Our research examines the relationship between teachers’ unions, teacher compensation, employment conditions, and turnover in Southern US states that prohibit the collective bargaining of public school teachers. We assess union strength by meet-and-confer status and the teacher union density of districts and estimate union impact using propensity score matching. We find that teachers’ unions are positively associated with teacher compensation and employment conditions, even in the absence of collective bargaining. Districts with strong unions have higher dismissals of nontenured teachers for poor performance and a lower attrition rate of qualified teachers, compared to districts with weak unions. This study shows that teachers’ unions in the United States still organize without formal labor-management institutions and make a significant impact on teachers’ work lives, even in a hostile legal environment toward unions.
BarlingJulianFullagarCliveKellowayKevin. 1992. The Union and Its Members: A Psychological Approach. New York: Oxford University Press.
4.
BattRosemaryColvinAlexanderKeefeJeffrey. 2002. “Employee Voice, Human Resource Practices, and Quit Rates: Evidence from the Telecommunications Industry.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review55: 573-94.
5.
BaughWilliam H.StoneJoe A.. 1982. “Teachers, Unions, and Wages in the 1970s: Unionism Now Pays.” Industrial & Labor Relations Review35 (3): 368-76.
6.
BiaMichelaMatteiAlessandra. 2008. “A Stata Package for the Estimation of the Dose–Response Function Through Adjustment for the Generalized Propensity Score.” The Stata Journal: Promoting Communications on Statistics and Stata8 (3): 354-73.
7.
BridgesEdwin M. 1986. The Incompetent Teacher: The Challenge and the Response. Philadelphia: The Falmer Press.
8.
BrunnerEricHymanJoshuaJuAndrew. 2020. “School Finance Reforms, Teachers’ Unions, and the Allocation of School Resources.” The Review of Economics and Statistics102 (3): 473-89.
9.
BrunnerEricImazekiJennifer. 2010. “Probation Length and Teacher Salaries: Does Waiting Pay Off?” Industrial And Labor Relations Review64 (1): 164-80.
10.
BrunnerEricSquiresTim. 2013. “The Bargaining Power of Teachers’ Unions and the Allocation of School Resources.” Journal of Urban Economics76: 15-27.
11.
ColeStephen. 1969. The Unionization of Teachers: A Case Study of the UFT. New York: Praeger Publishers.
12.
CookJasonLavertuStéphaneMillerCorbin. 2021. “Rent-Seeking Through Collective Bargaining: Teachers Unions and Education Production.” Economics of Education Review85: 102193. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econedurev.2021.102193
13.
DelaneyJohn T.1985. “Unionism, Bargaining Spillovers, and Teacher Compensation.” In Advances in Industrial Relations, vol. 2, edited by LipskyDavid B., 111-42. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
14.
DemsetzRebecca S.1993. “Voting Behavior in Union Representation Elections: The Influence of Skill Homogeneity and Skill Group Size.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review47: 99-113.
15.
EbertsRandall W.StoneJoe A.. 1987. “Teachers Unions and the Productivity of Public Schools.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review40: 354-63.
16.
FingerLeslie K.2018b. “Interest Group Influence and the Two Faces of Power.” American Politics Research47 (4): 852-86.
17.
FingerLeslie K.2018a. “Vested Interests and the Diffusion of Education Reform Across The States.” Policy Studies Journal46: 378-401.
18.
FrandsenBrigham R.2016. “The Effects of CB Rights on Public Employee Compensation: Evidence from Teachers, Fire Fighters, and Police.” Industrial & Labor Relations Review69 (1): 84-112.
19.
FreemanRichard B.1980. “The Exit-Voice Tradeoff in the Labor Market: Unionism, Job Tenure, Quits, and Separations.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics94 (4): 643-73.
20.
FreemanRichard B.1984. “Longitudinal Analyses of the Effects of Trade Unions.” Journal of Labor Economics2 (1): 1-26.
21.
FreemanRichard B.1985. “Unions, Pensions, and Union Pension Funds.” In Pensions, Labor, and Individual Choice, edited by WiseDavid A., 89-121. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
22.
FreemanRichard B.HanEunice S.. 2013. “Public Sector Unionism Without Collective Bargaining.” Paper presented at the American Economic Association (AEA) Annual Meeting, San Diego, CA, January 6, 2013. Cited in the Council of Economic Advisers Issue Brief. October 2015. http://www.aeaweb.org/aea/2013conference/program/retrieve.php?pdfid=326.
23.
FreemanRichard B.MedoffJames L.. 1984. What Do Unions Do?New York: Basic Books.
24.
GoodladJohn I. 1984. A Place Called School. Prospects for the Future. St. Louis: McGraw-Hill.
HanEunice S.2019. “The Impact of Teachers Unions on Teachers’ Well-Being Under Different Legal Institutions: Evidence from District-Teacher Matched Data.” AERA Open5 (3): 233285841986729. https://doi.org/10.1177/2332858419867291.
27.
HanEunice S.2020. “The Myth of Unions’ Overprotection of Bad Teachers: Evidence from District-Teacher Matched Panel Data on Teacher Turnover.” Industrial Relations59 (2): 316-52. https://doi.org/10.1111/irel.12256.
28.
HanEunice S.KeefeJeffrey. 2020. “Teachers’ Unions: Engaging Teachers and Improving Student Achievement in States That Prohibit Collective Bargaining.” Educational Policy36 (2): 407-39. https://doi.org/10.1177/0895904820901476.
29.
HanEunice S.KeefeJeffrey. 2021. “Candidates for Free Riding in a Post Agency Shop Public Sector.” In Advances in Industrial and Labor Relations, edited by LewinDavidGollanPaul J.. Vol. 26, 39-72. UK: Emerald Publishing Limited.
30.
HartneyMichaelFlavinPatrick. 2011. “From the Schoolhouse to the Statehouse: Teacher Union Political Activism and U.S. State Education Reform Policy.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly11: 251-68.
31.
HiranoKeisukeGuido WImbens,. 2004. The propensity score with continuous treatments. In Applied Bayesian Modeling and Causal Inference from Incomplete-Data Perspectives, edited by A. Gelman and X.-L. Meng, 73-84.West Sussex, England: Wiley. InterScience.
32.
HirschBarry T.MacphersonDavid A.DuMondJ. Michael. 1997. “Workers’ Compensation Recipiency in Union and Nonunion Workplaces.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review50 (2): 213-36.
33.
HirschBarry T.MacphersonDavid A.WintersJon V.. 2011. “Teacher Salaries, State CB Laws, and Union Coverage.” Paper presented at Association for Education Finance and Policy (AEFP) Meetings, Seattle.
HoxbyCaroline M. 1996. “How Teachers’ Unions Affect Education Production.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics111 (3): 671-718.
36.
ImazekiJennifer. 2005. “Teacher Salaries and Teacher Attrition.” Economics of Education Review24: 431-49.
37.
IngersollRichard. 2001. “Teacher Turnover and Teacher Shortages: An Organizational Analysis.” American Educational Research Journal38 (3): 499-534.
38.
KeefeJeffrey. 2018. “Pennsylvania’s Teachers Are Undercompensated – and New Pension Legislation Will Cut Their Compensation Even More.” Economic Policy Institute, Washington, DC. Available at epi.org/138380.
39.
LindyBenjamin A. 2011. “The Impact of Teacher CB Laws on Student Achievement: Evidence from a New Mexico Natural Experiment.” Yale Law Journal120 (5): 1130-91.
40.
LovenheimMichael F. 2009. “The Effect of Teachers’ Unions on Education Production: Evidence from Union Election Certifications in Three Midwestern States.” Journal of Labor Economics27 (4): 525-87.
41.
MariannoBradley D.2019. “Compared to What? Changes in Interest Group Resources and the Proposal and Adoption of State Teacher Policy.” Policy Studies Journal48 (4): 982-1022. Online Publication. https://doi.org/10.1111/psj.12345.
42.
MariannoBradley D.BrunoPaulStrunkKathrine O.. 2021. “The Effect of Teachers’ Union Contracts on School District Efficiency: Longitudinal Evidence From California.” SAGE Open11 (1): 215824402098868. https://doi.org/10.1177/2158244020988684.
43.
MerkleJessica S.PhillipsMichelle Andrea. 2018. “The Wage Impact of Teachers Unions: A Meta-Analysis.” Contemporary Economic Policy36 (1): 93-115.
44.
MoeTerry M.2011. Special Interest. Washington D.C: Brookings Institution Press.
45.
MuellerCharlesPriceJames. 1990. “Economic, Psychological and Sociological Determinants of Voluntary Turnover.” Journal of Behavioral Economics19: 321-35.
46.
MurnaneRichard J.OlsonRandy J.. 1990. “The Effects of Salaries and Opportunity Costs on the Length of Stay in Teaching.” The Journal of Human Resources25 (1): 106-24.
47.
PaglayanAgustina S.2019. “Public-Sector Unions and the Size of Government.” American Journal of Political Science63 (1): 21-36.
48.
PodgurskyMichael J.2003. “Fringe Benefits: There is More to Compensation Than a Teacher’s Salary.” Education Next3 (3): 71-6.
RoseHeatherSonstelieJon. 2010. “School Board Politics, School District Size, and the Bargaining Power of Teachers’ Unions.” Journal of Urban Economics67 (3): 438-50.
51.
RosenbaumPaul R.2002. Observational Studies. New York: Springer.
52.
RosenbaumPaul R.RubinD. B.. 1985. “Constructing a Comparison Group Using Multivariate Matched Sampling Methods That Incorporate the Propensity Score.” The American Statistician39: 33-8.
RosenfeldJake. 2010. “Economic Determinants of Voting in an Era of Union Decline.” Social Science Quarterly91: 379-95.
55.
RosenholtzSusan. 1989. Teacher’s Workplace: The Social Organization of Schools. New York: Longman.
56.
SteerRichard M.MowdayRichard. 1981. “Employee Turnover and the Post-Decision Accommodation Process.” In Research in Organizational Behavior, edited by ShawB. M.CummingsL. L.. 235-281. Greenwich: JAI Press.
57.
StoddardChristiana. 2005. “Adjusting Teacher Salaries for the Cost of Living: The Effect on Salary Comparisons and Policy Conclusions.” Economics of Education Review24: 323-39.
58.
TaylorLori L.FowlerWilliam J.. 2006. “A Comparable Wage Approach to Geographic Cost Adjustment.” Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics.
59.
TheobaldNeil. 1990. “An Examination of the Influence of Personal, Professional, and School District Characteristics on Public School Teacher Retention.” Economics of Education Review9: 241-50.
60.
WestKristine L.2015. “Teachers’ Unions, Compensation, and Tenure.” Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society54 (2): 294-320.
61.
WintersJohn V.2011. “Teacher Salaries and Teacher Unions: A Spatial Econometric Approach.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review64 (4): 747-64.
62.
ZigarelliMichael. 1996. “Bargaining Law Provisions and Teacher Bargaining Outcomes.” Journal of Labor Research17 (1): 135-48.
63.
ZwerlingHarris L.ThomasonTerry. 1995. “CB and the Determinants of Teachers’ Salaries.” Journal of Labor Research16 (4): 467-84.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
