Prior studies of strategic consensus and firm performance have yielded inconsistent results. The authors synthesize and account for these divergent findings using a mediated moderation model. Results based on a sample of manufacturing companies in Spain suggest a pattern of mediated moderation such that the relationship between competitive method consensus (i.e., means) and organizational performance, which is moderated by environmental dynamism, is mediated by consensus on objectives (i.e., goals or ends). These results provide an alternative explanation for prior inconsistencies in research results regarding the consensus–performance relationship and point to the need for a more complex conceptualization of the relationship among competitive method consensus, consensus on objectives, organizational performance, and the organization’s surrounding environment.
AguinisH.AdamsS. K. R.1998. Social-role versus structural models of gender and influence use in organizations: A strong inference approach. Group and Organization Management, 23: 414-446.
4.
AguinisH.BeatyJ. C.BoikR. J.PierceC. A.2005. Effect size and power in assessing moderating effects of categorical variables using multiple regression: A 30-year review. Journal of Applied Psychology, 90: 94-107.
5.
AguinisH.BoydB. K.PierceC. A.ShortJ. C.2011. Walking new avenues in management research methods and theories: Bridging micro and macro domains. Journal of Management, 37: 395-403.
6.
AguinisH.HardenE. E.2009. Cautionary note on conveniently dismissing χ² goodness-of-fit test results: Implications for strategic management research. In BerghD. D.KetchenD. J. (Eds.), Research methodology in strategy and management, vol. 5: 111-120. San Diego, CA: Elsevier.
7.
AguinisH.PierceC. A.BoscoF. A.DaltonD. R.DaltonC. M.in press. Debunking myths and urban legends about meta-analysis. Organizational Research Methods.
8.
AnsoffH. I.1965. Corporate strategy. New York: McGraw Hill.
9.
ArmstrongJ. S.1982. The value of formal planning for strategic decisions: Review of empirical research. Strategic Management Journal, 3: 197-211.
10.
BantelK. A.1998. Technology-based, “adolescent” firm configurations: Strategy identification, context, and performance. Journal of Business Venturing, 13: 205-230.
11.
BaronR. M.KennyD. A.1986. The moderator–mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 51: 1173-1182.
12.
BensaouM.VenkatramanN.1995. Configurations of interorganizational relationships: A comparison between U.S. and Japanese automakers. Management Science, 41: 1471-1492.
13.
BerryW. D.1984. Nonrecursive causal models. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
14.
BourgeoisL. J.1980. Performance and consensus. Strategic Management Journal, 1: 227-248.
15.
BourgeoisL. J.1985. Strategic goals, perceived uncertainty, and economic performance in volatile environments. Academy of Management Journal, 28: 548-573.
16.
BoydB. K.BerghD. D.KetchenD. J.2010. Reconsidering the reputation–performance relationship: A resource-based view. Journal of Management, 36: 588-609.
17.
BoydB. K.GoveS.2006. Managerial constraint: The intersection between organizational task environment and discretion. In KetchenD. J.BerghD. D. (Eds.), Research methodology in strategy and management, vol. 3: 57-95. New York: Elsevier.
18.
BoyerK. K.McDermottC.1999. Strategic consensus in operations strategy, Journal of Operations Management, 17: 289-305.
19.
BrannickM. T.ChanD.ConwayJ. M.LanceC. E.SpectorP. E.2010. What is method variance and how can we cope with it? A panel discussion. Organizational Research Methods, 13: 407-420.
Campbell-HuntC.2000. What have we learned about generic competitive strategy? A meta-analysis. Strategic Management Journal, 21: 127-154.
22.
CaponN.FarleyJ. U.HoenigS.1990. Determinants of financial performance: A meta-analysis. Management Science, 36: 1143-1159.
23.
ChenI. J.PaulrajA.2004. Towards a theory of supply chain management: The constructs and measurements. Journal of Operations Management, 22: 119-150.
24.
ChenI. J.PaulrajA.LadoA. A.2004. Strategic purchasing, supply management, and firm performance. Journal of Operations Management, 22: 505-523.
25.
CortinaJ.ChenG.DunlapW.2001. Testing interaction effects in LISREL: Examination and illustration of available procedures. Organizational Research Methods, 4: 324-360.
26.
DaftR. L.WeickK. E.1984. Toward a model of organizations as interpretation systems. Academy of Management Review, 9: 284-295.
27.
DeeganJ.Jr.1978. On the occurrence of standardized regression coefficients greater than one. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 38: 873-888.
28.
DessG. G.1987. Consensus on strategy formulation and organizational performance: Competitors in a fragmented industry. Strategic Management Journal, 8: 259-277.
29.
DessG. G.OrigerN. K.1987. Environment, structure, and consensus in strategy formulation: A conceptual integration. Academy of Management Review, 12: 313-330.
30.
DessG. G.PriemR. L.1995. Consensus-performance research: Theoretical and empirical extensions. Journal of Management Studies, 32: 401-417.
31.
DillmanD. A.1978. Mail and telephone surveys: The total design method. New York: Wiley.
32.
DooleyR. S.FryxellG. E.JudgeW. Q.2000. Belaboring the not-so-obvious: Consensus, commitment, and strategy implementation speed and success. Journal of Management, 26: 1237-1257.
33.
EdwardsJ. R.2001. Ten difference score myths. Organizational Research Methods, 4: 264-286.
34.
EisenhardtK. M.1989. Making fast strategic decisions in high-velocity environments. Academy of Management Journal, 32: 543-576.
35.
FarmerS.AguinisH.2005. Accounting for subordinate perceptions of supervisor power: An identity-dependence model. Journal of Applied Psychology, 90: 1069-1083.
36.
FarmerS. M.TierneyP.Kung-McIntyreK.2003. Employee creativity in Taiwan: An application of role identity theory. Academy of Management Journal, 46: 618-630.
37.
FinkelsteinS.HambrickD. C.1996. Strategic leadership: Top executives and their effects on organizations. Minneapolis, MN: West.
38.
FiolC. M.1994. Consensus, diversity, and learning in organizations. Organizational Science, 5: 403-420.
39.
FloydS. W.WooldridgeB.1992. Managing strategic consensus: The foundation of effective implementation. Academy of Management Executive, 6: 27-39.
40.
FritzM. S.MacKinnonD. P.2007. Required sample size to detect the mediated effect. Psychological Science, 18: 233-239.
41.
HambrickD. C.1983. High profit strategies in mature capital goods industries: A contingency approach. Academy of Management Journal, 26: 687-707.
42.
HayesR. H.WheelwrightS. C.1984. Restoring our competitive edge: Competing through manufacturing. New York: Wiley.
43.
HenleyA. B.ShookC. L.PetersonM.2006. The presence of equivalent models in strategic management research using structural models: Assessing and addressing the problem. Organizational Research Methods, 9: 516-535.
44.
HittM. A.BoydB.LiD.2004. The state of strategic management research: A view of the future. In KetchenD. J.BerghD. D. (Eds.), Research methodology in strategy and management, vol. 1: 1-31. New York: Elsevier.
45.
HomburgC.KrohmerH.WorkmanJ. P.Jr.1999. Strategic consensus and performance: The role of strategy type and market-related dynamism. Strategic Management Journal, 20: 339-357.
HunterJ. E.GerbingD. W.1982. Unidimensional measurement, second order factor analysis, and causal models. Research in Organizational Behavior, 4: 267-320.
48.
IaquintoA. L.FredricksonJ. W.1997. Top management team agreement about the strategic decision process: A test of some of its determinants and consequences. Strategic Management Journal, 18: 63-75.
49.
JamesL. R.DemareeR. G.WolfG.1984. Estimating within-group interrater reliability with and without response bias. Journal of Applied Psychology, 69: 85-98.
50.
JamesL. R.MulaikS. A.BrettJ. M.2006. A tale of two methods. Organizational Research Methods, 9: 233-244.
51.
JoshiM. P.KathuriaR.PorthS. J.2003. Alignment of strategic priorities and performance: An integration of operations and strategic management perspectives. Journal of Operations Management, 21: 353-369.
52.
KathuriaR.PorthS. J.JoshiM. P.1999. Manufacturing priorities: Do general managers and manufacturing managers agree?International Journal of Production Research, 37: 2077-2092.
53.
KellermannsF. W.WalterJ.LechnerC.FloydS. W.2005. The lack of consensus about strategic consensus: Advancing theory and research. Journal of Management, 31: 719-737.
54.
KimE.NamD.StimpertJ. L.2004. The applicability of Porter’s generic strategies in the digital age: Assumptions, conjectures, and suggestions. Journal of Management, 30: 569-589.
55.
KnightD.PearceC. L.SmithK. G.OlianJ. D.SimsH. P.SmithK. A.FloodP.1999. Top management team diversity, group process, and strategic consensus. Strategic Management Journal, 20: 445-465.
KrauseD. R.PagellM.CurkovicS.2001. Toward a measure of competitive priorities for purchasing. Journal of Operations Management, 19: 497-512.
58.
LeBretonJ. M.JamesL. R.LindellM. K.2005. Recent issues regarding rWG, rWG, rWG(j), and rWG(j). Organizational Research Methods, 8: 128-138.
59.
LeBretonJ. M.WuJ.BingM. N.2009. The truth(s) on testing for mediation in the social and organizational sciences. In LanceC. E.VandenbergR. J. (Eds.), Statistical and methodological myths and urban legends: Doctrine, verity, and fable in the organizational and social sciences: 109-144. New York: Routledge
60.
LindmanF. T.CallarmanT. E.FowlerK. L.McClatcheyC. A.2001. Strategic consensus and manufacturing performance. Journal of Management Issues, 13: 45-64.
61.
LumpkinG. T.DessG. G.2001. Linking two dimensions of entrepreneurial orientation to firm performance: The moderating role of environment and industry life cycle. Journal of Business Venturing, 16: 429-451.
62.
MacKinnonD. P.2008. Introduction to statistical mediation analysis. New York: Lawrence Erlbaum.
63.
MacKinnonD. P.KrullJ. L.LockwoodC. M.2000. Equivalence of mediation, confounding, and suppression. Preventive Science, 1: 173-181.
64.
MacKinnonD. P.LockwoodC. M.HoffmanJ. M.WestS. G.SheetsV.2002. A comparison of methods to test mediation and other intervening variable effects. Psychological Methods, 7: 83-104.
65.
MathieuJ. E.TannenbaumS. I.SalasE.1992. Influences of individual and situational characteristics on measures of training effectiveness. Academy of Management Journal, 35: 828-847.
66.
MillerA.DessG. G.1993. Assessing Porter’s (1980) model in terms of its generalizability, accuracy and simplicity. Journal of Management Studies, 30: 553-585.
67.
MillerD.1992. Environmental fit versus internal fit. Organization Science, 3: 159-178.
68.
MillerD.FriesenP. H.1982. Innovation in conservative and entrepreneurial firms: Two models of strategic momentum. Strategic Management Journal, 3: 1-25.
69.
MintzbergH.1973. Strategy-making in three modes. California Management Review, 16: 44-53.
70.
MintzbergH.1990. The design school: Reconsidering the basic premises of strategic management. Strategic Management Journal, 11: 171-195.
71.
MintzbergH.Waters, 1985. Of strategies, deliberate and emergent. Strategic Management Journal, 6: 257-272.
72.
MullerD.JuddC. M.YzerbytV. Y.2005. When moderation is mediated and mediation is moderated. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 89: 852-863.
73.
Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development. 2009. Input-output tables edition 2009. Directorate for Science, Technology and Industry, Organisation of Economic Development and Co-operation. Retrieved from http://www.oecd.org/sti.
74.
PagellM.KrauseD. R.2002. Strategic consensus in the internal supply chain: Exploring the manufacturing-purchasing link. International Journal of Production Research, 40: 3075-3092.
75.
PorterM. E.1980. Competitive strategy. New York: Free Press.
76.
PorterM. E.1981. The contributions of industrial organization to strategic management. Academy of Management Review, 6: 609-620.
77.
PorterM. E.1985. Competitive advantage. New York: Free Press.
78.
PorterM. E.1996. What is strategy?Harvard Business Review, November/December: 61-78.
79.
PorterM. E.1997. Stop imitating, and get to the real strategy. Bank Advertising News, 21(8/9): 6.
80.
PrahaladC. KBettisR. A.1986. The dominant logic: A new linkage between diversity and performance. Strategic Management Journal, 7: 485-501.
81.
PriemR. L.1990. Top management team group factors, consensus, and firm performance. Strategic Management Journal, 11: 469-478
QuinnJ. B.1980. Strategies for change: Logical incrementalism. Homewood, IL: R. D. Irwin.
84.
RodgersJ. L.2010. The epistemology of mathematical and statistical modeling: A quiet methodological revolution. American Psychologist, 65: 1-12.
85.
RogelbergS. G.StantonJ. M.2007. Understanding and dealing with organizational survey nonresponse. Organizational Research Methods, 10: 195-209.
86.
SmithT. M.ReeceJ. S.1999. The relationship of strategy, fit, productivity, and organizational performance in a services setting. Journal of Operations Management, 17: 145-161.
87.
StepanovichP. L.MuellerJ. D.2002. Mapping strategic consensus. Journal of Business and Management, 8: 147-163.
88.
Stone-RomeroE. F.RosopaP. J.2008. The relative validity of inferences about mediation as a function of research design characteristics. Organizational Research Methods, 11: 326-352.
89.
TariganR.2005. An evaluation of the relationship between alignment of strategic priorities and manufacturing performance. International Journal of Management, 22: 586-597.
90.
TisakJ.SmithC. S.1994. Defending and extending difference score methods. Journal of Management, 20: 675-682.
91.
VandenbergR. J.GrelleD. M.2009. Alternative model specifications in structural equation modeling: Facts, fictions, and truth. In LanceC. E.VandenbergR. J. (Eds.), Statistical and methodological myths and urban legends: Received doctrine, verity, and fable in the organizational and social sciences: 165-191. New York: Routledge.
92.
VenkatramanN.1989. The concept of fit in strategy research: Toward verbal and statistical correspondence. Academy of Management Review, 14: 423-444.
93.
VenkatramanN.RamanujamV.1987. Measurement of business economic performance: An examination of method convergence. Journal of Management, 13: 109-123.
94.
WardP. T.DurayR.2000. Manufacturing strategy in context: Environment, competitive strategy and manufacturing strategy. Journal of Operations Management, 18: 123-138.
WestC. T.SchwenkC. R.1996. Top management team strategic consensus, demographic homogeneity and firm performance: A report of resounding nonfindings. Strategic Management Journal, 17: 571-576.
97.
WestS. G.2009. Alternatives to randomized experiments. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 18: 299-304.
98.
WooldridgeB.SchmidT.FloydS. W.2008. The middle management perspective on strategy process: Contributions, synthesis, and future research. Journal of Management, 34: 1190-1221.
