Many labor scholars, today as in the past, advocate greater partici pation by members in decision-making as a cure for what ails the labor movement. A review of experience with such participation, however, shows that it has different consequences in different settings, and that it rarely performs as advocates would like. Four historical types of partici patory unionism can be distinguished: radical, craft, classic industrial, and comanagement. The first three have had many exemplars and have long since revealed both their advantages and their limitations; the last is the least developed and most related to current management trends, and therefore worth better understanding.
Bahr, Morton (1986)."How should labor and management change their institutional structures to change with new work environment?" Address at Stanford University Law School, August 27, 1986.
2.
Bahr, Morton and Ketchum, William K (1992). "Workplace of the Future ." Human Resource Management32 (1992).
3.
Bronfenbrenner, Kate et al. Organizing to Win: new research on union strategies. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1998.
4.
Cobble, Dorothy Sue (1991). Dishing It Out: waitresses and their unions in the twentieth century. Urbana, Ill: University of Illinois Press, 1991
5.
Communications Workers of America / AT&T ( 1986). The emergence of second generation Quality of Worklife models.
6.
Deinard, Caitlin and Friedman, Raymond (1990)."Black caucus groups at Xerox Corporation (A) and (B)". Boston: Harvard Business School, 1990.
7.
Edelstein, J. David and Malcolm Warner (1976). "Comparative Union Democracy: organization and opposition in British and American Unions." N.Y.: John Wiley & Sons, 1976.
8.
Eldridge, Jet (1978)."Trade unions and bureaucratic control." in Clarke, Tom and Clements, Laurie (1978): ch. 11.
9.
Fletcher, Bill Jr. and Hurd, Richard W. "Beyond the organizing model: the transformation process in local unions." in Bronfebrenner, Kate et al, 1998: ch. 2.
10.
Form, William H. (1973). "Job vs political unionism: a cross-national comparison ." Industrial Relations12,2 (May 1973): 224-238.
11.
Goldthorpe, John H.; Lockwood, David; Bechhofer, Frank; and Platt, Jennifer (1969). The Affluent Worker in the Class Structure. Cambridge, Eng: Cambridge University Press , 1969 (vol. 3 of Cambridge Studies in Sociology).
12.
Goldthorpe, John H.; Lockwood, David; Bechhofer, Frank; and Platt, Jennifer (1968). The Affluent Worker: industrial attitudes and behavior. Cambridge, Eng: Cambridge University Press, 1968.
Heckscher, Charles (1993)."Le contrat social en pleine évolution: perspectives américaines." ("The changing social contract: American perspectives"). in Bernier, Colette et al (eds). La négociation collective du travail: adaptation ou disparition? Québec: Les Presses de l'Université Laval, 1993: ch. 7.
15.
Heckscher, Charles C.The New Unionism: employee involvement in the changing corporation . NY: Basic Books, 1988.
16.
Hinton, James (1973). The First Shop Stewards' Movement. London: George Allen & Unwin, 1973.
17.
Hoerr, John (1997). We Can't Eat Prestige: the women who organized Harvard. Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1997.
18.
Industrial Democracy in Europe, International Research Group (1981). Industrial democracy in Europe. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1981.
19.
Jacob, Betty M. (1978)."The effective trade union." International Sociological Association, Association Paper 78S09807.
20.
Lenin, V.I. "The role and functions of trade unions under the New Economic Policy ." January 12, 1922; in Selected Works in Three Volumes, Moscow: Progress Publishers , 1971.
21.
Lipset, SM, Trow, MA and Coleman, JS (1956). Union Democracy: the internal politics of the International Typographical Union. Glencoe, Ill: the Free Press, 1956.
22.
Mackenzie, Gavin (1973). The Aristocracy of Labor: the position of skilled craftsmen in the American class structure. Cambridge, Eng: Cambridge University Press, 1973.
23.
Mann, M. (1973). Consciousness & Action Among the Western Working Class. London: Macmillan, 1973.
24.
Maranto, Cheryl L. and Fiorito, Jack (1987)."The effect of union characteristics on the outcome of NLRB certification elections." Industrial and Labor Relations Review40 (January, 1987): 225-240.
25.
Matles, James J. and Higgins, James (1974). Them and Us: struggles of a rank-and-file union . Boston: Beacon Press, 1974.
26.
Miller, Robert W.; Zeller, Frederick A.; and Miller, Glenn W. (1965). The Practice of Local Union Leadership: a study of five local unions. Ohio State University Press, 1965.
27.
Nicholson, Nigel; Ursell, Gill; and Blyton, Paul (1981). The Dynamics of White-collar Unionism: a study of local union participation. NY: Academic Press, 1981.
28.
Palmer, David; Heckscher, Charles; and Friedman, Ray. "The Clerical and Technical Workers' organizing campaign at Harvard University". Boston, MA: Harvard Business School case 9-490-027: 1990.
29.
Piore, MJ (1985)."Thinking strategically for the industry: a new role for workers." mimeo: MIT, April 1985.
30.
Rankin, Thomas Donald.Unions & the Emerging Paradigm of Organization: The case of ECWU Local 800. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Pennsylvania , 1986.
31.
Rubinstein, Saul (1996). The Saturn Partnership: management and governance in team-based high performance manufacturing. Boston, MA : MIT Ph.D. dissertation, 1996.
32.
Rubinstein, Saul; Bennett, Michael; and Kochan, Thomas (1993)."The Saturn partnership: co-management and the reinvention of the local union." in Kaufman, B. and Kleiner, M (eds). Employee Representation: alternatives and future directions. Industrial Relations Research Association, 1993.
33.
Schatz, Ronald W (1996). "Cold War in the Working Class: The Rise and Decline of the United Electrical Workers." American Historical Review . 101,3 (June 1996): 928-929.
34.
Shaiken, Harley; Lopez, Steven; and Mankita, Isaac (1997)."Two routes to team production: Saturn and Chrysler compares". Industrial Relations36, 1 (January 1997): 17-45.
35.
Stepan-Norris, Judith and Zeitlin, Maurice (1995)."Union democracy, radical leadership, and the hegemony of capital". American Sociological Review60,6 (Dec, 1995): 829-850.
36.
Stepan-Norris, Judith, and Zeitlin, Maurice (1996)."Insurgency, radicalism, and democracy in America's industrial unions". Social Forces75,1 (Sep 1996): 1-32.
37.
Teny, Michael (1996)."Negotiating the government of Unison: Union democracy in theory and practice". British Journal of Industrial Relations34:1 (March 1996): 87-110.
38.
Valentine, Cynthia. "Internal union democracy: does it help or hinder the movement for industrial democracy?" Insurgent Sociologist8,2&3 (Fall 1978): 40-51.
39.
Walton, Richard E (1961). The Impact of the Professional Engineering Union . Boston: Division of Research, Graduate School of Business Administration, Harvard University, 1961.
40.
Warner, Malcolm. "Unions as complex organizations: strategy, structure, and the need for administrative innovation." Industrial Relations30 (April 1975): 43-59.
