Over the past two decades, more than 200 studies have been published on the effects of community service learning on university students. However, the majority of these studies have focused on the effects of such programming on White and affluent college students, and few have considered whether there are differential effects for participants depending on their racial and ethnic backgrounds. This study considered these differential effects in both the academic and experiential components of such programming.
Participants
This study compared the experiences of 244 White students and 118 students of color participating in a community service learning program at Beacon University (a pseudonym) during the 2008–2009 academic year.
Intervention
The Social Action Program is a community service learning program sponsored by Beacon University's philosophy department that seeks to educate participating students about social injustice. The academic component of the program is a year long course that includes interdisciplinary readings from the humanities and social sciences as well as weekly lectures and a discussion section. Participating students also spend 10 hours each week for the entire academic year at one of approximately 50 different service placements focused on antipoverty efforts.
Research Design
Mixed-methods research design involving quantitative analyses (analysis of covariance) of pre-post surveys and qualitative analyses of hour-long semistructured interviews.
Results
Students of color participating in the community service learning program characterized the academic component of the program as offering a weaker sense of community than did their White classmates, and many expressed a reluctance to engage in race discussions with their classmates or to respond to perspectives they perceived as naïve, inaccurate, or offensive.
Conclusions
Even university courses and programming explicitly designed to disrupt White privilege can inadvertently be normed to serve the interests, experiences, and learning goals of White students. Such reification of White privilege comes with a significant cost; the learning of all students is diminished when diverse perspectives are not fully represented or heard.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AndersonL. (1991). Acculturative stress: A theory of relevance to Black Americans. Clinical Psychology Review, 11, 685–702.
2.
AntonioA., ChangM., HakutaK., KennyD., LevinS., & MilemJ. (2004). Effects of racial diversity on complex thinking in college students. Psychological Science, 15(8), 507–510.
3.
AstinA. (2000). How service affects students. Los Angeles, CA: Higher Education Research Institute.
4.
AstinA., & SaxL. (1998). How service affects undergraduates. Journal of College Student Development, 39, 251–263.
5.
BatchelderT., & RootS. (1994). Effects of an undergraduate program to integrate academic learning and service: Cognitive, prosocial cognitive, and identity outcomes. Journal of Adolescence, 17, 341–355.
6.
BeaumontE., ColbyA., EhrlichT., & Torney-PurtaJ. (2006). Promoting political competence and engagement in college students: An empirical study. Journal of Political Science, 2(3), 249–170.
7.
BeckerH. (1996). The epistemology of qualitative research. In ColbyA., JessorR., & ShwederR. A. (Eds.), Ethnography and human development: Context and meaning in social inquiry (pp. 53–71). Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
8.
Bonilla-SilvaE., & EmbrickD. (2008). Recognizing the likelihood of reproducing racism. In PollockM. (Ed.), Everyday antiracism (pp. 328–334). New York, NY: New Press.
9.
Boyle-BaiseM., & KilbaneJ. (2000). What really happens? A look inside service-learning for multicultural teacher education. Michigan Journal of Community Service Learning, 7, 54–64.
10.
Boyle-BaiseM., & LangfordJ. (2004). There are children here: Service-learning for social justice. Equity & Excellence in Education, 37, 55–66.
11.
ButinD. (2003). Of what use is it? Multiple conceptions of service-learning within education. Teachers College Record, 105(9), 1674–1692.
12.
ButinD. (2006). The limits of service-learning in higher education. Review of Higher Education, 29(4), 473–498.
13.
CarnevaleA.P., & FryR. A. (2002). The demographic window of opportunity: College access and diversity in the new century. In HellerD. E. (Ed.), Condition of access: Higher education for lower income students (pp. 137–152). Washington, DC: American Council on Education/Praeger.
14.
CarrollG. (1998). Environmental stress and African Americans: The other side of the moon. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.
15.
CarterD. (2008). On spotlighting and ignoring racial group members in the classroom. In PollockM. (Ed.), Everyday antiracism: Getting real about race in schools (pp. 230–235). New York, NY: New Press.
16.
ChangM. J., DensonN., SaenzV., & MisaK. (2006). The educational benefits of sustaining cross-racial interaction among undergraduates. Journal of Higher Education, 77(3), 430–455.
17.
CheslerM., FordK., GaluraJ., & CharbeneauJ. (2006). Peer facilitators as border crossers in community service learning. Teaching Sociology, 34(4), 341–356.
18.
CohenL. (1995). Facilitating the critique of racism and classism: An experiential model for Euro-American middle class students. Teaching Sociology, 23, 87–93.
19.
ColesR. (1999). Race-focused service-learning courses: Issues and recommendations. Michigan Journal of Community Service Learning, 6, 97–105.
20.
DillmanD. (2007). Mail and Internet surveys: The tailored design method. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.
21.
DoteL., CramerK., DietzN., & GrimmR. (2006). College students helping America. Washington, DC: Corporation for National and Community Service.
22.
EllsworthE. (1994). Why doesn't this feel empowering? Working through the repressive myths of critical pedagogy. In StoneL. & BoldtG. (Eds.), The education feminism reader (pp. 300–327). London, England: Routledge.
23.
EnosS. (1999). A multicultural and critical perspective on teaching through community: A dialogue with Jose Calderon of Pitzer College. In Cultivating the sociological imagination: Concepts and models for service-learning in sociology (pp. 55–72). Washington, DC: American Association for Higher Education.
24.
GilesD., & EylerJ. (1994). The impact of a college community service laboratory on students’ personal, social, and cognitive outcomes. Journal of Adolescence, 17, 327–339.
25.
GlaserB. G., & StraussA. L. (1967). The discovery of grounded theory: strategies for qualitative research. Chicago, IL: Aldine.
26.
GreenA. (2001). ‘But you aren't White’: Racial perceptions and service-learning. Michigan Journal of Community Service Learning, 8, 18–26.
27.
GurinP., DeyE. L., HurtadoS., & GurinG. (2002). Diversity and higher education: Theory and impact on educational outcomes. Harvard Educational Review, 72, 330–367.
HowardA. (2008). Learning privilege: Lessons of power and identity in affluent schooling. New York, NY: Routledge.
30.
HowardA. (2010). Elite visions: Privileged perceptions of self and others. Teachers College Record, 12(8), 1971–1992.
31.
HurtadoS. (2003). Preparing college students for a diverse democracy: Final report to the U.S. Department of Education, OERI, Field Initiated Studies Program.Ann Arbor, MI: Center for the Study of Higher and Postsecondary Education.
32.
HurtadoS., DeyE., GurinP., & GurinG. (2003). College environments, diversity, and student learning. In SmartJ. (Ed.), Higher education: Handbook of theory and research (pp. 145–191). Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Kluwer.
33.
JonesL., CastellanosJ., & ColeD. (2002). Examining the ethnic minority student experience at predominantly White institutions: A case study. Journal of Hispanic Higher Education1(1), 19–39.
34.
JonesM., & YonezawaS. (2002). Student voice, cultural change: Using inquiry in school reform. Equity & Excellence in Education, 35(3), 245–254.
35.
JonesS., & AbesE. (2004). Enduring influences of service-learning on college students’ identity development. Journal of College Student Development, 45(2), 149–166.
36.
KeanC., & HallK. (2009). Engaging with difference matters: Longitudinal student outcomes of co-curricular service-learning programs. Journal of Higher Education, 80(1), 59–79.
37.
LechugaV., ClercL., & HowellA. (2009). Power, privilege and learning: Facilitating encountered situations to promote social justice. Journal of College Student Development, 50(2), 229–244.
38.
LiuA., RuizS., DeAngeloL., & PryorJ. (2009). Findings from the 2008 Administration of the College Senior Survey (CSS): National aggregates.Los Angeles, CA: Higher Education Research Institute, UCLA.
39.
MaxwellJ. (1996). Qualitative research design: An interactive approach.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
40.
MayhewM., & EngbergM. (2010). Diversity and moral reasoning: How negative diverse peers interactions affect the development of moral reasoning in undergraduate students. Journal of Higher Education, 81(4), 459–482.
41.
MaykutR., & MorehouseR. (1994). Beginning qualitative research: A philosophic and practical guide. New York, NY: Routledge.
42.
MilesM., & HubermanA. (1999). Qualitative data analysis.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Myers-LiptonS. (1996). Effect of a comprehensive service-learning program on college students’ level of modern racism. Michigan Journal of Community Service Learning, 3(1), 47–54.
45.
Nelson LairdT. F., EngbergM. E., & HurtadoS. (2005). Modeling accentuation effects: Enrolling in a diversity course and the importance of social action engagement. Journal of Higher Education, 76, 448–476.
OsborneR., HammerichS., & HensleyC. (1998). Student effects of service-learning: Tracking change across a semester. Michigan Journal of Community Service Learning, 5, 5–13.
48.
PascarellaE. T., EdisonM., NoraA., HagedornL.S., & TerenziniP. T. (1996). Influences on students’ openness to diversity and challenge in first year of college. Journal of Higher Education, 67, 174–195.
49.
PattonM. (1990). Qualitative evaluation and research methods (2nd ed.) Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
50.
PerryJ. (1996). Measuring public service motivation: An assessment of construct reliability and validity. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 6(1), 5–22.
51.
PerryP. (2008). Creating safe spaces in predominantly White classrooms. In PollockM. (Ed.), Everyday antiracism: Getting real about race in schools (pp. 226–230). New York, NY: New Press.
52.
PewewardyC., & FreyB. (2002). Surveying the landscape: Perceptions of multicultural support services and racial climate at a predominantly White university. Journal of Negro Education, 71(1/2), 77–95.
53.
PhilipsenM. (2003). Race, the college classroom, and service learning: A practitioner's tale. Journal of Negro Education, 72(2), 230–240.
54.
PollockM. (2008). Everyday antiracism: Getting real about race in schools.New York, NY: Free Press.
55.
SaldanaD. (1994). Acculturative stress: Minority status and distress. Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences, 16, 116–128.
56.
SaltmarshJ. (2005). The civic promise of service learning. Liberal Education, 91(2), 50–55.
57.
SchultzK. (2010). After the blackbird whistles: Listening to silences in classrooms. Teachers College Record, 112(11), 8–9.
58.
SeiderS., GillmorS., & RabinowiczS. (2012). The impact of community service learning upon the expected political voice of participating college students. Journal of Adolescent Research, 27(1), 44–77.
59.
SeiderS., RabinowiczS., & GillmorS. (2010). Changing American college students’ conceptions of poverty through community service learning. Analyses of Social Issues & Public Policy, 10(1), 215–236.
60.
SeiderS., RabinowiczS., & GillmorS. (2011). The impact of philosophy and theology service-learning experiences on the public service motivation of participating college students. Journal of Higher Education, 82(5), 597–628.
61.
SingletonG., & HaysC. (2008). Beginning courageous conversations about race. In PollockM. (Ed.), Everyday antiracism: Getting real about race in schools (pp. 18–24). New York, NY: New Press.
62.
VernezG., AbrahamseA., & QuigleyD. (1996). How immigrants fare in U.S. education.Los Angeles, CA: Rand.
63.
WattsR., WilliamsN., & JagersR. (2003). Sociopolitical development. American Journal of Community Psychology, 31, 185–194.
64.
WhittE. J., EdisonM. I., PascarellaE. T., TerenziniP. T., & NoraA. (2001). Influences on students’ openness to diversity and challenge in the second and third years of college. Journal of Higher Education, 72, 172–204.
65.
ZlotkowskiE. (1998). Successful service-learning programs: New models of excellence in higher education. Bolton, MA: Anker.
