This paper examines media coverage of sports labor issues from a political economic perspective by analyzing New York Times coverage of the 2011 National Football League lockout. We find that sports labor issues are framed in a manner consistent with findings by scholars such as Martin (2004), Schmidt (1993), and McChesney (2008). In particular, the media cover labor from a consumer-based perspective, simplify the conflict between players and owners as being disagreements between “millionaires and billionaires,” and focus more on offers made by owners to players than on owner demands. Other expected findings, such as media denigration of player labor and a general focus on player finances rather than owner finances, were not evident.
BattistaJudy. 2011g. N.F.L. and players union extend deadline. New York Times, March4, 10.
9.
BattistaJudy. 2011h. Openness of owners on finances could be key in talks. New York Times, March8, 13.
10.
BattistaJudy. 2011i. Sides seeking leverage before deadline in N.F.L. New York Times, February27, SP1.
11.
BattistaJudy. 2011j. Union rejects N.F.L.’s offer to share more financial data. New York Times, March9, 11.
12.
BattistaJudy. 2011k. With N.F.L. deal in sight, each side can claim gains. New York Times, July20, B13.
13.
BattistaJudy. 2011l. With stakes high, N.F.L. relies on a star lawyer. New York Times, April4, D2.
14.
BeckHoward. 2011. Two lockouts, each with a different playbook. New York Times, July10, SP8.
15.
BettigRonald V.2002. The Frankfurt School and the political economy of communication. In Rethinking the Frankfurt School: Alternative legacies of cultural critique, edited by NealonJeffrey T.IrrCaren, 81–96. Albany: State University of New York Press.
16.
BishopGreg. 2011. Jets players are locked out but keep working out. New York Times, April21, B12.
17.
BrunoRobert. 2008. Evidence of bias in the Chicago Tribune coverage of organized labor. Labor Studies Journal34:385–407.
CarrollCraig E.McCombsMaxwell. 2003. Agenda-setting effects of business news on the public’s images and opinions about major corporations. Corporate Reputation Review6 (1): 36–46.
20.
CoatesDennisHumphreysBrad R.2001. The economic consequences of professional sports strikes and lockouts. Southern Economic Journal67 (3): 737–47.
21.
CraggsTommy. 2011. David Stern V. Roger Goodell. New York Times, March27, MM19.
22.
CraneAgnes T.GoldfarbJeffrey. 2011. The aftershocks in U.S. treasuries. New York Times, March15, B2.
23.
CroteauDavid R.HoynesWilliam D.2006. The business of media: Corporate media and the public interest. 2nd ed.Thousand Oaks, CA: Pine Forge Press.
FortunatoJohn A.2000. Public relations strategies for creating mass media content: A case study of the National Basketball Association. Public Relations Review26 (4): 481–97.
29.
FreemanRichard B.HanEunice. 2012. The war against public sector collective bargaining in the US. Journal of Industrial Relations54 (3): 386–408.
SmytheDallas W.1977. Communications: Blindspot of Western Marxism. Canadian Journal of Political and Social Theory1 (3): 1–27.
54.
SteuterErin. 1999. The Irvings cover themselves: Media representations of the Irving Oil Refinery strike, 1994–1996. Canadian Journal of Communication24:629–47.
55.
StoldtG. ClaytonSmetanaGale K.MillerLori K.2000. Changes in USA Today’s sports coverage patterns during the National Basketball Association lockout: Implications for sport managers. Sport Marketing Quarterly9 (3): 124–30.
56.
SullivanPaul. 2011. In pro athletes’ finances, a defensive line pays. New York Times, March5, B5.
57.
TamariJonathan. 2011. Key issues in NFL labor dispute. Philadelphia Inquirer, February3, E03.
58.
TanierMike. 2011a. Football on the fringe. New York Times, June28, B11.
59.
TanierMike. 2011b. Players have plenty to say, in short bursts. New York Times, March13, SP2.
60.
TellemArn. 2011. When a players union doesn’t help the players. New York Times, May8, SP9.
61.
WinseckDwayne. 2010. Financialization and the “crisis of the media”: The rise and fall of (some) media conglomerates in Canada. Canadian Journal of Communication35:365–93.
62.
WiseMike. 1998. NBC may face boycott by players after lockout. New York Times, October30, D1.
63.
ZinserLynn. 2011a. Big news at the ballpark. New York Times, May3, Sports Desk sec.
64.
ZinserLynn. 2011b. Divided over $9 billion. New York Times, March5, Sports Desk sec.
65.
ZinserLynn. 2011c. Lockout becomes part of playbook. New York Times, March12, 1.
66.
ZinserLynn. 2011d. N.F.L. commissioner takes some hits. New York Times, April29, Sports Desk sec.
67.
ZinserLynn. 2011e. An N.F.L. schedule with a catch. New York Times, April21, Sports Desk sec.
68.
ZinserLynn. 2011f. The N.H.L. shrugs. New York Times, March12, Sports Desk sec.
69.
ZinserLynn. 2011g. Pass the Heat a tissue. New York Times, March8, Sports Desk sec.
70.
ZinserLynn. 2011h. Score one for the players. New York Times, March3, Sports Desk sec.
71.
ZinserLynn. 2011i. Waiting for a deal. New York Times, July20, Sports Desk sec.
72.
ZinserLynn. 2011j. N.F.L. owners’ vote puts pressure on players. New York Times, July22, Sports Desk sec.
