Okun’s law is one of the best-known stylized facts in the economic literature, as well as one of the most widely used policy tools. The aim of this paper, which utilizes a comprehensive sample of 265 European regions by using annual observations covering the period from 2000 to 2019, is to deepen our knowledge of Okun’s law from two perspectives: on one hand, by checking the existence and intensity of regional differences, and on the other hand, by assessing the factors that explain them. To this end, in the first part, we apply a heterogeneous panel approach that deals with cross-sectional dependence, which allows us to obtain an average coefficient as well as region-specific coefficients. In the second part, a cross-sectional spatial model is used to uncover explanatory factors. Our findings reveal quite remarkable regional differences, as well as a somewhat geographical pattern in them. Moreover, they point out the importance of demographic factors (such as gender and age), labor market variables (share of employment in industry and construction, as well as self-employment and part-time employment and the severity of long-term unemployment), R&D expenditure, and some national institutional factors when it comes to explaining differences across regions.
AdanuK.2005. “A Cross-Province Comparison of Okun’s Coefficient for Canada.” Applied Economics37 (5): 561‐570.
2.
AddaJ.TriggariA.2016. “Labor Market Inequalities across Italian Demographic Groups: A Focus on the Youth and the Long-Term Unemployed.” Policy Brief, n° 1, IGER. Milan, Italy: Bocconi University.
3.
AnZ.BallL.JallesJ.LounganiP.2019. “Do IMF Forecasts Respect Okun’s Law? Evidence for Advanced and Developing Economies.” International Journal of Forecasting35 (3): 1131‐1142.
4.
AnguloA. M.MurJ.TrívezF. J.2018. “Measuring Resilience to Economic Shocks: An Application to Spain.” The Annals of Regional Science2: 349‐73.
5.
ApergisN.RezitisA.2003. “An Examination of Okun’s Law: Evidence from Regional Areas in Greece.” Applied Economics35: 1147‐1151.
6.
BailyM. N.1977. “On the Theory of Layoffs and Unemployment.” Econometrica45: 1043‐1063.
7.
BallL.FurceriD.LeighD.LounganiP.2019. “Does One Law Fit All? Cross-Country Evidence on Okun’s Law.” Open Economies Review30 (5): 841‐874.
8.
BandeR.Martín-RománA. L.2018. “Regional Differences in the Okun’s Relationship: New Evidence for Spain (1980-2015).” Investigaciones Regionales – Journal of Regional Research41: 137‐165.
9.
BasisthaA.Montero KuscevicC. M.2017. “The Role of Spatial GDP Spillovers in State-Level Okun’s Law.” Letters in Spatial and Resource Sciences10 (3): 353‐360.
10.
BellD.1964. “The Post-Industrial Society.” In Technology and Social Change, edited by GinzbergG., 540. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.
11.
BellD.1973. The Coming of Post-Industrial Society: A Venture in Social Forecasting. New York, NY: Basic Books.
12.
BentolilaS.BertolaG.1990. “Firing Costs and Labour Demand: How Bad Is Eurosclerosis?” Review of Economic Studies57 (3): 381‐402.
13.
BentolilaS.Saint-PaulG.1992. “The Macroeconomic Impact of Flexible Labor Contracts, With an Application to Spain.” European Economic Review36 (5): 1013‐1047.
14.
BinetM.-E.FacchiniF.2013. “Okun’s Law in The French Regions: A Cross-Regional Comparison.” Economic Bulletin33: 420‐433.
ChristopoulosD. K.2004. “The Relationship between Output and Unemployment: Evidence from Greek Regions.” Papers in Regional Science83: 611‐620.
22.
ChudikA.PesaranM. H.2015. “Large Panel Data Models with Cross-Sectional Dependence: A Survey.” In The Oxford Handbook of Panel Data, edited by BaltagiB. H., 3‐45. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
23.
Clar-LópezM.López-TamayoJ.RamosR.2014. “Unemployment Forecasts, Time Varying Coefficient Models and the Okun’s Law in Spanish Regions.” Economics and Business Letters3 (4): 247‐262.
24.
CörversF.HensenM.BongaertsD.2009. “Delimitation and Coherence of Functional and Administrative Regions.” Regional Studies43 (1): 19‐31.
25.
CoulterS.2016. “The UK Labour Market and the Great Recession.” In Unemployment, Internal Devaluation and Labour Market Deregulation in Europe, edited by MyantM.TheodoropoulouS.PiasnaA., 197‐227. Brussels, Belgium: European Trade Union Institute.
26.
Cuéllar-MartínJ.Martín-RománA. L.MoralA.2019. “An Empirical Analysis of Natural and Cyclical Unemployment at the Provincial Level in Spain.” Applied Spatial Analysis12: 647‐696.
27.
DunschS.2016. “Okun’s Law and Youth Unemployment in Germany and Poland.” International Journal of Management and Economics49: 34‐57.
28.
DurechR.MineaA.MusteaL.SlusnaL.2014. “Regional Evidence on Okun’s Law in Czech Republic and Slovakia.” Economic Modelling42: 57‐65.
29.
EberhardtM.TealF.2010. Productivity Analysis in Global Manufacturing Production. Economics Series Working Papers, 515. University of Oxford, Department of Economics.
30.
FeldsteinM.1976. “Temporary Layoffs in the Theory of Unemployment.” Journal of Political Economy84: 937‐951.
31.
FreemanD. G.2000. “Regional Tests of Okun’s Law.” International Advances in Economic Research6 (3): 557‐570.
32.
FreesE.W.1995. “Assessing Cross-Sectional Correlation in Panel Data.” Journal of Econometrics69: 393‐414.
33.
FriedmanM.1937. “The Use of Ranks to Avoid the Assumption of Normality Implicit in the Analysis of Variance.” Journal of the American Statistical Association32: 675‐701.
34.
FontanariC.PalumboA.SalvatoriC.2020. “Potential Output in Theory and Practice: A Revision and Update of Okun’s Original Method.” Structural Change and Economic Dynamics54: 247‐266.
35.
GartnerH.SchankT.SchnabelC.2013. “Wage Cyclicality Under Different Regimes of Industrial Relations.” Industrial Relations52 (2): 516‐540.
36.
Gonzalez PrietoN.LounganiP.MishraS.2018. “What Lies Beneath? A Sub-National Look at Okun’s Law in the United States.” Open Economies Review29: 835‐852.
37.
GuisingerA. Y.Hernandez-MurilloR.OwyangM. T.SinclairT. M.2018. “A State-Level Analysis of Okun’s Law.” Regional Science and Urban Economics68 (C): 239‐248.
38.
HerwartzH.NiebuhrA.2011. “Growth, Unemployment and Labour Market Institutions: Evidence from a Cross-Section of EU Regions.” Applied Economics43 (30): 4663‐4676.
39.
HeyesJ.LewisP.2014. “Employment Protection under Fire: Labour Market Deregulation and Employment in the European Union.” Economic and Industrial Democracy35 (4): 587‐607.
40.
HollyS.PesaranM. H.YamagataT.2010. “A Spatio-Temporal Model of House Prices in the USA.” Journal of Econometrics158: 160‐173.
41.
HorningB. C.1994. “Labor Hoarding and the Business Cycle.” International Economic Review35 (1): 87‐100.
42.
HutengsO.StadtmannG.2014. “Age- and Gender-Specific Unemployment in Scandinavian Countries: An Analysis Based on Okun’s Law.” Comparative Economic Studies56: 567‐580.
43.
KangasharjuA.TavéraC.NijkampP.2012. “Regional Growth and Unemployment: The Validity of Okun’s Law for the Finnish Regions.” Spatial Economic Analysis7 (3): 381‐395.
44.
KapetaniosG.PesaranM. H.YamagataT.2011. “Panels with Nonstationary Multifactor Error Structures.” Journal of Econometrics160: 326‐348.
45.
LesterA.1999. Labour Demand and the Economic Cycle. Sydney, Australia: Reserve Bank of Australia Bulletin. February.
46.
MazaA.VillaverdeJ.2011. “EU Regional Convergence and Policy: Does the Concept of Region Matter?” Journal of Policy Modeling33 (6): 889‐900.
47.
MelguizoC2017. “An Analysis of Okun’s Law for the Spanish Provinces.” Review of Regional Research37 (1): 59‐90.
48.
MonastiriotisV.MartelliA.2021. “Crisis, Adjustment and Resilience in the Greek Labor Market: An Unemployment Decomposition Approach.” International Regional Science Review44 (1): 85‐112.
49.
Montero KuscevicC. M.2014. “Okun’s Law and Urban Spillovers in US Unemployment.” The Annals of Regional Science53 (3): 719‐730.
50.
MoranP.1948. “The Interpretation of Statistical Maps.” Journal of the Royal Statistical Society B10: 243‐251.
51.
MortensenD.PissaridesC.1994. “Job Creation and Job Destruction in the Theory of Unemployment.” Review of Economic Studies61 (3): 397‐415.
52.
MorrisD. A.HeathcoteJ.2005. “Housing and the Business Cycle.” International Economic Review46 (3): 751‐784.
53.
NightingaleM.2021. “Part-Time Employment and the Gender Gap in Low Pay for UK Employees: What Changed over the Period 1996–2016?” Community, Work and Family24 (3): 272‐290.
54.
OkunA. M.1962. “Potential GNP: Its Measurement and Significance.” In Proceedings of the Business and Economic Statistic Section, 98‐104. Boston, MA: American Statistical Association.
55.
PalombiS.PermanR.TavéraC.2015. “Regional Growth and Unemployment in the Medium Run: Asymmetric Cointegrated Okun’s Law for UK Regions.” Applied Economics47 (57): 6228‐6238.
56.
PedroniP.2000. “Fully Modified OLS for Heterogeneous Cointegrated Panels.” Advances in Econometrics15: 93‐130.
57.
PedroniP.2001. “Purchasing Power Parity Tests in Cointegrated Panels.” Review of Economics and Statistics83: 727‐731.
58.
PedroniP.2007. “Social Capital, Barriers to Production and Capital Shares: Implications for the Importance of Parameter Heterogeneity from a Nonstationary Panel Approach.” Journal of Applied Econometrics22: 429‐451.
59.
PereiraR. M.2014. “Okun’s Law, Asymmetries and Regional Spillovers: Evidence from Virginia Metropolitan Statistical Areas and The District of Columbia.” The Annals of Regional Science52 (2): 583‐595.
60.
PermanR.GaetanS.TavéraC.2015. “Okun’s Law – A Meta-Analysis.” Manchester School83 (1): 101‐126.
61.
PermanR.TavéraC.2007. “Testing for Convergence of the Okun’s Law Coefficient in Europe.” Empirica34: 45‐61.
62.
PesaranM. H.2004. “General Diagnostic Tests for Cross Section Dependence in Panels.” Cambridge Working Papers in Economics No. 0435.
63.
PesaranM. H.2006. “Estimation and Inference in Large Heterogeneous Panels with a Multifactor Error Structure.” Econometrica74: 967‐1012.
64.
PesaranM. H.2007. “A Simple Panel Unit Root Test in the Presence of Cross-Section Dependence.” Journal of Applied Econometrics22: 265‐312.
65.
PesaranM. H.SmithR.1995. “Estimating Long-Run Relationships from Dynamic Heterogeneous Panels.” Journal of Econometrics68: 79‐113.
66.
PontarolloN.SerpieriC.2021. “Challenges and Opportunities to Regional Renewal in the European Union.” International Regional Science Review44 (1): 142‐169.
67.
Porras-ArenaM. S.Martín-RománA. L.2019. “Self-Employment and the Okun’s Law.” Economic Modelling77 (C): 253‐265.
68.
RyanP.2001. “The School-To-Work Transition: A Cross-National Perspective.” Journal of Economic Literature39 (1): 34‐92.
69.
SarafidisV.RobertsonD.2009. “On the Impact of Error Cross-Sectional Dependence in Short Dynamic Panel Estimation.” Journal of Econometrics12: 62‐81.
70.
SoskiceD.1990. “Wage Determination: the Changing Role of Institutions in Advanced Industrialized Countries.” Oxford Review of Economic Policy6 (4): 36‐61.
71.
VillaverdeJ.MazaA.2009. “The Robustness of Okun’s Law in Spain. 1980-2004.” Journal of Policy Modeling31: 289‐297.
72.
VillaverdeJ.MazaA.2021. “The Role of Spillovers in Okun’s Law: Empirical Evidence from Spain.” Panoeconomicus68 (4): 507‐530.
73.
ZaninL.2014. “On Okun’s Law in OECD Countries: An Analysis by Age Cohorts.” Economic Letters125: 243‐248.
74.
ZaninL.2018. “The Pyramid of Okun’s Coefficient for Italy.” Empirical45: 17‐28.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
