This exploratory study examined the effect of corporate acquisitions on shareholder wealth by reviewing the current literature and then analyzing a selected group of recent takeovers. In order to determine whether or not any effect did in fact exist, six "acquiring " corporations were compared with similar "non-acquirors"from the same industries on a number offinancial indicators readily available to the average investor Analyses of these data indicated that, contrary to what would be expectedfrom classical economic theory, the acquisitions studied had essentially negative impacts on shareholder wealth. These results lead to discussion of alternative rationales for initiating merger activities and possible long term effects of the recent merger trend.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Asquith, P.1983. Mergers, bids, uncertainty, and shareholders returns. Journal of Financial Economics, 11:57-84.
2.
Biggadike, R.1979. The risky business of diversification. Harvard Business Review, 57 (3): 103-111.
3.
Buffa, E.S.1984. Making American manufacturing competitive. In Carol, G. and Vogel, D. (Eds.) Strategy and Organization: A West Coast Perspective: 20-37. Marshfield, MA: Pitman Publishers.
4.
Bradley, M.1980. Interfirm tender offers and the market for corporate control. Journal of Business, 53 (4):345-376.
5.
Bradley, J.W., & Korn, D.H.1982. The changing role of acquisitions. Journal of Business Strategy, 2 (4):30-42.
6.
Brigham, E., & Gapenski, C.1985. Financial management: Theory and practice. Chicago: Dryden Press.
7.
Conboy, R.M., & Kennedy, WE1988. Shareholder wealth as a goal of the firm. Proceedings of the 18th Annual Meeting of the Southeastern Region of the Decision Sciences Institute: 42-43. Winston-Salem, NC: SE DSI.
8.
Dodd, P.1980. Merger proposals, management discretion, and stockholder wealth. Journal of Financial Economics, 8:105-137.
9.
Dodd, P., & Ruback, R.1978. Tender offer and stockholder returns, an empirical analysis. Journal of Financial Economics, 5:351-374.
10.
Dobrzynski, J.H.1988. A new strain of merger mania: Companies seeking a competitive edge are replacing the raiders.Business Week, March 21:122-126.
11.
Drucker, PE1956. The practice of management.New York: Harper & Brothers.
12.
Eberling, H.W, Jr., & Doorley, TL., III.1983. A strategic approach to acquisitions.Journal of Business Strategy,3 (3):44-45.
Ellert, P1976. Mergers, antitrust law enforcement, and stockholder returns.Journal of Finance,32 (2):715-734.
15.
Fama, E.E1980. Agency problems and the theory of the firm.Journal of Political Economy, 88 (2): 288-307.
16.
Farrell, C.1988. Learning to live with leverage: New risks, new rewards-and bigger failures?Business Week, November 7:138-143.
17.
Farrell, C.1989. The LBO isn't a superior new species.Business Week, October 23:126-126.
18.
Fortune.1985. The Fortune directory of the largest U.S. industrial corporations. April 29:266-316.
19.
Freundlich, N.1989. As LBOs Take A Rocket Ride, R&D Takes A Nosedive.Business Week, February 27:70-70.
20.
Halpern, P1973. Empirical estimates of the amount and distribution of gains to companies in mergers.Journal of Business,66:554-575.
21.
Halpern, P1983. Corporate acquisitions: A theory of special cases? A review of event studies applied to acquisitions. Journal of Finance,38 (2):297-317.
22.
Hogarty, TE1970. Conglomerate mergers and acquisitions: operational analyses.St. John's Law Review,44:317-327.
23.
Jarrell, G., & Bradley, M.1980. The economic effects of federal and state regulations on cash tender offers.Journal of Law and Economy,23:37-407.
24.
Jarrell, G.A., Brickley, J.A., & Netter, J.M.1988. The market for corporate control: The empirical evidence since 1980.Journal of Economic Perspectives2 (1):49-68.
25.
Jensen, M., & Ruback, R.1983. The market for corporate control.Journal of Financial Economics,11:5-49.
26.
Kerlinger, EN. 1973. Foundations of behavioral research (2nd ed.). New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
27.
Kitching, J.1967. Why do mergers miscarry?Harvard Business Review,45 (6):84-101.
28.
Knoeber, C.R.1986. Golden parachutes, shark repellents, and hostile tender offers.The American Economic Review,76 (1):155-167.
29.
Langetieg, T1978. Application of a three-factor performance index to measure stockholder gains from merger.Journal of Financial Economics,6:365-383.
30.
Langetieg, TC., Haugen, R.A., & Weichern, D.W1980. Mergers and stockholder risk.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,15:689-710.
31.
Lester, T1985. The corporate buying spree.Management Today,9:51-57.
32.
Logue, D.E.1984. Shareholder wealth and management compensation.Corporate Accounting,2 (1):38-45.
33.
Lubatkin, M.1983. Mergers and the performance of the acquiring firm.Academy of Management Review,8 (2):218-225.
34.
Lubatkin, M., & Shrieves, R.E.1986. Towards reconciliation of market performance measures to strategic management research.Academy of Management Review,11 (3):497-512.
35.
Malatesta, P 1981. Corporate mergers. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Rochester, Rochester, NY
36.
Mandelker, G.1974. Risk and return: The case of merging firms.Journal of Financial Economics,1:303-335.
37.
March, J.G., & Simon, H.A.1958. Organizations.New York: John Wiley
38.
Mason, H.R., & Goudzwaard, M.B.1976. Performance of conglomerate firms: A portfolio approach.Journal of Finance,21:39-48.
39.
Melicher, R.W, & Neilson, J.E1978. Financial factors that affect acquisition prices.Review of Business and Economic Research, 13:95-108.
40.
Mergers and Acquisitions. 1985. Almanac and index: 1984 profile. January: 25-44.
41.
Meulbroek, L.K., Mitchell, M.L., Mulherin, J.H., Netter, J.M., & Poulsen, A.B. in press. Shark repellents and managerial myopia: An empirical test.Journal of Political Economy.
42.
Murphy, K.J.1986. Top executives are worth every nickel they get.Harvard Business Review,64:125-132.
43.
Nader, R.1988. Put some stoplights on the urge to merge.USA Today, October 25: 1OA-10A.
44.
Netter, J. & Poulsen, A.1989. State corporation laws and shareholders: the recent experience.Financial Management,18 (3):29-40.
45.
Perrow, C.1961. The analysis of goals in complex organizations.American Sociological Review,26: 854-866.
46.
Pound, J.1987. The effects of antitakeover amendments on takeover activity: Some direct evidence.Journal of Law & Economics,30 (2):353-367.
47.
Rappaport. A.1983. Corporate performance standards and shareholder value.Journal of Business Strategy,3 (4):28-38.
48.
Ravenscraft, D.J. & Scherer, FM.1987. Mergers, sell-offs, and economic efficiency.Washington, DC: The Brookings Institute.
49.
Richards, M.D.1986. Setting strategic goals and objectives (2nd ed.). St. Paul, MN: West Publishing.
50.
Schipper, K., & Thompson, R.1983. Evidence on the capitalized value of merger activity for acquiring firms.Journal of Financial Economics,11:85-119.
51.
Schumann, L. & Stoner, R.1988. Letters to the Editor.California Management Review,30 (3): 144-149.
52.
The Wall Street Journal.1982. The 4 horsemen: Did main characters in big takeover saga let egos sway them? September 24:1-1, 24-24.
53.
The Wall Street Journal Index: Corporate News, 1984.1985. New York: Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
54.
Waldman, P1989. New RJR chief faces a daunting challenge at debt-heavy firm.The Wall Street Journal, March 14:A1-A1, A16-A16.
55.
Weidenbaum, M., & Vogt, S.1987. Takeovers and stockholders: Winners and losers.California Management Review,29 (4):157-168.
56.
Weidenbaum, M.L., & Vogt, S.1988. Murray L. Weidenbaum and Stephen Vogt respond. California Management Review30 (3):149-151.
57.
Weston, JE, & Mansinghka, S.K.1971. Test of the efficiency performance of conglomerate firms.Journal of Finance,26:219-936.
58.
Wheelen, TL., & Hunger, J.D.1986. Strategic management and business policy (2nd ed.). Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
59.
Young, J.1986. Report of the President's commission on industrial competitiveness.Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
