Managing Social Equity: Insights from Local Public Managers

Abstract

Since its genesis in public administration, social equity has framed the field’s discussions of fairness in governance and management. Here we explore how local public managers conceptualize and operationalize social equity as a public value in the communities they lead. Based on in-depth interviews with 23 local government leaders, we find that these managers often define social equity in ways that emphasize procedural fairness. In addition, while social equity was a priority among the public managers, several expressed that they often face resistance from their elected officials when attempting to prioritize equity.

Keywords

social equity local government public manager

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Berry-James

R. M.

Gooden

S. T.

Johnson

R. G.

III . 2020. “Civil Rights, Social Equity, and Census 2020.” Public Administration Review 80 (6): 1100–8.

Blader

Tyler

2003. “A Four-Component Model of Procedural Justice: Defining the Meaning of a “Fair” Process.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 29 (6): 747–58.

Blessett

Fudge

Gaynor

2017. Moving from Theory to Practice: An Evaluative Assessment of Social Equity Approaches. Washington, DC: Center for Accountability and Performance.

Bradbury

M. J.

Kellough

2010. “Representative Bureaucracy: Assessing the Evidence on Active Representation.” The American Review of Public Administration 41 (2): 157–67.

Bradley

E. H.

Curry

L. A.

Devers

K. J.

2007. “Qualitative Data Analysis for Health Services Research: Developing Taxonomy, Themes, and Theory.” Health Services Research 42 (4): 1758–72.

Cepiku

Mastrodascio

2021. “Equity in Public Services: A Systematic Literature Review.” Public Administration Review 81 (6): 1019–32.

Cohen

I. J.

Rogers

M. F.

1994. “Autonomy and Credibility: Voice as Method.” Sociological Theory 12:304–18.

Demir

Nyhan

R. C.

2008. “The Politics–Administration Dichotomy: An Empirical Search for Correspondence between Theory and Practice.” Public Administration Review 68 (1): 81–96.

Dodge

Ospina

S. M.

Foldy

E. G.

2005. “Integrating Rigor and Relevance in Public Administration Scholarship: The Contribution of Narrative Inquiry.” Public Administration Review 65 (3): 286–300.

10.

Durant

R. F.

Rosenbloom

D. H.

2017. “The Hollowing of American Public Administration.” American Review of Public Administration 47:719–36.

11.

Ewick

Silbey

S. S.

1995. “Subversive Stories and Hegemonic Tales: Toward a Sociology of Narrative.” Law & Society Review 29:197–226.

12.

Gooden

S. T.

, 2017. “Social Equity and Evidence: Insights from Local Government.” Public Administration Review 77 (6):822–8.

13.

Gooden

S. T.

Portillo

2011. “Advancing Social Equity in the Minnowbrook Tradition.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 21 (suppl 1): i61–76.

14.

Gooden

S. T.

Rissler

G. E.

2017. “Local Government: Social Equity “First Responders”.” State and Local Government Review 49 (1): 37–47.

15.

Guy

M. E.

McCandless

S. A.

2012. “Social Equity: Its Legacy, its Promise.” Public Administration Review 72:5–13.

16.

Frederickson

H. G.

1990. “Public Administration and Social Equity.” Public Administrative Review 50 (2): 228–37.

17.

Frederickson

H. G.

2005. “The state of Social Equity in American Public Administration.” National Civic Review 94:31–38.

18.

Frederickson

H. G.

2010. Social Equity and Public Administration: Origins, Developments, and Applications. Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe, Inc.

19.

Hassett

W. L.

Watson

D. J.

2002. “Long–Serving City Managers: Practical Application of the Academic Literature.” Public Administration Review 62 (5): 622–9.

20.

Herian

M. N.

Hamm

J. A.

Tomkins

A. J.

Pytlik Zillig

L. M.

2012. “Public Participation, Procedural Fairness, and Evaluations of Local Governance: The Moderating Role of Uncertainty.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 22 (4): 815–40.

21.

International City/County Management Association. (n.d.a). Declaration of Ideals. https://icma.org/declaration-ideals.

22.

International City/County Management Association. (n.d.b). ICMA Code of Ethics Review Focusing on Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion. https://icma.org/page/icma-code-ethics-review-focusing-diversity-equity-and-inclusion.

23.

Johnson

Svara

2011. Justice for All: Promoting Social Equity in Public Administration. Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe, Inc.

24.

Kim

Kwak

Nwakpuda

Sullivan

Fenley

V. M.

2023. “Social Equity for Wicked Problems: Achieving Racial Equity in Homeless Service Provision.” Public Management Review 0 (0): 1–33.

25.

La Porte

. 1971. “The Recovery of Relevance in the Study of Public Organization.” In Toward a New Public Administration: The Minnowbrook Perspective, edited by Marini

, 17–47. Scranton, PA: Chandler Publishing Company.

26.

Larson

S. J.

Jacob

Butz

2017. Linking Social Equity and Performance Measurement: A Practitioner’s Roadmap. Washington, DC: Center for Accountability and Performance.

27.

Lavelle James

Brockner

Joel

Konovsky

Mary A.

Price

Kenneth H.

Henley

Amy B.

Taneja

Aakash

Vinekar

Vishnu

. 2009. “Commitment, Procedural Fairness, and Organizational Citizenship Behavior: A Multifoci Analysis.” Journal of Organizational Behavior 30 (3): 337–57.

28.

Maines

1993. “Narrative’s Moment and Sociology’s Phenomena.” Sociological Quarterly 34:17–30.

29.

Marshall

Rossman

1999. Designing Qualitative Research. 3rd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

30.

McCandless

Bishu

S. G.

Gómez Hernández

Paredes Eraso

Sabharwal

Santis

E. L.

Yates

2022. “A Long Road: Patterns and Prospects for Social Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion in Public Administration.” Public Administration 100 (1): 129–48.

31.

Morgan

Bacon

K. G.

Bunch

Cameron

C. D.

Deis

1996. “What Middle Managers do in Local Government: Stewardship of Public Trust and the Limits of Reinventing Government.” Public Administration Review 56:359–66.

32.

Nalbandian

1999. “Facilitating Community, Enabling Democracy: New Roles for Local Government Managers.” Public Administration Review 59 (3): 187.

33.

Nalbandian

O’Neill

Wilkes

M. J.

Kaufman

2013. “Contemporary Challenges in Local Government: Evolving Roles and Responsibilities, Structures, and Processes.” Public Administration Review 73:567–74.

34.

Norman-Major

2011. “Balancing the Four Es; or Can We Achieve Equity for Social Equity in Public Administration?” Journal of Public Affairs Education 17:233–52.

35.

Oberweis

Musheno

M. C.

2001. Knowing Rights: State Actors Stories of Power, Identity, and Morality. Burlington, VT: Ashgate.

36.

Ott

M. A.

2023. “Reimagining Local Government in the Wake of Recent Crises Will Build Public Trust.” State and Local Government Review 55 (2): 91–95.

37.

Pope

Ziebland

Mays

2000. “Qualitative Research in Health Care: Analysing Qualitative Data.” British Medical Journal 320 (7227): 114.

38.

Portillo

2010. “How Race, Sex and Age Frame the Use of Authority by Local Government Officials.” Law & Social Inquiry 35 (3): 603–23.

39.

Pynes

J. E.

Rissler

G. E.

2017. “Social Equity in the Trump Era: What Can Local Public Administrators Do to Improve Social Equity for Their Residents and Community in the Face of Federal Cuts?” State and Local Government Review 49 (1): 48–59.

40.

Rivera

J. D.

Knox

C. C.

2023. “Bureaucratic Discretion, Social Equity, and the Administrative Legitimacy Dilemma: Complications of New Public Service.” Public Administration Review 83 (1): 65–77.

41.

Rosenbloom

2005. “Taking Social Equity Seriously in MPA Education.” Journal of Public Affairs Education 11 (3): 247–52.

42.

Ruijer

Porumbescu

Porter

Piotrowski

2023. “Social Equity in the Data Era: A Systematic Literature Review of Data-Driven Public Service Research.” Public Administration Review 83 (2): 316–32.

43.

Spina

S. F.

2013. “Addressing Remnants of the Past: Proactive Responses to Equity Issues in Public Administration.” State and Local Government Review 45 (2): 98–107.

44.

Stillman

R. J.

1974. The Rise of the City Manager: A Public Professional in Local Government. Albuquerque, NM: University of New Mexico Press.

45.

Stokan

Hatch

M. E.

Overton

2023. “Fifty Years as the Fourth Pillar of Public Administration: A Polycentric Extension of the Social Equity Framework.” Public Administration 101 (4): 1427–42.

46.

Stone

H. A.

Stone

K. H.

Price

D. K.

1940. City Manager Government in the United States. Chicago, IL: Public Administration Clearing House.

47.

Svara

J. H.

2001. “The Myth of the Dichotomy: Complementarity of Politics and Administration in the Past and Future of Public Administration.” Public Administration Review 61 (2): 176–83.

48.

Svara

J. H.

Brunet

J. R.

2004. “Filling in the Skeletal Pillar: Addressing Social Equity in Introductory Courses in Public Administration.” Journal of Public Affairs Education 10 (2): 99–109.

49.

Svara

J. H.

Brunet

J. R.

2005. “Social Equity is a Pillar of Public Administration.” Journal of Public Affairs Education 11 (3): 253–58.

50.

Thibaut

Walker

1975. Procedural Justice. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.

51.

Van der Wal

. 2020. “Being a Public Manager in Times of Crisis: The Art of Managing Stakeholders, Political Masters, and Collaborative Networks.” Public Administration Review 80 (5): 759–64.

52.

Van Ryzin

G. G

. 2011. “Outcomes, Process, and Trust of Civil Servants.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 21 (4): 745–60.

53.

Wilson

1887. “The Study of Administration.” Political Science Quarterly 2 (2): 197–222.

54.

Wooldridge

Gooden

2009. “The Epic of Social Equity: Evolution, Essence, and Emergence.” Administrative Theory & Praxis 31 (2): 222–34.

55.

Wright

J. E.

Merritt

C. C.

2020. “Social Equity and COVID-19: The Case of African Americans.” Public Administration Review 80 (5): 820–6.