Policy makers allocate billions of dollars each year to tax incentives that increasingly favor creative industries. This study scrutinizes that approach by examining motion picture incentive programs used in over thirty states to encourage film and television production. It uses a quasi-experimental strategy to determine whether those programs have contributed to employment growth. Results mostly show no statistically significant effects. Results also indicate that domestic employment is unaffected by competing incentives offered outside the United States. These findings are robust to several alternative models and should lead policy makers to question the wisdom of targeted incentives conferred on creative industries.
AdkissonRichard V.2013. Policy convergence, state film-production incentives, and employment: A brief case study. Journal of Economic Issues47:445–54.
2.
BonhamCarlFujiEdwinImEricMakJames. 1992. The impact of the hotel room tax: An interrupted time series approach. National Tax Journal45:433–11.
3.
ChirinkoRobert S.WilsonDaniel J.. 2008. State investment tax incentives: A zero-sum game?Journal of Public Economics92:2362–84.
4.
ChristophersonSusan. 2008. Beyond the self-expressive creative worker: An industry perspective on entertainment media. Theory, Culture & Society25:73–95.
5.
ChristophersonSusanRightorNed. 2010. The creative economy as “big business”: Evaluating state strategies to lure filmmakers. Journal of Planning Education and Research29:336–52.
6.
CookThomas D.2014. “Big data” in research on social policy. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management33:544–47.
7.
CoyneChristopher J.SobelRussell S.DoveJohn A.. 2010. The non-productive entrepreneurial process. Review of Austrian Economics23:333–46.
8.
FloridaRichard. 2002. The rise of the creative class. New York: Basic Books.
9.
FloridaRichard. 2005. The flight of the creative class. New York: HarperCollins.
HamersmaSarah. 2008. The effect of an employer subsidy on employment outcomes: A study of the work opportunity and welfare-to-work tax credits. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management27:498–520.
14.
HicksMichael J.LaFaiveMichael. 2011. The influence of targeted economic development tax incentives on county economic growth: Evidence from Michigan’s mega credits. Economic Development Quarterly25:193–205.
15.
HowkinsJohn. 2001. The creative economy. New York: Penguin.
16.
JennMark A.NourzadFarrokh. 1996. Determinants of economic development incentives offered by states: A test of the arms race hypothesis. Review of Regional Studies26:1–16.
17.
JensenNathan M.MaleskyEdmund J.. 2018. Incentives to pander: How politicians use corporate welfare for political gain. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
18.
KeynonDaphneLangleyAdam H.PaquinBethany P.. 2012. Rethinking property tax incentives for business. Cambridge, MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy Report.
19.
KolkoJedNeumarkDavid. 2010. Do some enterprise zones create jobs?Journal of Policy Analysis and Management29:5–38.
20.
LeiserStephanie. 2017. The diffusion of state film incentives: A mixed-methods case study. Economic Development Quarterly31:255–67.
21.
LeRoyGreg. 2005. The great American jobs scam: Corporate tax dodging and the myth of job creation. San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler.
22.
LindenAriel. 2015. Conducting interrupted time-series analysis for single- and multiple-group comparisons. The Stata Journal15:480–500.
23.
MaorMosche. 2014. Policy bubbles: Policy overreaction and positive feedback. Governance27:469–87.
24.
McChesneyFred S.1997. Money for nothing: Politicians, rent extraction, and political extortion. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
25.
MullerAndreas. 2004. Florida’s motorcycle helmet law repeal and fatality rates. American Journal of Public Health94:556–58.
26.
MurrayMatthew N.BruceDonald J.. 2017. Evaluation of Alabama’s Entertainment Industry Incentive Program and New Markets Development Program. Report prepared for the Alabama Department of Revenue.
27.
NeumarkDavidKolkoJed. 2010. Do enterprise zones create jobs? Evidence from California’s Enterprise Zone Program. Journal of Urban Economics68:1–19.
28.
O’KeefeSuzanne. 2004. Job creation in California’s enterprise zones: A comparison using a propensity score matching model. Journal of Urban Economics55:131–50.
29.
PatrickCarlianne. 2014. Does increasing available non-tax economic development incentives result in more jobs?National Tax Journal67:351–86.
30.
PetersAlanFisherPeter. 2004. The failures of economic development incentives. Journal of the American Planning Association70:27–37.
31.
ReeseLaura A.2014. If all you have is a hammer: Finding economic development policies that matter. American Review of Public Administration44:627–55.
32.
ScottAllen J.2000. The cultural economy of cities. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
33.
St. ClairTravisCookThomas D.HallbergKelly. 2014. Examining the internal validity and statistical precision of the comparative interrupted time series design by comparison with a randomized experiment. American Journal of Evaluation35:311–27.
34.
SutherlandAlexArielBarakFarrarWilliamAndaRandy De. 2017. Post-experimental follow-ups—Fade-out versus persistence effects: The rialto police body-worn camera experiment four years in. Journal of Criminal Justice53:110–16.
35.
SwensonCharles W.2017. Preliminary evidence on film production and state incentives. Economic Development Quarterly31:65–80.
36.
ThomMichael. 2018. Lights, camera, but no action? Tax and economic development lessons from state motion picture incentive programs. American Review of Public Administration48:33–51.
37.
ThomMichaelAnBrian. 2017. Fade to black? Exploring policy enactment and termination through the rise and fall of state tax incentives for the motion picture industry. American Politics Research45:85–108.
38.
WassmerRobert W.1994. Can local incentives alter a metropolitan city’s economic development?Urban Studies31:1251–78.
39.
WasylenkoMichael. 1997. Taxation and economic development: The state of the economic literature. New England Economic Review1997:37–52.
40.
WilsonDaniel J.2009. Beggar thy neighbor? The in-state, out-of-state, and aggregate effects of R&D tax credits. The Review of Economics and Statistics91:431–36.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
