Legal scholars have cited the Fifth Circuit's ruling in Dixon v. Alabama State Board of Education (1961) as the beginning of a revolution for students’ rights that ended the in loco parentis relationship between colleges and their students. But little has been written about the students’ activism that led to this seminal case.
Research Question
Students’ rights, in general, benefited from the Dixon precedent. But how did the student activists who brought the case personally benefit? None were able to tell their stories in court in a way that challenged separate but equal laws. None of them took advantage of the due process that the Fifth Circuit ruled that Alabama State College must provide. None re-enrolled at the college after the case was over. And segregation was still alive and well in Alabama after Dixon was decided. So what did they win?
Research Design
This study presents a historical analysis of the student activism that led to the Dixon case, the case itself, and its interplay with future civil rights activism.
Conclusions
Despite the divergence of interests between the student activists and the lawyers, both the sit-in and the litigation empowered students all over the country to engage in the civil rights struggle.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abernathy telegrams urge officials to “restore order.” (1960, February 28). Montgomery Advertiser. ASU Student Sit-In Newspaper Clipping File Collection. Archives Dept., Alabama State University, Montgomery, AL.
2.
AlexanderM. (2012). The new Jim Crow: Mass incarceration in the age of colorblindness. New York, NY: The New Press.
3.
BellD. (1976). Serving two masters: Integration ideals and client interests in desegregation litigation. Yale Law Journal, 85(4), 470–516.
4.
BickelR. D., & LakeP. F. (1999). The rights and responsibilities of the modern university: Who assumes the risk of college life?Durham, NC: Carolina Academic Press.
5.
CarsonC. (1995). In struggle: SNCC and the Black awakening of the 1960s. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
6.
CastleberryF. (1960, February 29). Governor's expulsion orders aimed primarily at sitdown ringleaders. Alabama Journal. ASU Student Sit-In Newspaper Clipping File Collection. Archives Dept., Alabama State University, Montgomery, AL.
7.
CoombesJ. (1960, February 28). Two demonstrations staged by Negroes. Montgomery Advertiser. ASU Student Sit-In Newspaper Clipping File Collection. Archives Dept., Alabama State University, Montgomery, AL.
8.
Courthouse grill limited to employees. (1960, March 1). Montgomery Advertiser. ASU Student Sit-In Newspaper Clipping File Collection. Archives Dept., Alabama State University, Montgomery, AL.
9.
Dixon v. Alabama State Board of Education, 186 F. Supp. 945 (M.D. Ala. 1960), rev'd 294 F.2d 150 (5th Cir. 1961), cert. den'd 368 U.S. 930 (1961).
10.
Dr. Trenholm asks for clear thinking. (1960, February 27). Montgomery Advertiser. ASU Student Sit-In Newspaper Clipping File Collection. Archives Dept., Alabama State University, Montgomery, AL.
11.
Due v. Florida A&M University, 233 F. Supp. 396 (N.D. Fla. 1963).
12.
GelberS. (2014). Expulsion litigation and the limits of in loco parentis, 1860–1960. Teachers College Record, 116.
13.
Goss v. Lopez, 419 U.S. 565 (1975).
14.
GrayF. (1995). Bus ride to justice: Changing the system by the system. Montgomery, AL: Black Belt Press.
15.
GuinierL. (1998). Lift every voice: Turning a civil rights setback into a new vision of social justice. New York, NY: Simon & Schuster.
16.
HinesD., & IngramB. (1960a, February 26). Expel Negro sitdowners, college told: Alabama State president given mandate in governor's office. Montgomery Advertiser. ASU Student Sit-In Newspaper Clipping File Collection. Archives Dept., Alabama State University, Montgomery, AL.
17.
HinesD., & IngramB. (1960b, March 4). Pledge-free students troop back to classes. Montgomery Advertiser. ASU Student Sit-In Newspaper Clipping File Collection. Archives Dept., Alabama State University, Montgomery, AL.
18.
Hymn-singing students hold rally at Capitol. (1960, March 2). Montgomery Advertiser. ASU Student Sit-In Newspaper Clipping File Collection. Archives Dept., Alabama State University, Montgomery, AL.
19.
IngramB. (1960, March 5). 900 Negroes shout pledge of protest. Montgomery Advertiser. ASU Student Sit-In Newspaper Clipping File Collection. Archives Dept., Alabama State University, Montgomery, AL.
20.
JenkinsR. (1960, February 28). Violence erupts on Dexter, woman clubbed with bat. Montgomery Advertiser. ASU Student Sit-In Newspaper Clipping File Collection. Archives Dept., Alabama State University, Montgomery, AL.
21.
JolyT. (2010, Summer). Taking a seat against segregation. ASU Today, 3(2), 5–7, 29.
22.
KaplinW. A., & LeeB. (2006). The law of higher education (4th ed.). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
23.
King expects “sitters” in 3 more states. (1960, February 23). Alabama Journal. ASU Student Sit-In Newspaper Clipping File Collection. Archives Dept., Alabama State University, Montgomery, AL.
24.
King urges demonstrators to “fill up jails.” (1960, February 28). Montgomery Advertiser. ASU Student Sit-In Newspaper Clipping File Collection. Archives Dept., Alabama State University, Montgomery, AL.
25.
Knight v. State Board of Education, 200 F. Supp. 174 (M.D. Tenn. 1961).
26.
KovarikG. (1960a, February 26). Negroes disband after march into courthouse here: 250 stage loyalty demonstration in behalf of youth who later pleaded guilty in court. Alabama Journal. ASU Student Sit-In Newspaper Clipping File Collection. Archives Dept., Alabama State University, Montgomery, AL.
27.
KovarikG. (1960b, February 27). Bat-carrying men patrol Dexter: Out-of-town cars spotted at rally. Alabama Journal. ASU Student Sit-In Newspaper Clipping File Collection. Archives Dept., Alabama State University, Montgomery, AL
28.
LeeB. (1960a). Students petition the Governor [Students’ petition to Governor Patterson]. National Archives (Exhibit A of Defendant's Answer, Transcript of Record for Dixon v. Alabama State Board of Education, 5th Cir.), Fort Worth, TX.
29.
LeeB. (1960b). Western Union Telegram [Telegram to Governor Patterson from Bernard Lee dated February 27, 1960]. National Archives (Exhibit B of Defendant's Answer, Transcript of Record for Dixon v. Alabama State Board of Education, 5th Cir.), Fort Worth, TX.
30.
LeeB. (1960c). Statement of students of Alabama State College after nine students were expelled on March 2, 1960 [Students’ statement to press]. National Archives (Exhibit D of Defendant's Answer, Transcript of Record for Dixon v. Alabama State Board of Education, 5th Cir.), Fort Worth, TX.
31.
LossC. P. (2014). Institutionalizing in loco parentis after Gott v. Berea College (1913). Teachers College Record, 116.
32.
Marzette v. McPhee, 294 F. Supp. 561 (W.D. Wis. 1968).
33.
Obituary: Rev. Bernard Lee, 55, civil rights advocate. (1991, February 14). The New York Times.
34.
Student ouster sparks Negro college walkout: 9 expelled, 20 given probation. (1960, March 3). Montgomery Advertiser. ASU Student Sit-In Newspaper Clipping File Collection. Archives Dept., Alabama State University, Montgomery, AL.
35.
Sullivan receives no report of incident. (1960, February 28). Montgomery Advertiser. ASU Student Sit-In Newspaper Clipping File Collection. Archives Dept., Alabama State University, Montgomery, AL.
Transcript of proceedings. (1960, August 22). Trial Transcript in Dixon v. Alabama State Board of Education. National Archives (Transcript of Record for Dixon v. Alabama State Board of Education, 5th Cir.), Fort Worth, TX.
38.
WatkinsL. (1987). Fighting hard: The Alabama State experience. Detroit, MI: Harlo Press.
39.
WilliamsonJ. A. (2008). Radicalizing the ebony tower: Black colleges and the Black freedom struggle in Mississippi. New York, NY: Teachers College Press.
