Two opposing views of service-led development contend, on the one hand, that services can be a propulsive force in rural economic development and, on the other, that services are neither independent of, nor a replacement for, older forms of rural industrialization such as agriculture, mining, and manufacturing. Both views fail to account for the dualistic nature of rural services growth, which does not mirror the developmental experience commonly associated with services in the nation's cities. This article reviews the literature on services and economic development, summarizes definitions, discusses national growth of rural services and recent trends, examines models of spatial distribution of services, and identifies gaps in existing knowledge.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abler, R.
, and T. Falk. 1981. Public information services and the changing role of distance in human affairs. Economic Geography57: 10-22.
2.
Anding, T.
, J. Adams, W. Casey, S. de Montille, and M. Goldfein. 1990. Trade centers of the Upper Midwest: Changes from 1960 to 1989. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota, Center for Urban and Regional Affairs.
3.
Aydalot, P.
(ed.) 1984. Crises economique et espace. Paris: Economica.
4.
Bailly, A.1986. Le sectuer des services: Une change pour le development local. In The present and future role of services in regional development, ed. S. Illeris. Brussels: Commission of the European Communities, OP-74.
5.
Bailly, A., and D. Maillat. 1986. Le secteur tertiaire en question. Paris: Anthropos.
6.
Bailly, A.
, D. Maillat, and W. Coffey. 1987. Service activities and regional development: Some European examples, Environment and Planning A19: 653-668.
7.
Barkley, D.1978. Plant ownership characteristics and the locational stability of rural Iowa manufacturers. Land Economics54: 92-99.
8.
Beale, C.
, and G. Fuguitt. 1986. Metropolitan and nonmetropolitan population growth in the United States since 1980. In New dimensions in rural policy: Building upon our heritage, ed. Joint Economic Committee. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office.
9.
Bender, L.
, B. Green, T. Hady, J. Kuehn, M. Nelson, L. Perkinson, and P. Ross. 1985. Diverse social and economic strategies of nonmetropolitan America. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Agriculture Economic Research Service, Rural Development Research Report 49.
10.
Beyers, W.
1991. Service industries, service occupations, and the division of labor. Paper presented at the North American Regional Science Association Meetings, New Orleans.
11.
Beyers, W.
, and M. Alvine. 1985. Export services in postindustrial society. Papers of the Thirty-First North American Meetings of the Regional Science Association 57: 33-45.
12.
Bluestone, H.
, and J. Hession. 1986. Patterns of change in the nonmetro and metro labor force since 1979. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Agriculture, Economic Research Service.
13.
Boddewyn, J.
, M. Halbrich, and A. Perry. 1986. Service multinationals: Conceptualization, measurement, and theory. Journal of International Business Studies17(3): 41-57.
14.
Bradshaw, T.
, and E. Blakely. 1979. Rural communities in advanced industrial society. New York: Praeger.
15.
Browne, L.1992. Why New England went the way of Texas rather than California. New England Economic Review. Jan/Feb: 23-42.
16.
Buck, N.1988. Service industries and local labor markets: Towards an anatomy of service job loss. Urban Studies25: 319-332.
17.
Cappellin, R.1988. The diffusion of producer services in the urban system. Regional Science Association European Summer Institute on Theories and Policies of Technological Development at the Local Level. Department of Economics, July 1-23. Milan, Italy: Universita Luigi Boccone.
18.
Christaller, W.1966. Places in Southern Germany. Translated by C. W. Baskin. Englewood Cliffs, NJ.: Prentice-Hall
19.
Christopherson, S.1989. Flexibility in the U.S. service economy and the emerging spatial division of labor. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers14: 131-143.
20.
Coffey, W.
, and A. Bailly. 1990. Producer services and the rise of flexible production systems. Paper presented at the Western Regional Science Association Meetings, Bilingual Special Session on Services and Regional Development, Molokai, Hawaii.
21.
Coffey, W.
, and M. Polese. 1987. Trade and location of producer services: A Canadian perspective. Environment and Planning A19: 597-611.
22.
Cohen, S.
, and J. Zysman. 1987. Manufacturing matters: The myth of the post-industrial economy. New York: Basic Books.
23.
Corey, K.1991. The role of information technology in Singapore's planning and development. In Collapsing time and space: Geographical aspects of communications and information, eds. S. D. Brunn and T. R. Leinbach. London: Unwin Hyman.
24.
Daniels, P.1982. Service industries: Growth and location. Cambridge: Cambridge University.
25.
Daniels, P.1985. Service industries: A geographical appraisal. London: Methuen & Co. Ltd.
26.
Daniels, P.1987. The geography of services. Progress in Human Geography11: 433-447.
27.
Daniels, T.
, and M. Lapping. 1988. The rural crisis and what to do about it: An alternative perspective. Economic Development Quarterly2: 339-341.
28.
Deller, S.
, and J. Holden. 1991. Rural retail market development: A policy for economic development. In Proceedings from the Conference on Rural Planning and Development: Visions of the 21st Century, February 13-15. Orlando, Fla.: University of Florida.
29.
Dickstein, C.1991. Offshore competition for back offices: Policy implications for promotion of back offices in West Virginia. Morgantown: West Virginia University, Report to the Institute for Public Affairs.
30.
Dillman, D.
, and D. Beck. 1986. The past is not the future: Urban quality of life as we approach the 21st century. Urban Resources3(3): 43-47.
31.
Drennan, M.1989. Information intensive industries in metropolitan areas of the United States of America. Environment and Planning A21: 1603-1618.
32.
Drucker, P.1989. Information and the future of the city. The Wall Street Journal, April 4, A22.
33.
Duncan, J.1988. Service sector diversity — A measurement challenge. In The Service Economy2(2): 1-5. Washington, D.C.: Coalition of Service Industries.
34.
Dunning, J.
, and G. Norman. 1987. The location choice of offices of international companies. Environment and Planning A19: 613-631.
35.
Eckstein, A.
, and D. Heien. 1985. The U.S. experience: Causes and consequences of service sector growth. Growth and Change16(2): 12-17.
36.
Enderwick, P.1987. The strategy and structure of service-sector multinationals: Implications for potential host regions. Regional Studies21: 215-223.
37.
Falk, L.
, and A. Broner. 1980. Specialization in service industry employment as a state policy. Growth and Change11(4): 18-23.
38.
Forester, T.1988. The myth of the electronic cottage. Futures20: 227-240.
39.
Fuguitt, G.
, D. Brown, and C. Beale. 1989. Rural and small town America. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
40.
Garnick, D.1983. Shifting patterns in the growth of migration in metro and nonmetro areas. Survey of Current Business63(5): 39-44.
41.
Gershuny, J.
, and I. Miles. 1983. The new service economy. New York: Praeger Publishers.
42.
Gillespie, A.
, and A. Green. 1987. The changing geography of producer services employment in Britain. Regional Studies21: 397-411.
43.
Gillespie, A.
, and K. Robins. 1989. Geographic inequalities: The spatial bias of the new communications technologies. Journal of Communication33(3): 7-18.
44.
Gillis, W.1987. Can service-producing industries provide a catalyst for regional economic growth?Economic Development Quarterly1: 249-256.
45.
Glasmeier, A.
, and G. Borchard. 1989. From branch plants to back offices: Prospects for rural services growth. Environment and Planning A21: 1565-1583.
46.
Glasmeier, A.
, and M. Howland. 1989. Services in the rural economy. A collaborative research proposal to the Ford Foundation Rural Economic Policy Program, Washington, D.C.
47.
Goe, R.1990. Producer services, trade, and the social division of labor. Regional Studies24: 327-342.
48.
Goode, F.1990. Community service sector structure as an industrial location determinant. University Park: Pennsylvania State University, unpublished paper.
49.
Gottman, J.1983. The coming of the transactional city. College Park: University of Maryland Institute for Urban Studies.
50.
Green, A. E.1987. Spatial prospects for service growth in Britain. Area19: 111-122.
51.
Greenfield, H.1966. Manpower and the growth of producer services. New York: Columbia University.
52.
Guile, B.1988. Introduction to services industries policy issues. Technological Forecasting and Social Change34: 315-325.
53.
Guile, B.
, and J. Quinn. 1988. Technological forecasting and social change. 34: 313-314.
54.
Hamilton, J.1990. Entangling alliances: How the Third World shapes our lives. Cabin John, Md.: Seven Locks.
55.
Hansen, N.1990. Do producer services induce regional economic development. Journal of Regional Science30: 465-476.
56.
Harrington, J.
1992. Information-intensive services and local economic development. Paper presented at the Southern Regional Science Association Meetings, Charleston, S.C.
57.
Harrington, J.
, and J. Lombard. 1989. Producer-service firms in a declining manufacturing region. Environment and Planning A21: 65-79.
58.
Harrington, J.
, A. Macpherson, and J. Lombard. 1991. Interregional trade in producer services: Review and synthesis. Growth and Change22(4): 75-94.
59.
Hepworth, M.1990. Geography of the information economy. New York: Guilford.
60.
Hepworth, M.
, A. Green, and A. Gillespie. 1987. The spatial division of information labor in Great Britain. Environment and Planning A19: 793-806.
61.
Hirschl, T.
, and G. Summers. 1982. Cash transfers and the export base of small communities. Rural Sociology47: 295-316.
62.
Howells, J. R. L.1984. The location of research and development: Some observations and evidence from Britain. Regional Studies18: 13-29.
63.
Howells, J.
, and A. Green. 1986. Location, technology, and industrial organization in U.K. services. Progress in Planning26(2): 85-183.
64.
Howland, M.1993. Technological change and the spatial restructuring of data entry and processing services. Technological Forecasting and Social Change43: 185-196.
65.
Howland, M.
, and T. Miller. 1990. UDAG grants to rural communities: A program that works. Economic Development Quarterly4: 128-136.
66.
Illeris, S.1989. Services and regions in Europe. Avebury, England: Aldershot.
67.
Kahan, S.1990. The service economy — At present, employment tells the whole story. In The Service Economy4(2): 1-8. Washington, D.C.: Coalition of Service Industries.
68.
Keil, S.
, and R. Mack. 1986. Identifying export potential in the service sector. Growth and Change17(2): 1-10.
69.
Kellerman, A.1985. The evolution of service economies: A geographical analysis. The Professional Geographer37: 133-143.
70.
Kirk, R.1987. Are business services immune to the business cycle?Growth and Change18(2): 15-23.
71.
Kirkland, R., Jr.1985. Are service jobs good jobs?Fortune (June 10): 38-43.
72.
Kirn, T.1987. Growth and change in the service sector of the U.S.: A spatial perspective. Annals of the Association of American Geographers77: 353-372.
73.
Kirn, T.
, R. Conway, and W. Beyers. 1990. Producer services development and the role of telecommunications: A case study in rural Washington. Growth and Change21(4): 33-50.
74.
Kraut, R.1989. Telecommuting: The trade-offs of home work. Journal of Communication39(3): 19-47.
75.
Kuznets, S.1977. Notes on the study of economic growth of nations. Economic Development and Cultural Change25: 300-314.
76.
Langdale, J.1983. Competition in the United States' long-distance telecommunications industry. Regional Studies17: 393-409.
77.
Lohr, S.1989. The growth of the `global office.'New York TimesFebruary 2, p. 27.
78.
McGranahan, D.
, J. Hession, F. Hines, and M. Jordan. 1988. Social and economic characteristics of the population in metro and nonmetro counties, 1970-80. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Agriculture Economic Research Service, Rural Development Research Report 58.
79.
Majchrowicz, T.1989. Patterns of change in the rural economy, 1969-86. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Agriculture Economic Research Service, Rural Development Research Report No. 73.
80.
Majchrowicz, T.
1990. Regional economic performance of nonmetro counties, 1969-87. Paper prepared for the Southern Regional Science Association Meetings, Washington, D.C.
81.
Majchrowicz, T.
1991 Employment changes in rural America's farm and farm-related industries during 1975-87. In Proceedings from the Conference on Rural Planning and Development: Visions of the 21st Century, February 13-15. Orlando: University of Florida.
82.
Marshall, J.
, and C. Jaeger. 1990. Service activities and uneven development in Britain and its European partners: Determinist fallacies and new options. Environment and Planning A22: 1337-1354.
83.
Marshall, J.
, P. Damesick, and P. Wood. 1987. Understanding the location and role of producer services in the United Kingdom. Environment and Planning A19: 575-595.
84.
Marshall, J.
, P. Wood, P. W. Daniels, A. McKinnon, J. Bachtler, P. Damesick, N. Thrift, A. Gillespie, A. Green, and A. Leyshon. 1988. Services and uneven development. New York: Oxford University.
85.
Martinelli, F. 1986. Producer services in a dependent economy: Their role and potential for regional economic development. Ph.D. dissertation, University of California, Berkeley.
86.
Martinelli, F.1989. Business services, innovation, and regional policy: Consideration of the case of Southern Italy. In Regional policy at the crossroads, eds. L. Albrechts, F. Moulaert, P. Roberts, and E. Swyngedouw. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
87.
Mawson, J.1987. Services and regional policy. Regional Studies21: 471-475.
88.
Metzger, R.
, and M. Glinow. 1988. Off-site workers: At home and abroad. California Management Review30(3): 101-111.
89.
Miles, I.1988. The electronic cottage: Myth or near-myth?Futures20: 355-366.
90.
Miller, J.1987. Recent contributions of small businesses and corporations to ruraljob creation. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Agriculture Economic Research Service, Staff Report AGS H61212.
91.
Miller, J.
, and H. Bluestone. 1988. Prospects for service sector employment growth in nonmetro America. In Rural Economic Development in the 1980s: Prospects for the future. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Agriculture Economic Research Service, Rural Development Research Report 69.
92.
Moore, G.1987. The service industries and the business cycle. Business Economics22(2): 12-24.
93.
Morrill, R.1982. Continuing deconcentration trends in trade. Growth and Change13(1): 46-48.
94.
New York Times. 1988. American Express goes high tech. July 31.
95.
Nilles, J.1985. Teleworking from home. In The information technology revolution, ed. T. Forester. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
96.
Nilles, J.
, R. Carlson, P. Grey, and G. Heineman. 1976. Telecommunications-transportation trade-offs: Options for tomorrow. New York: Wiley.
97.
North, D.1955. Location theory and regional economic growth. Journal of Political Economy63: 243-258.
98.
Noyelle, T.1986. Economic transformation. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science488(November): 9-17.
99.
Noyelle, T.1987. Beyond industrial dualism: Market and job segmentation in the new economy. Boulder: Westview.
100.
Noyelle, T.
, and T. Stanback, Jr.1983. The economic transformation of American cities. Totowa, NJ.: Rowman and Allanheld.
101.
O'Connor, K.1987. The location of services involved with international trade. Environment and Planning A19: 687-700.
102.
O'Farrell, P.
, and D. Hitchens. 1990. Producer services and regional development: Key conceptual issues of taxonomy and quality measurement. Regional Studies24: 163-171.
103.
Parker, E.
, H. Hudson, D. Dillman, and A. Roscoe. 1989. Rural America in the information age: Telecommunications policy for rural development. Boston: University Press of America.
104.
Planque, B. 1982. Le dévelopment décentralisé. Paris: Litrec.
105.
Polbse, M.1982. Regional demand for business services and interregional service flows in a small Canadian region. Papers of the Regional Science Association50: 151-163.
106.
Porat, M.1977. The information economy: Definition and measurement. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Commerce Office of Telecommunications, Special Publication77-12(1).
107.
Porterfield, S.
, and G. Pulver. 1991. Services producers, exports, and the generation of economic growth. International Regional Science Review14: 41-59.
108.
Price, D.
, and A. Blair. 1989. The changing geography of the service sector. London: Belhaven.
109.
Pulver, G.
1987. The changing economic scene in rural America. Paper prepared for the Center for Agriculture and Rural Development, Council of State Governments, Lexington, Ky.
110.
Quinn, J.1988. Technology in services: Past myths and future challenges. Technological Forecasting and Social Change34: 327-350.
111.
Quinn, J.
, and T. Doorley. 1988. Key policy issues posed by services. Technological Forecasting and Social Change34: 405-423.
112.
Quinn, J.
, and C. Gagnon. 1986. Will services follow manufacturing into decline?Harvard Business Review86(6): 95-103.
113.
Quinn J.
, J. Baruch, and A. Paquette. 1987. Technology in services. Scientific American257(6): 50-58.
114.
Quinn J.
, J. Baruch, and A. Paquette. 1988. Exploiting the manufacturing services interface. Sloan Management Review29(4): 45-56.
115.
Redwood, A.1988. Job creation in nonmetropolitan communities. The Journal of State Governments61: 9-15.
116.
Reich, R.1988a. The rural crisis, and what to do about it. Economic Development Quarterly2: 3-8.
117.
Reich, R.1988b. Response to letter from Daniels and Lapping. Economic Development Quarterly2: 342.
118.
Reich, R.1991. The real economy. The Atlantic Monthly. 267(2): 35-52.
119.
Reid, N.
, and M. Frederick. 1990. Rural America: Economic performance, 1989. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Agriculture Economic Research Service, Agriculture and Rural Economy Division, Agriculture Information Bulletin No. 609.
120.
Richter, K.1985. Nonmetropolitan growth in the late 1970s: The end of the turnaround?Demography22: 245-263.
121.
Riddle, D.1986. Services-led growth. New York: Praeger.
122.
Riefler, R.1976. Implications of service industry growth for regional development strategies. Annals of Regional Science10: 88-103.
123.
Sauvant, K.1986. International transactions in services: The politics of transborder data flows. Boulder: Westview.
124.
Scott, A.1988. New industrial spaces. London: Pion.
125.
Singlemann, J.1979. From agriculture to services. Beverly Hills: Sage.
126.
Smith, S.1984. Export orientation of nonmanufacturing businesses in nonmetropolitan communities. American Journal of Agricultural Economics66: 145-155.
127.
Smith, S.
, and G. Pulver. 1981. Nonmanufacturing business as a growth alternative in nonmetropolitan areas. Journal of the Community Development Society12: 32-47.
128.
Stabler, J.1987. Nonmetropolitan population growth and the evolution of rural service centers in the Canadian prairie region. Regional Studies21: 43-53.
129.
Stabler, J.
, and E. Howe. 1988. Service exports and regional growth in the postindustrial era. Journal of Regional Science28: 303-315.
130.
Stanback, T.1979. Understanding the service economy: Employment, productivity, location. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University.
131.
Stanback, T.
, and T. Noyelle. 1982. Cities in transition. Totowa, NJ.: Allenheld, Osmun.
132.
Stone, K.
1987. Impact of the farm financial crisis on the retail and service sectors of rural communities. Paper presented at the American Agricultural Economics Association (AAEA) Symposium on Farm Debt Stress, Kansas City, Mo.
133.
Stone, K.1989. The impact of Wal-Mart stores on other businesses in Iowa. Ames: Iowa State University, unpublished paper.
134.
Summers, G.
, F. Horton, and C. Gringeri. 1990. Rural labor market change in the U.S. In National Rural Studies Committee: A Proceedings(Cedar Falls, Iowa). Corvallis: Oregon State University Department of Agricultural Economics.
135.
Thompson, W.1965. A preface to urban economies. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University.
136.
Thurow, L.
, and G. Billard. 1989. Service activities and deindustrialization. In Deindustrialization experiences of the U.S. and Japan, ed. L. Rodwin. London: Allen and Rowenfeld.
137.
Tiebout, C.1956. Exports and regional growth. Journal of Political Economy64: 160-164, 169.
138.
Tschetter, J.1987. Producer services industries: Why are they growing so rapidly?Monthly Labor Review110(December): 31-39.
139.
U.S. Congress. Government Accounting Office
. 1990. Facilities location policy: GSA should propose a more consistent and businesslike approach. (September 28), pp. 1-31.
140.
van Dinteren, J.1987. The role of business service offices in the economy of mediumsized cities. Environment and Planning A19: 669-686.
141.
Vernon, R.1966. International investment and international trade in the product cycle. Quarterly Journal of Economics80: 190-207.
142.
Walker, R.1985. Is there a service economy? The changing capitalist division of labor. Science and Society49: 42-83.
143.
Washington Post. 1989. Global offices on rise as firms shift service jobs abroad. April 20.
144.
Wheeler, J.1986. Corporate spatial links with financial institutions: The role of the metropolitan hierarchy. Annals of the Association of American Geographers76: 262-274.
