Just over 100 years ago, Frederick Taylor conducted the pig-iron handling experiments. After reviewing discrepancies in Taylor’s accounts of these experiments, some have concluded that the episode was no more than a “pig-tale.” Through the use of historiographic approaches, including evaluation of Frank Gilbreth’s 1912 filmed recreation, this research supports Taylor’s use of the “pig-tale.” Taylor told the story to persuade listeners that even the most basic processes could be improved for the joint prosperity of employer and employee. When evaluating historical records, we must not allow relatively minor discrepancies to overshadow the object lesson of the story.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abrahamson, E. (1996). Management fashion. Academy of Management Review, 21, 254–285.
2.
Amar, J. (1920). The human motor or the scientific foundations of labour and industry. Translated by E. P. Butterworth & G. E. Wright. London: George Routledge & Sons. (Original work published in 1914).
3.
Bedeian, A. G. (1998). Exploring the past. Journal of Management History, 4, 4–15.
4.
Bello, R. (2000). Determinants of equivocations: the influence of situational formality, interaction phase, and ambiguity tolerance. Communication Research, 27, 161–193.
5.
Conger, J. A. (1998). The necessary art of persuasion. Harvard Business Review, 76 (3), 84–95.
6.
Copley, F. B. (1923). Frederick W. Taylor: father of scientific management (Volume II). New York: Harper and Brothers.
7.
Cragan, J. F., & Shields, D. C. (1998). Understanding communication theory: the communicative forces for human action. Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
8.
Drucker, P. F. (1989). The new realities. New York: Harper & Row.
9.
Ford, J. D., & Ford, L. W. (1995). The role of conversations in producing intentional change in organizations. Academy of Management Review, 20, 541–570.
10.
Freeman, M. (1996). Scientific management: 100 years old; poised for the next century. SAM Advanced Management Journal, 61, 35–41.
11.
Fry, L. W. (1976). The maligned F. W. Taylor: a reply to his many critics. Academy of Management Review, 1, 124–129.
12.
Gantt, H. L. (1901). A bonus system of rewarding labor. American Society of Mechanical Engineers Transactions, 23, 341–372.
13.
Gilbreth, F. B. (1911). Motion study: a method for increasing the efficiency of the workman. New York: D. Van Nostrand Company.
14.
Gilbreth, F. B., & Gilbreth, L. M. (1953). Applied motion study. In W. R. Spriegel & C. E. Myers (Eds.), The Writings of the Gilbreths. (pp. 207–274). Homewood, IL: Richard D. Irwin. (Original work published in 1917).
15.
Gilbreth, F. B., & Gilbreth, L. M. (1921). Stop-watch time study: an indictment and a defense. Bulletin of the Taylor Society, 6 (3), 100–108, 117–135.
16.
Gilbreth, L. M. (1926). The quest of the one best way: a sketch of the life of Frank Bunker Gilbreth. New York: Society of Women Engineers.
17.
Gillespie, J., & Wolle, H. C. (1899, June 17). Report on the loading of pig iron.South Bethlehem, PA. [Available from the Taylor archives at Stevens Institute]
18.
Hubbard, R., & Vetter, D. E. (1996). An empirical comparison of published replication research in accounting, economics, finance, management, and marketing. Journal of Business Research, 35, 153–164.
19.
Kanigel, R. (1997). The one best way: Frederick Winslow Taylor and the enigma of efficiency. New York: Viking.
20.
Lee, J. A. (1980). The gold and the garbage in management theories and prescriptions. Athens, OH: Ohio University Press.
21.
Locke, E. A. (1982). The ideas of Frederick W. Taylor: an evaluation. Academy of Management Review, 7, 14–24.
22.
Lucey, W. L. (1958). History: methods and interpretation (2nd ed). Chicago: Loyola University Press.
23.
Nunnally, J. C., & Bernstein, I. H. (1994). Psychometric theory (3rd ed). New York: McGraw–Hill.
24.
Perkins, J. S (Producer & Commentator), Barnes, R. M. (Collaborator), & Gilbreth, L. M. (Commentator). (1968). The original films of Frank B. Gilbreth: the quest of the one best way [Film available at the University of Oklahoma Library in the Bass Collection. Video available from Perkins Associates, Cypress Village, 13848 Silkvine Lane, Jacksonville, FL 32224].
25.
Person, H. S. (1921). Stop-watch time study: an indictment and a defense. Bulletin of the Taylor Society, 6 (3), 97–98.
26.
Rossler, P. E., & Beruvides, M. G. (1994). Management theory deja vu? Scientific and total quality management. Engineering Management Journal, 6 (2), 6–15.
27.
Schachter, H. L. (1989). Frederick Taylor and the public administration community: a reevaluation. Albany, NY: State University of New York.
28.
Schank, R. C. (1990). Tell me a story: a new look at real and artificial memory. New York: Charles Scribner & Sons.
29.
Shafritz, J. M., & Ott, J. S. (1995). Classics of organization theory (4th ed). Fort Worth, TX: Harcourt Brace.
30.
Spaeth, R. A. (1921). Stop-watch time study: an indictment and a defense. Bulletin of the Taylor Society, 6 (3), 114–117.
31.
Taylor, F. W. (1903). Shop management. American Society of Mechanical Engineers Transactions, 24, 1337–1480.
32.
Taylor, F. W. (1947). The principles of scientific management. In Scientific management. New York: Harper & Brothers. (Original published in 1911).
33.
Thompson, S. E. (1915, October 15). Stages between Midvale and Bethlehem. In Frederick Winslow Taylor: a memorial volume from an address at the Memorial Meeting, Houston Hall, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA.
34.
Webster’s new world dictionary of the American language (2nd college ed.). 1976. Cleveland, OH:William Collins + World Publishing.
35.
Wrege, C. D., & Greenwood, R. (1998). Frederick W. Taylor’s “pig iron loading observations” at Bethlehem, March 10, 1899 —May 31, 1899: the real story. Canal History and Technology Proceedings, 27, 159–201.
36.
Wrege, C. D., & Greenwood, R. G. (1991). Frederick W. Taylor the father of scientific management: myth and reality. Homewood, IL: Business One Irwin.
37.
Wrege, C. D., & Perroni, A. G. (1974). Taylor’s pig-tale: a historical analysis of Frederick W. Taylor’s pig-iron experiments. Academy of Management Journal, 17, 6–27.
38.
Wrege, C. D., & Stotka, A. M. (1978). Cooke creates a classic: the story behind F. W. Taylor’s principles of scientific management. Academy of Management Review, 3, 736–749.
39.
Wren, D. A. (1987). Management history: issues and ideas for teaching and research. Journal of Management, 13, 339–350.
40.
Wren, D. A. (1994). The evolution of management thought (4th ed.). New York: John Wiley & Sons.
41.
Wren, D. A. (1996). Frederick W. Taylor: myth and reality. Published in German as “Frederick W. Taylor: mythos und wirklichkeit.” In H. Hax, Frederick W. Taylor, The principles of scientific management (pp. 49–75). Dusseldorf: Verlag Wirtschaft und Finanzen GmbH.
42.
Zald, M. N. (1993). History, sociology, and theories of organization. In J. E. Jackson (Ed.), Institutions in American society: essays in market, political, and social organization (pp. 81–108). Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
43.
Zald, M. N. (1996). More fragmentation? Unfinished business in linking the social sciences and humanities. Administrative Science Quarterly, 41, 251–261.
