Drawing on survey results from three British trade unions, this paper examines why members leave trade unions. In this study, as anticipated, a great many members left their unions because of some change to their employment circumstances (they were made redundant, they changed employers, or they retired). A significant proportion left because they were dissatisfied with some aspect of union organization. The paper also demonstrates that the proportion of members leaving because of dissatisfaction varied according to a range of factors, including union "type" and sector of organization. The research implies that if unions are to reverse membership decline and promote retention, they must address a range of issues in addition to introducing new means of organizing and recruitment.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Ackers, Peter, and Jonathan Payne.1998. British trade unions and social partnership: Rhetoric, reality and strategy. The International Journal of Human Resource Management9, no. 3:529-550.
2.
Barker, Allan, Paul Lewis, and Michael McCann.1984. Trade unions and the organization of the unemployed. British Journal of Industrial Relations22, no. 3:391-404.
3.
Brown, William.2000. Putting partnership into practice. British Journal of Industrial Relations38, no. 2:299-316.
4.
Brown, William, Simon Deakin, David Nash, and Sarah Oxenbridge.2000. The employment contract: From collective procedures to individual rights. British Journal of Industrial Relations38, no. 4:611-630.
5.
Cully, Mark, Stephen Woodland, Andrew O'Reilly, and Gill Dix.1999. Britain at work: As depicted by the 1998 workplace employee relations survey. London: Routledge.
6.
de Turberville, Simon.2004. Does the "organizing model" represent a credible union renewal strategy?Work, Employment and Society18, no. 4:775-794.
7.
Diamond, Wayne, and Richard Freeman .2001. What workers want from workplace organizations. TUC Report. London: Trades Union Congress.
8.
Fiorito, Jack, Daniel Gallagher, and Cynthia Fukami.1988. Satisfaction with union representation. Industrial and Labor Relations Review41, no. 2:294-307.
9.
Gallie, Duncan.1996. Trade union allegiance and decline in British urban labour markets. In Trade unionism in recession, edited by Duncan Gallie, Roger Penn, and Michael Rose.Oxford: Oxford University Press.
10.
Heery, Edmund.2002. Partnership versus organising: Alternative futures for British trade unionism. Industrial Relations Journal33, no. 1:20-35.
11.
Heery, Edmund, Melanie Simms, Rick Delbridge, John Salmon, and Dave Simpson.2000. Union organizing in Britain: A survey of policy and practice. International Journal of Human Resource Management11, no. 5:986-1007.
12.
Jarley, Paul.2005. Unions as social capital: Renewal through a return to the logic of mutual aid? Journal of LaborStudies29, No. 1:1-26.
13.
Jørgensen, Henning, Morten Lassen, Jens Lind, and Morten Madsen.1992. Medlemmer og Meninger. Aalborg: CARMA.
14.
Kerr, Allan.1992. Why public sector workers join trade unions: An attitude survey of workers in the health service and local government. Employee Relations14, no. 2:39-54.
15.
McBride, Anne.2001. Gender democracy in trade unions. Aldershor: Ashgate.
16.
McDonald, Charles.1986. The AFL-CIO's blueprint for the future: A progress report . Industrial Relations Research Association Series , Proceedings of the thirty-ninth annual meeting , December 28-30.
17.
Millward, Neil, Alex Bryson, and John Forth.2000. All change at work?London: Routledge.
18.
Munro, Anne.1999. Women, work and trade unions. London : Mansell.
19.
Rose, Joseph, and Gary Chaison.1996. Linking union density and union effectiveness: The North American experience. Industrial Relations35, no. 1:78-105.
20.
Russo, John, and Andy Banks.1996. Teaching the organizing model of unionism and campaign-based education: National and international trends. Paper presented at AFL-CIO/Cornell University Research Conference on Union Organizing, April 1, Washington D.C.
21.
Sapper, Simon.1991. Do members' services packages influence trade union recruitment?Industrial Relations Journal22, no. 4:309-316.
22.
Stratton-Devine, Kay.1992. Union merger benefits: An empirical analysis. Journal of Labor Research13, no. 1:133-143.
23.
Terry, Michael.2003. Partnership and the future of unions in the UK . Economic and Industrial Democracy24, no. 4:485-507.
24.
Tuc.1947. Trade union structure and closer unity. London: Trades Union Congress.
25.
Tuc.1963. Report of the Ninety-eighth Annual Congress. London: Trades Union Congress.
26.
Tuc.1999. Meeting the millennial challenge. London: Trades Union Congress.
27.
Undy, Roger, Patricia Fosh, Huw Morris, Paul Smith, and Roderick Martin .1996. Managing the unions: The impact of legislation on trade unions' behavior. Oxford : Clarendon Press.
28.
Waddington, Jeremy, and Colin Whitston.1997. Why do people join unions in a period of membership decline?British Journal of Industrial Relations35, no. 4:515-546.
29.
Waddington, Jeremy, and Allan Kerr.1999a. Membership retention in the pubic sector. Industrial Relations Journal30, no. 2:151-165.
30.
Waddington, Jeremy, and Allan Kerr.1999b. Trying to stem the flow: Union membership turnover in the public sector. Industrial Relations Journal30, no. 3:184-196.
31.
Waddington, Jeremy, Marcus Kahmann, and Jurgen Hoffmann.2005. A comparison of the trade union merger process in Britain and Germany: Joining forces?London: Routledge .
