Over the past half-century, the courts have played an increasingly important role in educational governance and decision-making. However, since the courts began to take such an active role in education, the efficacy and effectiveness of judicial intervention in education remain uncertain. Largely in response to problems that they have persistently faced in education litigation in the past, courts ruling in several recent school finance reform cases have begun to experiment with new types of remedial orders requiring the implementation of particular educational programs or systems of governance. Free preschool for students constitutes the most common of these educational programs recently ordered by courts.
Purpose/Objective/Research Question/Focus of Study
This study examines and analyzes the trend of courts to experiment with new remedial orders requiring the implementation of particular educational programs or systems of governance by analyzing the judicial consideration of preschool programs in two major school finance cases in New Jersey and North Carolina.
Research Design
This study frames its analysis in the legal literature examining the courts’ role in educational policy, the particular legal and historical contexts of school finance reform litigation, and the educational research evaluating the effectiveness of preschool. Using historical case study analysis and methods more traditionally associated with legal analysis, this study analyzes the opportunities and pitfalls of the preschool remedy and the implications for the imposition of other like remedies.
Conclusions
This study concludes that, although the preschool remedy is well designed to respond to some major problems that courts have persistently faced in school finance reform litigation, courts have considered the preschool remedy inconsistently and in an oversimplified fashion that does not reflect nuances in the underlying research on preschool. Moving forward, courts need to find a middle route that allows them to respond to problems they have faced in the past while treating scientific research in a more nuanced fashion.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abbeville County School District v. State, No. 31-0169 (S.C. Ct. Comm. Pl. 2005).
2.
Abbott v. Burke, 575 A.2d 359 (N.J. 1990) (Abbott II).
3.
Abbott v. Burke, 693 A.2d 417 (N.J. 1997) (Abbott IV).
4.
Abbott v. Burke, 710 A.2d 450 (N.J. 1998) (Abbott V).
5.
Abbott v. Burke, 748 A.2d 82 (N.J. 2000) (Abbott VI).
6.
AckermanD. J., BarnettW. S., & RobinK. B. (2005). Making the most of kindergarten: Present trends and future issues in the provision of full-day programs.New Brunswick, NJ: National Institute for Early Education Research, Rutgers University.
7.
AlmeidaT. (2004). Refocusing school finance litigation on at-risk children: Leandro v. State of North Carolina.Yale Law and Policy Review, 22, 525–569.
8.
BarnettW. S. (1995). Long-term effects of early childhood programs on cognitive and school outcomes.Future of Children, 5(3), 25–50.
9.
BarnettW. S., HustedtJ. T., RobinK. B., & SchulmanK. (2005). The state of preschool.New Brunswick: NJ: National Institute for Early Education Research.
10.
Brown v. Board of Education, 347 U.S. 483 (1954).
11.
Campaign for Fiscal Equity, Inc. v. State of New York, 719 N.Y.S.2d 475 (Sup. Ct. 2001).
12.
Campaign for Fiscal Equity, Inc. v. State of New York, 801 N.E.2d 326 (N.Y. 2003).
13.
Campbell County School District v. State of Wyoming, 907 P.2d 1238 (Wyo. 1998).
14.
CardiffC. F., & StringhamE. (2006). Is universal preschool beneficial? An assessment of RAND Corporation's analysis and proposals for California.Washington, DC: Reason Foundation.
15.
Carolina Abecedarian Project. (2000). Early learning, later success: The Abecedarian study.Chapel Hill, NC: Child Development Institute.
16.
ChayesA. (1976). The role of the judge in public law litigation.Harvard Law Review, 89, 1281–1316.
17.
CheslerM. A., SandersJ., & KalmussD. S. (1988). Social science in court: Mobilizing experts in the school desegregation cases.Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
18.
ChristinaR., & Nicholson-GoodmanJ. (2005). Going to scale with high-quality early education: Choices and consequences in universal pre-kindergarten efforts.Santa Monica, CA: RAND.
19.
Claremont School District v. Governor, 635 A.2d 1375 (N.H. 1993).
20.
Claremont School District v. Governor, 794 A.2d 744 (N.H. 2002).
21.
Coalition for Adequacy and Fairness in School Funding, Inc. v. Childes, 680 So.2d 400 (1996).
22.
CohenD. K., RaudenbushS. W., & BallD. L. (2003). Resources, instruction, and research.Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 25, 119–142.
23.
ColemanJ., CampbellE. Q., HobsonC. J., McPartlandJ., MoodA. M., WeinfeldF. D.. (1966). Equality of educational opportunity survey.Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
24.
Columbia Falls Elementary School District Number 6 v. State of Montana, 2004 WL 844055 (Mont. Dist. 2004).
25.
Committee for Educational Rights v. Edgar, 672 N.E.2d 1178 (1996).
26.
CurrieJ. (2000). Early childhood intervention programs: What do we know.Los Angeles: UCLA.
27.
Danson v. Casey, 299 A.2d 360 (Pa.1979).
28.
DeRolph v. State, 677 N.E.2d 733 (Ohio1997).
29.
DeRolph v. State, 728 N.E.2d 993 (Ohio2000).
30.
DeRolph v. State, 780 N.E.2d 529 (Ohio2004).
31.
EhrlichE., & KornblattT. (2004). Developmental education: The value of high quality preschool investments as economic tools.Washington, DC: Committee for Economic Development.
32.
EisenbergT., & YeazellR. C. (1980). The ordinary and the extraordinary in institutional litigation.Harvard Law Review, 93, 465–517.
33.
EnrichP. (1995). Leaving equality behind: New directions in school finance reform.Vanderbilt Law Review, 48, 101–194.
34.
FordR. T. (2004). Brown's ghost.Harvard Law Review, 117, 1305–1333.
35.
General Accounting Office. (1997). Head Start: Research provides little information on impact of current program.Washington, DC: General Accounting Office.
36.
General Accounting Office. (1998). School finance: State efforts to equalize funding between wealthy and poor school districts.Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
37.
GlazerN. (1975). Toward an imperial judiciary.The Public Interest, 41, 104–123.
38.
GreifA. (2004). Politics, practicalities, and priorities: New Jersey's experience implementing the Abbott V mandate.Yale Law and Policy Review, 22, 615–656.
39.
GriffithM. (2005). School finance litigation and beyond. Retrieved August 1, 2006, from Education Commission of the States Web site: http://www.ecs.org/clearinghouse/60/26/6026.htm Hancock v. Driscoll, 2004 WL 877984 (Mass. Super. 2004).
40.
Hancock v. Driscoll, 822 N.E.2d 1134 (Mass. 2005).
41.
HanushekE. A. (1989). The impact of differential expenditures on school performance.Educational Researcher, 18(4), 45–65.
42.
HeiseM. (2002). The courts, educational policy, and unintended consequences.Cornell Journal of Law and Public Policy, 11, 636–663.
43.
HeiseM. (2004). Litigated learning and the limits of law.Vanderbilt Law Review, 57, 2417–2461.
44.
Hoke County Board of Education v. State, 95 CVS 1158 (N.C. Super. Ct., Oct. 12, 2000) (Hoke County I).
45.
Hoke County Board of Education v. State, 95 CVS 1158 (N.C. Super. Ct., Oct. 26, 2000) (Hoke County II).
46.
Hoke County Board of Education v. State, 95 CVS 1158 (N.C. Super. Ct., Apr. 4, 2002) (Hoke County IV).
47.
Hoke County Board of Education v. State of North Carolina, 599 S.E.2d 365 (N.C. 2004).
48.
JaffeM., & KerschK. (1991). Guaranteeing a state right to a quality education: The judicial-political dialogue in New Jersey.Journal of Law and Education, 20, 271–300.
49.
JoondephB. W. (1995). The good, the bad and the ugly: An empirical analysis of litigation prompted school finance reform.Santa Clara Law Review, 35, 763–824.
50.
KarolyL. A., & BigelowJ. H. (2005). The economics of investing in universal preschool education in California.Santa Monica, CA: RAND.
51.
KarolyL. A., GreenwoodP. W., EveringhamS. S., HoubeJ., KilburnM. R., RydellP. C.. (1998). Investing in our children: What we know and don't know about the benefits of early childhood interventions.Santa Monica, CA: RAND.
52.
KarweitN. L. (1989). Effective preschool programs for students at risk. In SlavinR. E., KarweitN. L., & MaddenN. A. (Eds.), Effective programs for students at risk (pp. 75–102). Needham Heights, MA: Allyn and Bacon.
53.
KaufmanM. (2005). Rhetorical questions concerning justice and equality in educational opportunities.Loyola University of Chicago Law Journal, 36, 495–511.
54.
KingM. P. (1998). Abbott v. Burke: Report and decision of Remand Court, printed in Abbott v. Burke, 710 A.2d 450 (N.J. 1998) (Abbott V).
55.
KoskiW. S. (2003). Of fuzzy standards and institutional constraints: A re-examination of the jurisprudential history of educational finance reform litigation.Santa Clara Law Review, 43, 1185–1298.
56.
Lake View School District No. 25 v. Huckabee, 91 S.E.3d 472 (Ark. 2002).
57.
Lake View School District v. Huckabee 2005 WL 3436660 (Ark. 2005).
58.
Leandro v. State, 488 S.E.2d 249 (N.C. 1997).
59.
LeeV. E., & LoebS. (1995). Where do Head Start attendees end up? One reason why preschool effects fade out.Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 17(1), 62–82.
60.
LevineG. F. (1991). Meeting the third wave: Legislative approaches to recent judicial school finance rulings.Harvard Journal on Legislation, 28, 507–542.
61.
Levittown Union Free School District v. Nyquist, 439 N.E.2d 359 (N.Y. 1982).
62.
MagnusonK. A., MeyersM. K., RuhmC. J., & WaldfogelJ. (2004). Inequality in preschool education and school readiness.American Educational Research Journal, 41, 115–157.
63.
MagnusonK., MeyersM. K., RuhmC. J., & WaldfogelJ. (2005). Inequality in children's school readiness and public funding.Focus, 24(1), 12–18.
64.
ManningH. (1998, October 28). Order in Hoke County Board of Education v. State, 95 CVS 1158.
65.
MayrowetzD., & LaphamJ. F. (2008). “But we're in a court of law. We're not in a legislature.” The promise and pitfalls of educational policy reform through the judicial branch. Educational Policy, 22(3), 379–421.
66.
McDaniel v. Thomas, 285 S.E.2d 156 (Ga. 1981).
67.
McDermottK. A. (2006). “Expanding the moral community” or “blaming the victim”? The politics of state education accountability policy.American Educational Research Journal, 44, 77–111.
68.
McDuffy v. Secretary of the Executive Office of Education, 615 N.E.2d 516 (Mass. 1993).
69.
McUsicM. S. (1999). The law's role in the distribution of education: The promises and pitfalls of school finance litigation. In HeubertJ. P. (Ed.), Law and school reform (pp. 88–159). New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
70.
MontieJ. E., XiangZ., & SchweinhartL. J. (2006). Preschool experience in 10 countries: Cognitive and language performance at age 7.Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 21, 313–331.
71.
Montoy v. State of Kansas 2004 WL 1094555 (D. Kan. 2004).
72.
MulliganG. M., BrimhallD., WestJ., & ChapmanC. (2005). Child care and early education arrangements of infants, toddlers, and preschoolers: 2001. Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics.
73.
MurrayM. D., & DeSanctisC. H. (2006). Legal research methods.New York: Foundation Press.
74.
National Institute of Childhood and Human Health Development Early Child Care Research Network. (2002). Early child care and children's development prior to school entry: Results from the NICHD study of early child care.American Educational Research Journal, 39, 133–164.
75.
National Institute of Child Health and Human Development Early Child Care Research Network. (2004). Multiple pathways to early academic achievement.Harvard Educational Review, 74(1), 1–28.
76.
National Institute of Childhood and Human Health Development Early Child Care Research Network. (2005). Early child care and children's development in the primary grades: Follow-up results from the NICHD study of early child care.American Educational Research Journal, 42, 537–570.
77.
National Research Council. (1998). Preventing reading difficulties in young children.Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
78.
National Research Council. (2001). Eager to learn.Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
79.
N.J.A.C.6: 19A-3.3(b) (1999).
80.
New Jersey Department of Education. (2005). Self-Assessment Validation System (SAVS) 2004–2005: Preliminary report on statewide progress in Abbott preschool program implementation:Trenton: New Jersey Department of Education, Office of Early Childhood Education.
81.
OddenA. (1997). Recommendations for resolving New Jersey Abbott v. Burke IV, after the November and December 1997 Hearings, December 30, 1997, printed in Abbott v. Burke, 710 A.2d 450 (N.J. 1998), pp. 527–541.
82.
OgletreeC. J. (2004). All deliberate speed: reflections on the first half century of Brown v. Board of Education.New York: W. W. Norton.
83.
OlsenD. A. (1999). Universal preschool is no golden ticket.Washington, DC:Cato Institute.
84.
Olsen v. State, 55 P.2d 139 (Or. 1976).
85.
RebellM. A., & BlockA. R. (1982). Educational policy making and the courts: An empirical study of judicial activism.Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
86.
RebellM. A., & HughesR. L. (1997). Efficacy and engagement: The remedies problem posed by Sheff v. O'Neill.Connecticut Law Review, 29, 1115–1186.
87.
ReedD. R. (2001). On equal terms: The constitutional politics of educational opportunity.Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
88.
Robinson v. Cahill, 303 A.2d 273 (N.J. 1973).
89.
Rose v. Council for Better Education, 790 S.W.2d 186 (Ky. 1989).
90.
RosenbergG. N. (1991). The hollow hope: Can courts bring about social change?Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
91.
RyanJ. (2006). A constitutional right to preschool?California Law Review, 94, 49–99.
92.
San Antonio Independent School District v. Rodriguez, 411 U.S. 1 (1973).
93.
ShonkoffJ. P., & PhillipsD. A. (2000). From neurons to neighborhoods: The science of early childhood development.Santa Monica, CA: RAND.
94.
SkocpolT. (1984). Sociology's historical imagination. In SkocpolT. (Ed.), Vision and method in historical sociology (pp. 1–21). New York: Cambridge University Press.
95.
SlavinR. E. (Ed.). (1994). Preventing early school failure: Implications for policy and practice.Needham Heights, MA: Allyn and Bacon.
96.
SturmS. P. (1991). A normative theory of public law remedies.Georgetown Law Journal, 79, 1357–1446.
97.
TyackD., & BenavotA. (1985). Courts and public schools: Educational litigation in historical perspective.Law and Society Review, 19, 339–380.
98.
UnderwoodJ. (1995). School finance adequacy as vertical equity.University of Michigan Journal of Law Reform, 28, 493–519.
99.
WelnerK. G., & KupermintzH. (2004). Rethinking expert testimony in education rights litigation.Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 26, 127–142.
100.
ZiglerE., WaltersG. S., & JonesS. M. (2006). A vision for universal preschool education.New York: Cambridge University Press.
101.
ZillN., CollinsM., WestJ. & HauskenE. G. (1995). Approaching kindergarten: A look at preschoolers in the United States.Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics.
