
DuGoffE.SchulerM., & StuartE. (2014). Generalizing observational study results: Applying propensity score methods to complex surveys. Health Services Research, 491, 284—303.
28.
DunbarA.HosslerD.ShapiroD.ChenJ.MartinS.TorresV.ZerqueraD., & ZiskinM. (2011). National postsecondary enrollment trends: Before, during, and after the Great Recession. National Student Clearinghouse Research Center.
EngbergM. E. (2012). Pervasive inequality in the stratification of four-year college destinations. Equity & Excellence in Education, 454, 575—595.
31.
GibsonD., & ClarkeJ. (2000). Growing toward systemic change: Developing personal learning plans at Montpelier High School. Northeast and Islands Regional Educational Laboratory, Brown University.
32.
GollwitzerP. M. (1999). Implementation intentions: Strong effects of simple plans. American Psychologist, 547, 493—503.
33.
GoodmanJ., & CohodesS. (2014). Merit aid, college quality, and college completion: Massachusetts’ Adams scholarship as an in-kind subsidy. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 64, 251—285.
34.
GoyetteK. A. (2008). College for some to college for all: Social background, occupational expectations, and educational expectations over time. Social Science Research, 372, 461—484.
35.
Heldrich Center for Workforce Development. (2012). New Jersey Department of Education personalized student learning plan pilot program, 2011-2012. Evaluation report. Bloustein School of Planning and Public Policy, Rutgers University.
36.
HornL. J.ChenX., & ChapmanC. (2003). Getting ready to pay for college: What students and their parents know about the cost of college tuition and what they are doing to find out. National Center for Education Statistics.
37.
HouleJ. N. (2014). Disparities in debt parents’ socioeconomic resources and young adult student loan debt. Sociology of Education, 871, 53—69.
38.
IngelsS. J.PlantyM., & BozickR. (2005). A profile of American high school in 2004: A first look. Initial results from the first follow-up of the Education Longitudinal Study of 2002 (ELS: 2002). National Center for Education Statistics.
39.
JacobB. A., & LinkowT. W. (2011). Educational expectations and attainment. In DuncanG. J., & MurnaneR. J. (Eds.), Whither opportunity? Rising inequality, schools, and children's life chances (pp. 133—164). Russell Sage Foundation.
40.
KimD. H., & SchneiderB. L. (2005). Social capital in action: Alignment of parental support in adolescents’ transition to postsecondary education. Social Forces, 842, 1181—1206.
41.
KirstM. W., & VeneziaA. (2004). From high school to college: Improving opportunities for success in postsecondary education. Jossey-Bass.
42.
LongM. C. (2008). College quality and early adult outcomes. Economics of Education Review, 275, 588—560.
43.
LongM. C. (2010). Changes in the returns to education and college quality. Economics of Education Review, 293, 338—347.
44.
Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education. (2014). Massachusetts guide for implementing individual learning plans (ILP). Preparing all students for success after high school. Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education.
45.
McDonoughP. M. (1997). Choosing colleges: How social class and schools structure opportunity. State University of New York Press.
46.
McDonoughP. M. (2005). Counseling and college counseling in America's high schools. National Association for College Admission Counseling.
47.
MelguizoT. (2008). Quality matters: Assessing the impact of attending more selective institutions on college completion rates of minorities. Research in Higher Education, 493, 214—236.
48.
Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education. (2015). School counselor's guide to the K–12 individual student planning process.
49.
MurnaneR. J., & WillettJ. B. (2011). Methods matter: Improving causal inference in educational and social science research. Oxford University Press.
National Center for Education Statistics. (2016). Digest of Education Statistics: Undergraduate retention and graduation rates. U.S. Department of Education.
52.
New Jersey Department of Education. (2014). A guide for implementing personalized student learning plan (PSLP) programs. New Jersey Department of Education.
53.
NickersonD. W., & RogersT. (2010). Do you have a voting plan? Implementation intentions, voter turnout, and organic plan making. Psychological Science, 212, 194—199.
54.
NiuS. X.TiendaM.CortesK. (2006). College selectivity and the Texas top 10% law. Economics of Education Review, 25, 259—272.
55.
OakesJ., & GuitonG. (1995). Matchmaking: The dynamics of high school tracking decisions. American Educational Research Journal, 321, 3—33.
56.
OrmsmithM., & MansfieldK. C. (2014). A study of “career pathways” policy with implications for school leaders. Education Leadership Review of Doctoral Research, 12, 1—22.
57.
PallaisA., & TurnerS. (2006). Opportunities for low-income students at top colleges and universities: Policy initiatives and the distribution of students. National Tax Journal, 592, 357—386.
58.
PhelpsL. A.DurhamJ., & WillsJ. (2011). Education alignment and accountability in an era of convergence: Policy insights from states with individual learning plans and policies. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 19, 31.
59.
PlankS. B., & JordanW. J. (2001). Effects of information, guidance, and actions on postsecondary destinations: A study of talent loss. American Educational Research Journal, 384, 947—979.
RogersT.MilkmanK. L.JohnL., & NortonM. I. (2015). Beyond good intentions: Prompting people to make plans improves follow-through on important tasks. Behavioral Science & Policy, 12, 33—41.
62.
RosenbaumJ. (2001). Beyond college for all: Career pathways for the forgotten half. Russell Sage Foundation.
63.
RosenbaumP. R., & RubinD. B. (1983). The central role of the propensity score in observational studies for causal effects. Biometrika, 70, 41—55.
64.
Rowan-KenyonH.PernaL., & SwanA. (2011). Structuring opportunity: The role of school context in shaping high school students’ occupational aspirations. The Career Development Quarterly, 594, 330—344.
65.
Scott-ClaytonJ., & MinayaV. (2015). Should student employment be subsidized? Conditional counterfactuals and the outcomes of work-study participation. Economics of Education Review, 52, 1—18.
66.
SmithJ.PenderM., & HowellJ. S. (2013). The full extent of student-college academic undermatch. Economics of Education Review, 32, 247—261.
67.
SolbergV. S.PhelpsL. A.HaakensonK. A.DurhamJ. F., & TimmonsJ. (2012). The nature and use of individualized learning plans as a promising career intervention strategy. Journal of Career Development, 306, 500—514.
68.
StephanJ. L.RosenbaumJ. E., & PersonA. E. (2009). Stratification in college entry and completion. Social Science Research, 38, 572—293.
69.
TerenziniP. T.SpringerL.YaegerP. M.PascarellaE. T., & NoraA. (1996). First-generation college students: Characteristics, experiences, and cognitive development. Research in Higher Education, 371, 1—22.
VargasJ. H. (2004). College knowledge: Addressing information barriers to college. The Education Resources Institute.
73.
VenegasK. M. (2006). Internet inequalities: Financial aid, the Internet, and low-income students. American Behavioral Scientist, 49, 1652—1669.
74.
VeneziaA., & KirstM. W. (2005). Inequitable opportunities: How current education systems and policies undermine the chances for student persistence and success in college. Educational Policy, 19, 283—207.
