Research increasingly suggests that the high school diploma has lost its meaning as a symbol of life preparation. Having faced economic struggles earlier and longer than most regions of the United States, the “Rust Belt” region offers important lessons for the broader nation regarding how high schools might prepare youth for stable futures. Much like in towns in India and China, communities in the United States’ Rust Belt experience a paradox of wanting youth to find successful careers but not leave the area.
Focus of Study
Recent research connections between high school and college have focused on the role of signaling strategies in preparing young people for postsecondary opportunities. High-quality signals that are clear, aligned, and consistent can positively influence student outcomes. This article examines the types of policy signals that local Rust Belt communities are trying to develop to both improve postsecondary attendance of young people and retain young people in their home communities as they choose career pathways.
Research Design
Three cases—”Steeltown,” “Milltown,” and “Railtown”—were chosen using a comparative case study design intended for the purpose of explanation building. Data-collection strategies consisted of a combination of semistructured interviews and document collection to ascertain the visions, intentions, and implementation of the reform efforts of the selected communities. Interview protocols explored the actors, problem definitions, collaborative patterns, and implementation of initiatives. Extensive written documentation from each city that served as validity checks of the interview data. Data analysis involved a grounded theory approach of moving from raw data to conclusions using a data reduction process that involved an extensive coding strategy and case histories.
Findings
The strategies of the three cases suggest that three specific signaling strategies were most often used to address individual and community policy needs in these Pennsylvania communities: achievement, alignment, and awareness. The focus on academic achievement was the most consistent strategy, but weak in terms of providing a connection to postsecondary signaling. Awareness strategies consisted of teaching youth and their families about the growing fields of industry in a local area. Alignment strategies provided a way for youth to see the full pathway to potential careers. They included a focus on creating easier transitions between traditional high school, vocational-technical high schools, community colleges, technical schools, and four-year institutions.
Conclusions
The alignment strategies presented in these cases were not always consistent with the awareness strategies that encouraged youth to stay local in job searches. Alignment strategies therefore often prioritized youth needs over community needs. If alignment efforts are paired with building awareness of local career opportunities, however, they could help to strengthen and rebuild Rust Belt communities. A combined strategy could both increase understanding of careers and provide a pathway to get the training necessary to compete for these available jobs.
BrodyL. E., AssoulineS. G., & StanleyJ. C. (1990). Five years of early entrants: Predicting successful achievement in college. Gifted Child Quarterly, 34, 138–142.
8.
CabreraA. F., BurkumK. R., & LaNasaS. F. (2003, November). Pathways to a four-year degree: Determinants of degree completion among socioeconomically disadvantaged students. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Association for the Study of Higher Education, Portland, OR.
9.
CarnevaleA. P. (2007a). All one system: The promise of O*Net. In HoffmanN., VargasJ., VeneziaA., & MillerM. S. (Eds.), Minding the gap: Why integrating high school with college makes sense and how to do it (pp. 15–26). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
10.
CarnevaleA. P. (2007b). Confessions of an education fundamentalist: Why Grade 12 is not the right end point for anyone. In HoffmanN., VargasJ., VeneziaA., & MillerM.S. (Eds.), Minding the gap: Why integrating high school with college makes sense and how to do it (pp. 86–92). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
11.
ChoyS. (2002). Access & persistence: Findings from 10 years of longitudinal research on students. Informed practice: Syntheses of higher education research for campus leaders.Washington, DC: American Council on Education.
12.
CollinsM. (2007). Postsecondary numerical goals as catalyst for P–16 reform: Texas sends a message. In HoffmanN., VargasJ., VeneziaA., & MillerM.S. (Eds.), Minding the gap: Why integrating high school with college makes sense and how to do it (pp. 221–226). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
13.
ConklinK. D., & SanfordS. (2007). A college ready nation: An idea whose time has come. In HoffmanN., VargasJ., VeneziaA., & MillerM.S. (Eds.). Minding the gap: Why integrating high school with college makes sense and how to do it (pp. 65–72). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
14.
ConleyD. T. (2003). Connecting the dots: Linking high schools and postsecondary education to increase student success. Peer Review, 5(2), 9–12.
15.
ConleyD. T. (2004). Connecting measures for success in high school and college. In KazisR., VargasJ., & HoffmanN. (Eds.), Double the numbers: Increasing postsecondary credentials for underrepresented youth (pp. 139–144). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
16.
CortrightJ. (2005). The young and restless in a knowledge economy. Chicago: CEOs for Cities.
17.
CubanL., & UsdanM. (2002). Powerful reforms with shallow roots: Improving America's urban schools. New York: Teachers College Press.
18.
CunninghamC., & MatthewsR. S. (2007). Lessons from the field: A tale of two early college high schools. In HoffmanN., VargasJ., VeneziaA., & MillerM.S. (Eds.), Minding the gap: Why integrating high school with college makes sense and how to do it (pp. 123–132). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
19.
CunninghamC., & WagonlanderC. (2000). Establishing and sustaining a middle college high school. New Directions for Community Colleges, 111, 41–51.
20.
Deil-AmenR., & RosenbaumJ. E. (2004). Charter-building and labor market contacts in two-year colleges. Sociology of Education, 77, 245–265.
21.
Deil-AmenR., & TurleyR. L. (2008). A review of the transition to college literature in sociology. Teachers College Record, 109, 2324–2366.
22.
FerryN. (2003). Turning points: Adolescents’ and young adults’ reasoning about career choice and future employment. In Retaining and attracting young adults to the Pennsylvania heartland (pp. 8–33). Williamsport, PA: Industrial Modernization Center Pennsylvania.
23.
FloridaR. (2005). The flight of the creative class. New York: Harper Business.
24.
FuhrmanS., & O'DayJ. (Eds.). (1996). Rewards and reform: Creating educational incentives that work.San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
25.
GibbsR. M., & CromartieJ. B. (1994). Rural youth outmigration: How big is the problem and for whom?Rural Development Perspectives, 10, 9–16.
26.
GoldbergerS. (2007). Doing the math: What it means to double the number of low-income college graduates. In HoffmanN., VargasJ., VeneziaA., MillerM.S. (Eds.), Minding the gap: Why integrating high school with college makes sense and how to do it (pp. 27–40). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
27.
GoldinC., & KatzL. (2008). The race between education and technology. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press.
GrayK. C., & HerrE. L. (2000). Other ways to win (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press.
30.
GrobeT. (2007). Another route to college. In HoffmanN., VargasJ., VeneziaA., & MillerM.S. (Eds.), Minding the gap: Why integrating high school with college makes sense and how to do it (pp. 133–138). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
31.
HansenW. L., & StampenJ. O. (2004). Making the nation's investment in student access and success Part I: Refocusing the HEA reauthorization to reflect the priorities of higher education policy analysts and researchers. Madison: Wisconsin Center for the Advancement of Postsecondary Education.
32.
HauptmanA. (2004). Using institutional incentives to improve student performance. In KazisR., VargasJ., & HoffmanN. (Eds.), Double the numbers: Increasing postsecondary credentials for underrepresented youth (pp. 123–134). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
33.
HenryG. T., & RubensteinR. (2002). Paying for grades: Impact of merit-based financial aid on educational quality. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 21(1), 93–109.
34.
HoffmanN. (2004). Challenge, not remediation: The Early College High School Initiative. In KazisR., VargasJ., & HoffmanN. (Eds.), Double the numbers: Increasing postsecondary credentials for underrepresented youth (pp. 213–220). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
35.
HoffmanN. (2007). Using dual enrollment to build a 9–14 system. In HoffmanN., VargasJ., VeneziaA., & MillerM. S. (Eds.), Minding the gap: Why integrating high school with college makes sense and how to do it (pp. 191–202). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
36.
HoffmanN., VargasJ., VeneziaA., & MillerM.S. (Eds.). (2007). Minding the gap: Why integrating high school with college makes sense and how to do it.Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
37.
HowleyC. B., HarmonH. L., & LeopoldG. D. (1996). Rural scholars or bright rednecks? Aspirations for a “sense of place” among rural youth in Appalachia. Journal of Research in Rural Education, 12(3), 150–160.
38.
IngelsS. J., PlantyM., BozickR., & OwingsJ. A. (2005). A profile of the American high school senior in 2004: A first look. Initial results from the first follow-up of the Education Longitudinal Study of 2002.Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics.
39.
JonesS. (2007). Raising expectations for academic achievement. In HoffmanN., VargasJ., VeneziaA., & MillerM. S. (Eds.), Minding the gap: Why integrating high school with college makes sense and how to do it (pp. 73–78). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
40.
KirstM. W., & BraccoK. R. (2004). Bridging the great divide: How the K–12 and postsecondary split hurts students, and what can be done about it. In KirstM. W. & BraccoK. R. (Eds.), From high school to college (pp. 1–30). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
41.
KirstM. W., & UsdanM. D. (2007). The history of the separation of K–12 and postsecondary education. In HoffmanN., VargasJ., VeneziaA., & MillerM. S. (Eds.), Minding the gap: Why integrating high school with college makes sense and how to do it (pp. 55–64). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
42.
KirstM. W., & VeneziaA. (2004a). The case for improving connections between k–12 schools and colleges. In KazisR., VargasJ., & HoffmanN. (Eds.), Double the numbers: Increasing postsecondary credentials for underrepresented youth (pp. 61–72). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
43.
KirstM., & VeneziaA. (Eds.). (2004b). From high school to college: Improving opportunities for success in postsecondary education. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
44.
KirstM. W., VeneziaA., & AntonioA. L. (2004). What have we learned and where do we go next? In KirstM. W. & BraccoK. R. (Eds.), From high school to college: Improving opportunities for success in postsecondary education (pp. 285–319). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
45.
LernerJ. B., & BrandB. (2006). The college ladder: Linking secondary and postsecondary education for success for all students. Washington, DC: American Youth Policy Forum.
46.
LincolnY. S., & GubaE. G. (1985). Naturalistic inquiry.Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
47.
LongB. T., & RileyE. K. (2007). Sending signals to students: The role of early placement testing in improving academic preparation. In HoffmanN., VargasJ., VeneziaA., & MillerM. S. (Eds.), Minding the gap: Why integrating high school with college makes sense and how to do it (pp. 105–112). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
48.
McLaughlinM. W. (1991). The Rand Change Agent study: Ten years later. In OddenA. R. (Ed.), The evolution of education policy implementation (pp. 143–156). Albany: State University of New York Press.
49.
McLaughlinM. W., & TalbertJ. E. (2001). High school teaching in context. Chicago: University of Chicago.
50.
MeadeT., & HoffmanE. (2007). CUNY College Now: Extending the reach of dual enrollment. In HoffmanN., VargasJ., VeneziaA., & MillerM. S. (Eds.), Minding the gap: Why integrating high school with college makes sense and how to do it (pp. 143–150). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
51.
MilesM. B., & HubermanA. M. (1994). Qualitative data analysis. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
52.
MitraD. L., & FrickW. F. (2010). Civic capacity in educational reform efforts: Finding agency in a time of globalization. Manuscript submitted for publication.
53.
MitraD. L., FrickW. C., & MovitM. A. (2008). Brain drain in the Rust Belt: Can educational reform help to build civic capacity in struggling communities?Educational Policy, 22, 731–757.
54.
PersonA. E., RosenbaumJ. E., & Deil-AmenR. (2006). Student planning and information problems in different college structures. Teachers College Record, 108, 374–396.
55.
RosenbaumJ. E. (2001). Beyond college for all: Career paths for the forgotten half. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
56.
SchwartzR. B. (2004). Multiple pathways—and how to get there. In KazisR., VargasJ., & HoffmanN. (Eds.), Double the numbers: Increasing postsecondary credentials for underrepre-sented youth (pp. 21–34). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
57.
ShillenJ. K. (2003). Preservation of human capital: The importance of retaining young adults. In Retaining and attracting young adults to the Pennsylvania heartland (pp. 79–90). Williamsport, PA: Industrial Modernization Center Pennsylvania.
58.
SpenceD. S. (2007, January 4). A road map to college and career readiness. Education Week, p. 59.
59.
StakeR. E. (1995). The art of case study research.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
60.
SteinbergA., & AlmeidaC. A. (2008). Raising graduation rates in an era of high standards: Five commitments for state action. White paper prepared for Staying the Course: High Standards and Improved Graduation Rates, Jobs for the Future, Boston, MA.
61.
StraussA., & CorbinJ. (1990). Basics of qualitative research: Grounded theory procedures and techniques. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
62.
StoneC., HenigJ., JonesB., & PierannunziC. (2001). Building civic capacity: The politics of reforming urban schools. Lawrence: University Press of Kansas.
63.
StoneD. (1998). Policy paradox: The art of political decision making. New York: W. W. Norton.
64.
TellC., & CohenM. (2007). Alignment of high school expectations to college and work. In HoffmanN., VargasJ., VeneziaA., & MillerM.S. (Eds.), Minding the gap: Why integrating high school with college makes sense and how to do it (pp. 81–86). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
65.
TierneyW. G., CorwinZ. B, & ColyarJ. E. (Eds.). (2005). Preparing for college: Nine elements of effective outreach. Albany: State University of New York Press.
VargasJ. (2004). Dual enrollment: Lessons from Washington and Texas. In KazisR., VargasJ., & HoffmanN. (Eds.), Double the numbers: Increasing postsecondary credentials for underrepresented youth (pp. 205–212). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
68.
VeneziaA., FinneyJ., & CallanP. M. (2007). Common ground. In HoffmanN., VargasJ., VeneziaA., & MillerM. S. (Eds.), Minding the gap: Why integrating high school with college makes sense and how to do it (pp. 45–54). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
69.
YinR. (1994). Case study research: Design and methods (2nd ed.). Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
